-
At one point or another, you've probably heard the old saying
about "sending horses to the glue factory"
-
when they get old and sick. Jokes about making horses
into glue pop up in places like the Simpsons,
-
and—shockingly—copious internet memes.
-
So if you've ever wondered if glue really is made
from horses, you're not alone.
-
And if you've ever tried Googling it,
get ready to hear an entirely different answer.
-
From the myths and facts about horse
glue, to vegan glue options,
-
to how to tell if a product contains animal glue,
I'm here to guide you through this sticky subject.
-
Hi, it's Emily from BiteSizeVegan.org,
where you can find free resources, eCourses,
-
kids' content, and a Guided Search
to help you find just what you need,
-
even if you don't know what to ask!
-
All my sources and additional info
are available in this video’s article,
-
where I cover significantly more information
than we're going to go through in the video.
-
So, to dive in deeper, go to bitesize.link/IsGlueVegan
-
So, is glue made from horses? Well, horse skin, bones, connective
tissues, and hooves can be used to make glue.
-
However, while countless blog posts around the internet
-
claim that horses have been
made into glue for thousands of years,
-
I could not find any solid evidence that horses
were ever used more than any other animal.
-
In fact, horses were not even directly mentioned in any of the
academic, industry, and historical-minded sources I read.
-
This is not to say that glue has never
been made from horses—it has.
-
In fact, it's entirely possible that parts of horses
slaughtered in today's horse meat industry
-
are used to make animal glue. But the idea that
animal glue was—or is—primarily made from horses
-
is most likely a myth, overblown stereotype or—my
personal guess—a manifestation of speciesism.
-
If you're not familiar, "speciesism" is “a
prejudice or attitude of bias in favour
-
of the interests of one species and
against those of other species.”
-
A simplified example is how
we love dogs but eat pigs.
-
Speciesism presumes that humans determine
the inherent value of other sentient beings.
-
In regards to this topic, our human bias for
horses over those beings we deem "food animals"
-
became extremely apparent when I compared
keyword research (meaning what people Google)
-
to academic research (meaning reality).
-
This may sound boring, but stick with me for a moment.
-
Pun intended.
-
As of this video, the phrase "is glue made from
horses" is searched for 5,000 times a month,
-
while the phrase "is glue made from cows"
receives 60 searches a month.
-
Even more telling, the phrase "is glue
made from pigs" returned no data at all.
-
Yet, the reality is that most animal glue is made from
cows and pigs slaughtered in the meat and dairy industries.
-
For an idea of the disparity, in the same year
that 138,000 horses from the United States
-
were sent to slaughter, 34.2 million cows and
110.3 million pigs were killed in the US alone.
-
But, if you want clicks, you have to talk
about what—or whom—humans care about,
-
which only continues to reinforce
the valuing of some lives over others
-
—further pushing into obscurity
the sentient beings we most exploit.
-
To learn about other false horse glue claims,
the state of horse slaughter in the US,
-
and what happens to unwanted horses,
please see the article for this video.
-
So, if not horses, what IS
glue made of? And is it vegan?
-
These days, most glues you'll encounter are
synthetic rather than animal-derived.
-
So yes, most glues are vegan. But animal glues and
glues of animal origin are still manufactured.
-
While you would most likely know
if you were purchasing hide, bone,
-
or fish glue in their pure form, you're more
likely to encounter glues made from animals
-
within finished products like shoes, cosmetics,
and musical instruments. Later on in this video,
-
we'll address how to tell if a product
is made with glues of animal origin.
-
The history and modern technology of
adhesives is more vast and complex
-
than I could possibly hope to cover. So,
without breaking YouTube with a multi-day
-
adhesive treatise, let's explore
a (very) abridged history of glue.
-
Glue is nothing new. Perhaps the oldest
evidence of glue is a plant-based birch bark adhesive
-
dated back to the Middle Palaeolithic period.
-
In fact, birch bark glue may be the first known synthetic
material our ancestors ever created.
-
Possibly the first known usage of animal
glue dates back to over 8,000 years ago.
-
Early Egyptians used a range of glues
of both plant and animal origin,
-
and the Greeks and Romans further
refined and developed adhesives.
-
Roman naturalist Pliny the Elder wrote
rather extensively about adhesives,
-
claiming that "The finest glue is made
from the ears and genitals of bulls."
-
Jumping ahead to the 1100's -
I did say this was an abridged history,
-
the pseudonymous author Theophilus, wrote
instructions for preparing a variety of glues,
-
including those from fish bladders,
cheese, animal skins, horns, and blood.
-
Fast forward to about 1690 when
the first commercial factory for
-
producing animal glue from hides was set up in Holland.
-
A flurry of glue patents were issued after the first
(for fish glue) was granted in 1754 in the UK.
-
The first animal glue factory
was started in the United States in 1808,
-
and by 1900 there were multiple factories
manufacturing glue from a variety of sources.
-
Up until the 1920s, most adhesives were
either animal or plant-based in origin,
-
but the development of synthetic
polymers rapidly overtook natural glues.
-
However, as glues of animal origin do
still exist, we'll cover some of them.
-
Before we get into specific
types of animal-based glues,
-
I wanted to note that nothing in my research
has shown that animals are killed solely to make glue.
-
Animal glues primarily use parts
of animals slaughtered for their meat,
-
or after their bodies give out from
the demands of the dairy industry.
-
However, animal glue cannot accurately be deemed
-
"just a byproduct" of the meat industry.
With a multi-billion dollar global market value,
-
there's no doubt that animal glue is a
fully developed industry all its own.
-
So, animal glue—like leather—is
a coproduct rather than byproduct
-
of the meat and dairy industries. To
learn more about what a coproduct is,
-
check out my video and article "Is
Leather a Byproduct of the Meat Industry?"
-
“Animal glue” technically refers to glues
derived from mammalian collagen and keratin..
-
The most prominent animal glues are those made
by extracting the collagen from animal skins,
-
bones and connective tissues through boiling.
-
Collagen is a fibrous structural protein present in the
extracellular matrix and connective tissue of animals.
-
It's sometimes referred to as
the "glue" that holds the body together.
-
Gelatin is essentially denatured collagen and is
-
"the purified active ingredient of any collagen-derived glue."
-
Hide glue—made specifically from animal skins
—is said to be of higher quality than bone glue.
-
Most hide and bone glue is produced from cows and pigs
slaughtered for their meat or after their bodies give out.
-
Rabbit skin glue is just what it
sounds like—glue made from rabbit skin,
-
though other small mammals are sometimes included.
-
Less widely used animal glues are those made
from extracting keratin—another structural protein
-
—by boiling hooves and horns. Hoof
glue is still used in some woodworking,
-
though it seems more smaller-scale artisan
woodworkers than commercial manufacturing.
-
Other glues of animal origin that don't fall under
-
the technical term "animal glue" include
fish, casein, shellac, and albumin glues.
-
Fish glue can be produced from the skin of
"non-oily" fish, along with their bones,
-
or from isinglass, a form of collagen
procured from the swim bladders of fish.
-
Isinglass is more commonly used in the fining of some wine and beer.
-
See my article and video
"Is Alcohol Vegan?" to learn more.
-
While Isinglass and fish glue may seem like niche products,
-
the impact of the global fishing industry
is a threat to all life on this planet.
-
See my mini documentary "Empty Oceans" to learn more.
-
Casein is a protein found within milk,
-
and is originally what Elmer's glue was made with.
-
Casein glue is what Theophilus referred to in
his 12th century writings as "the glue of cheese."
-
You may be more familiar with shellac as a finish for wood,
or the shiny coating on candy and some fresh fruit.
-
Secreted from the female lac beetle, shellac is a resin
-
that can also be used for adhesive purposes,
though its usage has declined due to its cost.
-
As we learned in the brief history of glue, blood
albumin - a protein, and egg albumen
-
- what we call "egg whites", have been used to make glue,
and may still be used in limited applications.
-
As I mentioned earlier, animal glue is
still used in some modern manufacturing.
-
The best way to know if a product contains
animal glue—or any animal-derived ingredients,
-
byproducts or coproducts—is to contact the company.
-
I will say that this can be a frustrating—if not
fruitless—endeavor depending on the company.
-
If in doubt, see if there is an alternative product that you can verify,
-
but don't lose yourself in tracking down
every adhesive in every product.
-
Oftentimes, the information isn't even available.
When it comes to necessary prescriptions that may contain gelatin,
-
please refer to my video and article "Is Medication Vegan?"
-
Overall, focus on the big things.
When buying actual glue, buy vegan.
-
These days, you kind of have to make an effort not to!
-
As we learned in our abridged history,
-
the first known glue was entirely plant-based.
Long before the advent of synthetic glues,
-
natural adhesives were made from a variety
of non-animal sources. While most commercial
-
glues are now petroleum-based, natural
plant-based glues are still in use today.
-
There is a developing interest in (re)expanding
-
the usage of bio-based polymers for their
environmental advantages over synthetics:
-
they're biodegradable, non-toxic, and
are said to have lower carbon footprints.
-
Starch is an inexpensive and abundant
natural polymeric carbohydrate found in plants.
-
Dextrin is simply starch that's been further processed.
-
For adhesives, starch is most commonly derived
from maize, corn, potatoes, rice, and wheat.
-
Starch glues are commonly referred to
as "paste," and are widely used in bonding paper
-
products as well as in textiles. Due to their
many advantageous attributes over synthetics,
-
starch and dextrin-based adhesives still
hold their own in a largely synthetic market.
-
Cellulose is "the most important skeletal
component in plants." In the glue-world,
-
cellulose adhesive is use for such applications as wallpaper,
-
window decals and apparently to secure the packaging of cigarettes.
-
Natural rubber is sourced from certain trees and plants,
and used primarily in pressure-sensitive adhesives.
-
While natural rubber is plant-derived,
-
there is serious concern over deforestation,
environmental impact, and sustainability.
-
As I stated early on, the world of synthetic
adhesive is far beyond the scope of this video.
-
If you really want to dive in, feel free to read one or more of the
multi-hundred-page textbooks in my bibliography!
-
At a very high-level, most synthetic glues are petroleum-based.
-
So while animal-free, there
are issues of environmental sustainability.
-
Synthetic glues include everything from
pressure-sensitive adhesives made with
-
synthetic rubber, to two-part epoxies, to hot
glue, to contact cement, and countless others.
-
Rather than get lost in a chemistry lesson,
-
let's touch on which major glue
types and brands are vegan.
-
Let's tackle the biggest one first:
Elmer's Glue. Elmer's glue is vegan,
-
though it wasn't originally. First produced by the Borden Company,
a conglomerate with its roots in the dairy industry,
-
Elmer's was casein glue - made from milk.
-
Despite the bull mascot on the bottle, it
was never made with horses, hooves, hides,
-
or other animal components. Elmer the bull is
simply the "husband" of Borden Dairy's mascot,
-
Elsie the cow. Modern Elmer's
glue is entirely synthetic.
-
Other common glues that are animal-free include:
-
Super Glue, Krazy Glue, most eyelash glues
- which is apparently a thing, and Gorilla Glue
-
—a company which actually affirmed the
inherent rights of animals when replying to an inquiry.
-
For more specifics on vegan glues,
check out the article for this video.
-
It's time to "stick" the landing of this subject
- couldn't help myself.
-
Here's the major takeaways:
-
The myth of horse glue is likely driven by the
fact that we humans care more about horses
-
than the cows and pigs most animal glue actually comes from.
When it comes to buying glue, you're likely clear of animals.
-
When it comes to pre-made products,
do your best and find alternatives if possible.
-
I hope this has been helpful.
To support educational content like this,
-
please consider making a donation. To stay in the loop
about new Bite Size Vegan content and updates,
-
please sign up for the newsletter or follow the Telegram
channel for the most reliable notifications.
-
Now go live vegan, and I'll see you soon.