-
- There are a lot of
misconceptions out there,
-
and this is a video about
one of the most common ones.
-
So I went around asking people
-
"What makes the Moon go around the Earth?"
-
And they told me...
-
- The Earth puts a
gravitational force on the Moon.
-
- But does the Moon put a
gravitational pull on the Earth?
-
- Pull on the Earth? Yes it does,
-
hence we have tides, et cetera.
-
- The Moon pulls on the Earth too.
-
It affects like the tides and women.
-
(both laughing)
-
It does, it's very powerful.
-
- Does the Moon pull on the Earth?
-
- Probably that as well, yeah.
-
- So what I want to know
is how does that force,
-
that the Moon exerts on the Earth,
-
how does that compare in terms of size
-
to the force the Earth exerts on the Moon?
-
- Well, I'm no scientist,
-
but I think that one would be
more powerful than that one.
-
- It's got a greater force
coming from the Earth,
-
'cause it's greater mass.
-
- 'Cause the Earth probably has more mass.
-
- 'Cause it's a big mass.
-
I thought greater mass is
more like, is more force.
-
- Does the Moon pull on the Earth?
-
- Yes.
-
But a lot less.
-
- Yeah, Not as much as the
Earth pulls on the Moon.
-
- Yeah, but a little bit.
-
- But not very strongly.
-
- Yes, but much, much, much, much smaller.
-
- Because of its mass, size
-
- It's got less Mass
-
- Because it's smaller, it's
much smaller than the Earth.
-
- Because it's smaller.
-
- Because it's smaller.
-
- Allow me to let you
in on a little secret.
-
Everyone got it wrong.
-
The force that attracts
the Moon to the Earth
-
is exactly the same size
-
as the force that attracts
the Earth to the Moon.
-
So what's going on here?
-
Why did everyone get it wrong?
-
Well I think it comes
down to cause and effect.
-
The effect of the force on
the Moon is quite clear.
-
The Moon goes in circles around the Earth,
-
but the effect of that force on the Earth
-
is basically negligible.
-
The Earth barely wobbles at all.
-
So people interpret this negligible effect
-
as indicating there's very
little force affecting the Earth,
-
but that is forgetting the
third key piece of the puzzle
-
which is inertia.
-
Inertia is the tendency of mass
-
to maintain its state of motion.
-
Since the Earth has a greater mass,
-
it has a greater inertia.
-
And so even with the same
amount of force on it,
-
it doesn't accelerate that much.
-
Now the funny thing is many
of the people I interviewed
-
could state Newton's
third law, which is...
-
Every force has...
-
- an equal and opposite reaction.
-
- Something about Newton's law
-
doesn't seem to fit into that.
-
(laughing)
-
- You're good at this.
-
(laughing)
-
Which Newton's law are we talking about?
-
- The whole equal and
opposite force thing?
-
Yeah, that one.
-
- So tell me what you're thinking now.
-
- Uh well, one would think that
-
if the Earth putting a force on me,
-
I would be putting an equal force upon it.
-
- So why didn't they
apply it to this problem?
-
Well, I think they may
have memorized the words,
-
but not really believe Newton's
third law in their core.
-
Do they really feel it in their spleen?
-
I don't think they did.
-
So, allow me to try to
convince you, all of you,
-
spleen included
-
that Newton's third law really is true.
-
Let's consider two objects.
-
Initially they have the same
mass, one kilogram each.
-
So obviously the gravitational
force of attraction
-
must be the same on both of the objects.
-
Now let's add a second
kilogram to the first object.
-
The force on the second object
will now be twice as great
-
because that one kilogram
is attracted equally
-
to each of the kilograms
in the first object.
-
But what is often forgotten,
is that new kilogram
-
is also attracted to the second object.
-
Meaning that the total
force on each object
-
is still the same.
-
They're attracted to each other
-
with an equal and opposite force.
-
We could add a third kilogram
-
and we would find the same thing,
-
the force on both objects
is still the same,
-
even though the object on the
left has three times the mass
-
of the object on the right.
-
So we can see that no
matter what the mass,
-
any two objects will have
the same gravitational force
-
towards each other.
-
Can you feel Newton's third
law in your spleen now?
-
It should settle inside you
and become a part of you.