-
Would you ever forgive a person
who kills a member of your family?
-
In September of 2019,
-
Dallas police officer Amber Guyger
was sentenced for murder,
-
and then the brother of the victim
-
forgave her.
-
Brandt Jean was 18 years old,
-
and I joined the rest of the country
watching on television in awe
-
at that act of grace.
-
But I also worried.
-
I worried that people
who are African American like Brandt Jean
-
are expected to forgive
more often than other people.
-
And I worried that a white
police officer like Amber Guyger
-
receives a lesser sentence
-
than other people
who commit wrongful killings.
-
But because I'm a law professor,
-
I also worried about the law itself.
-
The law leans so severely
towards punishment these days
-
that it's part of the problem.
-
And that's what I want to talk about here.
-
The powerful example
of one individual's forgiveness
-
makes me worry that lawyers and officials
too often overlook the tools
-
that law itself creates
to allow forgiveness,
-
when the principle should be
the cornerstone of a thriving society.
-
I worry that lawyers and officials do not
adequately use the tools of forgiveness,
-
by which I mean letting go
of justified grievance.
-
And those tools are many.
-
They include pardons,
commutations, expungement,
-
bankruptcy for debt,
-
and the discretion that's held
by police and prosecutors and judges.
-
But I also worry -- I worry a lot --
-
(Laughter)
-
I worry these tools, when used,
replicate the disparities,
-
the inequities along the lines
of race and class and other markers
-
of advantage and disadvantage.
-
Biases or privileged access are at work
-
when United States presidents
pardon people charged with crimes.
-
Historically, white people
are pardoned four times as often
-
as members of minority groups
for the same crime, same sentence.
-
Forgiveness between individuals
is supported by every religious tradition,
-
every philosophic tradition.
-
And medical evidence now shows
-
the health benefits of letting go
of grievances and resentments.
-
As Nelson Mandela
led South Africa's transition
-
from apartheid to democracy,
-
he explained,
-
"Resentment is like drinking a poison
and hoping it will kill your enemies."
-
Law can remove the penalties for those
who apologize and seek forgiveness.
-
For example, in 39 states
in the United States
-
and the District of Columbia,
-
there are laws that allow
medical professionals to apologize
-
when something goes wrong
-
and not fear that that statement
could later be used against them
-
in an action for damages.
-
More actively, bankruptcy law
offers debtors, under some conditions,
-
the chance to start anew.
-
Pardons and expungements
sealing criminal records can, too.
-
I have been teaching law
for almost 40 years, hard to believe,
-
but recently, I realized
-
that we don't teach law students
about the tools of forgiveness
-
that are within the legal system,
-
and nor do law schools
usually explore
-
the potential for new
avenues for forgiveness
-
that law can adopt or assist.
-
These are lost opportunities.
-
These are lost obligations, even,
-
because the students that I teach
-
will become prosecutors, judges,
governors, presidents.
-
Barack Obama, my former student,
-
used his power as the President
of the United States to give pardons.
-
That released several hundred people
from prison after the law changed
-
to provide shorter sentences
for the same drug crimes
-
for which they had been convicted.
-
But if he hadn't used his pardon power,
they would still be in prison.
-
Legal tools of forgiveness
should be used more,
-
but not without reason and not with bias.
-
A "New Yorker" cartoon shows a judge
with a big nose and a big mustache
-
looking down at a defendant
with the exact same nose
-
and exact same mustache
-
and says, "Obviously not guilty."
-
(Laughter)
-
Forgiveness could undermine
the commitment that law has
-
to treat people the same
under the same circumstances,
-
to apply rules evenly.
-
In this age of resentment,
mass incarceration,
-
widespread consumer debt,
-
we need more forgiveness,
but we need a philosophy of forgiveness.
-
We need to forgive fairly.
-
Contrast the treatment globally
of child soldiers
-
with the treatment of juvenile
offenders in the United States.
-
International human rights
condemn and punish adults
-
who involve children in armed conflict
-
as those most responsible,
-
but treat the children themselves
quite differently.
-
The International Criminal Court,
-
now with 122 member nations,
-
convicted Thomas Lubanga, warlord
in the [Democratic Republic of the] Congo,
-
for enlisting, recruiting and deploying
children, teens, as soldiers.
-
Many nations commit to ensuring
that people under the age of 15
-
do not become child soldiers,
-
and most nations treat those
who do become soldiers
-
not as objects of punishment
-
but as people deserving a fresh start.
-
Compare and contrast how the United States
treats juvenile offenders,
-
where we severely punish minors,
-
often moving them to adult courts,
even adult prisons.
-
And yet, like child soldiers,
-
teens and children are drawn
into violent activity in the United States
-
when there are few options,
-
when they are threatened
-
or when adults induce them
with money or ideology.
-
The rhetoric of innocence is resonant
when we talk about child soldiers,
-
but not when we talk about
teen gang members in the United States.
-
Yet in both settings, youth are caught
in worlds that are made by adults,
-
and forgiveness can offer
both accountability and fresh starts.
-
What if, instead, young people
caught in criminal activity and violence
-
could have chances
to accept responsibility
-
while learning and rebuilding their lives
and their own communities?
-
Legal frameworks inviting youth
to describe their conduct
-
could also involve community members
to hear and forgive.
-
Called "restorative justice,"
-
such efforts emphasize
accountability and service
-
rather than punishment.
-
Many schools in the United States have
turned to use restorative justice methods
-
to resolve conflicts and to prevent them,
-
and to disrupt
the school-to-prison pipeline.
-
Some American high schools
have replaced automatic suspensions
-
with opportunities for victims
to narrate their experiences
-
and for offenders to take
responsibility for their actions.
-
As they describe their experiences
and feelings about a theft
-
or hateful graffiti or a verbal
or physical assault,
-
the victims and offenders
often express strong emotions.
-
And other members
of the community take turns
-
describing the impact
of the offense on them.
-
The leader is often a student peer,
who is trained to deescalate the conflict
-
and orchestrate a conversation
about what the offender can do
-
that would help the victim.
-
Together, they come to an agreement
about how to move forward,
-
what the wrongdoer can do
to repair the injury,
-
and what all could do
to better avoid future conflicts.
-
Consider this example,
recently in a publication.
-
A young woman named Mercedes M.
transferred, in California,
-
from one high school to another
-
after she was so repeatedly suspended
in her old high school
-
for getting into fights.
-
And here in her new high school,
-
two other young women accused her of lying
-
and called her the b-word.
-
A counselor came over and talked to her
and earned enough trust
-
that she acknowledged she had stolen
the shoes of one of the other classmates.
-
Turns out, the three of them
had known each other for a long time,
-
and they didn't know any other way
to deal with each other
-
other than to fight.
-
The facilitator invited them
to participate in a circle,
-
a confidential conversation
about what happened,
-
and they agreed.
-
And initially, each of them
expressed a lot of emotion.
-
And then Mercedes apologized.
-
And she said she had stolen the shoes
-
but she did so because
she wanted to sell them
-
and take the money to pay for a drug test
-
so that her mother
could show she was clean
-
and try to regain custody
of two younger children
-
who were then in state protective care.
-
The other girls heard this,
-
saw Mercedes crying,
-
and they hugged her.
-
They did not ask her
to return what she'd stolen,
-
but they did say they wanted a restart.
-
They wanted a reason they could trust her.
-
Later, Mercedes explained
-
that she was sure she would
have been suspended
-
if they hadn't had this process.
-
And her high school has reduced
suspensions by more than half
-
through the use of this kind
of restorative justice method.
-
Restorative justice alternatives
involve offenders and victims
-
in communicating in ways
-
that an adversarial and defensive
process does not allow,
-
and it's become the go-to method
-
in places like the District of Columbia
juvenile justice system
-
and innovations like
Los Angeles's Teen Court.
-
If tuned to fairness,
-
forgiveness methods like bankruptcy
would be available
-
not only for the for-profit college
that goes belly-up
-
but also for the students
stuck with the loans;
-
pardons would not be given
to campaign contributors;
-
and black men would no longer have
20 percent longer criminal sentences
-
than do white men,
-
due to how judges exercise discretion.
-
Forgiveness across the board
is one way to avoid such biases.
-
Sometimes, a society just needs a reset
-
when it comes to punishment and debt.
-
The Bible calls for periodic
forgiveness of debts
-
and freeing prisoners,
-
and it recently helped to inspire
a global movement.
-
Jubilee 2000 joined Pope John Paul II
-
and rock star Bono and over 60 nations
-
in an effort to seek the cancellation
and succeed in canceling
-
the debt of developing countries,
-
amounting to over 100 billion dollars
-
of debt canceled,
-
resulting in measurable
reduction in poverty.
-
In a similar spirit, there are people
who are copying the techniques
-
of commercial debt collectors
-
who purchase debt
for pennies on the dollar
-
and then seek to enforce it.
-
Late-night television host John Oliver
partnered with a nonprofit group
-
called RIP Medical Debt,
-
and for only 60,000 dollars,
-
they purchased 15 million dollars'
worth of medical debt,
-
and then they forgave it.
-
(Applause)
-
That allowed nearly 9,000 people
to have a restart in their lives.
-
This kind of precedent should trigger
and encourage more such actions.
-
It's time for a reset,
-
given mass incarceration,
-
medical and consumer debt
-
and given indigent criminal defendants
-
who are charged and put in debt
-
because they're expected to pay
for their own probation officers
-
and their own electronic monitors.
-
Forgiving violations of law
-
or promises to pay back loans
-
does pose risks.
-
Forgiveness may encourage more violations.
-
Economists even have a name for it.
-
They call it "moral hazard."
-
Should there be amnesty
for immigration violations?
-
Should a president offer pardons
to protect himself
-
or to induce lawbreaking?
-
These are tough questions for our time.
-
But escalating resentments
hold their own dangers.
-
So does attributing blame to individuals
-
for circumstances largely outside
their own control.
-
To ask how law may forgive
is not to deny the fact of wrongdoing.
-
Rather, it's to widen the lens,
-
to enable glimpses of the larger patterns
-
and to enable new choices
that can go forward
-
if we can wipe the slate clean.
-
Thank you.
-
(Applause)