-
I have never been arrested,
-
never spent a night in jail,
-
never had a loved one
thrown into the back of a squad car
-
or behind bars,
-
or be at the mercy of a scary,
confusing system
-
that at best sees them with indifference,
-
and at worst as monstrous.
-
The United States of America locks up
more people than any other nation
-
on the planet,
-
and Louisiana is our biggest incarcerator.
-
Most of you are probably like me --
-
lucky.
-
The closest we get to crime and punishment
is likely what we see on TV.
-
While making "Unprisoned,"
-
I met a woman who used to be like us --
-
Sheila Phipps.
-
(Recording) Sheila Phipps:
Before my son went to jail,
-
I used to see people be on television,
-
fighting, saying, "Oh, this person
didn't do it and this person is innocent."
-
And you know, you snub them
or you dismiss them,
-
and like, "Yeah, whatever."
-
Don't get me wrong,
-
there's a lot of people
who deserve to be in prison.
-
There's a lot of criminals out here.
-
But there are a lot of innocent
people that's in jail.
-
EA: Sheila's son, McKinley,
is one of those innocent people.
-
He served 17 years of a 30-year sentence
on a manslaughter charge.
-
He had no previous convictions,
-
there was no forensic
evidence in the case.
-
He was convicted solely
on the basis of eyewitness testimony,
-
and decades of research have shown
-
that eyewitness testimony
isn't as reliable
-
as we once believed it to be.
-
Scientists say that memory isn't precise.
-
It's less like playing back a video,
-
and more like putting together a puzzle.
-
Since 1989, when DNA testing
was first used to free innocent people,
-
over 70 percent of overturned convictions
were based on eyewitness testimony.
-
Last year,
-
the district attorney whose office
prosecuted McKinley's case
-
was convicted of unrelated
corruption charges.
-
When this district attorney
of 30 years stepped down,
-
the eyewitnesses
from McKinley's case came forward
-
and said that they had been pressured
into testifying by the district attorneys,
-
pressure which included
the threat of jail time.
-
Despite this, McKinley is still in prison.
-
(Recording) SP: Before this happened,
-
I never would've thought it.
-
And well, I guess it's hard
for me to imagine
-
that these things is going on, you know,
-
until this happened to my son.
-
It really opened my eyes.
-
It really, really opened my eyes.
-
I ain't gonna lie to you.
-
EA: Estimates of how many innocent
people are locked up
-
range between one and four percent,
-
which maybe doesn't sound like a lot,
-
except that it amounts
to around 87,000 people:
-
mothers, fathers, sons locked up,
-
often for decades,
-
for crimes they did not commit.
-
And that's not even counting
the roughly half a million people
-
who have been convicted of nothing --
-
those presumed innocent,
-
but who are too poor to bail out of jail
-
and therefore sit behind bars
for weeks upon months,
-
waiting for their case to come to trial --
-
or much more likely,
-
waiting to take a plea just to get out.
-
All of those people
have family on the outside.
-
(Recording) Kortney Williams: My brother
missed my high school graduation
-
because the night before,
-
he went to jail.
-
My brother missed my birthday dinner
-
because that day, actually,
he went to jail.
-
My brother missed his own birthday dinner
-
because he was in the wrong place
at the wrong time.
-
(Recording) EA: So all these times
when he ended up going to jail,
-
were charges pressed
or did he just get taken to jail?
-
KW: The charges would be pressed
-
and it would have a bond posted,
-
then the charges will get dropped ...
-
because there was no evidence.
-
EA: I met Kortney Williams
when I went to her college classroom
-
to talk about "Unprisoned."
-
She ended up interviewing her aunt,
Troylynn Robertson,
-
for an episode.
-
(Recording) KW: With everything
that you went through
-
with your children,
-
what is any advice that you would give me
-
if I had any kids?
-
(Recording) Troylynn Roberston:
I would tell you when you have them,
-
you know the first thing
that will initially come to mind is love
-
and protection,
-
but I would tell you,
-
even much with the protection
to raise them
-
with knowledge of the judicial system --
-
you know, we always tell our kids
about the boogeyman,
-
the bad people, who to watch out for,
-
but we don't teach them
how to watch out for the judicial system.
-
EA: Because of the way
our criminal legal system
-
disproportionately targets
people of color,
-
it's not uncommon for young people
like Kortney to know about it.
-
When I started going into high schools
to talk to students about "Unprisoned,"
-
I found that roughly one-third
of the young people I spoke with
-
had a loved one behind bars.
-
(Recording) Girl: The hardest part
is like finding out where he's at,
-
or like, when his court date is.
-
Girl: Yeah, he went to jail
on my first birthday.
-
Girl: My dad works as a guard.
-
He saw my uncle in jail.
-
He's in there for life.
-
EA: According to the Annie E.
Casey Foundation,
-
the number of young people with a father
incarcerated rose 500 percent
-
between 1980 and 2000.
-
Over five million of today's children
will see a parent incarcerated
-
at some point in their childhoods.
-
But this number disproportionately
affects African-American children.
-
By the time they reach the age of 14,
-
one in four black children
will see their dad go off to prison.
-
That's compared to a rate
of one in 30 for white children.
-
One key factor determining the future
success of both inmates and their children
-
is whether they can maintain ties
during the parent's incarceration,
-
but prisoners' phone calls home
can cost 20 to 30 times more
-
than regular phone calls,
-
so many families
keep in touch through letters.
-
(Recording: Letter being unfolded)
-
Anissa Christmas: Dear big brother,
-
I'm making that big 16 this year, LOL.
-
Guess I'm not a baby anymore.
-
You still taking me to prom?
-
I really miss you.
-
You're the only guy
that kept it real with me.
-
I wish you were here so I can vent to you.
-
So much has happened since
the last time I seen you.
-
(Voice breaking up) I have some good news.
-
I won first place in the science fair.
-
I'm a geek.
-
We're going to regionals,
can't you believe it?
-
High school is going by super fast.
-
In less than two years,
-
I hope you'll be able to see me
walk across the stage.
-
I thought to write to you
because I know it's boring in there.
-
I want to put a smile on your face.
-
Anissa wrote these letters to her brother
-
when she was a sophomore in high school.
-
She keeps the letters he writes to her
tucked into the frame
-
of her bedroom mirror,
-
and reads them over and over again.
-
I'd like to think
that there's a good reason
-
why Anissa's brother is locked up.
-
We all want the wheels of justice
to properly turn,
-
but we're coming to understand
-
that the lofty ideals we learned
in school look really different
-
in our nation's prisons
and jails and courtrooms.
-
(Recording) Danny Engelberg: You walk
into that courtroom and you're just --
-
I've been doing this for a quite a while,
and it still catches your breath.
-
You're like, "There are so many
people of color here,"
-
and yet I know that the city is not
made up of 90 percent African-Americans,
-
so why is it that 90 percent
of the people who are in orange
-
are African-American?
-
(Recording) EA: Public defender Danny
Engelberg isn't the only one noticing
-
how many black people
are in municipal court --
-
or in any court.
-
It's hard to miss.
-
Who's sitting in court
waiting to see the judge?
-
What do they look like?
-
(Recording) Man: Mostly
African-Americans, like me.
-
Man: It's mostly, I could say,
85 percent black.
-
That's all you see in the orange,
in the box back there, who locked up.
-
Man 2: Who's waiting? Mostly black.
-
I mean, there was a couple
of white people in there.
-
Woman: I think it was about
85 percent African-American
-
that was sitting there.
-
EA: How does a young black person
growing up in America today
-
come to understand justice?
-
Another "Unprisoned" story
was about a troupe of dancers
-
who choreographed a piece
called "Hoods Up,"
-
which they performed
in front of city council.
-
Dawonta White was in the seventh grade
for that performance.
-
(Recording) Dawonta White: We was wearing
black with hoodies because Trayvon Martin,
-
when he was wearing his hoodie,
he was killed.
-
So we looked upon that,
-
and we said we're going to wear
hoodies like Trayvon Martin.
-
(Recording) EA: Who came up
with that idea?
-
DW: The group. We all agreed on it.
-
I was a little nervous,
but I had stick through it though,
-
but I felt like it was a good thing
so they could notice what we do.
-
(Recording) EA: Shraivell Brown
was another choreographer and dancer
-
in "Hoods up."
-
He says the police criticize
people who look like him.
-
He feels judged based on things
other black people may have done.
-
How would you want
the police to look at you
-
and what would you want them to think?
-
SB: That I'm not no threat.
-
EA: Why would they think
you're threatening?
-
What did you say, you're 14?
-
SB: Yes, I'm 14, but because he said
a lot of black males
-
are thugs or gangsters and all that,
-
but I don't want them thinking
that about me.
-
EA: For folks who look like me,
-
the easiest and most comfortable
thing to do is to not pay attention --
-
to assume our criminal
legal system is working.
-
But if it's not our responsibility
to question those assumptions,
-
whose responsibility is it?
-
There's a synagogue here that's taken on
learning about mass incarceration,
-
and many congregants have concluded
-
that because mass incarceration
throws so many lives into chaos,
-
it actually creates more crime --
-
makes people less safe.
-
Congregant Teri Hunter says
-
the first step towards action
has to be understanding.
-
She says it's crucial for all of us
to understand our connection to this issue
-
even if it's not immediately obvious.
-
(Recording) Teri Hunter:
It's on our shoulders
-
to make sure that we're not
just closing that door
-
and saying, "Well, it's not us."
-
And I think as Jews, you know,
we've lived that history:
-
"It's not us."
-
And so if a society
closes their back on one section,
-
we've seen what happens.
-
And so it is our responsibility as Jews
-
and as members of this community
-
to educate our community --
-
at least our congregation --
-
to the extent that we're able.
-
EA: I've been using
the pronouns "us" and "we"
-
because this is our criminal legal system
-
and our children.
-
We elect the district attorneys,
-
the judges and the legislators
who operate these systems
-
for we the people.
-
As a society,
-
we are more willing to risk
locking up innocent people
-
than we are to let guilty people go free.
-
We elect politicians
who fear being labeled "soft on crime,"
-
encouraging them to pass harsh legislation
-
and allocate enormous resources
toward locking people up.
-
When a crime is committed,
-
our hunger for swift retribution
has fed a police culture
-
bent on finding culprits fast,
-
often without adequate resources
to conduct thorough investigations
-
or strict scrutiny
of those investigations.
-
We don't put checks on prosecutors.
-
Across the country,
over the last couple of decades,
-
as property and violent crimes
have both fell,
-
the number of prosecutors employed
and cases they have filed has risen.
-
Prosecutors decide
whether or not to take legal action
-
against the people police arrest
-
and they decide what charges to file,
-
directly impacting how much time
a defendant potentially faces behind bars.
-
One check we do have
on prosecutors is defense.
-
Imagine Lady Liberty:
-
the blindfolded woman holding the scale
-
meant to symbolize the balance
in our judicial system.
-
Unfortunately, that scale is tipped.
-
The majority of defendants in our country
-
are represented by
government-appointed attorneys.
-
These public defenders
receive around 30 percent less funding
-
than district attorneys do,
-
and they often have caseloads
far outnumbering
-
what the American Bar
Association recommends.
-
As Sheila Phipps said,
-
there are people who belong in prison,
-
but it's hard to tell
the guilty from the innocent
-
when everyone's outcomes are so similar.
-
We all want justice.
-
But with the process weighed
so heavily against defendants,
-
justice is hard to come by.
-
Our criminal legal system
operates for we the people.
-
If we don't like what's going on,
-
it is up to us to change it.
-
Thank you very much.
-
(Applause)