-
It’s been a while.
-
I hope you all are doing well.
-
As I’m sure you all know, I’ve been on
a journey of self discovery these last couple
-
of months.
-
I read Edward Snowden’s new autobiography.
-
And honestly, it changed my life.
-
I also saw the new Joker movie.
-
And honestly, it changed my life.
-
And then, I tried vegemite.
-
And honestly, it changed my life.
-
But you’re probably not here to listen to
me talk about that, considering none of that
-
is in the title of the video.
-
So instead, we’re going to take a deep,
hard, throbbing look at the lore tablets located
-
at the very beginning of Hollow Knight.
-
For being the first lore tablets we see, it’s
surprising how little I’ve discussed them.
-
I briefly went over them in that one MatPat
response video I made, but that video was
-
bonkers enough without me going on an insane
tangent explaining abstract concepts like
-
“souls”, and “true forms”, and “words”.
-
But now, I think it’s time to finally get
to the bottom of this mystery.
-
These lore tablets are located in an area
called the King’s Pass.
-
This is basically the tutorial level where
the player is taught tricky maneuvers like
-
walking, jumping and focusing soul.
-
This last ability is specifically taught to
the player by reading this first lore tablet.
-
But even if the tablet’s main goal is to
teach the player a move, there still must
-
be some lore explanation for why the tablet
is there.
-
Considering this area is called the King’s
Pass, it seems likely that these tablets were
-
written, or scribbled, by the Pale King.
-
One thing that separates these tablets from
most of the other lore tablets found in the
-
game is how they all start with the same phrase:
Higher beings, these words are for you alone.
-
So these tablets were left specifically for
a group of people known as “Higher beings”.
-
But who exactly are these higher beings supposed
to be?
-
Some have argued that the tablets were left
for the vessels.
-
After all, the first lore tablet teaches the
Knight how to focus, a very specific ability
-
seemingly only vessels are shown performing.
-
And the vessels are the children of two gods,
so it would be reasonable to call them Higher
-
beings.
-
Another interpretation is that these tablets
are speaking directly to you, the player.
-
So I guess Higher beings in this case would
be humans.
-
Not sure how I feel about that.
-
I’m not a huge fan of either of these interpretations.
-
Instead, I’d like to argue that these tablets
were specially written for bugs that traveled
-
to Hallownest from the lands beyond.
-
I like this theory because it ties these tablets
into other parts of the lore, such as the
-
Mask Maker and the Pale King’s beacon.
-
But be warned, this theory is a little bit…
out there.
-
You might even call this theory a little “speculative”
or in other words “nonsense”.
-
So please keep an open mind while watching,
and don’t just assume that I’m right.
-
It’s entirely possible that we simply don’t
have enough information to truly answers some
-
of these questions, and that’s okay.
-
Let’s start with the very first hurdle we
have with this theory: “Higher beings”.
-
The game uses this phrase a total of six times:
three in the King’s Pass, one in the Howling
-
Cliffs, and one in the Ancient Basin, near
the entrance to the Abyss.
-
The last time it is used is to refer to the
Pale King and the White Lady’s union which
-
resulted in the creation of the worst charm
in the game, the Kingsoul.
-
Now the game never gives us a formal definition
of what Higher beings are, but we do have
-
a few external sources that mention it.
-
In a Reddit AMA, William Pellen explained
that Higher beings are creatures that exist
-
above all others, such as the Radiance, the
Pale King and the White Lady.
-
There is also a developer’s note found in
Hollow Knight’s code that states that Higher
-
beings are God-like creatures.
-
So by that logic, my theory makes no sense,
since the bugs regularly traveling to Hallownest
-
were probably not as powerful as the Pale
King.
-
But at the same time, it seems highly unlikely
that the Pale King would have written these
-
tablets for creatures of immense power like
himself.
-
He didn’t exactly roll out the welcome wagon
for the Radiance, after all.
-
So why exactly would the Pale King call regular
bugs Higher beings?
-
It all ties into the promise of Hallownest.
-
The second King’s Pass lore tablet, located
next to the Fury of the Fallen charm reads:
-
Let all bask in your majesty, for only this
kingdom could produce ones such as you.
-
From this tablet, we can tell that the “Higher
beings” the Pale King is referring to are
-
creatures with abilities produced by Hallownest.
-
The lore tablet in the Pale King’s throne
room tells us that the Pale King’s beacon
-
expanded the minds of bugs, and the lore tablet
in the Howling Cliff also mentions that the
-
kingdom grants bugs minds.
-
This is further backed up by Dream Nail dialogue
from both the Whispering Root, and this chonky
-
bug corpse.
-
So the King’s Pass tablet says that Higher
beings are produced by Hallownest, and several
-
sources claim that Hallownest itself expands
the minds of bugs, so this must be what the
-
Pale King means when he refers to Higher beings.
-
The reason the kingdom is called Hallownest
is because that is literally what it is.
-
An area of land hallowed, or made holy, by
the Pale King, granting those within it higher
-
thought.
-
So why exactly does William’s definition
of Higher beings conflict with these tablets?
-
Is William on bath salts again?
-
Well maybe, but another explanation could
be that the Pale King is likening his subjects
-
to gods as a way to make his gift sound even
greater.
-
It’s a bit of a lie on his part, and it
seems like his main motivation was to earn
-
the devotion of these bugs, but he is still
elevating their powers nonetheless.
-
Alright, that’s eight words down.
-
Let’s look at the other twenty-one words:
Your great strength marks you amongst us.
-
Focus your soul and you shall achieve feats
of which others can only dream.
-
This first sentence appears to parallel a
line from the Quirrel comic.
-
Quirrel explains that the path to Hallownest
is difficult to achieve, stating that Hallownest
-
accepts only the strong.
-
Of course, this raises the issue of how complete
weakling like Zote and Cloth were able to
-
make it to Hallownest in the first place.
-
But then again, Zote is just too cryptic of
a character in general.
-
I’ve been trying to pin down his political
ideology for months now.
-
I mean, is he an authoritarian, an anarchist
or a liberatarin?
-
This next sentence about focusing soul is
where things get a bit complicated.
-
Now in the mechanics of Hollow Knight, focusing
is when the Knight consumes souls in order
-
to repair its shell.
-
But what does it mean for regular bugs to
focus soul?
-
This ability seems to be reserved specifically
for Vessels.
-
And it seems very unlikely that the Pale King
wanted his subjects to mess with soul in that
-
way, considering he condemned the actions
of the Soul Master and his followers.
-
To answer why the Pale King would want his
subjects to “focus [their] soul”, I think
-
we’ll need to look at this from a different
angle.
-
Let’s talk about what the word “focus”
actually means.
-
If we look at how the word is used throughout
parts of the game, it appears to link up often
-
with both the use of soul and the use of mind.
-
This might not be true in every case, but
I think it’s a good framework to work from
-
when discussing this part of the game’s
lore.
-
Let’s start with the scholars of the Soul
Sanctum.
-
These bugs were hoarding soul in some strange
attempt to avoid the Radiance’s plague as
-
well as achieve immortality.
-
In one of their lore tablets, the scholars
mention a desire to “attain a pure focus”.
-
Now your guess is as good as mine as to what
that actually means, but it seems safe to
-
assume that it requires an impressive mastery
of soul.
-
And we can see that this act took quite a
heavy toll on the minds of the scholars, with
-
the Soul Twisters mentioning how their minds
swell and ache.
-
The possibility of a connection between focusing
and the mind becomes explicit when we look
-
at the Godseekers.
-
The Godseeker straight up tells the Knight
that they are using a Godly focus to attune
-
to the Gods of Hallownest and ascend their
own mind.
-
The Weathered Mask description also states
that it allows its wearer to focus their thoughts.
-
So in this instance.
-
focusing doesn’t seem to be related to soul
at all, but it still involves the mind.
-
We also have the Void Statue in the Hall of
Gods which reads “Void Given Focus”, which
-
in the initial release of Godmaster read “Void
Given Mind”.
-
This cut text might give us a hint of what
is going on here.
-
I have heard some argue that Team Cherry removed
the word “Mind” because void in it’s
-
base form already has a mind.
-
I, however, think that “Focus” and “Mind”
are somewhat interchangeable terms, which
-
is why Team Cherry used one instead of the
other.
-
It’s hard to say for sure, but I think we’re
supposed to understand that the Shade Lord
-
is some kind of conscious void being unlike
anything we’ve really seen before.
-
Now there are more examples we could look
at, but hopefully you can see what I’m getting
-
at.
-
Focusing for many characters in Hollow Knight
means the use of one’s mind in some capacity.
-
The scholars of the Soul Sanctum strained
their minds to try and attain a pure focus,
-
and the Godseekers used their focus in a way
to ascend their minds.
-
Let’s use that framework when interpreting
this final line from the most cryptic bastard
-
in this whole game: Mask Maker:
A wonderful thing to have, a face.
-
Not a thing with which we all are blessed.
-
For this kingdom's faceless, I shall provide.
-
A mask!
-
A face!
-
Does it need one?
-
Does it not?
-
To define.
-
To focus.
-
To exist.
-
The Mask Maker is basically equating being
able to focus with having a face.
-
To have a face means to exist.
-
So if we say that focusing means having a
mind, then the Mask Maker is saying that a
-
face is required in order to have a mind.
-
I know that sounds stupid and dumb, but if
you think about it philisophically, it makes
-
sense.
-
Having senitience or consciousness is paramount
to having a sense of self.
-
And what represents the concept of the self
better than the face?
-
There’s a parallel between this line from
Mask Maker and the lore tablet in the King’s
-
Pass.
-
Both establish the idea that not everyone
is capable of focusing, or in other words,
-
not everyone has a face.
-
Focusing allows you to achieve feats others
can only dream of, while having a face (which
-
lets you focus) is not something with which
all are blessed.
-
So in other words, this lore tablet might
be saying that Hallownest grants bugs “faces”
-
which allow them to think.
-
I know that might sound strange, but it actually
ties nicely into the second King’s Pass
-
lore tablet:
Within our lands do not hide your true form.
-
Let all bask in your majesty, for only this
kingdom could produce ones such as you.
-
What does true form mean?
-
Well the phrase “true form” is only used
in two other places in the game.
-
It is used in the Pure Nail description, as
well as the Ancient Mask description.
-
The Ancient Mask description reads:
A complete mask.
-
When whole, a mask protects its wearer, shielding
the true form beneath.
-
So this second tablet could be implying that
the reader might be wearing some kind of mask
-
in order to hide their true form.
-
They might be wearing this mask as a way to
be able to define, focus and exist, as Mask
-
Maker explains.
-
But this tablet is telling the reader that
their mask is no longer needed, implying that
-
this “face” is now provided by Hallownest
itself.
-
Now I know what you’re thinking.
-
What the hell is mossbag talking about?
-
Is he on bath salts again?
-
How does wearing a mask or having a face help
you focus?
-
And how does entering Hallownest affect any
of that.
-
Let’s look at the first lore tablet again;
the one that tells the reader to “focus
-
your soul”.
-
Now, the use of the word soul here might connect
to the Elegy for Hallownest.
-
At one point the poem states that Hallownest
tamed the “savage souls” of its subjects.
-
Perhaps this focusing of the soul is how this
taming occurs.
-
In other words, Hallownest grants bugs the
ability to focus their own souls, turning
-
them from savages to civilized bugs.
-
This resulted in the expansion of their minds,
as stated in the throne room tablet.
-
This line of thinking implies that bugs outside
of Hallownest can’t focus their souls as
-
well, which could be what we see in the Quirrel
comic.
-
The bugs in the wilderness must forgo higher
thought in order to adapt to the harsh conditions
-
of the land.
-
The Elegy of Hallownest also states that bugs’
“base instincts were redeemed”.
-
In other words, these bugs have unfavorable
instincts, but the Pale King’s beacon makes
-
up for these flaws, allowing the bugs to show
their true forms without shame.
-
However, it seems like some of these bugs
that wandered the wilderness wore masks, since
-
the second King’s Pass tablet mentions how
these bugs would hide their true forms.
-
We do see travelers wearing mask ingame, particularly
the Grimm Troupe and the Godseekers.
-
But I don’t know how representative these
characters are of the bugs that routinely
-
traveled to Hallownest.
-
Okay, so you just witnessed a bunch of mental
gymnastics there.
-
These last several minutes were dedicated
solely to trying to explain the “focus your
-
soul” line.
-
And to be perfectly honest, part of me wonders
if Team Cherry even intended half of these
-
connections I just made.
-
The fact that they changed that line of dialogue
about the Void being given focus may indicate
-
that a lot of this stuff might be pretty vague,
even to them.
-
But if we take a step back, I think this concept
still makes sense in a broader view.
-
Basically you need a “face” in order to
achieve higher thought, or to have an identity.
-
But not everyone is blessed with this naturally,
as some numbskulls are only capable of relying
-
on instinct to survive.
-
However, some would wear masks as a way to
supplement their savage nature.
-
But then the Pale King came along and promised
a world where masks weren’t needed.
-
He granted a “face” to bugs outright,
giving them the ability to control their savage
-
nature and achieve higher thought.
-
And now we come to the final lore tablet,
located right outside the sealed up door to
-
Hallownest:
Beyond this point you enter the land of King
-
and Creator.
-
Step across this threshold and obey our laws.
-
Bear witness to the last and only civilisation,
the eternal Kingdom.
-
Hallownest
Now this tablet specifically makes it clear
-
to me that these lore tablets are directed
at newcomers to the kingdom and not the vessels
-
or the player directly.
-
These tablets were likely erected during Hallownest’s
prime, whereas the vessels would have probably
-
appeared much, much later after the kingdom
fell.
-
And why would the Pale King be telling us
to obey Hallownest’s laws?
-
What, is he expecting me to pay taxes or something?
-
But of course, there is another problem with
this tablet that we need to discuss.
-
The Pale King calls Hallownest the “last
and only civiliszation”.
-
But we know that was a fucking lie because
there’s Pharloom, as well as wherever it
-
is Ze’mer is from.
-
So is the Pale King just unaware of these
other kingdoms, or is he purposefully lying
-
to the bugs entering Hallownest?
-
I wouldn’t be surprised if the Pale King
were being a bit dishonest here.
-
After all, his whole motivation appears to
be based on accruing worshippers to devote
-
themselves to him.
-
His servants even thought that he created
the world and everything in it, which obviously
-
isn’t true.
-
And that pretty much wraps up these tablets.
-
I should take a moment to address a few counter
arguments to my theory.
-
In the Wanderer’s Journal, the character
Ellina remarks the following when standing
-
next to the locked door in the Ancient Basin:
If only I could decipher the message on the
-
tablet next to the door, perhaps I could figure
out how to open it.
-
This dialogue might imply that Ellina is completely
incapable of reading the lore tablet, which,
-
just like the King’s Pass tablets, begins
with the phrase about Higher beings.
-
Is it because my assumption about what “Higher
beings” means in this context is wrong?
-
Is it because the text is written in a language
that Ellina can’t read?
-
My interpretation is that Ellina can read
this tablet, however, she can’t decipher
-
what the Pale King’s message means.
-
Perhaps she thinks that she could open the
door if she understood what regrets were hidden
-
in the Abyss.
-
Another explanation might be that bugs with
higher intelligence already, like Ellina,
-
can’t read these tablets because they only
appear to bugs whose minds were actually elevated
-
by Hallownest.
-
Regardless, I don’t think this sentence
from Ellina has to debunk the whole theory.
-
Another issue is how bugs like Zote, Cornifer,
Iselda, and Tiso are perfectly capable of
-
traversing the lands beyond Hallownest without
seemingly needing to wear masks.
-
My theory doesn’t really do anything to
address this problem, but it might be due
-
to what species of bugs these characters are.
-
Mask Maker mentions that only some bugs are
blessed with a face.
-
Maybe these characters are born with higher
thought and don’t need any help to show
-
intelligence.
-
I mean, Cornifer is obviously smart, the dude
wears glasses after all.
-
Or maybe I am completely misunderstanding
what masks actually do.
-
After all, none of what I’ve talked about
answers why the Mask Maker has those anime
-
swirly void eye things.
-
Like seriously what the fuck are those?
-
And does that play any roll into why he is
wearing a mask?
-
And that leaves a few questions about other
bugs in Hallownest as well.
-
Did the Vengeflies become Higher beings, or
are they still dumb as rocks even with the
-
Pale King’s beacon?
-
What about the bugs of Deepnest?
-
It’s unclear if they are in the beacon,
since Deepnest technically isn’t part of
-
Hallownest.
-
Are these bugs just naturally intelligent?
-
Midwife seems to think so, but she might be
a bit biased.
-
This would also imply that Mantises, Mushrooms
and some of the bees already had the intelligence
-
to focus their soul before the Pale King arrived.
-
Which makes it odd that this is never really
mentioned anywhere in the game.
-
We just kinda have to assume that they could
do this.
-
And that’s it for this video.
-
In general, I think it’s a compelling argument,
but remember, just because something is compelling,
-
that doesn’t mean it’s right.
-
That’s how you get cults like Scientology
and the NSA, the United States Bowling Congress.