Salt Shaker or Pepper Shaker: Which Has More Holes?

The seasoning of our food is a significant
aspect of the dining experience.

In this respect, the salt and pepper shaker
plays an important role.

But a question that often arises, is which
shaker should have more holes, the salt or

the pepper?

Let’s find out with PAA
Hi, I am Shao Chieh Lo, welcome to what people

also ask, where I answered some of the most
Googled questions with even more Googling.

Today’s question is “Which shaker should
have more holes, the salt or the pepper?

”
The answer is not as straightforward as you

might think.

It depends on a variety of factors such as
cultural norms, health considerations, and

personal preferences.

So let’s explore all of these considerations
one by one:

Cultural Practices and Historical Considerations
Historically, salt has been a crucial ingredient,

enhancing flavors and preserving foods.

Its importance dates back to prehistoric times,
with its production traced to 450 BC in China.

Pepper, on the other hand, originating from
India, has been exported for about 4000 years.

Before shakers and grinders, pepper was prepared
using a mortar and pestle.

The origin of the salt and pepper shaker is
attributed to John Mason in the mid-1800s,

but it only became widespread in the 1920s.

This was after Morton introduced magnesium
carbonate to salt, ensuring a more free-flowing

pour of the salt.

Before this, salt was kept in cellars and
broken into clumps or kept in bowls with spoons.

The introduction of magnesium carbonate revolutionized
salt storage and usage.

That’s why The Morton Salt company later
adopted the slogan "When it rains it pours",

meaning that its salt containing magnesium
carbonate would not stick together in humid

weather.

.
As ceramics became more common, the design

and popularity of shakers evolved, turning
them into collectibles and souvenirs.

The Smithsonian highlights that most salt
shakers have one hole, while pepper shakers

have two or three.

The Great Depression boosted the popularity
of these shakers due to their affordability.

The pairing of salt and pepper, despite their
distinct flavors and uses, led to them being

marketed together.

However, it's essential to differentiate between
a pepper shaker and a pepper mill or grinder.

Modern times have seen the evolution of shakers,
with electric peppermills and specialty saltshakers

emerging.

There's even a museum in Tennessee dedicated
to salt and pepper shakers, showcasing over

20,000 pairs of different type of salt and
pepper shakers.

These shakers, while functional, also serve
as nostalgic relics and souvenirs, and their

future remains promising as they continue
to hold sentimental value on dining tables.

Counter to public belief, the number of holes
in a shaker is not universally standardized

and varies greatly based on cultural practices
and historical reasons.

In the United States, for instance, salt shakers
generally have fewer holes.

This practice is influenced by health trends
advocating for lower sodium intake.

On the other hand, in parts of Europe, it’s
not uncommon to find pepper shakers with fewer

holes, a practice rooted in historical times
when pepper was considered a valuable commodity,

so you don’t want to use too much of it.

So how about the health considerations?

Let’s talk about it with our next PAA:
Health Consideration: Can fewer holes in a

salt shaker reduce how much salt we use?

Health consciousness can significantly impact
the design and usage of salt and pepper shakers.

As awareness grows regarding the health risks
of excessive salt consumption, such as high

blood pressure and heart disease, many people
are making efforts to reduce their sodium

intake.

This shift in health awareness has led to
the design of salt shakers with fewer holes,

especially in health-conscious societies like
the US.

However, when it comes to controlling salt
intake, the size of the holes a salt shaker

has might have a bigger impact compared to
the number of holes.

A study conducted by Greenfield H, Smith AM,
and Wills RB, published in “Human nutrition.

Applied Nutrition” on 1984 , provides valuable
insights into this topic.

The research involved 2,241 Australian adults
who consumed main meals at a cafeteria.

The salt shakers, both single-holed and multi-holed
(with 5, 9, 13 holes), were weighed before

and after use.

The findings revealed that for all hole numbers,
salt usage increased linearly with an increase

in hole area.

Interestingly, for a given hole area, multi-holed
shakers resulted in decreased salt use compared

to single-holed shakers.

This suggests that multi-holed shakers offer
consumers better control over salt dispensing.

I mean, accidentally putting too much salt
into your food is the worst of both worlds,

cuz then you would not only ingest too much
sodium but also would not enjoy it.

However, the most significant reduction in
salt use, amounting to 0.37 g per meal, was

achieved using a single-holed shaker with
a hole area of 3 mm^2.

So if you want to reduce your salt intake,
remember that the hole size of shakers should

also be taken into account.

That led to our next consideration:
Grain Size and Practicality Consideration

Another essential factor to consider is the
size and texture of the salt and pepper grains.

Some salts and peppers are coarse, while others
are very fine, which impacts how easily they

pour from the shakers.

The practicality of usage tends to outweigh
traditional norms in this case.

Larger, coarser grains require larger holes
to dispense properly, irrespective of whether

it’s salt or pepper.

That led to our next point:
Personal Preference Consideration

Obviously, personal preference plays a crucial
role.

The best advice is to match your shaker’s
hole size with the type of salt or pepper

you’re using to get your desired result.

For instance, if you prefer using coarse Himalayan
pink salt or cracked black pepper, you might

need to modify your shakers to have larger
holes.

Your salt and pepper shakers should serve
your needs first and foremost, making your

seasoning experience as smooth and enjoyable
as possible

So here’s my conclusion, the number of holes
in your salt and pepper shaker should depend

on your individual taste, health considerations,
and the specific type of salt or pepper you’re

using.

So If you made it to the end of the video,
chances are that you enjoy learning what people

also ask on Google.

But let's face it, reading PAA yourself will
be a pain.

So here's the deal, I will do the reading
for you and upload a video compiling some

fun PAAs once a week, all you have to do is
to hit the subscribe button and the bell icon

so you won't miss any PAA report that I compile.

So just do it right now.

Bye!