-
A question that I get with surprising frequency
from non-vegans and vegans alike is whether it's
-
ethical to consume eggs from a rescued
or backyard chicken. It goes something like this.
-
“My friend has her own chickens and
she loves them and takes really good care
-
of them and they’re happy and healthy and
they lay eggs all the time that aren’t fertilized.
-
So, wouldn’t it be okay for her to eat them?
I mean if the chicken just drops the egg and
-
walks away? Or carries it to my friend and
offers the egg to her with outstretched wings?
-
Or leaves a little note on the ground saying
‘please take this thing that came out
-
of my vagina/anus and put it in your mouth?"
-
Okay I may have made up those last two.
-
But you get the idea. There’s even a new dietary
distinction called “veggan.”
-
(and I have no idea if that’s how it’s pronounced,
but that’s what it’s going to be today).
-
So, let’s finally tackle this beast. What
is the ethical concern with eating eggs
-
from rescued or backyard hens?
-
Hi it's Emily from Bite Size Vegan and welcome
to another vegan nugget. I’ve answered this
-
question briefly in the Q&A for a speech I
gave, which you can watch here. But today
-
I’m going to go into greater depth. And
I’ll warn you ahead of time,
-
I'm rather snarky in this video.
-
First off, let’s address this veggan thing.
Veggans, according to dietitian Jessica Cording,
-
“follow the ‘rules’ of a vegan diet
— they avoid animal and dairy products and
-
eat a plant-based diet —
they just also eat eggs.”
-
Yes, because something that comes
out of the sphincter of a bird
-
is definitely NOT an animal product.
-
Instagram is aflutter with the new hashtag
and several articles have already been written
-
on vegganism, one of which includes this gem
from registered dietitian Alissa Rumsey, a
-
spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition
and Dietetics: “As people become more interested
-
and aware of how food affects both their health
as well as the environment, plant-based diets,
-
including veganism, are becoming more and
more popular and mainstream. Veganism may
-
be appealing to people, but many find that
it is too restrictive.”
-
Because once you rule out the flesh of animals’
bodies the secretions and objects that come
-
out of their orifices, there’s just really
nothing left to eat!
-
So why do veggans feel compelled to consume
the shelled menstruation of another species?
-
Protein, of course.
-
I mean, where else can you get it?
-
Food writer Vicki Anne Hadley, featured in The Daily Mail, was vegan for a whole 6 months before adding
-
eggs back into her diet when her friend,
-
who has her own chickens,
offered her an egg dish.
-
Hadley says, “I am very into fitness and
have a very active lifestyle so I wanted to
-
ensure that I would be getting enough protein
in my diet.”
-
Never mind the fact that the USDA has deemed
it illegal for the egg industry to advertise
-
eggs as “a protein-rich food” if they’re
using government money. It’s also illegal
-
to say they “contribute nutritionally,”
are “healthful” or even “contribute
-
healthful components.” They can’t say
eggs are “good for you,” “healthy”
-
or an “important part of well-balanced,
healthy diet.” Or even “safe.”
-
Eggs were even found to have the same atherosclerotic
effect as cigarettes in a 2012 study.
-
However, the egg industry has been trying
valiantly for decades to portray their product
-
as healthy, rarely letting legal restrictions
hold them back and by and large succeeding
-
in their goal. To hear the entire sordid conspiracy
behind eggs, see my video The Great Egg Conspiracy:
-
Lies, Corruption & Kevin Bacon, linked here
and below.
-
Long story short, eggs are one of the worst
things you can put in your body.
-
However, as you may know and as I always emphasize,
veganism at its core is not about health.
-
It can be the healthiest way to eat, but poor
health doesn’t necessarily mean poor ethics.
-
So even if eggs are horrendous for our health,
what’s the ethical issue with
-
eggs from backyard or rescued chickens?
-
If you don’t already know, chickens on standard
farms and even free-range farms are kept indoors
-
in cramped, filthy conditions and forced to
produce an unnaturally large amount of eggs,
-
robbing their body of essential nutrients
and leading to premature death. If they don’t
-
die from exhaustion, disease, or malnutrition,
they’re sent to slaughter when their production
-
declines, typically around 68-72 weeks of
age, though their
-
life expectancy is around 8-10 years.
-
The most horrifying aspect of eggs is that
male layer chicks are ground up alive or suffocated
-
by the hundreds of millions every year.
These are brand new, fluffy baby chicks,
-
thrown into grinders while they’re still
conscious.
-
So, all of that horror aside, what about the
idyllic backyard and rescue chickens, living
-
out their lives outside in the grass, free
to roam and peck as nature intended?
-
There are several aspects to look at here.
First, where did these beloved chickens come
-
from? Did your friend -- because everyone
who asks me this refers to their friend or
-
some hypothetical situation, so I’ll follow
suit: did they buy them from someone involved
-
in the animal products industry? If so, that
act in itself is supporting cruelty. But let’s
-
say your friend rescued their chickens
from a sanctuary.
-
Another consideration is, does your friend
really have the resources and know-how to
-
care for chickens? Backyard chickens seem
to be the new urban hipster accessory.
-
They are to hipsters what the purse
Chihuahua is to socialites.
-
Many people who excitedly bring home their
chickens don’t realize the high cost of
-
properly caring for them and either end up
offering a sub-par or even low-quality home
-
for their chickens, turning around and passing
them off on someone else, or even
-
letting them go as if they’ll return
to the chicken wild.
-
But let’s say your friend knows their chicken
stuff and has the finances and land.
-
Is it okay to take the eggs then?
-
What not everyone knows is that chickens will
cannibalize their own eggs. This is an important
-
practice that returns vital nutrients to their
system lost with egg production. Making an
-
egg is a serious endeavor involving an extreme
loss of calcium and pressure on the hen’s body.
-
This is part of why hens in the egg industry
die so early. In addition, taking a hen's egg
-
away sends the signal to her body to make
a replacement. So the more eggs we take away
-
the more she’ll produce, thus continually
depleting her body.
-
If your friend’s hens don’t seem interested
in eating the egg, they can always crack it
-
a little, which usually let’s the hen know
it’s not going to turn in to a baby and
-
is available for eating. This is something
I did when I volunteered at SASHA Farm Animal
-
Sanctuary. And trust me, there
was nothing left.
-
But what if your friend has cracked the egg
and the hens still won’t eat it. Can they
-
then, finally, serve it up over easy, despite,
of course, the health consequences?
-
Isn't an omelete ethical at this point?
-
Here’s what it comes done to. Hens do not
make eggs for us. They are not ours. And this
-
insane drive to justify something – anything
– that came from an animal because, god forbid
-
we not eat something that came out
of someone else, is part of
-
the addict behavior of animal product consumption.
-
If you think that’s extreme, take in this
excerpt from an article in The Guardian quoting
-
Isobel Davies, co-founder of Hen Nation, an
“ethical egg” farm.
-
Hold on, you couldn’t see me because
the image was up. An “ethical egg” farm.
-
Let's proceed.
-
Davies says, “I get so many emails from
vegans about our eggs. One woman said she
-
couldn’t sleep the night before trying them
because she was so excited. “
-
Linda Turvey, who runs the Hen Heaven sanctuary
says, “I get calls from all over the country.
-
Virtually all the eggs are going to vegans
or their friends and family. I recently got a call from
-
a new vegan who works out in the gym and wanted to order 80 eggs a week for protein."
-
She also recalled one man from London
who caught the train to Horsham, a bus to
-
Henfield and then walked a mile and a half
to the Sussex sanctuary just to get
-
some eggs for his vegan daughter.
-
Now if that’s not addict behavior, I don’t
know what is.
-
I hope this video was helpful. If you want
to learn more about eggs, check out the videos
-
below, including my egg video for kids. I’d
love to hear your thoughts on the backyard
-
chicken debate and the veggan phenomenon.
Let me know what you think in the comments.
-
If you liked this golden egg of a nugget,
do give the video a thumbs up and share it
-
around to answer this oft-asked question.
If you’re new here, I’d love to have you
-
as a subscriber. I put out fresh content covering
all aspects of veganism every Monday, Wednesday,
-
and some Fridays. To help support Bite Size
Vegan’s educational efforts, please see
-
the support links below or click on the Nugget
Army icon or the link in the sidebar.
-
Now go live vegan, stop eating sphincter food,
and I’ll see you soon.
-
That was my favorite part. “They avoid animal
products. And they eat eggs.”
-
When you’re eating something that came out
… of an animal…
-
…the animal produced it. It’s literally…
an animal product.
-
It’s something that literally fell … out
of an animal …
-
… I don’t understand how this is not connecting.