-
PROFESSOR: I'll
go over the exam.
-
It's good review for
the final, and it's
-
a good feedback for you in
case you have questions.
-
I do not change grades,
I do not curve your exam.
-
I do not make adjustments
after I give you the grade.
-
Therefore, it's very
important for me
-
to explain why you
got what you got.
-
Not everybody did
well on this exam.
-
Most people did
pretty good, and I'm
-
quite happy with what I see
as a average for the class.
-
However, there are
many open questions
-
from many people, things
they didn't quite understand,
-
and I would like
to discuss those.
-
-
First of all, the midterm
exam was 11 questions.
-
10 were mandatory, so
the maximum possible
-
percentage-wise was 110%.
-
So for somebody who
did perfectly fine,
-
they would have 110%.
-
-
There is one person
only who got the high.
-
I didn't disclose
his name, but I would
-
like to say congratulations.
-
And I'm going to go ahead and
solve each problem with you,
-
for you.
-
So you have the
function f of x, y,
-
to be x squared minus y squared.
-
And the differential was f
sub x dx plus f sub y dy,
-
whihc is 2x dx, minus 2y dy.
-
-
That was something very easy.
-
It was not supposed to give you
any headache, and most of you
-
did a fine job on this one.
-
What created some
problems to most students
-
was the second problem, though.
-
And I sorry to hear
that, sorry to see that.
-
Find the directional
derivative of a function,
-
the same function as before.
-
-
So I have taken advantage
of the previous problem,
-
in order to make
your do time shorter.
-
At the point p of coordinates
x equals 0, y equals 1,
-
you will have a direction
given by the vector.
-
What does it mean
direction given?
-
Analyze that direction given
by the vector means what?
-
Not the vector i minus j is y,
because it's not a unit vector.
-
What is the corresponding
direction given by it?
-
A corresponding
direction given by it
-
is 1 over square root of 2i
minus 1 over square root of 2j.
-
So it's a collinear vector--
that is, unit varies.
-
Say it again, [INAUDIBLE]?
-
The direction u represents
a collinear vector.
-
So pointing in the
same direction as v,
-
but it has to be unitary.
-
Why?
-
Because the definition of
the directional derivative
-
is a function along the
direction u at the point p,
-
was given by the formula
partial derivative at p
-
and at 1, plus partial
derivative at p times 2.
-
Did I expect to
write all this down?
-
Yes, I did, as I
showed you last time.
-
So you have 2x evaluated
at-- what is x?
-
0.
-
1 times u1.
-
This is u1 minus 2y,
evaluated at 0, 1 times
-
minus 1 over root
2, which is u2.
-
-
Well that means the
first term goes away,
-
because this is going to be 0.
-
And after the second
term, you have a plus.
-
y is 1, thank god, that's easy.
-
2 over square root of
2, the answer is root 2.
-
So any other answer would
normally receiving a 0.
-
The answer was b, square root 2.
-
Now, on number three, the
function given is different.
-
f of x, y equals e to the xy.
-
-
And they say, the
gradient of this function
-
is at an arbitrary point.
-
Say is again?
-
The gradient of this function
is at an arbitrary point.
-
That was only part
of the problem.
-
A little bit of credit for
just writing the gradient.
-
This is actually
easy, a piece of cake.
-
y is that.
-
You have f sub x
i plus f sub y j.
-
It equals y to the xy
i plus x to the xyj.
-
That's very good.
-
-
Alright, OK?
-
Then, which direction-- it's
just the gradient right?
-
The direction corresponds
to the gradient.
-
They don't ask you for the u.
-
Actually, you don't need the u.
-
You just need the tangent
plane in this case.
-
And if you know the equation
of the tangent plane,
-
as I told you to remember that,
that would be very helpful.
-
Write your answer in
the space provided.
-
So what did I expect you to do?
-
First this, and then write
the equation z minus z0
-
equals f sub x times x minus
x0, plus f sub y, y minus y0.
-
Here at the point p,
evaluate it at the point p.
-
But attention, what
is the point p?
-
Well, p is the origin,
because we say at the origin.
-
Oh, so that makes things easier.
-
I'm not done.
-
Half of the problem
is still coming.
-
If you did until this point, I
can only give you 5 out of 10
-
or something like that.
-
-
Many people made
a mistake at z0.
-
Attention guys, you plus
in that 0, you don't get 0.
-
For god's sake, it's 1, right?
-
So z0 is 1.
-
Now you're getting
the sense that you
-
have z minus 1 equals
f sub x, computed as 0,
-
0 will be 0, lucky you.
-
f sub y computed at 0, 0, you
were expected to say that.
-
So the answer for this
problem was z equals 1.
-
Still, if you messed up, I
gave some partial credit,
-
because I didn't want to punish
you too much, too harshly.
-
-
On number four, find
the direction u-- now
-
you're using number
three, so I should not
-
erase number three completely.
-
On number four, you
use number three, so
-
the same type of function.
-
But it says find the
direction in which
-
this function increases most
rapidly, at the point 1, 1.
-
OK.
-
So what do you do? you compute
the gradient at the point 1,1,
-
and you say, this
is a piece of cake.
-
It's going to be ei plus ej, ee.
-
-
Wonderful.
-
So what you do is a u is the
gradient f over the length
-
of the gradient of f at p.
-
Which is ee divided
by the length of it.
-
But you say, I don't have
to compute the length of it.
-
I know what is pulling
your two e's is what?
-
And no matter what you have here
you get the same unique result.
-
Remember we talked
about that uniqueness?
-
This is what I
tried to emphasize,
-
that you can have 77,
ee, 99, 55, 100 and 100.
-
If you divide by the norm,
you still get the same answer.
-
Not 11, but 1 over
root 2, 1 over root 2.
-
So no matter what
you had there--
-
it could have had a million,
or something instead of e,
-
you still have the same u.
-
-
Yes, put it back.
-
Give yourself
points, modify that.
-
-
OK, so let me tell you.
-
Normally I should penalize,
because I say write the answer
-
in the space provided.
-
And thank god you had
enough space, right?
-
Look, this person wrote--
I shouldn't show you who
-
he is, he's not in here anyway.
-
He has space and he
provided last year
-
with no square root
of 2, because only two
-
rows are enough to write that.
-
It's OK, I understand
you forgot to copy.
-
My son did the same thing.
-
He got a scantron at the UIL.
-
Come to visit my son, I wanted
to kill him, but it's OK.
-
He got all the answers
right, and then
-
the teacher-- that reminds
me of a movie with Mr. Bean.
-
So the teacher comes
to him and says,
-
wow your scantron is blank.
-
So what was I supposed to do?
-
Adjust for all the answers
you got in the box,
-
put them in the scantron.
-
Oh, really?
-
So he goes quickly.
-
And then he got only
75% of them transferred.
-
The rest of them
were not transferred.
-
I don't know what they did.
-
I have no idea.
-
But the professor would
have given full credit,
-
even for the answers
that he had in the box.
-
From what I understood,
the rule for scantrons,
-
exams like you I only say,
if you don't have them
-
on the scantron,
they don't count.
-
This is very harsh,
because we don't do that.
-
For example, the
final-- if you--
-
that's why I'm trying
to read everything.
-
Suppose you box you answer and
it's 1 over square root of 2.
-
If that's the right answer.
-
Then if have the
multiple choice,
-
and they forgot to circle
1 over square root of 2.
-
I still give you
100% on that problem.
-
Some professor do not.
-
So this is at the latitude
at whoever makes the rules,
-
or whoever writes the exam.
-
OK.
-
-
So again for the final, even for
the multiple choice problems,
-
I still need the solutions.
-
I'm going to ask you
to use a bluebook.
-
Some professors do not
ask you to use a bluebook.
-
They say, as long as you can
write on the sheet, circle
-
the answer, I'm fine.
-
I'm not fine.
-
I want to keep what's
in the bluebook.
-
So buy-- how much is it?
-
Like a dollar?
-
Buy the books ahead of time,
make sure you have them.
-
Now, number five was a piece of
cake once you did number four.
-
You have a question?
-
STUDENT: What size bluebook
do you need for the final?
-
PROFESSOR: The big one.
-
Bigger than that, right?
-
The direction u for five.
-
With the problem four was i
plus j over root 2, right?
-
This is what you remember
that you did in problem four.
-
If you didn't do problem four,
you cannot do problem five.
-
Problem five says, this
is parallel to one line.
-
This is parallel to--
what is i plus j?
-
Of course, you don't
have to draw that.
-
I'm not expecting
you to draw that.
-
y equals x is the
first bisection.
-
-
All you had to do was
circle C, and that
-
was-- once you circled
C, you get full credit.
-
If you don't do that, you
don't get credit for anything.
-
Now six.
-
What is the maximum rate
of increase of the function
-
z the same of your friend,
your fellow z equals
-
e to the xy at p0,
coordinates 1, 1?
-
Then the value of the
maximum rate of change is?
-
A noun.
-
-
What's the simplest
way to do it?
-
There are two ways to do it.
-
One is the long way,
one is the short way.
-
What's the short way, guys?
-
Just compute the
length of the gradient.
-
The length of the
gradient at the point P.
-
So you have whatever
that was, ee in length.
-
So the answer was e root 2.
-
Am I right?
-
What was the long way?
-
I saw somebody do it.
-
This is a lot more
work, but of course,
-
would be to compute the
directional derivative
-
at the point p
for this function.
-
In the direction of u,
where u is the gradient
-
divided by the length.
-
at the point p.
-
And you get, of course,
the same answer.
-
Why?
-
Because we proved that actually
the maximum rate of change
-
represented directional
derivative exactly
-
in the direction
given by the gradient.
-
This is something we proved.
-
One of the few things
we proved in this class.
-
Alright.
-
So the answer was e root 2.
-
Let's move on to number seven.
-
Number seven-- and remind
me of your five points.
-
Can you email me, so
I have an Excel sheet,
-
and I'll put it in.
-
Consider the function f of x,
y e to the negative x squared,
-
y squared.
-
What can you tell me about
this type of function?
-
It's the headache function.
-
If I would ask you to do
an anti-derivative of each
-
of the negative squares,
you would say Magdalene,
-
didn't you say that
this is impossible?
-
While the anti-derivative
exists, it cannot be expressed.
-
It cannot be expressed as
an elementary function.
-
And that's a big headache.
-
This problem is beautiful,
why is it beautiful?
-
Because in the end,
it becomes magic.
-
So it's a positive function.
-
It's like a bell on top
of the church something.
-
And then, you have to
compute double integral
-
over the unit disk of
centers of 0 and radius 1.
-
Of e to the negative x
squared minus y squared dx/dy.
-
-
Well then you say, well
I've done this kind of thing
-
before, but not with
Cartesian coordinates.
-
We did it with the Jacobian
r, that changes everything
-
into polar coordinates.
-
So this guy becomes e
to the minus r squared.
-
Each of the numbers are
squared dr, d theta.
-
D on the unit
[INAUDIBLE] disk means
-
the radius goes from 0 to 1.
-
This is a blessing for us,
because it's easy data.
-
Then we have 0 to 2 pi.
-
You could have put
it in any order.
-
For u, it's easier to close your
eyes when it comes to theta.
-
Say, theta is independent.
-
He is like a partition
that has to do nothing
-
with what's inside here.
-
So let's pull him
out of this picture.
-
And he wants to live by himself.
-
An integral from 0 to 2 pi of
d theta was of course 2 pi.
-
He's happy to go
out, having fun.
-
This guy inside has to
be thoroughly computed.
-
In the sense that you
perform the substitution.
-
I was actually amused that half
of you did u equals r squared,
-
and half of you did u
equals minus r squared.
-
It really doesn't
matter which one.
-
But the problem is
that some of you
-
made a mess when you put the
limit points back in place,
-
and you made mistakes.
-
Somebody even got
negative answers,
-
I was about to
fall off the chair.
-
Of course, I was in a good
mood because it was a holiday,
-
I graded them.
-
Fortunately, I graded
them over the break.
-
So after I came
back from Georgia.
-
I have minus r dr. rdr
was minus a half du.
-
-
This fellow is just
into the u, and he's
-
a blessing because
the [INAUDIBLE]
-
So into the u, however,
take it between 1 and what?
-
Not 0 and 1.
-
But when you have 0
here, you have 0 here.
-
When you have 1,
you have minus 1.
-
So pay attention to
that, otherwise, you
-
get something that
makes no sense.
-
Times minus a half.
-
That, you will have
to be careful about.
-
Why?
-
Because there will be a minus
from here and here, in the end,
-
the answer will be positive.
-
And that's reminding me
of that city plumber joke
-
when he doesn't pay attention
to the limits of integration.
-
And you can get a minus
volume, or a minus area.
-
So e to the minus 1 minus 1.
-
But that leaves a
negative number,
-
but when you multiply it by a
minus, you have 1 minus 1/e.
-
1 minus 1/e.
-
-
Good, thank god.
-
This is a nice guy, less than 1.
-
And this is key to your
answer, because 2 goes away
-
and pi stays in place
and this is less than pi.
-
So the answer to this question
was an answer less than pi.
-
And if you didn't get
it, I'm very sorry,
-
if you didn't get less than
pi, you didn't get any points.
-
But, there are enough chances
for you to get another point.
-
I was brokenhearted for 10
people or more out of 25
-
did not remember what I
taught in class about the area
-
of a collateral triangle.
-
And it broke my heart,
and I was about to cry,
-
but I said, c'mon, they'll
do it better in the final.
-
Honestly, I was
so brokenhearted.
-
So this is 1, 0, 0.
-
This was 0, 1, 0.
-
This was 0, 0, 1.
-
On number eight.
-
Thank you.
-
-
Beautiful.
-
It's an equilateral
triangle, and the l side
-
of that equilateral triangle
is the square root of 2.
-
I even taught you how to cheat.
-
That's why I was mad.
-
I taught you how to cheat,
and you didn't take advantage.
-
So the area was l squared,
square root of 2, 4.
-
Which we did this together
in fifth or sixth grade
-
by multiplying that height and
the width and divided by 2.
-
And then we came up with this
formula with the Pythagorean
-
theorem in the classroom.
-
If eligible to, you can
very quickly get an answer.
-
So that's going to be 2 root
2 over 4, just root 3 over 2.
-
And when I saw that people got
something else except root 3
-
over 2, that broke my heart.
-
Really.
-
You have plenty of
time to catch up
-
with that being on your final.
-
-
Did I expect you to really
do the surface integral?
-
Some people again, need to write
integral over the shaded domain
-
d a square root
of f sub x squared
-
plus f sub y squared plus 1.
-
That was the right track,
because this is root 3.
-
And then the area, you get the
area of the 1 times 1 over 2,
-
right?
-
1/3 is the area.
-
Root 3 gets out of this, so
you have-- when you integrate,
-
you have the area of the
shaded base that I have.
-
And you get the same answer.
-
No matter how you do
it, with calculators
-
or without calculators, you
still could have passed.
-
Am I if you didn't
get the answer?
-
No.
-
Absolutely.
-
But it hurts me as if, I
don't know, a relative of mine
-
messed up some task.
-
That's why it's better that
you don't know your students,
-
because when you
know your students,
-
you know that they
could have done better,
-
because you know them.
-
So we can say, OK,
it really hurts
-
when you know that they messed
up, not because they are not
-
smart or educated, but because
they just either didn't
-
pay attention or they
were stressed out.
-
However, my substitute,
the guy who came here,
-
was my Ph.D. student.
-
He got a doctoral degree
mathematics with me last year.
-
And he told me you were
not stressed out at all.
-
And I said, thank god.
-
I'm glad that they were calm.
-
And he said, I didn't
look at the exam,
-
but it seemed like they did very
well and they were comfortable.
-
And I was so happy.
-
I was in Athens, Georgia.
-
And reading this
email I said, yay!
-
Everybody's going to get an A!
-
So I come home and
I start grading it.
-
I was sad to see that my
prediction was not correct.
-
But anyway, [INAUDIBLE]
with an average of B.
-
For an honors class, it's OK.
-
I just expected a lot better.
-
And I know it's going to be
a lot better in the final.
-
Number nine.
-
This was done by
almost everybody,
-
except for a few people who
messed up on the limits.
-
I don't know why.
-
When they compute-- when they
drew, they drew x squared,
-
and they drew square root of xn.
-
Of course, you were supposed--
the answer was 0 to 1,
-
integral of.
-
Now, if you do first
x, you have x from y
-
squared to square root of y.
-
You guys with me?
-
Because this is
smaller than that.
-
OK?
-
So you have 1 and dx dy equals
to integral from 0 to 1,
-
integral x squared to
square root of x1 dy dx.
-
-
Now, what a few people did--
and I just forgave them.
-
They just-- one
put this like that.
-
And here, he put root 2.
-
Root y and y squared.
-
Don't do that.
-
It's like chasing that
a positive number equals
-
a negative number, which
is all complete nonsense.
-
So the correct answer was
we put y squared down,
-
and square root of y
because this guy is
-
bigger than this guy for
something between 0 and 1.
-
Because I told you.
-
Square root of 0.04 is bigger
than the square of that.
-
OK.
-
Now am I happy with that?
-
I'm quite happy.
-
In general, people understood
the vertical strip method
-
compared to the
horizontal strip method.
-
And why am I happy?
-
Because I was asked by three
people from other classes
-
to help them, over
there, on the corridor.
-
And I asked them,
who is your teacher?
-
This and that.
-
But we did not understand
reversing the order
-
of integration in class.
-
And I said, how come?
-
Well, they didn't
explain it very well.
-
So I started
explaining it to them.
-
And then I realized that
it's a conflict of interest.
-
I'm not allowed to do that.
-
And then I go, oh my god, I
cannot do the homework for you.
-
I'm not allowed.
-
But I was already talking.
-
So I said, guys, can you do it?
-
I don't know.
-
I said, do you draw?
-
Why would we draw?
-
They didn't teach
us how to draw.
-
I said, but how do you
know about vertical strips
-
and horizontal strips?
-
No.
-
And how do you do this?
-
We don't know.
-
We felt like we have
to figure it out.
-
Without drawing, without
understanding how the vertical
-
strips are drawn
between two functions,
-
and how you switch
the horizontal strips,
-
you cannot do this
problem, period.
-
So if you don't have--
maybe some people have
-
enough imagination--
but that's very rare--
-
That they can close
their eyes and they
-
can see a picture
with their eyes closed
-
and they can solve that.
-
But that's not the way to learn.
-
The way to learn is a very
visual learning thing.
-
So that's why we
draw all the time.
-
-
STUDENT: Professor, you
can cheat these with Cal 2.
-
PROFESSOR: Yes.
-
You can do that with Cal 2.
-
What's the problem?
-
You have integral from 0 to 1.
-
Square root of y
minus y squared.
-
Well, they learn to
do the other one.
-
The one with square root x
minus x squared, 0,1 and so on.
-
But they were told explicitly
to write-- the professor even
-
left these empty and put
spaces, fill in the spaces.
-
And they say, how the heck
do we fill in those spaces?
-
Plus the whiteboard problems
have the empty spaces.
-
And they couldn't
believe that at all.
-
And one of them went to the
tutoring center and was lucky.
-
Because he got--
this is like when
-
you go to a medical
doctor, sometimes you
-
are lucky and get a good
doctor who takes care of you,
-
figures out what
your problem is.
-
And sometimes, they give
you the wrong medicine.
-
So one of them got the right
tutor who knew how to explain
-
and sort of knew something.
-
But the other one got a tutor
who never took Calculus 3
-
and said, I don't know what the
heck these multiple snakes are.
-
So I'm not going to
be able to help you.
-
So he was very disappointed.
-
OK.
-
Compute the area of the domain
D from the previous problem.
-
This was something that
nobody's telling you,
-
hey, you have to do it
with the double snakes.
-
You can do it with just
with a simple snake
-
and you're still fine.
-
So in Calc 1-- this
Calc 1, whatever it is.
-
In Calc 1, you learn that
you have to integrate this
-
and you'll get 2/3 x
to the 3/2 minus 1/3 x
-
cubed at x equals 1 minus
whatever you have with 0.
-
But at 0, you have 0, so
you say, forget about it.
-
And you have 2/3 minus 1/3
equals 1/3, then you're done.
-
OK?
-
Did I expect you
to show me work?
-
No.
-
For everybody who
wrote 1.3-- and there
-
were many people who
did this mentally,
-
and they came up with 1/3.
-
They got 10 pionts
on the problem.
-
Finally, number 11.
-
Without computing the
volume inside the sphere,
-
x squared plus y squared
plus z squared equals 2.
-
-
Set up a triple integral
corresponding to it
-
in the space provided below.
-
-
Some people, a few
people, messed up.
-
They forgot the Jacobian.
-
So they put the 1 instead of
r squared [? side-side. ?]
-
When you work in
three components,
-
they do fine setting
up the limits.
-
[INAUDIBLE] 1 here.
-
Don't look at it in the final.
-
You can ruin your life this way.
-
So we have r squared sine phi.
-
Phi was the latitude
from the North Pole.
-
it doesn't matter in
which order you do it.
-
But I would do to
er b phi b theta.
-
You tell me what the end
points are, and we are done.
-
STUDENT: From 0 to 5.
-
PROFESSOR: 0 to--
-
STUDENT: No, on the first one.
-
PROFESSOR: 0 to--
-
STUDENT: Dr?
-
It's the square root of 2.
-
PROFESSOR: Mm-hmm.
-
STUDENT: And b theta--
-
PROFESSOR: 0.
-
2pi.
-
And theta, all around.
-
STUDENT: 2pi.
-
PROFESSOR: Longitude
360 meridian degrees.
-
OK.
-
0 to 2pi.
-
So good.
-
So we are done.
-
Did I expect you
to write it down?
-
No.
-
I had three people who
were nice and wrote down 4.
-
I mean, they actually
did the work.
-
Maybe they had
nothing better to do.
-
I have no idea why.
-
4pi i cubed over 3, right?
-
And then they proved the formula
in general using the Jacobian.
-
Using the formula, they got
the correct formula for r
-
equals square root of 2.
-
And I was very happy.
-
But did I ask you to do that?
-
No.
-
Did I give you extra credit.
-
No.
-
So all the extra credit
was just one problem to
-
asked to do exactly what
you were told to do.
-
-
I don't know about how
you feel about this exam,
-
but it wasn't a hard exam.
-
It was not an easy exam.
-
It was an exam that
was supposed to test
-
what you learned until now
all through the course.
-
And that was the whole idea.
-
I think you've
learned very much,
-
and I think you did fine,
the majority of you.
-
And that should ease
the pressure on you
-
when it comes to
preparing for the final.
-
I was thinking last night, I'm
going to send you, probably
-
by email or in-person
in class, two
-
or three samples of the
final from old finals
-
that inspire us when
we write the final.
-
A few of us will provide
problems and comments
-
and suggestions when we write
out the departmental final.
-
But the final will be
departmental for all sections.
-
I don't expect more than
15 problems on the final.
-
I have yet to think and
decide if I want to [? lift ?]
-
probably the same policy.
-
I mean, the final is
the same for everybody.
-
But the policy about how
to give partial credit
-
or not give partial
credit. [INAUDIBLE].
-
And I already decided that
I'm going to read everything,
-
so in case that you mess up
at the end with your miracle
-
answer, you still
get partial credit
-
for your integrals
[INAUDIBLE] shown.
-
Also, one of those 15 problems.
might be for extra credit.
-
I have to think a
little bit better
-
how-- what is the maximum
weight I want to put.
-
What I would say, since I never
[INAUDIBLE] open a homework,
-
and I never curve
exams, I would think
-
I could make 110% as
the possible maximum.
-
In this case, you
have some cushion
-
to make a mistake or two and
still get a perfect score.
-
OK.
-
I'm going to move
on to a new chapter.
-
I have actually
moved on already,
-
but nobody believed me.
-
Last time, I started Chapter 13.
-
Chapter 13 is a mixture of
mathematics and physics.
-
You will be surprised
how many things
-
are coming from solid
mechanics, fluid mechanics.
-
Yes, Regan.
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE]
-
PROFESSOR: For a job?
-
You want me to come with you?
-
[LAUGHTER]
-
STUDENT: Because I tried
to talk to you [INAUDIBLE].
-
PROFESSOR: Yes, yes.
-
Yes.
-
Yeah.
-
And you have to sign up.
-
Start a [? sheet, ?] attend
[? the sheet, ?] and sign
-
your name and good luck
with the interview.
-
You should have told me before!
-
I could have said
a prayer for you.
-
This things are very stressful!
-
I remember my own interviews.
-
There were several.
-
I didn't know anything about it,
and my hands were all sweaty.
-
And you know you should never
shake hands with somebody
-
when your hands are sweaty.
-
You have to do like this first.
-
Be confident and
don't be nervous.
-
Don't sweat or anything.
-
Because they can see that.
-
All right.
-
You just be yourself.
-
Do you have earrings?
-
Because after my
several job interviews--
-
those are good earrings-- I
was told that I should never
-
wear dangling earrings at the
interviews, which I did not,
-
because I didn't have any.
-
But I love dangling earrings.
-
And I was asking some academics
why that was [? our ?] problem.
-
And they say they
are distracting.
-
Because mathematicians
are like cats.
-
[LAUGHTER]
-
PROFESSOR: --pendulum,
and then they
-
get hypnotized by the dangling.
-
So I don't know.
-
I think most of the
interviewers have some problems
-
and they find some things
distracting or annoying.
-
Otherwise, I think you are fine.
-
You're dressed fine
for an interview.
-
OK.
-
So now serious job.
-
We have to remember some of
the things we don't remember.
-
Which are the gradient for
a function of let's say
-
three variables.
-
Let's grow up a little bit.
-
And that was what
the vector field
-
F sub xi plus F sub
[? I j ?] plus F sub z k.
-
Right?
-
At an arbitrary point
xyz in your domain.
-
So where xyz is in some
domain, you are in a potato.
-
And the meaning of the gradient,
the geometric meaning of this,
-
doesn't look like a
theta [INAUDIBLE].
-
It's some sort of solid
that it corresponds
-
to a closed surface.
-
And this closed surface
that closes up on its own
-
is having a hard
time [INAUDIBLE].
-
It has a normal.
-
And this normal is given by
the gradient of this function,
-
we can increase
[? it ?] like that.
-
You remember that.
-
And that was a long time ago.
-
But you should
still master that.
-
Last time, I gave you
the z equals f of xy,
-
z equals little f
of xy, as a graph
-
of the function of two variables
over a domain in plane.
-
We computed the
gradient of that.
-
But that's what we did all
through the [? meter ?].
-
So that's no fun.
-
We know that too well.
-
On this problem, I
gave you some new piece
-
of information last time.
-
So I said, if you have
a vector field that
-
looks F 1i plus F
2j plus F 3k, where
-
Fi is C1, that means
that the differentiable
-
and the derivatives
are continuous,
-
what was the divergence of it?
-
Well, that was before
the Easter break.
-
And I know we had a long break.
-
I cannot recover from this break
so easily, because it was long.
-
And I also traveled last week.
-
But before I traveled, I
remember that I gave you this.
-
And you memorized it.
-
Most of you memorised it.
-
How was it?
-
The first component
differentiated with respect
-
to the first variable
plus the second component
-
differentiated with respect
to the second variable.
-
Plus the third component
differentiated with respect
-
to the third variable.
-
So I'm asking you, as
an exercise, like I
-
did last time, the same thing.
-
Exercise one for this section.
-
Compute divergence
of the gradient
-
of F, where F is a
C1 function of xyz.
-
That means F is
[? like this ?] differentiable
-
and with continuous derivatives.
-
What does it mean?
-
It means that you have to
compute divergence of F sub xi
-
plus F sub yj plus F sub zk.
-
And you're thinking,
I can do that!
-
By definition, I take the
first component-- who was that?
-
Hmm?
-
STUDENT: Brian.
-
PROFESSOR: Oh, right.
-
I thought that somebody
wanted to come in
-
and then he heard me
and changed his mind.
-
[LAUGHTER]
-
PROFESSOR: F sub x
parentheses [INAUDIBLE]
-
x plus F sub-- like when
you go on a blind date
-
and you see, change your mind.
-
OK.
-
F sub y y plus F sub z z.
-
Do you remember that
I gave away 95 cents
-
for this type of question?
-
So what was this operator?
-
We can write it better.
-
We can write it using the
second partial derivatives
-
with respect to z, y, and z.
-
And we gave a name to this one.
-
We called this names--
-
STUDENT: Laplacian.
-
PROFESSOR: Laplacian.
-
Laplace operator.
-
Laplace.
-
Laplace.
-
Laplacian.
-
That's how you spell it.
-
Laplac-ian.
-
OK?
-
Of F. And then what do you have?
-
-
You have to introduce
a new notation in.
-
When you see this
triangle that looks
-
like an equilateral
triangle, this
-
means Laplacian of something.
-
So if you have a function
of two variables-- so
-
let's say z equals F of xy.
-
What is the Laplacian
of this little f?
-
Little f x x plus little f y y.
-
So we could be second
partial with respect
-
to x plus the second
partial with respect to y.
-
What if I have something else?
-
Like let me give you a
more general function.
-
Let's say I have a
differentiable function
-
of N variables with
continuous derivatives.
-
And it looks like crazy.
-
It looks like that.
-
x1, x2, x n minus what?
-
Well, the Laplace operator in
this case will be F sub x1 x1
-
plus [? A of ?] sub x2 x2.
-
Which means the partial of
F, the second derivative
-
with respect to x2.
-
And plus the last derivative
with respect-- two [INAUDIBLE]
-
with respect to
the same variable.
-
The last variable is xm minus 1.
-
This could be one million and 1.
-
I don't know.
-
You can have this as many
variables as you want.
-
Now, actually in
engineering, there
-
are functions that
have many parameters.
-
You have three
special opponents.
-
Then you have time.
-
Then you have temperature,
then you have pressure,
-
then you have god knows what.
-
The surface tension
of the membrane.
-
Many things.
-
You really have a
million parameters.
-
Actually, it's impossible.
-
It's even hard to work
with 10 parameters.
-
Imagine always
working with equations
-
that have lots of variables
and having do deal with that.
-
In fluid flows,
hydrodynamical problems,
-
most the time in
3D turbulent flows,
-
for example, then you have
xyz spatial coordinates
-
and time T. So even
with four variables,
-
once you get those operators,
you could have something like F
-
sub x x x t plus g sub
x x t plus and so on.
-
All sorts of ugly components.
-
Sometimes you'll have
equations of fluid flows
-
in dynamic software.
-
Fluid flows with
turbulence are really
-
an area of
mathematics in itself,
-
of really complicated equations
with most of the operators.
-
I was looking at
them in Georgia,
-
where I went to this conference.
-
Most of those
equations were order 4.
-
Of course, most of them you
cannot even think about solving
-
by hand, or with
any known methods.
-
You can solve them numerically
with computational software.
-
That is the only [INAUDIBLE]
that modern mathematics
-
has in some areas right now.
-
The right software, in
order to find solutions
-
to a fluid flow with turbulence.
-
That is the solution to
this type of equation.
-
Like [INAUDIBLE], for example.
-
Now we are going to see--
well, you are going to see.
-
I'm too old and I saw
that 20 years ago.
-
When you're going
3350 [INAUDIBLE]
-
differential equations.
-
And then, if you do PD
3350 one in engineering,
-
You're going to see
lots of equations
-
that are hard to solve.
-
But in many of them, you're
going to see partials,
-
like that.
-
And you're going to
say, oh, thank god
-
that I like partials
in Calc Three
-
so they became my friends.
-
And you'll never have
headaches-- [? you know what ?]
-
would be easy, if you understood
that notion of differential
-
well, the notion of partial
derivatives very well.
-
So I'm going to erase this one.
-
-
OK.
-
And then I'll say, I
don't how many of you--
-
I'll try to make this
formula more visible.
-
Some of you maybe, who
are engineering majors
-
know about curl.
-
Have you heard about curl?
-
Curl of a vector value function.
-
No.
-
You haven't.
-
Suppose that you have a
vector value function.
-
-
That is F of coordinates
x, y, z, the coordinates.
-
The C1 of over
seven domain omega.
-
Omega is the domain that your
special coordinates live in.
-
Xyz living some potato.
-
That's it.
-
Whose solid body enclosed
by a closed surface.
-
In that potato, F is a
differentiable function
-
with respect to xyz, and the
derivatives are continuous.
-
Now, in most cases, if
you work with Laplacian,
-
this is not enough C1.
-
If you work with Laplacian,
what do you want?
-
What do you need?
-
You have F sub x
x plus F sub y1.
-
So you need C2.
-
You work with at least C2.
-
Many examples have C infinity.
-
That means you're having
really beautiful functions that
-
are elementary.
-
Some of them even
polynomial approximations.
-
And then you really
can differentiate
-
them ad infinitum and all
the derivatives [INAUDIBLE],
-
and then you can
call yourself lucky.
-
How do you introduce the
notion of curl of it?
-
And it sounds funny, and this
is why they made this fun.
-
And my hair used to be
curly, but I shaved my head
-
over the holiday,
and now it's between.
-
So curl of F is something
that looks horrible
-
when you try to memorize it.
-
So you say, OK, if I'm going
to get this on the final,
-
you better wear this T-shirt.
-
No, there is something
better than that.
-
One time I was the wearing-- OK.
-
My students got no permission
from the [INAUDIBLE]
-
to come in with a cheat sheet.
-
But I was wearing a T-shirt
that had Green's theorem.
-
I don't know how
many of you have
-
heard about Green's theorem.
-
We are going to learn
it in two weeks.
-
And I was wearing that T-shirt.
-
And it was by accident, OK?
-
I didn't do it on purpose
to help my students cheat.
-
So one student at some
point goes like, well, I
-
don't remember Green's theorem.
-
And then he looked my T-shirt.
-
Oh, all right.
-
Never mind.
-
So I had Green's theorem
on my shirt, [INAUDIBLE].
-
-
But it's hard to wear like
10 T-shirts, one for the-- I
-
have one for the formula of the
curvature of a curve in space.
-
Remember that one,
how it is so nasty?
-
OK, I have this one.
-
I have Green's theorem.
-
I have [INAUDIBLE], all the
important formulas actually.
-
I have 10 T-shirts.
-
And then I was
thinking, how will I
-
be if I were like taking ten
T-shirts on top of the other
-
and taking them one off at
a time during the final.
-
There is no cheat sheet.
-
There are no formula
sheets, no nothing.
-
But I would look like
Joey from "Friends."
-
Remember Joey, when he was
dressed in many layers.
-
So rather than
that, I say ask me.
-
Say oh, you know,
I'm freaking out.
-
I'm taking this final,
and I forgot curl.
-
Rather than not attempting
the complex problem at all,
-
ask me before the exam,
and I will remind everybody
-
how to set up the curl formula.
-
So you simply have
to think in terms
-
of operators-- ddx, ddy, ddz.
-
What are these?
-
These are derivative operators.
-
So if you take this and
multiply it by a function,
-
that means df, ds-- [INAUDIBLE].
-
All right, so in this
case, if F is-- I'll
-
go by my T-shirt-- PI plus QJ
plus RK, where PQ and R are all
-
scalar functions of xyz.
-
-
STUDENT: Then we
will not forget it.
-
PROFESSOR: Then we are
no longer forget it,
-
and you'll no longer
need my T-shirt.
-
All right, so how
do you do that?
-
You go expand along
your first row,
-
I times whoever the minor
will be, which is this guy.
-
How do you do the
[? cowboy ?] problem?
-
These guys multiply each other.
-
So you go dr, dy.
-
Plus or minus?
-
Minus dq, dz.
-
Close times I. So the I is
the corresponding element
-
to the minor that
I just completed.
-
This minor is the determinant,
which is exactly this guy.
-
And this is exactly
what my T-shirt says.
-
Right, precisely.
-
OK.
-
The second term, if
we put the minus-- no,
-
they changed the signs.
-
That's the thing.
-
I would put minus, because I am
expanding along the first row.
-
And the second that I'm in
minus something minor times
-
J. Which minor?
-
Let me make in the lime.
-
Lime is a nice color.
-
And then I'll take this,
this, this, and that-- dr,
-
dx shooting [? cowboys ?]
there-- minus dq, dz.
-
And of course they wrote
dq, dz minus dr, dx.
-
So I would leave it like that.
-
It doesn't matter.
-
You can put the
minus in if you want.
-
Plus the k dot.
-
k goes at the end.
-
All right, now k
goes at the end.
-
-
And then k multiplies this
determinant-- dq, dx minus dp,
-
dy.
-
-
dq, dx minus dp, dy.
-
-
Is it hard?
-
No.
-
It is not going to
be hard to memorize.
-
So then how did we do that?
-
We set up the first row to
be I, J, K, the second row
-
to be ddx, ddy, and ddz.
-
And then all in order the
components of your vector value
-
function in the exact
order they are with respect
-
to the standard basis i j k.
-
All right, now there
are other names
-
and other symbols for
curl of F. They use
-
curl because it's in English.
-
Well actually, in
Great Britain I
-
saw that they used [INAUDIBLE],
or else they use both.
-
In my language, in Romanian,
we call it [? rotore. ?]
-
And I saw that in French
it's very similar.
-
They use the same.
-
Now in the mechanical
engineering notation
-
it's funny.
-
They use another symbol and a
cross [? broad dot ?] symbol F.
-
And by that they mean
curl F. So if you
-
talk to a professor who's
in mechanical engineering,
-
or fluid mechanics,
or something,
-
when they talk about curl,
they will use this notation.
-
When they use this
other notation,
-
what do you think this is again?
-
Divergence, yes.
-
I told you last time
that is divergence of F.
-
So make the distinction
between-- again,
-
when are you leaving?
-
Huh?
-
OK, so you have
been in [INAUDIBLE].
-
And then we have
this distinction
-
we use here, like
for dot product
-
and you use here
as a cross product.
-
Now you have to understand
the conceptual difference is
-
huge between these guys.
-
This is a scalar function.
-
This is a vector function--
vector, scalar-- vector,
-
scalar, vector scalar.
-
Because I've had to do
it on so [INAUDIBLE].
-
It makes [INAUDIBLE].
-
And I heard of
colleagues complaining
-
while grading the final
that the students did not
-
understand that this is a
vector, and this is a scalar.
-
OK, a few simple exercises--
I'm going to go ahead and do
-
some of them.
-
We tried to make the
data on the final exam
-
very accessible and very
easy to apply in problems.
-
And one of the problems that--
we'll start with example 2--
-
would be this one.
-
And you may think, why?
-
Sometimes we put it in disguise.
-
And we said assume you
have a sphere-- that's
-
the unit sphere-- of
origin O. And say compute.
-
-
What is the equation of
the unit sphere, guys?
-
X squared plus y squared plus
z squared equals one, right?
-
From [INAUDIBLE], F
equals normal-- external
-
normal-- to the unit sphere
pointing out, [? through ?]
-
than N is the same at a
different point as the position
-
vector.
-
-
Then compute.
-
-
[? Now follow. ?] Gradient
of F, divergence of F,
-
and curl of F. Now that
should be a piece of cake.
-
Now one is not [INAUDIBLE]
so much of a piece of cake
-
if you don't understand what
the problem wants from you.
-
It is to actually graph
the expression of this one.
-
So you're going to
say what is the normal
-
to a function like that?
-
First of all, we just
talked today about it.
-
If you have a function, even
if it's implicitly as F of x,
-
y, z equals c, in that case N
is your friend from the past.
-
If it's a unit normal,
unit normal to a surface
-
happens all the
time in engineering.
-
Whether you do solid
mechanics or fluid mechanics,
-
you always have to
complete these things.
-
This is going to be hard.
-
The gradient of F
divided by the length
-
of-- but here I have a problem.
-
I have to put G here, because
G will be my position vector.
-
This is the point x,y,z.
-
Or you prefer big R. But
I think I prefer big G,
-
because big R looks
like a scalar radius,
-
and I don't like that.
-
So the position vector
will be the circle middle
-
that starts at the origin and
whose N is on the surface,
-
right?
-
And this is the equation,
xy equals yj plus [? ek1. ?]
-
Because my point x,y,z has a
corresponding vector xi plus yj
-
plus zk-- big deal.
-
Now I'm trying to convince
you that, for the unit
-
normal for the sphere, I
have the same kind of thing.
-
So how do we compute
this normally?
-
I take the function F that
implicitly defines the surface.
-
All right, so in my case
F is something else.
-
What is it? x squared plus
y squared plus z squared.
-
-
Let's compute it.
-
N is going to be [INAUDIBLE].
-
It's very nice.
-
2x comma 2y comma 2z divided
by the square root of the sums.
-
Do I like this?
-
Uh, no, but I'll have to do
it whether I like it or not.
-
-
I want to simplify
up and down via 2.
-
Can I do that?
-
Of course I can.
-
I'm going to get x,y,z divided
by square root of x squared
-
plus y squared plus z squared.
-
-
And this was 1.
-
-
STUDENT: Wouldn't
there still be a 2
-
there, because it's 2
squared [INAUDIBLE]?
-
PROFESSOR: No, I pulled it out.
-
That's exactly what I said.
-
There was a 4 inside.
-
I pulled out with the forceps.
-
I put it up here,
square root of 4.
-
And I have a 2 here,
and that cancels out.
-
So I got something much
simpler than you guys
-
expected at first.
-
I got xi plus yj plus
zk as being the normal.
-
Did you expect this?
-
And you were supposed to
expect that this is y,
-
because this is the position
vector that has one length.
-
The length of a
root vector is 1,
-
and the point is on the sphere.
-
The normal will be
exactly the continuation.
-
Take your root
vector, and continue
-
in the same direction--
this is the beauty
-
of the normal to a surface,
that it continues the radius.
-
It continues the radius of the
sphere in the same direction.
-
So you copy and paste
your vector here.
-
Position vector G will be
the same as the normal N.
-
All you do is you shift,
but it's the same vector
-
at the different point.
-
Instead of starting at
O, it starts at P. So
-
[? that ?] is the same vector.
-
So you take the radius vector
from inside the sphere--
-
the position vector--
and you shift it out,
-
and that's the
normal to the sphere.
-
So the equation is still
xi plus yj plus zk.
-
Yes, sir.
-
STUDENT: Does it remain the
same for any other functions,
-
like [INAUDIBLE]?
-
-
PROFESSOR: For the
unit sphere, yes it is.
-
But for a general sphere, no.
-
For example, what
if my sphere will be
-
of center origin and radius R?
-
-
And its position vector
v is x,y,z-- like that.
-
-
[INAUDIBLE] I don't know.
-
G, right?
-
That's the position normal.
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE] just
divide them by the R.
-
PROFESSOR: You just
divide by the R.
-
So instead of
radius being big R,
-
your unit vector
will be this one.
-
And you take this one
and shift it here,
-
and that's all you have.
-
For the sphere, it's beautiful.
-
For any surface in general, no.
-
Let me show you.
-
You have a bunch of [INAUDIBLE],
and your position vectors
-
look like crazies like that.
-
And the normals could
be-- they don't have
-
to continue their position.
-
They could be-- it depends how
the tangent planes look like.
-
And the tangent
plane at the point
-
has to be perpendicular
to the normal.
-
So the normal field is the
N of [INAUDIBLE] vectors.
-
But the little thingies
that look like rectangles
-
or whatever they are--
those are the tangent planes
-
of those points.
-
So in general there is
no obvious relationship
-
between the position and
the normal for the surface.
-
You are really lucky
for this [? field. ?]
-
And for many reasons, like
how beautiful the sphere is,
-
these functions will
be easy to compute.
-
Can you tell me what they
are without computing?
-
Because that should
be a piece of cake.
-
What is the gradient field?
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE]
to that one?
-
That's the x, y, and z.
-
PROFESSOR: For the sphere.
-
STUDENT: 2x, 2y--
-
PROFESSOR: Actually, let's do it
for both divergence G and curl
-
G. And you say wait, they
will be-- so gradient-- no,
-
I meant here.
-
You don't have gradient.
-
When F is a scalar function,
then you have gradient.
-
Then for that gradient you're
going to have divergence.
-
And for that-- I changed
notations, that's shy
-
I have to fix it.
-
Because F used to be that,
and it's not a vector anymore.
-
So big F is not
a vector anymore.
-
It's a scalar function, and now
I have to change the problem.
-
What is the gradient there?
-
What's divergence
of the gradient?
-
[INAUDIBLE] gradient of F.
And for the G that I gave you,
-
I want the divergence
in the curve?
-
So I made the problem
fluffier that it was before.
-
More things to
confuse for practice.
-
What's the gradient?
-
We did it before.
-
2x--
-
STUDENT: 2xi, 2--
-
PROFESSOR: 2y, 2z-- we are at a
[? 93 ?] point p on the sphere.
-
It could be anywhere--
anywhere in space.
-
What's the divergence
of this individual?
-
So remember guys,
what I told you?
-
First component differentiated
with a straight 2x
-
plus second component
differentiated with respect
-
to y plus third
component differentiated
-
with respect to z.
-
2 plus 2 plus 2 equals
6-- piece of cake.
-
And curl of the gradient
of F-- is that hard?
-
[? STUDENT: Yeah. ?]
-
PROFESSOR: No, but we have
to know the definition.
-
And without looking at the
T-shirt, how do we do that?
-
-
The determinant-- I, J, K.
Operators-- ddx, ddy, and ddz.
-
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE]
2x, 2y, 2z, correct?
-
PROFESSOR: And we copy and
paste the three components.
-
[INAUDIBLE] in the trash.
-
I'll take the blue.
-
So we put 2x, 2y, 2z.
-
Do you think it's going
to be easy or hard?
-
Do you see the answer?
-
Some of are very sharp,
and you may see the answer.
-
For example, when the
cowboys shoot at each other
-
like this, dz, dy is here.
-
dy, dz is here.
-
So this, as a minor, is
0-- 0I, an eye for an eye.
-
And what else?
-
dz, dx-- dx dz, same
thing, minus 0j.
-
Is this meant to say minus 0j?
-
Yes it is.
-
But I did it because I want
you to have the good habit
-
of saying plus minus plus.
-
And that's finally
the same kind of thing
-
that'll give you 0k
if you think that when
-
you do partial derivative of
y with respect to [? f ?],
-
you get 0.
-
You have 0.
-
So some student of mine asked,
so this is the 0 vector,
-
how in the world do I
write a 0 vector on short?
-
Let me show you how.
-
You're going to laugh at me.
-
Some people write 0 bar,
which means the 0 vector.
-
Some other people don't
like it, it's silly.
-
Some people write O with
double like that, meaning that,
-
hey, this is a vector element,
the vector with its components
-
of 0, 0, 0-- to distinguish
that vector from the number 0,
-
which is not in bold-- So the
notations for the vector are 0.
-
So I'm going to
write here 0, 0, 0.
-
How about Mr. G?
-
Mr. G will act similarly.
-
When you do the divergence
it's going to be-- 1
-
plus 1 plus 1 equals 3.
-
-
You should remember this thing.
-
We are going to do
the divergence 3,
-
and they will ask you to do a
triple integral of a divergence
-
of a vector field.
-
And when you do
that, you are going
-
to get a triple
integer of something
-
like 3, which is a custom, which
will make your life very easy.
-
So you will very easily
compute those triple integrals
-
of constants.
-
Curl of G, G being
of [? a. ?] OK?
-
I should make the distinction
between a scalar function
-
and a vector function by putting
a G bar on the vector function.
-
How about this?
-
Is it hard?
-
No, because it's
the same fellow.
-
Instead of that, I
have just x, y, z.
-
The answer will be the same.
-
So I still want to get
0, 0, 0-- the vector 0.
-
So the point was that
we will give you enough.
-
You may expect them
to be very hard,
-
but they are not
going to be very hard.
-
Let's do one more like the
ones we have in the book.
-
What do you think
this one will be?
-
I'm making you a new
vector value function.
-
That's maybe two
little exercises
-
we can do just working
exercise three, four,
-
I don't know what they are.
-
-
Let me give you R
vector of x, y, z
-
equals yzI plus xzj plus xyk.
-
Compute the curl.
-
Let me write it like engineers
do just for fun-- [INAUDIBLE]
-
cross.
-
R is the same as
curl R, which is I,
-
J, K-- oh my god--
ddx, ddy, ddz.
-
-
Why is z-- xz-- xy.
-
Are you saying oh, that's
not so easy anymore.
-
You-- you will see
that it becomes easy,
-
OK? i times what is the minor?
-
This times-- x, right?
-
Minus x plus minus j
times 1 minus what?
-
Minor will be the red thingie.
-
And the red thingie
is beautiful,
-
because it's gonna be y
minus y plus k times--
-
who do you think it's
gonna be? z z minus.
-
So it's still 0.
-
Do we expect something
like that on the final?
-
An easy computation.
-
Somebody says, find me the
curve of this function.
-
And the functions
usually we give
-
you are nice and significant.
-
Something where the
result will be pretty.
-
OK.
-
-
Let me see what else I wanted.
-
I'm gonna-- I have space here.
-
So compute the curl and
Laplace operator of f of xyz
-
equals x squared yzi plus x y
squared zj plus xy z squared k.
-
-
Of divergence.
-
Sorry, guys.
-
This is not a-- it's
not a scalar function.
-
I want the divergence
and the curl.
-
The curl will be a vector.
-
The divergence will
be a scalar function.
-
Later on I'll give you a
nice function where you can
-
compute the Laplace operator.
-
That's gonna have to
be a scalar function.
-
And although the
Laplace operator
-
can be generalized
to vector functions,
-
and I'll tell you later
how-- what that is.
-
It's very easy.
-
It's practically the Laplace
operators in every direction.
-
OK.
-
So let's see the curl.
-
-
i j k, d dx, d dy, d dz.
-
Today I'm gonna cook
up the homework.
-
And with all the practice
that we are doing now,
-
you should have absolutely
no problem doing the homework
-
for the first two sections.
-
At least for the section--
today's section, 13.1.
-
x squared yz, x y
squared z, xy z squared.
-
You see there is some
sort of symmetry.
-
I'm playing a game here.
-
-
So I have i.
-
I want you to tell me
[INAUDIBLE], see now,
-
I don't work much in groups.
-
I don't make you
work in groups, but I
-
want you to answer my question.
-
So what is going to be this
minor that I-- the first thing
-
is gonna be?
-
STUDENT: x z squared.
-
PROFESSOR: Very good.
-
STUDENT: Minus x y squared.
-
-
PROFESSOR: Minus j.
-
Potential [? plus or ?] minus.
-
OK, what is the next guy?
-
STUDENT: y z squared.
-
PROFESSOR: y z
squared, thank you.
-
STUDENT: x squared.
-
PROFESSOR: x squared, right?
-
Plus k times--
-
STUDENT: y squared z.
-
PROFESSOR: So, you
see what I'm doing?
-
I'm doing this from
respect to x. y squared z.
-
You said it, right.
-
Minus this guy, x squared z.
-
Can I write it more-- I don't
really like the way I wrote it.
-
But I'll write like that.
-
How about x times z squared
minus y squared i minus j.
-
Or maybe better plus j.
-
I'll change this up.
-
Plus j at the end.
-
Because it's the
vector. y times x
-
squared minus z squared
j plus-- who gets out?
-
z-- z times y squared
minus x squared k.
-
-
OK.
-
Good There is some
symmetry in there.
-
The break in the symmetry
is in the middle.
-
Because, as you
see, x is separate,
-
and then z is followed
by y, and then
-
x squared-- x is followed
by z and y is followed by x.
-
So I have some-- some
symmetry of some sort.
-
-
What else did I want?
-
Divergence operator.
-
And that will be the
last example of the kind.
-
[INAUDIBLE]
-
How do you write the divergence?
-
Is this hard?
-
Very easy?
-
-
I'm going go ask you to simplify
because I don't like it,
-
like, as a sum.
-
2xyz--
-
STUDENT: 2xyz plus
2xyz plus 2xyz.
-
PROFESSOR: And now you see
why I don't like it as a sum.
-
Because it's 6xyz and it's
very pretty like that.
-
I'd like you-- on
the exam, I'd like
-
you to take the function
and box the answer,
-
and that's all I want you to do.
-
All right.
-
I'm gonna go ahead and erase.
-
-
I'm going to move
on to 13.2, but I'd
-
like to review some physics
a little bit with you
-
and see what you
remember from physics.
-
-
It's a little bit messy.
-
I'll use this instead because
I like the board to be clean.
-
If I were to ask you to
remember work in physics,
-
I would say-- I'm changing a
little bit the order in 13.2.
-
I'd like you to go
back in time and see
-
what work was in physics class.
-
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE] force dx.
-
-
PROFESSOR: What if you
didn't know any calculus?
-
Let's go a long time.
-
The section is
13.2 preliminaries.
-
STUDENT: Force
multiplied distance.
-
PROFESSOR: Very good.
-
Preliminary work.
-
[INAUDIBLE] The notion of work
from physics-- hey, come on.
-
-
Physics, or engineering,
mechanics, whatever you study,
-
work.
-
Imagine that you're
taking a-- this
-
is your body that you're playing
with-- not your own body,
-
but the body you are
acting on in physics.
-
And you are dragging this
object from a place A
-
to a place B, another position.
-
A B is the distance.
-
And the force is parallel
to the trajectory.
-
This is very important.
-
This is a simpler case.
-
In general, it's not so simple.
-
So this force is acting,
and it's a constant force.
-
And you pull the object
from one place to another.
-
That's case one.
-
In case two, life is harder.
-
You actually pull
the poor object
-
with the force in
this direction.
-
Actually, most of
us do that, right?
-
If I were to have a gliding
object on the surface,
-
I would actually act on
that object in the direction
-
of my arm by pulling it.
-
So when I displace this body
from point a to point b,
-
I still travel the
distance d, but-- so d
-
is a displacement vector
that can be written like--
-
or it can be drawn like that.
-
I have to be smart
in both cases,
-
figure out what
I want from life,
-
because it's not so clear.
-
When they taught me I
think the first time
-
I was in-- oh my
God-- eighth grade,
-
and they-- that was
a long time ago.
-
In this case, w is
gonna be a scalar
-
and I'm gonna have the magnitude
of the force F. F is a vector,
-
but to indicate it in Newtons
or whatever I measure it in,
-
it's gonna be in magnitude.
-
Times the little d,
but instead of little d
-
I should be a little
smarter and say,
-
Magdalena, this is the magnitude
of the vector A B, which
-
is a displacement vector.
-
-
So this is called work.
-
And if the force is 10
Newtons, and the distance
-
is 10 meters, because we
want to go international.
-
We want to be global, right,
at Texas Tech, so good.
-
So we have 100 Newton-meters.
-
-
Now you can measure-- well,
you can have another example.
-
I'm thinking gravity and then
you can say it in pounds,
-
and that measures force.
-
And you have other units
that are not international.
-
I'm not gonna mess up.
-
When you have the work
in this case, though,
-
it's more complicated.
-
And I'm not gonna be mad
at you. [INAUDIBLE] is
-
trying to tell me what it is.
-
I'm not going to be mad at
the people who don't know
-
what the work is in this case.
-
Although, I was looking
at-- I am the person
-
who has run a
committee to oversee
-
the finals for different
math classes, all the math
-
classes we offer here.
-
And every semester I see the
[? streak ?] pre-calculus,
-
calc 1, calc 2, calc 3.
-
In trig and
pre-calculus, they'll
-
always have a work there.
-
And I was wondering how many
of you took pre-calculus,
-
and how many of you
remember that you
-
studied this in pre-calculus.
-
It's a little bit awkward.
-
I'm thinking, how do they do
it, but I gave you the formula.
-
And they say the force in
itself as a vector dot product
-
the displacement vector.
-
So they are both
forces in dot product.
-
And I was surprised to see
that they gave you [INAUDIBLE]
-
If I were to express it,
how would I express it?
-
I'll say the magnitude
of F, of course,
-
in Newtons, whatever it
is, times the magnitude
-
of the displacement vector--
-
STUDENT: Multiply those cosines.
-
PROFESSOR: Cosine of
the angle between.
-
And I'm too lazy, I
don't know, theta.
-
Let's call it angle theta.
-
Because I don't want to
include that in locations, OK?
-
It really doesn't matter
in which direction
-
I'm going, because cosine theta,
thank God, is an even function.
-
It's equal to cosine
of minus theta.
-
So whether I go this way or
that way, it's the same cosine.
-
All right.
-
So the cosine of the
angle between the two.
-
It's very easy when you
don't need calculus.
-
But when you use calculus,
because your trajectory is
-
no longer a line, life is
becoming more complicated.
-
So we have to come up
with a different formula,
-
with a different notion of work.
-
I'm gonna erase-- are
you guys done with that?
-
Is it visible?
-
You're done.
-
-
OK.
-
-
So again, life is not so
easy in reality anymore.
-
I have a particle in physics-- a
photon enters a four-star hotel
-
and says-- talks to the
bellboy, and the bellboy,
-
can I help you
with your luggage.
-
No, I'm traveling light.
-
[LAUGHTER]
-
So the particle, the
photon-- whatever.
-
A particle is moving-- is
moving on a trajectory.
-
Suppose that
trajectory is planar,
-
just to make your
life easier at first.
-
It's in the plane x y.
-
And this is the little
particle that's moving.
-
And this is R. And
that is x i plus yj.
-
-
Good.
-
And this is the point x, y.
-
And that's the position,
the current position
-
of my particle, right now.
-
Not in the past,
not in the future.
-
My particle is moving,
and this is now.
-
Suppose time doesn't even exist.
-
We think of the movies
that we saw lately,
-
in The Theory of Everything.
-
So then, they say OK, we only
care about now. x, y is now
-
and that is the current
position vector.
-
Well, what would be
the work between now--
-
whatever now-- and the next,
let's say, this is gonna be x1,
-
y1.
-
And this is x0, y0.
-
-
That's the general formula,
will be x i plus yj.
-
So I actually cannot
forget about time.
-
Not as much as I want.
-
So x and y-- x and y are
both changing in time.
-
We're gonna have x equals
x sub t, y equals y sub t.
-
Do you guys remember what we
call that kind of equation
-
for a curve from here to here?
-
Para--
-
STUDENT: Parametrization.
-
PROFESSOR: Parametrization,
or parametric equations.
-
Parametric equations.
-
-
Good.
-
So I have may the
force be with you.
-
I have a force.
-
I have a force, and I have
some sort of displacement.
-
But I cannot express that
displacement linearly anymore.
-
I'm moving along a
[INAUDIBLE] of a curve.
-
So I have to think differently.
-
And the work will be defined,
whether you like it or not,
-
as F vector field, dot
product with dR over c.
-
And you say, what in
the world is that?
-
What would c be?
-
How do I integrate along a path?
-
And I will tell you in a
second what we mean by that.
-
-
Meaning that-- this is by
definition if you want.
-
This is like an
application of calculus 1.
-
It can be proved, but we
don't-- we do a rigorous job
-
in the book about introducing
and proving that along
-
a curvilinear path.
-
This is gonna be-- where
am I here, at time t0?
-
And this is at time t1.
-
That means x0 is x of t0.
-
y0 is y of t0.
-
And at the finish point,
I'm at x1, which is x of t1,
-
and y1 equals y of t1.
-
So between t0 and
t1, I have traveled
-
and I have F where
measure at x of t y of t,
-
where t is between--
moving between t0 and t1.
-
I'm done with this
is the F part.
-
What is the dR?
-
Now you guys know
about differential.
-
Thank God you know
about differential,
-
because this is gonna
help you very much.
-
OK.
-
So instead of dR, I'm going
to write dot, and let's
-
see how I write-- what I write
in terms of dR. You may say,
-
well, what does she mean?
-
dR was dxi plus dyj.
-
And you say, why is that?
-
I don't understand.
-
Because R itself is x i plus yj.
-
And x is a function of t,
and y is a function of t.
-
That means that when you
apply the differential,
-
you are gonna apply the
differentials to dx and dy,
-
and these are gonna be
infinitesimal displacement.
-
Infinitesimal displacement.
-
-
Infinitesimal displacement.
-
What is an infinitesimal
displacement in terms of time?
-
Well, we have our
parametric equations.
-
So Mr. dx as a differential
is just x prime dt.
-
It's like in the
[INAUDIBLE] substitution.
-
dy is just y prime dt.
-
So let me write this down again.
-
This is x prime of t i plus
y prime of t j times dt.
-
So Mr. dt is like
a common factor.
-
If he wants to go
out for a walk,
-
he says, I'm gonna
go out for a walk.
-
I go out for a walk.
-
So dR is actually x
prime of t times i
-
plus y prime of t times j dt.
-
-
And this will represent
the derivative of R
-
with respect to pi.
-
So that will be what?
-
The differential.
-
Differential of R
with respect to pi.
-
-
This is the same as
writing dx i plus dy j.
-
-
And it's the same as writing
dR. Why is this happening?
-
Because it's [INAUDIBLE]
Because x and y
-
themselves are functions of one
variable only, which is time.
-
This is why it happens.
-
Oh, so we will
simply have to do--
-
to learn new things, right?
-
We are gonna have
to learn new things,
-
like integral from a time--
fixed time 0 to t1, which
-
is 10 seconds, of a dot product
between a certain vector that
-
depends on time and another
vector that depends on time,
-
and dt.
-
So we are gonna
have to learn how
-
to compute the work through this
type of curvilinear integral.
-
And this is-- this is called
either path integral-- path
-
integral along the curve c, or
curvilinear integral along c.
-
Yes.
-
STUDENT: Let's say if I
move the force this is
-
[INAUDIBLE] function, correct?
-
So if I can find
[? arc length ?] that
-
is between the x--
-
PROFESSOR: Yeah--
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE] points.
-
PROFESSOR: Yeah, we will do
the one with that length next.
-
The [? reason ?] so--
-
STUDENT: Is it harder?
-
PROFESSOR: No.
-
No, you can pass
through a plane.
-
And you can-- we'll
do that next time.
-
You will have an integral
with respect to S.
-
So the integration will
be with respect to dS,
-
they are correct.
-
And then you will have a
function that depends on S
-
[INAUDIBLE] So I'll-- for
today, I'll only teach you that.
-
Next time I'll teach
you that with respect
-
to arc length, which is also
very-- it's not hard at all.
-
STUDENT: OK.
-
PROFESSOR: So I will work
with you on [INAUDIBLE]
-
Now assume that we have-- I
will spray all this thing.
-
-
Assume that I have a problem.
-
I have a parabola-- arc
of a parabola, all right?
-
Between-- let's
say the parabola is
-
y equals x squared
between two points.
-
-
And I'll ask you to
compute some work,
-
and I'll tell you in a second
what [INAUDIBLE] to do.
-
-
So exercise-- assume
the parabola y
-
equals x squared between
points A of coordinates 0, 0
-
and point B of coordinates 1, 1.
-
a, Parametrized this parabola
in the simplest way you can.
-
-
And b, compute the work
along this arc of a parabola,
-
arc AB of this parabola.
-
-
For [INAUDIBLE] the
function big F of t,
-
you see that-- I'm going to say,
no, big F of the point x, y,
-
because you haven't parametrized
that yet, big F of x,
-
y being xi plus yg.
-
-
So you say, OK, wait a minute.
-
W will be integral over
the arc of a parabola.
-
Do you want to draw that first?
-
Yes, I need to draw that first.
-
So I have this parabola from A
to B. A is of coordinates 0, 0.
-
B is of coordinates 1, 1.
-
And this is y equals x squared.
-
So what kind of
parametrization is
-
the simplest one, the
regular one that people take?
-
Take x to be t?
-
And of course, take y in that
case. y will be t squared.
-
And for 1 you have 1.
-
For 0 you have 0.
-
When you have that work by
definition, what was that?
-
It was written as integral
or on the graph C. Let's call
-
this path C a curvilinear path.
-
Look, script C-- so beautiful.
-
Let me [INAUDIBLE] red and
draw the C of what is work?
-
F force-- may the force be with
us-- dot dR. All righty, that's
-
a little bit of a headache.
-
This F is going to be-- can I
write an alternative formula
-
that I have not written yet
but I will write in a second?
-
dR will be dxi plus dyj.
-
So I can also
write that F dot dR
-
as the dot product will seem to
be-- what was the dot product
-
guys, do you remember?
-
First component times
first component, F1dx
-
plus second scalar component
times second scalar component,
-
F2dy.
-
-
I'll write it down.
-
Along the path C I'll
have F1dx plus F2dy.
-
But god knows what it's
going to be in terms of time.
-
So I have to change
variable thinking.
-
Okey-dokey, Mr.
dx by substitution
-
was x prime to T. Mr. dy by
substitution was y prime dt.
-
So I'd rather write
this in a simpler way.
-
This is a new object,
path integral.
-
But we know this
object from Calc I
-
as being a simple
integral from time t0--
-
I'll write it down-- time
t1, F1x prime of t plus F2y
-
prime of t.
-
This is the integral dt.
-
This would be a
piece of cake for us
-
to apply in this problem.
-
Equals-- now you tell me
what I'm supposed to write.
-
Because if you don't, I'm
going to not write anything.
-
t0 for me is what time?
-
When did we leave this?
-
0.
-
And when did we arrive?
-
At 1 o'clock.
-
We arrived when t is 1, or
every one second or whatever
-
depending on [INAUDIBLE].
-
OK, from 0 to 1, now who is F1?
-
F1 is this.
-
But it drives me crazy.
-
Because I need this
to be expressed in t.
-
So I think of x and
y as functions of t.
-
So if 1 is not x,
not [INAUDIBLE]
-
right here, but t, which is the
same thing in parametrization--
-
this is t, t times.
-
Who is x prime?
-
1, thank god.
-
That is easy, times 1, plus F2.
-
Who is F2?
-
t squared.
-
I'll have to write it down.
-
Times who is y prime?
-
2t.
-
y prime is t2.
-
So I write it down-- 2t, dt.
-
-
So that's how I compute
this integral back.
-
Is it hard?
-
No, because it's just a simple
integral from Calculus I.
-
So I have to integrate
what function?
-
A polynomial, 2t cubed
plus t with respect
-
to t between 0,
time 0 and time 1.
-
-
Good, let's do it.
-
Because that's a piece of
cake-- 2 times t to the 4 over 4
-
plus t squared over 2.
-
I take the whole thing between,
I apply the fundamental theorem
-
of calculus, and I have between
t equals 1 up and t equals 0
-
down.
-
What's the final answer?
-
It's a single final answer.
-
And again, on the
exam, on the final,
-
do not expect a
headache computation.
-
Do expect something
simple like that
-
where you don't
need a calculator.
-
You just have either integers
only or simple fractions
-
to add, and you
should get the answer.
-
What is the answer, guys?
-
1-- 1/2 plus 1/2 equals 1.
-
So 1 is the value
of the work in what?
-
Measured in newtons
times meters,
-
whatever your units are.
-
When you drag the
object from this point
-
to this point, on which the
acting force is the only
-
acting force-- it
could be the result
-
that there are several forces.
-
That is that force
that you have here.
-
Is it useful?
-
It's very useful for engineers.
-
It's very useful for physicists.
-
It's very useful for
anybody who works
-
in applied mathematics, this
notion of work given like that.
-
I'm going to go ahead and erase.
-
And I'll ask you one
thing here that is not
-
in the book I think
as far as I remember.
-
Can you guys prove that this
sophisticated formula becomes
-
your formula of the
one you claimed,
-
the first formula you gave me?
-
Is it hard?
-
Do you think it's
hard to prove this?
-
OK, what if we have the
simplest possible case.
-
Let's think of--
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE]
-
-
PROFESSOR: Yeah,
I'm thinking maybe I
-
should do, well, A to B, right?
-
AB, what kind of expression
do I have [INAUDIBLE]?
-
If I take this to be-- I
could have any line, right?
-
I could have any line.
-
But if I have any line,
I can pick my frame
-
according to my preference.
-
Nobody's going to
tell me, well, you
-
have to take the
frame like that,
-
and then your line will be of
the form ax plus by equals.
-
No, I'll just take the
frame to be this one, where
-
AB will be x axis, and A
will be of coordinates 0, 0
-
and B will be of
coordinates B and 0.
-
And this is just my line.
-
So x will be moving between
0 and B. And y is 0, right?
-
It should be, at least.
-
And then F, let's say, should
be this function, this.
-
-
I'll assume the
angle is constant,
-
just like I had it with theta.
-
And then it's acting all
the way on your object.
-
You have the same
angle here always.
-
-
So F is F1i plus F2j.
-
-
dR will be dxi plus dyj.
-
-
But then you say, wait a minute,
but didn't you say, Magdalena,
-
that you are along this line?
-
Didn't you say that y is 0?
-
So which y?
-
So there is no y.
-
So this is 0, right?
-
OK, Mr. x, I want to
parametrize my trajectory.
-
How do I parametrize
it the simplest way?
-
I'll take x to be t.
-
And time will be
exactly between 0 and d.
-
And y will be 0.
-
And thank you god,
because that's easy.
-
And so all you
need to give me is
-
W is integral of F
dR C in that case.
-
So what am I going
to have in that case?
-
I'll have this formula.
-
I'll skip a step, and
I'll have that formula.
-
And that means I have integral
from t0 equals 0 to t1
-
equals B.
-
F1-- now you have to tell
me what F1 will be. x prime
-
[? noted ?] is 1.
-
The second guy is 0, thank you
very much, and [INAUDIBLE].
-
-
F1 will be what?
-
Well, life is nice.
-
F1 will be the projection of
the vector F on my x-axis.
-
So F1 is the length of
this blue vector, I'll say.
-
So F1 is a scalar.
-
Let's say F1 is a
scalar component.
-
That means it's F
length cosine theta.
-
Because it's hypotenuse
times cosine theta.
-
So it's easy.
-
So you have length
of F, how much it is,
-
how big this vector is, times
cosine theta, times what
-
when you integrate it, guys?
-
When you integrate 1 with
respect to t, what do you get?
-
t between d and 0.
-
So you have t between d and 0.
-
We got the formula.
-
So we got that F length
times [INAUDIBLE]
-
times cosine theta times d,
this is the displacement.
-
This is the cosine.
-
This is the magnitude of
the force that I'm-- look,
-
this is the force.
-
My force is along my arm.
-
I'm just dragging
this poor object.
-
The force I'm
acting with, suppose
-
it's always the same parallel
to that that I can feel.
-
So that's what I have, F
cosine theta, and it was easy.
-
So as a particular case
of this nasty integral,
-
I have my old work from
school that I had to believe.
-
I tell you guys, I did
not believe a word.
-
Because my teacher
in eighth grade
-
came up with this
out of nothing,
-
and we were supposed to
be good students preparing
-
for a high school like this
kind of scientific-- back home,
-
there are different
kinds of high school.
-
There is scientific high
school with emphasis
-
in math and physics.
-
There is one for
chemistry/biology.
-
There is one for language,
linguistics, [INAUDIBLE],
-
and so on.
-
And I was for the
math and physics one.
-
And I had to solve this formula
without understanding it.
-
And it took me many
other years to understand
-
that it's just a little
piece of a big picture,
-
and that there's
something bigger than what
-
we were taught in eighth grade.
-
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE]
-
-
PROFESSOR: Yeah,
yeah, it's true.
-
Now I want to ask
you a question.
-
So do you think that I would get
any kind of conservation laws
-
in physics that
apply to calculus?
-
I mean, how hard is it
really to compute the work?
-
-
And I'm making an
announcement now.
-
Since I have not
given you a break,
-
I have to let you
go in a few minutes.
-
-
But I'm making a
big announcement
-
without proving it.
-
-
So we will, in about
one week at the maximum,
-
in maximum one week, study the
independence of path of work
-
if that work is performed
by a conservative force.
-
-
And you're going to
say, wait a minute,
-
what the heck is a conservative
force and what does she mean?
-
Well, I just showed you that
the work is a path integral.
-
We don't know what that is.
-
I'll introduce more.
-
I just introduced the definition
of a path integral with respect
-
to parametrization, general
parametrization with respect
-
to t.
-
So that becomes an integral
with respect to dt,
-
like the one in
Calc I. This is how
-
you have to view it at first.
-
But guys, if this force
is not just any force,
-
it's something magic, if F comes
from a scalar potential that
-
is F represents the gradient
of a scalar function F--
-
this is called scalar
potential-- then
-
F is called-- now let's
see how much money I
-
have for just the last two or
three minutes that I have left.
-
I don't have money
or I have money?
-
Come on, big money.
-
-
No, I have $5.
-
I was looking for $1.
-
Here, I'll give you $5
if you give me $4 back
-
if you guess-- I don't know.
-
So maybe in your
engineering courses-- maybe
-
I give you some candy instead.
-
-
So if there is a scalar function
little f of coordinates x,
-
y, whatever you
have in the problem,
-
so that big F will be the nabla.
-
F nabla means the gradient.
-
We say that F comes
from a scalar potential.
-
But it has also a name,
which is called-- god.
-
It starts with a C, ends
with an E. In that case,
-
if this is going to be equal
to nabla F, in that case,
-
there is a magic theorem
that I'm anticipating.
-
I'm not proving.
-
I'm doing exercises right now.
-
We'll see it in two sections,
that the work does not depend
-
on the path you are taking.
-
So you can go from A to B like
that, or you can go like this.
-
You can go like this.
-
You can go like this.
-
You can go like that.
-
You can go on a parabola,
on a line, on anything.
-
The result is always the same.
-
And it's like the
fundamental theorem
-
of Calc III in
plane for the work.
-
So you have little f endpoint.
-
STUDENT: Is that [INAUDIBLE].
-
PROFESSOR: Little
f of [INAUDIBLE].
-
So all that matters is
computing this scalar potential
-
here and here, making
the difference,
-
and that will be your work.
-
It's a magic thing.
-
In mechanical
engineering maybe you
-
met it, in physics-- in
mechanical engineering,
-
because that's where you guys
drag all sorts of objects
-
around.
-
STUDENT: Conservative.
-
PROFESSOR: Ah, thank god.
-
Rachel, you're a
math major I think.
-
You're an engineering major.
-
STUDENT: [INAUDIBLE]
-
PROFESSOR: Wow, OK, and
who else said conservative?
-
And were there other people
who said conservative?
-
I'm sorry I don't have.
-
Well, next time I'll
bring a bunch of dollars,
-
and I'll start giving
prizes as dollar bills
-
like I used to give in
differential equations.
-
Everybody was so
happy in my class.
-
Because for everything that
they got quickly and right,
-
they got $1.
-
So conservative-- very good.
-
Remember that for
the next few lessons.
-
We will show that when this f is
magical, that is conservative,
-
you guys don't have to
compute the integral at all.
-
There's no parametrization,
no nothing.
-
It really doesn't depend
on what path you take.
-
All you would need is to figure
who this little f will be,
-
this scalar potential.
-
Our future work can do that.
-
And then you compute the values
of that scalar potential here
-
and here, make the difference.
-
And for sure you'll have
such a problem in the final.
-
So I'm just anticipating
it, because I
-
want this to be absorbed
in time into your system.
-
When we will do the
final exam review,
-
you should be baptized
in this kind of problem
-
so that everybody will get
100% on that for the final.
-
OK, now I'll let you go.
-
Sorry I didn't give you a break.
-
But now I give you more time.
-
And enjoy the day.
-
I'll see you Thursday.
-
-
I'm moving to my office.
-
If you have questions,
you can come to my office.
-
-
Maybe you were getting close.
-
How did-- did you know,
or it just came to you?
-
[BACKGROUND CHATTER]
-
-
STUDENT: Do you know
what section it would be?
-
Because I don't even think
he's listed or anything.
-
PROFESSOR: Send me an email
if you don't figure it out.
-
But for sure [INAUDIBLE].
-
STUDENT: OK, because I was
going to do the honors,
-
but it was with [INAUDIBLE].
-
I don't know if he's
good, or she's good.
-
PROFESSOR: She's good.
-
But he's fantastic in the
sense that he will help you
-
whenever you stumble.
-
He's an extremely good teacher.
-
He explains really well.
-
He has a talent.
-
-
STUDENT: I'll look for him.
-
Thank you.
-
PROFESSOR: And if
you don't get him,
-
she is good as well-- not
exceptional like he is.
-
He's an exceptional teacher.
-
-
STUDENT: I'll go to the office.
-
PROFESSOR: Yes,
yes, [INAUDIBLE].
-