-
--Okay Max now this is it.
Left or right?
-
--Come on Max!
-
--Left!
-
Hi, my name is Tony and this is a
quick Every Frame a Painting.
-
Be warned, this video
spoils all of Snowpiercer.
-
So I am giving you a choice.
Beyond this point in the video...
-
--There's no turning back.
--There is no turning back.
-
--There's no turning back.
--There is no turning back.
-
--There is no turning back.
--And there's no turning back
-
you understand?
--Yes I do.
-
In nearly every blockbuster you watch or
Telltale game that you’ve played,
-
you've seen moments like this.
The protagonist has to make a choice,
-
and there’s no way to reverse it.
-
--Okay it's you.
-
Just to be clear, I think moments like
these are great and a foundation
-
of good storytelling.
-
But I do wish in movies they weren’t
presented through dialogue.
-
So today I look at
one possible alternative.
-
In fact, this is one of the
oldest traditions in cinema.
-
How do you show character choice?
-
Left or Right. That’s it.
-
We often forget that screen direction is
a tool, and that character choices
-
can be presented simply
by having them look.
-
Snowpiercer depends on one simple rule:
-
camera left is the back of the train,
while camera right is the front.
-
And we gradually move
from left to right.
-
In fact, you could see this film as
the story of a man who thinks
-
he has to keep pushing forward.
-
And yet everything that anchors him
and gives him his humanity
-
is behind him.
--You have to lead us.
-
Each decision he faces seems to be a
simple variation on these two directions
-
But the film doesnt make it easy for him
and sometimes he goes backwards.
-
--Curtis, my friend, we understand each
other, listen to my words, it wasn't me!
-
When he finally reaches the end of his
journey, Curtis is pushed
-
by yet another person
to go forward.
-
--I have devoted my entire life to this,
the eternal engine.
-
And to see the humanity behind
him as something lesser.
-
--You can save them from themselves
-
And given one final choice
between right and above
-
or left and below.
-
He chooses this.
-
The best part of this is
that Bong Joon-ho
-
has shown the moral progression of his
choices without ever needing dialogue.
-
Snowpiercer is probably the most lateral
film you’ll see this year.
-
And it’s proof that the simplest visual
ideas have a lot of grace and subtlety.
-
So the next time your character
runs into a complex choice...
-
Who knows?
-
Maybe it’s actually just a simple matter
of left or right.