-
Most of us go through life trying
to do our best at whatever we do,
-
whether it's our job, family, school,
-
or anything else.
-
I feel that way. I try my best.
-
But some time ago, I came to a realization
-
that I wasn't getting much better
-
at the things I cared most about,
-
whether it was being a husband or a friend
-
or a professional or teammate,
-
and I wasn't improving
much at those things
-
even though I was spending a lot of time
-
working hard at them.
-
I've since realized from conversations
I've had and from research
-
that this stagnation, despite hard work,
-
turns out to be pretty common.
-
So I'd like to share with you
some insights into why that is
-
and what we can all do about it.
-
What I've learned is that
the most effective people
-
and teams in any domain
-
do something we can all emulate.
-
They go through life deliberately
alternating between two zones:
-
the learning zone
and the performance zone.
-
The learning zone is when
our goal is to improve.
-
Then, we do activities
designed for improvement,
-
concentrating on what
we haven't mastered yet,
-
which means we have to expect
to make mistakes,
-
knowing that we will learn from them.
-
That is very different from what we do
when we're in our performance zone,
-
which is when our goal is to do something
as best as we can, to execute.
-
Then, we concentrate
on what we have already mastered
-
and we try to minimize mistakes.
-
Both of these zones
should be part of our lives,
-
but being clear about when
we want to be in each of them,
-
with what goal, focus, and expectations
-
helps us better perform
and better improve.
-
The performance zone maximizes
our immediate performance,
-
while the learning zone
maximizes our growth
-
and our future performance.
-
The reason many of us don't improve much
-
despite our hard work
-
is that we tend to spend almost
all of our time in the performance zone.
-
This hinders our growth,
-
and ironically, over the long term,
also our performance.
-
So what does the learning zone look like?
-
Take Demosthenes, a political leader
and the greatest orator
-
and lawyer in Ancient Greece.
-
To become great, he didn't spend
all his time just being an orator
-
or a lawyer, which would be
his performance zone.
-
But instead, he did activities
designed for improvement.
-
Of course, he studied a lot.
He studied law and philosophy
-
with guidance from mentors,
-
but he also realized that being a lawyer
-
involved persuading other people,
-
so he also studied great speeches
-
and acting.
-
To get rid of an odd habit he had
of involuntarily lifting his shoulder,
-
he practiced his speeches
in front of a mirror,
-
and he suspended a sword from the ceiling
-
so that if he raised his shoulder,
-
it would hurt.
-
(Laughter)
-
To speak more clearly despite a lisp,
-
he went through his speeches
with stones in his mouth.
-
He built an underground room where
he could practice without interruptions
-
and not disturb other people,
-
and since courts at the time
were very noisy,
-
he also practiced by the ocean,
-
projecting his voice
above the roar of the waves.
-
His activities in the learning zone
-
were very different
from his activities in court,
-
his performance zone.
-
In the learning zone, he did
-
what Dr. Anders Erikson
calls deliberate practice.
-
This involves breaking down
abilities into component skills,
-
being clear about what subskill
we're working to improve,
-
like keeping our shoulders down,
-
giving full concentration
to a high level of challenge
-
outside our comfort zone,
-
just beyond what we can currently do,
-
using frequent feedback
with repetition and adjustments,
-
and ideally engaging the guidance
of a skilled coach,
-
because activities
designed for improvement
-
are domain-specific,
-
and great teachers and coaches
know what those activities are
-
and can also give us expert feedback.
-
It is this type of practice
in the learning zone
-
which leads to substantial improvement,
-
not just time on task performing.
-
For example, research shows that
after the first couple of years
-
working in a profession,
-
performance usually plateaus.
-
This has been shown to be true
in teaching, general medicine,
-
nursing, and other fields,
-
and it happens because once we think
we have become good enough,
-
adequate, then we stop spending time
in the learning zone.
-
We focus all our time on
just doing our job,
-
performing,
-
which turns out not to be
a great way to improve.
-
But the people who continue
to spend time in the learning zone
-
do continue to always improve.
-
The best salespeople at least once a week
-
do activities with
the goal of improvement.
-
They read to extend their knowledge,
-
consult with colleagues or domain experts,
-
try out new strategies,
solicit feedback, and reflect.
-
The best chess players
-
spend a lot of time
-
not playing games of chess,
-
which would be their performance zone,
-
but trying to predict the moves
grandmasters made and analyzing them.
-
Each of us has probably spent
many, many, many hours
-
typing on a computer
-
without getting faster,
-
but if we spent 10 to 20 minutes
each day fully concentrating
-
on typing 10 to 20 percent faster
than our current reliable speed,
-
we would get faster,
-
especially if we also identified
what mistakes we're making
-
and practiced typing those words.
-
That's deliberate practice.
-
In what other parts of our lives,
-
perhaps that we care more about,
-
are we working hard
but not improving much
-
because we're always
in the performance zone?
-
Now, this is not to say
that the performance zone has no value.
-
It very much does.
-
When I needed a knee surgery,
I didn't tell the surgeon,
-
"Poke around in there
and focus on what you don't know."
-
(Laughter)
-
"We'll learn from your mistakes!"
-
I looked for a surgeon
who I felt would do a good job,
-
and I wanted her to do a good job.
-
Being in the performance zone
allows us to get things done
-
as best as we can.
-
It can also be motivating,
-
and it provides us with information
to identify what to focus on next
-
when we go back to the learning zone.
-
So the way to high performance
is to alternate between
-
the learning zone
and the performance zone,
-
purposefully building out skills
in the learning zone,
-
then applying those skills
in the performance zone.
-
When Beyonce is on tour,
during the concert,
-
she's in her performance zone,
-
but every night when she gets
back to the hotel room,
-
she goes right back into
her learning zone.
-
She watches a video
of the show that just ended.
-
She identifies opportunities
for improvement, for herself,
-
her dancers, and her camera staff,
-
and the next morning,
-
everyone receives pages of notes
with what to adjust,
-
which they then work on during the day
before the next performance.
-
It's a spiral
to ever-increasing capabilities,
-
but we need to know when we seek to learn,
-
and when we seek to perform,
-
and while we want to spend
time doing both,
-
the more time we spend
in the learning zone,
-
the more we'll improve.
-
So how can we spend
more time in the learning zone?
-
First, we must believe and understand
-
that we can improve,
-
what we call a growth mindset.
-
Second, we must want to improve
at that particular skill.
-
There has to be a purpose we care about,
-
because it takes time and effort.
-
Third, we must have an idea
about how to improve,
-
what we can do to improve,
-
not how I used to practice
the guitar as a teenager,
-
performing songs over and over again,
-
but doing deliberate practice.
-
And fourth, we must be
in a low-stakes situation,
-
because if mistakes are to be expected,
-
then the consequence of make them
must not be catastrophic,
-
or even very significant.
-
A tightrope walker doesn't practice
new tricks without a net underneath,
-
and an athlete wouldn't set out
to try a new move
-
during a championship match.
-
One reason that in our lives
-
we spend so much time in
the performance zone
-
is that our environments often are,
unnecessarily, high stakes.
-
We create social risks for one another,
-
even in schools which are supposed
to be all about learning,
-
and I'm not talking about
standardized tests.
-
I mean that every minute of every day,
-
many students in elementary schools
through colleges
-
feel that if they make a mistake,
others will think less of them.
-
No wonder they're always stressed out
-
and not taking the risks
necessary for learning.
-
But they learn that
mistakes are undesirable
-
inadvertently
-
when teachers or parents are eager
to hear just correct answers
-
and reject mistakes rather than
welcome and examine them
-
to learn from them,
-
or when we look for narrow responses
-
rather than encourage
more exploratory thinking
-
that we can all learn from.
-
When all homework or student work
has a number or a letter on it,
-
and counts towards a final grade,
-
rather than being used for practice,
mistakes, feedback, and revision,
-
we send the message that school
is a performance zone.
-
The same is true in our workplaces.
-
In the companies I consult with,
-
I often see flawless execution cultures
-
which leaders foster
to encourage great work,
-
but that leads employees
to stay within what they know
-
and not try new things,
-
so companies struggle
to innovate and improve,
-
and they fall behind.
-
We can create more spaces for growth
-
by starting conversations with one another
-
about when we want to be in each zone.
-
What do we want to get better at,
-
and how?
-
And when do we want to execute
and minimize mistakes?
-
That way, we gain clarity
about what success is,
-
when, and how to best support one another.
-
But what if we find ourselves
in a chronic high-stakes setting
-
and we feel we can't
start those conversations yet?
-
And here are three things that
we can still do as individuals.
-
First, we can create low-stakes islands
in and otherwise high-stakes sea.
-
These are spaces where mistakes
have little consequence.
-
For example, we might find a mentor
or a trusted colleague
-
with whom we can exchange ideas
or have vulnerable conversations
-
or even role play,
-
or we can ask for feedback-oriented meetings as projects progress.
-
Or we can set aside time to read
or watch videos or take online courses.
-
Those are just some examples.
-
Second, we can execute and perform
as we're expected,
-
but then reflect on what we could
do better next time,
-
like Beyonce does,
-
and we can observe and emulate experts.
-
The observation, reflection,
and adjustment is a learning zone.
-
And finally, we can lead,
-
and lower the stakes for others
by sharing what we want to get better at,
-
by asking questions
about what we don't know,
-
by soliciting feedback
and by sharing our mistakes
-
and what we've learned from them,
-
so that others can feel safe
to do the same.
-
Real confidence is about modeling
ongoing learning.
-
What if, instead of spending
our lives doing, doing, doing,
-
performing, performing, performing,
-
we spent more time exploring,
-
asking,
-
listening,
-
experimenting, reflecting,
-
striving, and becoming?
-
What if we each always had something
-
we were working to improve?
-
What if we created more low-stakes islands
-
and waters?
-
And what if we got clear,
-
within ourselves and with our teammates,
-
about when we seek to learn
-
and when we seek to perform,
-
so that our efforts
can be more consequential,
-
our improvement never-ending,
-
and our best even better?
-
Thank you.
-
(Applause)