-
Despite decades of debate, denial, and dubious
behavior on the part of the tobacco industry
-
regarding the potential dangers of cigarettes,
it’s now generally agreed upon that smoking
-
is bad for your health. Smoking damages nearly
every organ in the body, causing strokes,
-
coronary heart disease, respiratory diseases,
a whole slew of cancers, and other deleterious
-
effects. And while big tobacco has
done its best to feign ignorance since the
-
40’s, we now know the answer to “Is smoking
bad for you?” is a resounding yes. But a
-
less-hotly debated question remains: is smoking
vegan?
-
Hi it’s Emily from Bite Size Vegan and welcome
to another vegan nugget. While being vegan
-
is often associated with a level of health
fanaticism approaching daily wheatgrass juice
-
enemas and coffee colonics, the truth is,
not everyone goes vegan for their health.
-
There are junk food vegans, vegans who drink
alcohol, and yes, even vegans who smoke. And
-
I mean tobacco, not the other thing everyone
assumes all vegans smoke…
-
But can cigarettes be considered vegan? As
usual, the answer to this question is more
-
complex than it would first appear. I’m
going to touch on the various areas of concern,
-
but please refer to the blog post for this
video for citations and more detailed information.
-
The main areas of concern we’ll be addressing
are: animal ingredients in cigarettes,
-
animals killed in the farming process, animal
testing, the environmental impact, second
-
hand smoke and companion animals child
labor and worker toxicity exposure and of
-
course a nod to health
-
The most basic measure of whether something
is vegan or not is whether it contains animals
-
or their byproducts. When we combine the myriad
of ways we disguise animal byproducts with
-
the close to 600 ingredients found in cigarettes, including arsenic, formaldehyde, lead, ammonia,
-
acetone and other far less-pronounceable elements,
it becomes rather difficult to ascertain if
-
anything is animal-derived.
-
This issue was brought to a very public head
back in 2010 when a press release, light on
-
the facts but big on the sensation, claimed
that cigarettes may contain pig’s blood.
-
This revelation came from artist Christien
Meindertsma’s three-year-long project entitled
-
Pig 05049, which tracked and documented all
of the ways one pig’s body was used post-slaughter,
-
including in cigarette filters.
-
Anti-smoking advocate Professor Simon Chapman
of the University of Sydney saw this as an
-
opportunity to use public outrage, particularly
among Jewish, Muslim, vegetarian and vegan
-
populations, to bring to light “concerns
that ingredients such as additives or processing
-
aids used in tobacco products are virtually
unregulated and non-transparent.”
-
After creating the press release, the story
went viral and built into quite a frenzy,
-
with Iranian officials calling it a Zionist
conspiracy and tobacco companies churning
-
out denials left and right. The truth of the
matter is far less titalating. In 1997 a Greek
-
tobacco company set out to create a healthier
cigarette, using pig’s blood in the filter
-
to mitigate toxins. The resulting BioFilter
led the company to second place in the Greek
-
tobacco industry, though every scientific
study to evaluate these claims found them
-
to be patently false, and in 2002
Greece finally outlawed their “healthier
-
smoking” claims. As far as I can tell, the
filters are still on the market and I have
-
link on the blog post to the company’s website
with more information.
-
There are also at least two other animal-derived
ingredients in cigarettes, which are far more
-
regularly employed: beeswax and castoreum.
Beeswax is rather self-explanatory and you
-
can see my video here on the vegan-ness of
bee products for more information. Castoreum,
-
used in cigarettes to lend a sweet, smoky
flavor, is another matter entirely.
-
I covered the glories of castoruem in one
of my very first vegan nuggets ever on What’s
-
Really In Your Food, back when both my editing
skills and language were a little less polished.
-
“If all of that isn’t enough for you,
have you ever wondered where artificial raspberry,
-
vanilla or strawberry flavors come from? Castoreum!
- An extract made from dried, ground up sacs
-
located by the anal glands of beavers.
-
Yes, we are talking about pouches in the *ss
of a beaver. It can be added to foods such
-
as gums, alcohol, candy and baked goods. Perhaps
tossing a beaver’s salad does give you a
-
nice little vanilla flavor but does that really
make it right?”
-
[I’ve come a long way…]
-
Castoreum is harvested by killing beavers
and cutting out their castor glands, making
-
it a most definitively un-vegan ingredient.
-
So when it comes to animals in your smokes,
bees and beaver butts are more likely than
-
pigs blood, but just as un-vegan.
-
Now I’ll just speak very briefly to the
concern of animals killed during tobacco farming
-
and harvesting. While we should strive for
pesticide-free, sustainable farming,
-
with any crop, field animals are going to
be unintentionally harmed and killed in the
-
farming and harvesting process. We have to
eat but we don’t have to smoke, so the animals
-
killed by tobacco farming are entirely avoidable
deaths.
-
And now, to the heavy-hitter of the vegan
cigarette debate: animal testing. I have a
-
four-part video series on animal testing which
goes into greater detail about the inefficacy
-
of animal tests, why we are still conducting
them, how they endanger and even kill humans,
-
and what viable alternatives exist, which
I’ve linked up here and below if you want
-
to delve deeper into this matter.
-
Perhaps the most insane aspect of animal testing
as a whole is its complete and utter lack
-
of credible results. It’s no secret that
our bodies differ greatly from other species,
-
and so, it follows, would our reactions to
stimuli and toxins.
-
In regards to tobacco specifically, Dr. C
Ray Greek of Americans for Medical Advancement
-
states that “Animal experiments failed notoriously
to demonstrate a smoking-cancer connection
-
for over half a century...If the greatest
killer of our time was promoted by physicians
-
based on animal experiments, there is obviously
something terminally wrong with the system."
-
A 2015 paper drawing on more than 50 recent
toxicology studies, demonstrated the superiority
-
of widely available modern, non-animal models
over inaccurate animal tests for measuring
-
the toxicity of tobacco products. In 2012,
the U.S. Congress even stated that “there
-
is significant scientific evidence that animals
are poor models for the testing of tobacco
-
products used by humans.”
-
Unlike all medications, tobacco products are
not required to undergo animal testing. The
-
UK, Germany, Belgium and other countries even
banned their usage and Canada requires only
-
in vitro studies, meaning on a cellular level
rather than on whole living animals.
-
Even the tobacco industry’s own studies
have concluded that “in vitro toxicology
-
tests can be successfully used both for better
understanding the biological activity of cigarette
-
smoke … and for guiding the development
of cigarettes with reduced toxicity.”
-
Despite this fact, tobacco companies, government
agencies, the American Cancer Society, National
-
Heart, Lung and Blood Institute, among other
organization and, yes, even anti-smoking groups
-
continue to test cigarettes on animals.
-
On this video’s blog post I have links to
several articles and studies which catalogue,
-
describe, and demonstrate the myriad of horrifying
animal tobacco tests,
-
but I’m going to just share a few of them
with you.
-
Perhaps the most visually shocking type of
tobacco testing are the direct smoking tests,
-
made famous in 1975 by undercover Sunday People
reporter Mary Beith in her expose known as
-
“The Smoking Beagles.” Beith got a position
in an Imperial Chemical Industries laboratory
-
where 48 beagles were restrained with straightjackets,
placed into what Beith described as “medieval
-
stocks” and fitted with tubed masks which
forcibly pumped cigarette smoke into their
-
lungs day in and day out for up to three years
for some of the dogs. Beith reported that,
-
“when they have finished their smoking stint
the dogs are killed and sent to pathology
-
laboratories to be cut up and examined for
signs of cancer, liver or heart diseases or
-
other possible effects. Some of the dogs have
acquired a smoker’s cough judging from the
-
sounds I heard.”
-
The images Beith captured sparked global outrage,
yet only two of the 48 beagles were rescued
-
in a technically illegal act of liberation
by activist Mike Huskisson and an unnamed
-
partner in the early days of the Animal Liberation
Front.
-
While not garnering the same level of disgust
from the public, direct smoking tests on mice
-
and rats are just as horrifying. Their entire
bodies are crammed into tiny canisters that
-
pump smoke directly into their noses for six
or more hours a day up to two years.
-
Direct smoking tests can also involve tracheotomies.
In a 2001 study at the Oregon National Primate
-
Research Center involving sixty-seven pregnant
Rhesus macaque monkeys, half of the monkeys
-
had tubes surgically implanted in order to
subject them to a continuous flow of nicotine
-
for the last four months of their pregnancies.
Five days before the mothers reached full
-
term, the experimenters cut out, killed and
dissected the fetuses of all 67 mothers.
-
These kind of experiments are still being
carried out on mice, rats, beagles, monkeys,
-
apes, and other sentient beings.They are not required by law,
-
have no scientific validity and they even
endanger humans with the cross-species application
-
of their results, and are all for a product
that is not only completely unnecessary but
-
also deadly to consumers and damaging to the
environment.
-
Speaking to the environmental impact of smoking,
around 5.6 trillion cigarette butts are dumped
-
into the environment every year. When these
butts land in water or on the soil, all of
-
the chemicals and carcinogenic ingredients
we discussed creates leachates, a toxic soup
-
that poisons fish and other wildlife.
-
Of course smoking also affects one’s home
environment as well. A series of studies at
-
Tufts University and Colorado State University
found that second hand smoke is just as harmful
-
to companion animals as it is humans. Cats
living with smokers are twice as likely to
-
develop malignant lymphoma, and dogs living
with smokers develop cancers of the nose and
-
sinus area, all of which are terminal within
a year.
-
And then there’s the human cost of tobacco
farming. Green Tobacco Sickness (GTS) is cause
-
by the constant exposure of workers to the
nicotine of the plants, which is absorbed
-
through their skin. This is exacerbated
in the case of child workers and child labor
-
is a major issue within America’s tobacco
farming. While several countries, including
-
major tobacco producers such as Brazil and
India, prohibit children under 18 from working
-
on tobacco farms, in the US children as young
as 12 work in fields for 50 to 60 hours a
-
week in extreme heat and with ongoing exposure
to pesticides and nicotine.
-
And of course, there are the health consequences,
which may or may not even be an inherently
-
vegan issue, and which is thoroughly documented
elsewhere. If you are a smoker and want to
-
stop for any reason, please see the blog post
for this video where I’ve included a list
-
of resources to support you in quitting.
-
I hope that this video has been helpful. I’d
love to hear your thoughts- do you think smoking
-
can be considered vegan? If you were a smoker
who went vegan, did you quit? Are you a non-vegan
-
smoker wanting to go vegan but overwhelmed
that now you have to ditch the cigarettes
-
too? [If so, personally, I’d say focus on
the meat, dairy, eggs and honey first and
-
then tackle big tobacco.]
The time it to produce this video clocks in
-
at around ____ . If you’d like to
help support Bite Size Vegan so I can keep
-
putting hours to bring you this educational
resource, please check out the support links
-
in the video description below where you can
give a one-time donation or receive perks
-
and rewards for your support by joining the
Nugget Army--the link for that is also in
-
the iCard sidebar.
-
If you enjoyed this video, please give it a
thumbs up and share it around to help inform
-
others. If you’re new here, be sure to hit
that big red subscribe button down there for
-
more awesome vegan content every Monday, Wednesday,
and some Fridays! Now go live vegan, just
-
say no, and I’ll see you soon.
-
In a repeated national survey, doctors in all branches of medicine
-
doctors in all parts of the country we asked, "what cigarette do you smoke doctor?"
-
Once again, the brand named most was Camel.
-
Yes, according to this repeated nationwide survey, more doctors smoke Camels than any other cigarette.
-
Why not change to Camels for the next 30 days and see what a difference it makes
-
in your smoking enjoyment. See how Camels agree with your throat.
-
See how mild and good tasting a cigarette can be.