-
Art...
-
ArtSleuth
-
A reviving meal
-
Reapers in a cornfield
-
Rolling countryside, as far as the eye can see,
-
A picture by Pieter Bruegel
-
Peasant life viewed with a sympathetic eye …
-
…or a powerful land-owner’s lofty condescension?
-
A question easily answered, one might think:
-
since this picture belongs to a series
-
painted by one city-dweller for another - a rich Antwerp merchant…
-
… and the florid,
-
haggard
-
and toil-worn faces
-
of the people in it hardly tempt one to join the club.
-
So what do artist and patron want with these peasants, these minute worker ants?
-
Do they enjoy looking down on them?
-
And making fun of them?
-
Or do they find them genuinely interesting?
-
Episode 10 : Bruegel - La Moisson
Le Bonheur est dans le pré ?
-
Part 1. Rustic joys
-
Under a pale moon …
-
… the golden corn…
-
methodically cut …
-
… bundled …
-
… bound …
-
… and carried off ...
-
… in a near-geometrical pattern …
-
… leads the eye in two directions:
-
towards the village ...
-
... with its houses clustered round the steeple.
-
And … through a carefully ordered landscape to the castle
-
with its dug-out pond,
-
dependent hamlet,
-
toll bridge
-
and winding roads.
-
This pear-laden tree
-
is a perfect image of man’s and nature’s productivity,
-
and these peasants are - literally and figuratively - at the root of it.
-
while one of them sleeps , exhausted by his labours,
-
the others settle down merrily to their meal.
-
Stirabout comes first,
-
then it’s out with the knives for bread and cheese,
-
with fruit as dessert.
-
A feast fit for a lord - almost!
-
But this is no general, freeze-frame celebration of the rural life, with its immemorial rhythms and rituals.
-
In fact, the whole picture is brimming with specifics, and time - the real time embodied in action and change - flows through and animates it.
-
These strange suspended shapes, for example ...
-
… are apples which this peasant has shaken from the tree …
-
… and the children are gathering.
-
And here, beside another fruit-picker, time speeds up
-
, and we see a group of men in hot pursuit of others
-
trespassers, perhaps, chased off by guards from the castle?
-
For others, it’s time to relax:
-
This scene of bathing monks is a full action sequence. We see them:
-
- clothed,
-
- stripped,
-
- entering the water,
-
- testing the temperature,
-
- getting ready to dive,
-
- going bottom-up
-
- waving jubilantly.
-
And these villagers are playing throw-the-stick:
-
the one who kills the goose gets to keep it
-
a game which Hogarth, two centuries later, attacked as cruel and barbaric
-
Further on, this man - caught in the act of relieving himself in front of the best-kept of the peasants’ houses.
-
This motif, which recurs in Bruegel’s Proverbs, is a classic expression of contempt
-
- either for the world, as here,
-
or for the authority symbolised by the gibbet.
-
At first sight, this landscape painting seems to depict the three orders in society
-
- as fixed and immutable as the seasons themselves:
-
the nobles, who fight to preserve peace and order in this world,
-
the clergy, who pray for everyone’s salvation in the next,
-
and ordinary people, who work to satisfy their own and others’ worldly needs.
-
But the castle here seems diminished and forlorn,
-
the monks are not praying,
-
and the only ones working are the peasants.
-
The only ones? Not quite! The ships in the distance stand for maritime trade, which is booming.
-
This is the fundamental change reflected in the picture
-
- and it is taking place on the horizon, well beyond the confines of the old feudal system.
-
So who is the picture’s real hero?
-
The peasant working his smallholding, or the merchant who dominates him - and the world?
-
Part 2. Remote - but riveting
-
The merchant’s name is Jongelinck,
-
and Bruegel’s seasons are to hang in the dining room at his country villa.
-
How does he regard these peasants?
-
They certainly don’t appear to put much trust in us
-
- indeed, our watching presence seems positively unwelcome!
-
…and this motif is ambiguous in Bruegel :
-
In The Beekeepers, the well-equipped specialists outsmart the amateur and make off with the honey.
-
In this scene, the jeering peasant, himself on the point of falling into the stream,
-
is as much the butt of the joke as the rash birdnester in the tree.
-
Theft itself can be a merry business - take this youthful peasant, who stands for the world,
-
as he slyly snips the sinister misanthrope’s purse from his belt.
-
Both Breugel and his patron habitually view ordinary life from a distance -
-
and this may predispose them to regard theft lightly.
-
The merchant, indeed, may see it in plain book-keeping terms:
-
since fruit and sheaves can be counted,
-
and also the people who need feeding -
-
the surplus can be calculated too!
-
But the distance between Bruegel and his subjects becomes most apparent
-
in his physical treatment of people at work.
-
Take this other summer scene,
-
where faces are hidden by carried objects and pitchers
-
women look like the sheaves they are binding,
-
and a water jar takes on human shape -
-
as if these people - otherwise strongly individualised
-
- were fusing with the work they are doing.
-
Work requiring physical effort and skill of a kind
-
far removed from the intellectual agility required of men like Jongelinck:
-
a passionate art-lover, he has commissioned two other series from Frans Floris.
-
These engravings reproduce them:one celebrates the seven liberal arts - specially to be admired, since they approximate to pure knowledge,
-
which serves no utilitarian purpose:
-
four are linked with mathematics,
-
- arithmetic,
-
geometry,
-
music
-
and astronomy –
-
and three with discourse
-
– grammar,
-
rhetoric
-
and logic -
-
The pictures in the other series trace the 12 labours of Hercules,
-
which symbolise aristocratic might.
-
The fact remains that these two series are infinitely more conventional and stereotyped than the Bruegel’s:
-
they are wooden allegories of a kind which a self-made man,
-
seeking to ape the style of some enlightened prince, might well choose to put on his walls.
-
Why do we get the feeling that these rough peasants
-
are the ones regarded with real interest?
-
Part 3. Peasants to the fore!
-
Before Bruegel, the peasants always seem to get mere walk-on parts.
-
In these nativity scenes, they remain just outside the sacred space - a stable!
-
Beside their dull, coarse faces, …
-
… the Virgin is a radiant, pale and delicate vision.
-
In this book of hours, their life is contrasted with that of the nobles,
-
in a world whose limits are set by their lord’s majestic castle.
-
Feasting, hunting and courtly love are for the nobles!
-
Back-breaking labour for the peasants!
-
A century later, Bruegel turns everything round: the work of the peasants is made to seem monumental …
-
… and the life of the nobles frivolous and irrelevant.
-
The other pictures in the “seasons” series confirm this impression:
-
the world has expanded,
-
the proud fortresses have receded
-
and, paradoxically, the peasant world has become interesting.
-
Why?
-
Perhaps because the middle-class elite – totally absorbed in the world’s affairs –
-
secretly envy the peasant’s narrow horizons.
-
While storm-battered ships are lost at sea, and fortunes lost with them…
-
… peasant life goes on quietly…
-
… and even leaves room for game and role playing
-
a paper crown, two thick cushions and a collar taken from a cow are enough
-
to make this child feel like one of the magi,
-
and a flute is all the adults need to parody the bucolic loves of classical mythology
-
Here, two obviously urban visitors appear between this unselfconscious figure
-
and the merrily cavorting dancers in front of the sinister gibbet …
-
… which also turns up in another seasonal panel.
-
The execution is a gri mly recent memory, …
-
… but the dominant note in this scene is pleasure at the sight of the fat rumps of these contented cattle,
-
…ambling home to the peaceful hamlet, with its playing children.
-
This winter scene, finally, suggests a similar link between the playful instincts of the artist,
-
who conceals the freezing dogs’ heads
-
and gives us a near-abstract bouquet of corkscrew tails ...
-
… and those of the skating villagers, who here display a far broader range of human reactions and feelings than they do when they are working.
-
Between the two extremes - the watchers from the edge
-
and the seasoned performers, we get:
-
…cautious beginners…
-
…those who help others…
-
…mishaps...
-
…disasters...
-
…and surprises
-
And so the difference between Jongelinck and the peasants is not a difference in their nature
-
- like that between serf and feudal lord -
-
but a difference in the breadth of their horizons.
-
Jongelinck owned one more picture by Bruegel:
-
The Tower of Babel,
-
which the artist placed in a contemporary Flemish town.
-
It certainly denounces human pride.
-
But it also marks a new divide between the ambitious urban elite, who fix their eyes on the horizon,
-
and who love to build
-
and take risks...
-
…and the great mass of the people, who stick to what they know,
-
and never dream of stirring from their own small patch of land.
-
The Seasons thus convey a sense of affinity and also remoteness:
-
affinity of the man who sees in the peasant a living reminder of humanity’s childhood, …
-
…with which it is good to reconnect;
-
remoteness of the merchant displaying all the superiority of a far- sighted visionary
-
and contesting the voluptuous, decadent nobles’ control of the land.
-
This was the last episode of ArtSleuth season 1
Do you want more?
-
Find more information on: www.canal-educatif.fr
-
Written and directed by:
-
Produced by:
-
Scientific expert:
-
Founding and public support:
-
Voiceover:
-
Editing & motion graphics:
-
Post-production / Sound recording
-
Music supervisor
-
Music
-
Special thanks
English subtitles: Vincent Nash
-
A CED film