-
Produced by KIM Jho-Kwang-soo
SHIN Chang-kil
-
HA Jung-woo
-
PARK Hee-soon
-
JANG Hyuk
-
Directed by SOHN Young-Sung
-
HAN Cheol-min?
-
HAN Cheol-min, right?
-
It's him.
-
You're under arrest
for the murder of your wife.
-
You have right to remain silent
and hire a lawyer.
-
Let's go.
-
Come on.
-
Watch your head.
-
The Client
-
Between midnight and 1 a.m.on December 9th 2010
-
HAN Cheol-min killed
his wife at home.
-
Using his silver SUV
-
he dumped the body
somewhere unknown.
-
Around 5 a.m.
-
he came back to the scene.
-
The police apprehended him
red-handed.
-
HAN was suspicious
of his wife's infidelity.
-
She asked for a divorce
4 days earlier.
-
And that gave him motive.
-
HAN is denying his crime.
-
But the prosecution says
-
they have enough evidence
-
to support his charge.
-
Wow.
-
What's your cut?
-
It's 5:5, as always.
-
You're kidding me.
-
Will you take HAN's case,
or not?
-
Not interested.
-
He's insisting on you
to represent him.
-
Did you know him?
-
No.
-
Why bother with a case
you can't win?
-
I understand.
There isn't even a body.
-
This kind of case has
two precedents.
-
Did it happen inside?
Or outside?
-
For the former,
without hard evidence
-
it's all circumstantial
and you have no case.
-
The suspect walks.
-
Even if the body turns up later
-
double jeopardy is prohibited.
-
What about the latter?
-
If the killer is human,
there's always evidence.
-
Then it's easier
to put the story together.
-
Mostly guilty.
-
The prosecution says
he planned it.
-
If it's true, 18 years at least.
-
Any possibility
HAN might confess?
-
I know.
-
That would knock some years off.
-
You know what he needs?
-
Pro bono.
-
Wait, KANG.
-
Okay.
Let's make it 6:4.
-
What are you, his agent?
-
Fine.
-
It's 7:3.
-
That is
-
KANG!
-
She's out!
-
Calm down, guys.
-
Be careful.
-
I'll take questions.
-
Why do you keep quiet
about a sex video?
-
That's not the issue here.
This is a libel suit.
-
Her agent scarred the life
of an innocent actress.
-
Ouch!
-
Don't step on my foot.
-
Is there a sex video?
-
That's not important.
Watch it, guys.
-
- What's the truth?
- I will tell you.
-
It's the prosecution's job
to uncover the truth.
-
Everything about the case is
on my website.
-
I've watched the video!
-
It's WWW
-
- Move it!
- Hold on.
-
Come on, guys.
-
What a clown.
-
This jerk is AHN's friend?
-
Get out of here, PARK.
-
Sir.
-
That PARK is a fucking joke.
-
This kid is representing
HAN Cheol-min?
-
Not decided yet.
-
Why does he keep
fucking with us?
-
Shit.
-
When he was with us,
he was good.
-
Better than you?
-
Why did he quit?
-
He took on a murder case
of this Vietnamese girl.
-
And he was accused of
using violence.
-
Soon he quit.
-
Now he's running a circus.
-
I'm late for a rehearsal.
-
They will be mad.
-
God, I have bags under my eyes.
-
My head hurts.
I drank too much last night.
-
You sure did.
-
Will they appeal?
-
Never.
-
- Hurry, I'm showering.
- I'm done.
-
Hello?
-
HAN fucked up.
-
What?
-
He tried to kill himself.
-
- Why?
- You don't know?
-
I would at least meet him.
You're a bad lawyer!
-
God, it's cold.
-
What took you so long?
-
When'd you get here?
-
A while ago.
-
Let's go.
I've seen enough.
-
You wore that suit yesterday.
-
I know.
-
So what?
What do you care?
-
You're so nosy.
-
He kills his wife
and dumps the body.
-
And he comes back with a gift
to the scene crowded by cops?
-
It was their anniversary.
-
He's a total psycho.
-
Let's take the stairs.
-
Married for 3 years.
No kids.
-
He works at a film developer's.
-
When the cops got here
-
they saw nothing
but a blood bed.
-
A DNA test confirms
it's wife's blood.
-
She's dead for sure.
-
No signs of forced entry.
-
Any evidence?
-
Nothing.
-
The body is gone.
So is the murder weapon.
-
Everything is circumstantial.
-
So it's a puzzle
without pieces.
-
Is this CCTV
on the evidence list?
-
No.
-
Hi.
-
I'm investing HAN's case.
-
Did the cops take
CCTV footage?
-
They did.
-
It's stored in file, right?
-
Sure.
-
You still have it?
-
We delete everything
past a month.
-
All right.
Thanks.
-
This might be fun.
-
There's an eye witness.
-
Isn't HAN strange?
-
I don't know.
-
Here's what makes the case
so complicated.
-
No fingerprints or DNA of his
found in his apartment.
-
Does it make sense?
-
Not a single hair of his
in his own place?
-
Right.
-
And here's the shocker.
-
He has no fingerprints.All 10 of them.
-
Your hand.
-
Let me.
-
Okay.
-
Your wife had a lover?
-
Yes.
-
How did you know?
-
I've seen her
on the phone with him.
-
And my gut feelings.
-
Is that what you said
to the police?
-
Yes.
-
You know the guy?
-
No.
-
Why is that missing
in the police report?
-
Sir?
-
Do you believe me?
-
Pretty much.
I believe everybody.
-
Mr. HAN.
-
People often ask me that.
-
It doesn't matter
whether I do or not.
-
I will just focus on getting
what we want.
-
It won't be easy
without his confession.
-
Cause AHN is on this?
-
What about him?
-
He's a hard nut to crack.
-
I couldn't care less.
-
Out.
-
In.
-
Out.
-
In!
-
What are you, a blind?
-
Fine.
-
His wife had a lover,
but it's not in the report.
-
If it's true,
her lover is a key suspect.
-
We should utilize this.
-
Let's try to make a deal with it.
-
Would he confess?
-
I will talk him into it
if it looks good.
-
If he killed on impulse
without intent?
-
We'll go for manslaughter.
-
That will take a lot of years off.
-
Prosecutor AHN?
It's been a while.
-
(Less than 5 years)
-
Good.
-
How's life treating you?
-
A plea bargain?
-
Listen to yourself.
-
Sounds like you're desperate.
-
We don't need his confession.
-
What about her lover?
-
She didn't have one.
-
Checked the phone record?
-
There's no one.
-
Yeah?
-
That's the truth.
-
I will request a discovery.
-
That won't happen.
-
This is a homicide
without the body.
-
No way I can't give you
what we have.
-
Okay.
-
I'll keep this.
-
Don't take this case.
-
You will regret it later.
-
You don't wanna make it
a habit to mess up.
-
It's a gift.
-
I will have him out
on lack of evidence.
-
Hi, Professor.
-
- How are you?
- Good.
-
Homicide without a body?
-
Right.
-
Let's talk over lunch.
-
More coffee?
-
No, thanks.
-
I'm leaving.
-
Professor AHN will be
here soon.
-
My father?
-
I will see him at home.
-
You'll take the case?
-
Why don't you get
a second thought?
-
It's weird.
-
They won't tell us
which judge will preside.
-
It is weird.
-
The victim's lover.
A missing living room light.
-
Why isn't CCTV
on the evidence list?
-
Get me that CCTV file.
-
I'm sure it has been
already deleted.
-
Then get me evidence
that it's been deleted.
-
KANG?
-
HAN's trial is set
to begin in 3 days.
-
Seems like they've already
found him guilty.
-
Good morning!
Come to my office.
-
Nobody's giving us answers.
-
We have to find them.
-
Here, coffee and donuts.
-
Do you know
what bothers me the most?
-
Everything took place
too quickly
-
as if the police saw it coming.
-
The police arrived
at 1 :30 a.m.
-
HAN was arrested at 5 a.m.
-
Isn't it strange?
-
No physical evidence.
Everything is circumstantial.
-
Within that short period of time
-
they were able to build a case.
-
Doesn't it smell?
-
Detective LEE?
-
Why isn't CCTV
on the evidence list?
-
Who took the living room light?
-
Check with that cop
who was at the scene.
-
I bet his story has loose ends.
-
Check witnesses as well.
-
The guy from downstairs.
-
He says he saw HAN that night.
-
He might be lying.
-
Okay.
-
I got it.
-
The victim's mother.
-
She claims her daughter came
3 days prior to murder
-
and told her
that HAN would kill her.
-
She's said to hate HAN.
-
So, see if her story sticks.
-
You handle the detective
and the mother-in-law.
-
I'll check the witness's alibi.
-
Time is not on our side.
Let's get to work.
-
Judge LEE?
-
What is this?
I can't be seen with you.
-
Come on, it's okay.
-
On the night of murder
-
HAN took a highway,
not a turnpike.
-
He said he was so tired
and missed it.
-
Then he hit a guardrail
and passed out.
-
He was arrested at 5.
-
So he was out
for over 3 hours.
-
We need to check that out.
-
Look here.
-
This is the highway he took.
-
Don't touch it.
-
It couldn't be better
if you find a witness.
-
If not, find a crash site
to prove his alibi.
-
Any questions?
-
I have one.
-
The trial begins in 3 days.
-
And you expect me
to do all that in 3 days?
-
It will be postponed.
-
What?
-
It will.
-
Got it.
-
HAN's attorney hasn't
contacted you, right?
-
I can't believe this.
-
Didn't my boss call you?
-
Your job evaluation is
next month.
-
Watch it.
You can't blackmail me.
-
Get HAN out of the way.
-
I'm concerned about
your promotion.
-
Judge LEE Jin-wook
-
The defendant was late
to appoint his attorney.
-
So he requests a postponement?
-
I won't allow it.
-
HAN has requested
a jury trial.
-
Hot!
-
The trial has been postponed.
-
Shit.
-
It takes at least 2 weeks
to pick jurors.
-
Good luck.
-
A jury trial?
-
Okay.
-
Once the trial begins,
there'll be a lot of hassles.
-
I will call you
as the date is set.
-
Okay.
I will be waiting.
-
Then
-
Mr. Prosecutor?
-
My daughter would feel
the same as I do.
-
You're doing the right thing.
Don't feel guilty.
-
You have to win this case
for my little girl.
-
So HAN left around 10 p.m.?
-
Yes, 10 o'clock.
-
That's about right.
-
Was he acting weird
that day?
-
Or said anything strange?
-
I don't know.
-
Nothing unusual.
-
A key to the prop room?
-
He was in a hurry, though.
-
Now that I think about it.
-
No.
-
Mt. Chunma, Chungpyong,
Namisum, Gapyong, Chuncheon.
-
Why can't he remember
where he crashed?
-
Wait!
Hold on!
-
What?
-
A dummy that we use
for a dead body was missing.
-
Hi.
-
That witness from downstairs.
-
He's not home.
-
I haven't seen him for a while.
-
He must be out of town.
-
Any idea when he'll be back?
-
We don't talk much.
-
Why'd you leave your office
for so long that night?
-
God, it was a nightmare.
-
I had to go to the park lot
by the next building.
-
It was a mess.
-
What time was it?
-
Not quite sure.
It was before midnight.
-
You don't know who it was?
-
All I saw was a dark figure.
-
Which company handles
your CCTVs?
-
A detective in charge took it.
-
LEE something.
-
Are you sure?
-
Let me check.
I kept the record.
-
Hold on.
-
Yes, it was him.
-
It was 1 :30 a.m.
-
No, a little before 1 :30.
-
The police arrived at 1 :30.
And he came before that?
-
Right.
-
Why would I lie?
-
Hello?
-
Detective LEE took it.
-
Everything from a month earlier.
-
If he doesn't have it,
the prosecution does.
-
Check that out.
-
Hello?
Hello?
-
Shit, I can't believe him.
-
Excuse me?
-
Detective LEE Byung-guk is
with you guys, right?
-
Beats me.
Ask someone else.
-
Wait.
-
Thanks for no help!
-
So it was a dummy?
Not a body?
-
Yeah.
-
What time was it?
-
Let me see.
-
Want one?
-
I would say around 1 1 .
-
Run the plate.
-
Nothing.
-
Yeah?
-
38 NA 6609, pull over.
-
Pull over now.
-
- How are you?
- What?
-
You were going awfully fast.
-
Step out of the vehicle.
-
It's just routine.
-
Let go!
What is this?
-
Cuff him and call for backup.
-
Okay.
-
Wait.
-
What's this?
-
Calm down, pal.
-
The vehicle wasn't registered?
-
Right.
-
You guys look good
in this one.
-
I popped the question
on this day.
-
Were you mad to learn
she was cheating?
-
Do I have to testify in court?
-
No, that won't do us
any good.
-
You will take the fifth.
-
Won't the jury be suspicious?
-
I don't know.
-
I will do whatever you say.
-
What's that?
-
They're the same candles
as the ones found at the scene.
-
For one, all the way.
-
For the other,
down to the line here.
-
Time how long it takes
and let me know.
-
What's this for?
-
Time difference.
-
What?
-
Only one didn't burn
all the way down.
-
Somebody lit it afterwards.
-
Who did?
-
HAN Cheol-min.
-
This will prove the fact
he was home.
-
I don't know.
-
I thought it was the wife.
-
But it could be somebody else.
-
-Sir!
-Get out of here!
-
Come on, listen to me.
-
I simply asked you
-
about an accident here
two months ago.
-
Why are you so mad?
-
What accident?
I don't know anything.
-
Wait, wait.
-
If you remember anything
-
Or if you hear of any,
-
I'll leave my card here.
-
Call me
if you remember anything.
-
Thanks!
-
Damn.
-
Hi, kid.
-
You live around here?
-
You're limping.
-
You hurt your leg?
-
Kid?
-
Hey!
-
He could've talked
instead of rubbing himself.
-
It'll be hard to find a witness
or an accident site.
-
What are you doing?
Are you in the shower?
-
Yeah.
-
Here's what I found out.
-
A prop dummy?
-
Can't ID the driver?
-
I'm sure
CCTV got the killer.
-
That detective took it
from a month earlier
-
even before they got
to the scene.
-
Maybe the wife's lover?
-
You think her lover did it?
-
It's a possibility.
-
Not sure yet.
-
It's okay if that detective
acted on his own.
-
If upstairs is involved?
It's a different story.
-
Why hide the killer?
-
Hi.
-
To confirm death
without the body
-
how much blood are we
talking about?
-
Blood loss of 2.4~3 liters is
usually lethal.
-
A sudden loss of over a liter
can kill you.
-
The amount at the scene was
way over 3 liters.
-
So it was enough for us
to confirm death.
-
Did forensics find DNA or
fingerprints at the scene
-
that didn't belong
to the defendant?
-
No, not at all.
-
- Signs of forced entry?
- None.
-
So it can't be anybody else
but the defendant.
-
Objection!
It's leading.
-
Let me rephrase it.
-
Is there any possibility
it could be someone else?
-
No.
-
No more questions.
-
The door was open
when they arrived at the scene.
-
So anything is possible.
-
You said nobody broke in.
Couldn't she have walked out?
-
That's possible.
-
But very unlikely.
-
So you're saying
it's not impossible.
-
Objection!
-
The defense is playing on words.
-
The witness was referring
to a general concept.
-
Sustained.
-
The killer walked out the door.
He didn't even clean the scene.
-
Doesn't that mean
it was on impulse?
-
These were taken
at the scene.
-
A blood-stained bed sheet.
-
A dining table.
-
Pay attention to this one.
-
Only one candle didn't
burn all the way down.
-
Because it was lit afterwards.
-
Estimated to be lit at 12:20 a.m.
-
That's the time of death
calculated by forensics
-
through a coagulation
of blood.
-
Say the killer lit it.
-
How would you evaluate
his mental state?
-
He didn't miss the candle,
excited after killing.
-
I suspect an anti-social
personality disorder.
-
What?
-
Speak English, please.
-
A psychopath.
-
Objection.
-
It's all circumstantial.
-
We shouldn't rule out
other possibilities.
-
It could've been lit
by the third person.
-
What's your basis on that?
-
I say the Government has
a reasonable theory.
-
Please, continue.
-
Let me remind you.
-
No other fingerprints
were found at the scene
-
except the victim and
the defendant's.
-
And there were no signs
of forced entry.
-
Only one person could
have lit that candle.
-
Thanks.
-
She became confident.
after the marriage.
-
And she worked very hard.
-
It was good.
-
Nobody would touch it.
-
It's all superstition.
-
Then again,
she was quite different.
-
What's wrong?
-
Her mother objected
to her husband?
-
Don't tell me.
-
Very possessive.
-
She considered her girl
a belonging.
-
She would've objected
to any guy.
-
Was she seeing someone?
-
No way.
-
She was almost obsessed
with her husband.
-
He's said to have the
delusion of infidelity.
-
No, it was her.
-
She was even seeing a shrink.
-
She was?
-
She was treated
for depression.
-
Find out what hospital
she went to.
-
And a month prior
to the murder
-
HAN was away for 3 days
on business.
-
Her colleague says
she got worse after that.
-
Delete?
-
Let's go home.
-
Go ahead.
-
KANG called Detective LEE
for his witness.
-
He's coming out swinging.
-
We expected that.
-
No.
-
It doesn't feel right.
-
LEE might start talking
in court to save his ass.
-
We will go as planned.
-
If it doesn't work,
we all go down.
-
Prepare for the worst.
-
We can't afford to make us
a laughing stock.
-
Know what I mean?
-
You want me to come in?
-
We don't know what he did
with the CCTV file.
-
That's why I called him
for our witness.
-
He finds out
we know he took it.
-
He doesn't wanna testify.
-
He will contact us.
-
If this doesn't work?
-
We will grind him in court.
-
OK, I'm on my way.
-
Who the hell are you?
-
Wait, wait.
-
I'm Detective LEE.
-
- Who?
- LEE Byung-guk.
-
- LEE Byung-guk?
- Yes, drive.
-
I have something to tell you.
Hit the road.
-
- Really?
- Yes.
-
You're Detective LEE?
-
That's me.
-
You have that CCTV file?
-
Prosecutor AHN does.
-
What's in it?
-
I have no idea.
-
We thought you deleted it.
-
If you want it
-
I can get you a copy.
-
In return?
-
No testimony.
And he'll talk through me.
-
That's all?
-
He wants to be left alone
once he hands us the file.
-
Can we trust him?
-
We have no choice.
-
They must've kept it
for a reason.
-
If they submit it to court
and HAN is in it?
-
We're fucked.
-
Let's see what's in it.
-
Okay.
-
KANG removed LEE
off the witness list.
-
He must've contacted him.
-
Should we proceed?
-
Sir?
-
What the...
-
Shut up.
-
AHN put a tail on me.
I had to lose him.
-
God, it's getting worse.
-
I'm scared shitless.
I don't think I can do this.
-
Don't back down now.
-
I know, but I'm too scared.
-
What should we do?
-
He was beaten up
by other inmates.
-
We almost lost him.
-
What are you talking about?
-
Think about it.
-
They got the scent
and put a tail on LEE.
-
There's this lieutenant
whose son has leukemia.
-
Hospital bills are
up to his eyeballs.
-
Are you suggesting
we buy their evidence?
-
No way in hell.
-
We have no other options.
-
No way!
-
Then what?
-
Stop the car.
-
KANG!
-
I said no.
-
We will put LEE
on the witness stand.
-
If HAN is in that CCTV file?
-
We're screwed in court!
-
My answer is still no!
-
Don't talk to LEE anymore.
-
Period!
-
God!
-
Resident Register
-
HAN Cheol-min
-
JANG Ho-won
-
Hey.
-
What's the emergency?
-
Remember that
high school girl killing?
-
Yeah.
-
A high school girl
went missing at night.
-
12 hours later,
found dead at the park.
-
The killer raped her
-
and banged her head
on the ground to death.
-
But he didn't leave behind
any evidence.
-
The police were afraid
it might lead to serial killings.
-
So they did everything.
-
They even went public
and put a bounty on him.
-
However, the killer is
still on the loose.
-
You know what?
They did have a suspect.
-
They were certain
he did it.
-
But he was released
on lack of evidence.
-
HAN was questioned
for 3 days.
-
That explains his 3 days
of disappearance.
-
Where'd you get this?
-
Somebody sent it
anonymously.
-
A cop?
-
You should've have done it.
-
He should know about him
as his attorney.
-
If you testify,
you can't come back.
-
If I don't?
-
We might lose the case.
-
You can win if I testify?
-
I don't know.
-
Let me level with you.
-
Whatever it takes,
I wanna win.
-
So I need you to testify.
-
Sergeant SEO?
A high school girl killing?
-
I don't know.
-
They sure can keep secrets.
-
Keep talking.
-
They had a suspect,
and he was a hard-ass.
-
They knew he did it,
but there was no evidence.
-
Know that Professor CHOI
from Police University?
-
The one who gets on TV?
-
He interrogated the guy
and said he was innocent.
-
Then they let him walk.
-
See you.
-
I'm not at liberty
to talk about HAN.
-
I'm only seeing you
cause you came to see me.
-
Why was HAN the suspect?
-
He was like the killer
-
Poker face.
-
No fingerprints.
-
And he wasn't shaken at all
for a 3-day-long questioning.
-
The cops were running
out of patience.
-
I'm not the killer.
-
What the fuck!
-
You piece of shit!
-
Motherfucker!
-
You can't book him
without evidence!
-
You wanna see my ass
getting fried?
-
The prosecutor said if we...
-
What are you, a moron?
-
If things go wrong?
-
It's us who take the fall!
-
Where's Sergeant SEO?
-
I want his ass in my office!
-
Boss?
-
Go get me evidence.
-
You saw him.
He has no fingerprints.
-
He can't leave evidence.
-
And that son of a bitch
doesn't have an alibi.
-
The witness said
it wasn't him?
-
I don't understand it.
-
He picked out his mugshot
and said no at the line up.
-
- He picked out his mugshot?
- Yes!
-
Get Professor CHOI.
-
Professor CHOI.
-
Why'd you use a lie detector?
-
Sorry.
-
Not even admissible in court.
-
There's no way
to get him to talk now.
-
What then?
-
We will do it tonight.
-
Place a pile of documentson the table to pressure him.
-
And get a bloody rock as if it were evidence.
-
The location of the table is important.
-
Put it where HAN has to
turn his head to look at it.
-
If he's the killer,
he can't ignore it.
-
I'm not asking if you did it.
-
I know you did it.
-
Why did you go back
to the scene?
-
I was walking by
and saw the crowd.
-
So I got curious.
-
We have a witness.
-
He identified you as a killer
at the scene.
-
You can choose.
-
A prison?
Or a hospital?
-
You will be treated
for insanity.
-
Your witness got the wrong person.
-
He's not the killer!
-
Release him now!
-
When I heard of his arrest,
I couldn't believe it.
-
The prosecutor for that case
-
It was AHN Min-ho.
-
HAN.
-
Are you that stupid?
-
If you hide it,
you only raise suspicion.
-
I wasn't thinking right.
-
I didn't think
it would do me any good.
-
So I kept it from you.
-
Can't you see
what's going on here?
-
They'll create a motive out of it!
-
Am I the only one
who cares about this trial?
-
Is that it?
-
Come on, spill the beans.
-
You did it, didn't you?
-
Tell me honestly!
-
You had no other reason
to keep it from me!
-
Come on.
-
You killed her, didn't you?
-
The way you look at me
-
It's not different
from the way others do.
-
That stopped me
from telling you.
-
You're the only one
I can depend on now.
-
But you don't believe me.
-
I didn't kill my wife.
-
I can't even accept the fact
she's dead.
-
So don't look at me like that.
-
I did not kill my wife.
-
KANG.
-
Why'd you turn your phone off?
-
KANG?
-
We're gonna lose.
-
No way.
-
It's not HAN
in that CCTV file.
-
If we get hold of it,
we can totally win.
-
If HAN was in it
-
they had no reason to hide it.
-
HAN was a suspect
for a high school girl killing.
-
I knew he was strange.
-
So we're giving up?
-
What should we do?
-
Who knows
what that detective did?
-
We need to get that file.
HAN isn't in it.
-
Let's call it a night.
I will call you.
-
What's this?
You hit the booze without me?
-
Being an attorney sucks.
-
What's going on here?
-
You think I can pull this off?
-
Damn.
-
Attorney KANG,
Can I tell you something?
-
Yeah.
-
It never crossed my mind
-
that you might lose.
-
This photo makes me feel weird.
-
So happy back then.
-
They didn't see this coming,
did they?
-
I know.
-
What if HAN is the killer?
-
Tell me.
-
Do you have doubts
about his innocence?
-
I do.
-
One thing is clear.
-
The police told the wife
her hubby was a killer.
-
She didn't believe it.
-
So they threatened her
with a conspiracy thing.
-
How do you think
that made her feel?
-
Well
-
Shitty, I bet.
-
She came to see you
3 days prior to murder?
-
We didn't talk much
after she got married.
-
So I was surprised
when she came without a call.
-
What did she say?
-
She was shaking out of fear.
-
Honey, what's wrong?
-
What is it?
Come on, tell me.
-
Come on!
-
He's not the man I knew.
-
What do you mean?
Be specific.
-
He might kill me.
-
Back then I didn't know
what that meant.
-
I shouldn't have sent her back.
-
Was she always
that sensitive?
-
No.
-
She was nice and docile
before the marriage.
-
But she changed completely.
-
Constantly nervous
as if she were being chased.
-
It's all because of him.
-
He ruined my daughter.
-
My little girl
-
Tell us.
-
What's he like to you?
-
He's not human.
-
He's a demon.
-
I knew it when I first saw him.
-
Do you think he's capable
of killing your daughter?
-
I do!
-
Thank you.
-
No more questions.
-
You knew she was in danger.
Why didn't you do anything?
-
You had 3 days.
-
You could've found a way
to help her.
-
Did you talk to her afterwards?
-
I was so confused then.
-
And I didn't know
how she would react.
-
So you put your feelings
before her safety?
-
Did she really say
her husband might kill her?
-
The victim missed work for 2 months
before the marriage.
-
Why was that?
-
She was so sick
I sent her to a prayer retreat.
-
Not a hospital?
Why a prayer retreat?
-
Why did she miss work
and go to the prayer retreat?
-
You should pray
to heal your mind.
-
So you sent her there
against her will?
-
Objection!
-
The defense is reviling
her religious life.
-
Watch yourself, counselor.
-
You opposed their marriage.
-
You felt betrayed
she was leaving you.
-
So you were mad at him.
Isn't that right?
-
Because he stole your girl.
-
What'd you say to her
that day?
-
Did you try to force her
into the prayer retreat?
-
Objection!
-
Counselor?
-
I just
-
You need to pray.
-
Let's go to the prayer retreat.
-
Let go.
-
You're insane.
-
You've fallen into a devil's trap!
-
Look at yourself!
-
I'm sorry I came.
-
I told her to leave that demon.
-
I told her to get out
of that demon's nest.
-
HAN Cheol-min!
-
You killed her, didn't you?
-
You ruined my girl!
-
You killed my girl!
-
No more questions.
-
Prosecutor AHN Min-ho
-
- I want it back ASAP.
- Okay.
-
I can get fired for this.
-
I'm risking my ass here.
-
Don't worry.
We're saving a man's life.
-
This will prove
we were right.
-
LEE, you're doing
the right thing.
-
As the leader of the pack is
nowhere to be seen
-
he tries to mate with her.
-
She resists hard, but it's of no use.
-
Asshole!
What the hell is this?
-
You fucking tricked me!
-
Asshole!
-
You're dead!
-
You fucking baldy!
-
You lying son of a bitch!
-
How can you...
-
Who the hell are they?
-
You called your buddies?
-
He was being cunning,
and the price should be paid.
-
What were you thinking,
stealing evidence?
-
I had no idea what it was.
-
My headache is gone.
-
We'll indict him for bribery.
-
His license will be revoked,
and he's done.
-
You'll get what you want.
-
What do I want?
-
HAN
-
To nail HAN Cheol-min.
-
I could've done that in court.
-
It's better than putting
Sergeant SEO on the stand.
-
All is well.
-
Your father.
-
Professor AHN
will be happy, too.
-
He never liked me
when he was my boss.
-
Send him my regards.
-
I never imagined
AHN would go that far.
-
An entrapment?
-
He sure keeps himself busy.
-
- Turn around.
- What?
-
Turn around.
-
Where are we going?
-
I need a lawyer.
-
Professor?
-
What are you doing here?
-
You're on KANG's case,
aren't you?
-
Yes.
-
What about it?
-
I'm here to see you
as his attorney.
-
What?
-
Professor AHN?
Where?
-
KANG, you crazy fuck!
-
Bye, Professor.
-
Hi.
-
Not going up?
-
No, I was going down.
-
You came to see PARK?
-
We have our own principles.
You might think...
-
Stop talking.
-
Okay.
-
Professor?
-
Why don't we have lunch?
-
Father.
-
Do you have to do this?
-
This isn't about winning.
It's about justice.
-
Save it.
Why are you doing this fight?
-
To catch a killer.
-
That's my job.
-
Not to save your pride?
-
That's right.
-
I've put my pride on this fight.
-
What you're doing isn't right.
-
It's not a good idea.
-
Sir?
-
He tried to buy evidence.
-
He's no good to defend.
-
It was an entrapment,
and they don't have a case.
-
I'm still good to defend.
-
He stole the hard evidence.
-
He should've submitted
CCTV file as evidence.
-
We were going to,
but he contaminated it.
-
They kept it from us
and used it to trap me.
-
I can prove my claim.
-
I call Detective LEE
for our witness.
-
I also call Detective LEE
for our witness
-
to prove his wrongdoing.
-
Shut up!
-
If he hasn't been indicted,
he's still good.
-
That doesn't mean
you're off the hook.
-
It's clear that the defense
tried to buy evidence.
-
Therefore, that CCTV file
is contaminated.
-
I don't wanna hear a word
about that anymore.
-
So I won't allow that witness.
Any questions?
-
Now
-
Any other witnesses?
-
I call Sergeant SEO.
-
A month prior to murder
-
the victim requested him
to investigate HAN.
-
- That doesn't
- I will consider it.
-
Listen, KANG.
-
I'm warning you.
-
If this happens again,
I'll hold you in contempt of court.
-
Okay.
-
Yes!
-
I'm driving like crazy now.
-
I will see you in no time.
-
That old man is dying
to see me now?
-
Excuse me.
-
I called you earlier.
-
What's the compensation?
-
My son is crippled for good.
-
Here.
-
Smiling?
-
My son is crippled,
and you're smiling?
-
Calm down and tell me
what happened.
-
So we can work out
something.
-
Is this your car?
49 DA 7595?
-
Oh
-
Do you remember
what time it happened?
-
It was 1 :30 in the morning.
-
You hit him and ran.
An apology would be nice.
-
Oh!
-
I'm really sorry.
-
I'm not really from
an insurance firm.
-
Can you tell me
what exactly happened?
-
My client will compensate
more than enough.
-
- You sure?
- Yes.
-
Now you're talking.
-
My son was riding a bike.
And then...
-
What?
-
How do you know the victim?
-
I was a homicide detective.
-
A high school girl was
killed a year ago.
-
And HAN was our suspect.
-
I met her then.
-
You knew the defendant first.
-
Yes.
-
We questioned him
off the record.
-
But he walked
on lack of evidence.
-
I've been watching him
ever since I left the force.
-
Why? You had nothing
against him.
-
I was sure
he was the killer.
-
I tailed him for a while,
but nothing.
-
So I decided to put a bug
in his place.
-
She knew he had lied about
his business trip.
-
So I told her
-
that we had questioned him
for murder for 3 days.
-
No evidence.
-
But he was still a key suspect.
-
I asked for help,
and she agreed.
-
Did that work?
-
No.
-
I lost contact with her
3 days prior to murder.
-
So I followed her around.
-
It was that high school girl
who got killed.
-
"Our beloved daughter
Rest in peace"
-
A few hours later,
she called me.
-
She said she had evidence
against HAN.
-
Objection!
-
It's argumentative.
-
I have a transcript.
-
The Criminal Procedure Code
states clearly
-
that evidence not acquired
through due process of law
-
can't be used as evidence
in the court of law.
-
There are two precedents
set by the Supreme Court.
-
Sustained.
It can't be evidence.
-
The witness' testimony is
based on illegal evidence.
-
It shouldn't affect the jury
in any ways.
-
I'd like to hear
what the witness has to say.
-
Overruled.
-
Then what?
-
What happened?
-
HAN suddenly left
on a business trip.
-
It didn't feel right
so I tailed him.
-
But he cut his trip short
and headed back home.
-
I ended up losing him.
-
I called the police right away
-
Good 30 minutes later,
the cops came.
-
You were a trusted detective.
-
Your work performance
was excellent.
-
Why did you quit?
-
Cops catch criminals.
-
Do you know how it feels,
releasing a killer?
-
I couldn't do anything
within the law.
-
I was so upset.
-
So I decided to catch him
at any cost.
-
Do you feel responsible
in any way
-
for the victim's death?
-
Until my last breath.
-
She had evidence
against the defendant.
-
And she was murdered.
-
All the facts are clear.
-
The defendant had motive
-
to murder his wife.
-
You said she was helpful.
-
Didn't you think
she would be in danger?
-
I did.
-
That's why I asked her.
-
No wife wouldn't be
shocked to learn
-
that her husband
might be a killer.
-
I did it to protect her.
-
From whom?
-
The man whom you let walk?
-
I was certain
he was the killer.
-
You said you would
catch him at any cost.
-
You don't care who gets hurt
as long as you get it done?
-
Objection!
-
He's distorting
the witness' good will.
-
Sustained.
-
It's all what you think it is.
-
No evidence to support
your claim.
-
It's very hard to believe
you acted alone.
-
Anybody else involved?
-
No.
-
This case is deeply related
to a high school girl killing.
-
Nobody else is involved?
-
No, I did it on my own.
-
Last question.
-
Please name the prosecutor
you worked with on that case.
-
Prosecutor AHN Min-ho.
-
No more questions.
-
Come on!
-
I don't like courts
and the police station.
-
My heart is racing.
I can't do it.
-
Look, listen to me.
-
His life is in your hands.
-
Go back in there
and tell them what you saw.
-
That's all I'm asking.
-
God
-
I don't wanna get involved
in someone else's life.
-
You work it out for yourselves.
-
I don't know shit.
-
Let's go home.
-
Damn it!
-
Sir?
-
Money?
-
Defendant, take the stand.
-
Wait.
-
The defense calls
a new witness.
-
He's not on the list.
-
May I approach?
-
Yes, both of you.
-
He will prove my client's alibi.
-
It's unacceptable.
-
We got a call this morning.
-
Be understandable.
-
No way.
-
I didn't object to Sergeant SEO.
-
Make it fair for us.
-
Hold on.
-
Let's listen to him.
-
- Make it short.
- Okay.
-
Witness, take the stand.
-
Stand up.
-
Raise your hand.
-
I swear to tell the truth.
-
The whole truth,
and nothing but the truth.
-
So help me, God.
-
On December 9th,
on a Seoul-bound highway.
-
You saw a car accident?
-
Yes.
-
Please tell us what you saw.
-
I run a five-and dime store
along the highway.
-
My son came in limping so I asked him what happened.
-
He said that a car drove
into the shoulder and hit him.
-
What?
-
I told you not to Bike at night!
-
So I ran outside.
-
And there was a SUV
standing on the shoulder.
-
I ran over to see the driver.
-
Hey!
-
And that bugger just bolted.
-
Hey!
-
- You saw the plate?
- Yes.
-
It's 49 DA 7595
-
Okay.
-
This photo was taken
right after his arrest.
-
Please, notice the bumper
that was damaged.
-
What time was it?
-
1 :30 in the morning.
-
No more questions.
-
Why didn't you
report it right away?
-
I didn't think
my boy got hurt that much.
-
It was a minor accident
from two months ago
-
How do you remember it so well?
-
I wrote down the time
and plate just in case.
-
You didn't get a look at the driver?
-
Right.
-
Was it your will to testify?
-
Or were you promised
to get paid?
-
Objection!
-
I just came for compensation
for a hit and run.
-
Oh, let me get this straight.
-
The defense promised compensation
-
for what you saw
two months ago?
-
And you didn't really
see it happen.
-
Objection!
-
The defense counsel tried
to buy evidence before.
-
Now he's trying to buy a witness.
-
Answer the question.
-
Were you promised
compensation?
-
What else would I be here for?
-
Listen.
-
Perjury is a serious crime.
-
It's maximum 5 years in jail!
-
What?
-
Sit down!
-
Where are you going?
-
Sit down.
-
What's going on here?
-
I'm going home!
-
Mr. HAN.
-
Why didn't you tell your wife
-
Why didn't you tell her
what happened?
-
Why didn't you?
-
Why didn't he tell his wife?
-
HAN Cheol-min.
-
You were questioned
for a high school girl killing.
-
Why didn't you tell your wife?
-
She was so vulnerable.
-
I just couldn't.
-
Did you know
what situation she was in?
-
No.
-
I had no idea
she was in so much pain.
-
I thought she was cheating on me.
Talking to a cop,
-
I never imagined it.
-
She'd been seeing a shrink
because of you.
-
It was bad enough for her
to try suicide.
-
As her husband,
how could you not know?
-
I didn't have the slightest idea
until today.
-
I often did overtime at work
and didn't spend much time with her.
-
I just thought she wasn't
as talkative as before.
-
I don't buy that.
You just avoided her on purpose.
-
No!
-
He's grinding him.
-
You can't let him testify.
AHN will fire back.
-
Then what do we have
to show the jury?
-
Emotions.
-
What about that trip?
-
You're a film developer.
Why'd you go to the set?
-
I was requested to be there.
Ask them.
-
Why'd you cut the trip short?
-
It was our anniversary.
-
I wanted to do something for her
to turn things around.
-
It took 5 hours
for you to get to Seoul.
-
Which is long enough
to make a round trip.
-
I had a hard time staying awake.
-
I missed the turnpike.
-
So I took a highway.
-
I didn't know where I was.
It was so dark.
-
When I came to, hours had passed.
-
I turned the car around
and headed home.
-
I didn't wanna leave her alone
on our anniversary.
-
Mr. HAN.
-
You just wanted to run from her.
-
You just wanted to end
your marriage.
-
You knew the pain she was in
and ignored it.
-
Please...
-
Are you responsible for her death?
-
Objection, Your Honor.
-
You don't have to answer
that question.
-
Let me ask you again.
-
Are you responsible
for your wife's death?
-
Whose fault is her death?
-
Who killed her?
-
Objection!
-
Counsel!
-
Who killed her?
-
I killed her.
-
Is that the answer you wanted?
-
Yes.
-
I killed her.
-
I wish I could drop dead.
-
Am I really a killer?
-
Did I...
-
Did I really kill my wife?
-
I didn't.
-
But people keep saying that I did.
-
So I must be mistaken.
-
Sometimes
-
I look in the mirror
and see a killer.
-
How's that possible?
-
My fingerprints?
-
My hands are wet with chemicals
for 12 hours a day.
-
My fingertips are always
split and raw.
-
So I used to wash them
hundreds of times a day.
-
After I was questioned
for murder
-
I never wash them anymore.
-
Because I know now
it can be a sin.
-
Yet,
-
I had my wife to help me stand.
-
Sure.
-
You can brand me as a killer.
-
But don't deny the fact
I truly loved my wife.
-
I still don't think she's dead.
-
I can't
-
I can't
-
I just can't accept it.
-
So, please.
Find my wife for me.
-
I did everything wrong.
-
Give me a chance
to seek forgiveness.
-
Please, give me a chance.
-
The defense rests.
-
Let me go to the bathroom.
-
That broker digs up
dirty witnesses for you?
-
What about you?
-
You brainwash them to lie.
Is it fun?
-
You turned a dumbass into a killer.
-
Did that ignite justice in you?
-
Sure.
-
It's on fire.
-
So shut your hole.
-
You know what?
-
You and your client are
so good together.
-
So much alike.
-
Sergeant SEO acted alone?
-
I would be fucked if he did.
-
How does it feel,
passing the buck?
-
The whole world knows
that you put him into it.
-
You give your father
a bad name.
-
Asshole!
-
Let go!
-
You're doing it
the wrong way.
-
Wrong?
-
I don't care if I can bust his ass.
-
HAN is the killer.
-
And you try to let him walk?
-
You got the wrong guy.
-
You guys killed his wife.
-
You'll pay the price for this.
-
Shit.
-
Were you scared yesterday?
-
He says it was noisy.
-
Yeah?
-
Yes, it was.
-
Everybody was getting so upset.
-
Yeah, I know.
-
Go ahead, counsel.
-
I admit it.
-
All we have against him is
circumstantial evidence.
-
But try to see the character
of the defendant's.
-
He was a prime suspect
for a high school girl killing.
-
His wife found out about it.
-
And he killed her cruelly
to destroy evidence.
-
Beneath that innocent face is
nothing but a killer.
-
An intentional, cold-blooded one
who killed his wife.
-
The defense counsel might
put it this way.
-
His wife was depressed
and stressed out.
-
She stabbed herself
-
and walked out the door alive.
-
But think about it.
-
Forensics testified there was
over 3 liters of blood at the scene.
-
You can't bleed that much
unless the artery is cut off.
-
Let me tell you again.
-
There were no signs
of forced entry.
-
Nobody but the defendant could
be inside that apartment.
-
Please, remember that.
-
Let me ask you.
What is justice?
-
All the facts say that
HAN is the killer.
-
But we can't punish him
for circumstantial evidence?
-
That's not justice.
It's evasion of responsibility.
-
We have to stop the killings.
-
And we need your help.
-
Please, let justice be brought.
-
Thank you.
-
Defense counsel?
-
Closing argument, please.
-
It's often said.
-
It's better to release
10 guilty men
-
than punishing
1 innocent man.
-
Why?
-
What violates justice the most is
-
a ruling that's not based
on evidence.
-
There's no evidence at all
HAN committed a crime.
-
As the prosecution admits,
it's all circumstantial.
-
It's a very dangerous thing.
-
It can be interpreted
in many different ways.
-
This case has become a tragedy
-
because everything was
based on circumstances.
-
No solid evidence.
-
They predetermined that
HAN killed that girl.
-
And they told his wife
what they believed was true.
-
Shocked and scared,
she went to her mother for help.
-
But her mother turned
her head away.
-
What drove the victim
off the cliff?
-
A wrong interpretation
of circumstances.
-
We call it prejudice.
-
HAN is just a man of himself.
-
An introvert.
-
Someone we may call
a clean freak.
-
And prejudice turned him
into a monstrous killer.
-
Why?
-
As I mentioned earlier
-
any theory is possible
without evidence.
-
I expect you to doubt
the prosecution's theory.
-
Is it really plausible?
-
Is his wife really dead?
-
Look.
-
I count to three.
-
And his wife will walk in
through the doors.
-
One.
-
Two.
-
Three.
-
Did you look at the doors?
-
If you did, you're not sure
if she's really dead.
-
It means that you all have
reasonable doubt.
-
Please, let my client be a free man.
-
Thank you.
-
Kid?
-
Tell me.
-
Is this the right way?
-
A shortcut?
-
This is a shortcut?
-
Thanks.
-
It looks familiar.
-
Why is that?
-
Have I been here
with my wife?
-
All rise.
-
JANG Ho-won
-
The jury didn't reach
a unanimous decision.
-
So I've given this case
a lot of thought.
-
We have a case
-
for which there isn't
physical evidence
-
such as the body
and a murder weapon.
-
In our court of law,
a crime can be proved
-
through indirect evidence
that is tolerated by reason
-
according to the precedents
set by the Supreme Court.
-
However
-
if contrary evidence shakes
the basis of the argument
-
then that indirect evidence
should be questioned.
-
Considering all indirect
evidence presented
-
I can't say it's strong enough
to support the charge.
-
I hereby deliver a verdict.
-
Defendant?
Please, rise.
-
Docket Number
2010-46514.
-
On the charge of murder,
I find the defendant...
-
Not guilty.
-
HAN.
-
You're free now.
-
Please, this way.
-
- Congratulations.
- Thanks.
-
Thanks.
-
KANG?
-
We will appeal.
-
Get some tangible evidence.
-
Your closing argument?
Pretty smart.
-
You know what?
-
At the count of 3,
he didn't look back.
-
A dam?
-
Yes.
-
This is where he took
that picture with his wife.
-
There's a back road here
leading to that store.
-
HAN knew about that?
-
Yes, I think he came out here
on purpose.
-
The car didn't run him over.
-
He biked into that car
parked there.
-
That old man lied.
-
He didn't wanna pay
for the damage.
-
HAN wasn't in the car then.
-
The boy saw him later
coming from the dam.
-
His wife will walk in
through the doors.
-
One.
-
Two.
-
Three.
-
I did not kill my wife.
-
KANG?
-
Do you believe me?
-
She's missing a tooth.
-
Him!
-
That guy!
-
Oh, the door is open.
-
How are you doing?
-
Life is funny, isn't it?
-
The killer will be caught.
-
He knew she had been
talking to a cop.
-
38 NA 6609, pull over.
Pull over now.
-
The prosecution was wrong
from the get-go.
-
If she felt her life
was threatened
-
she would've run,
not making dinner.
-
She trusted her husband.
-
Tell me it's not true.
-
Tell me it's not.
-
No.
-
Please...
-
You need to calm down.
-
I wonder how he moved the body.
-
You know how, don't you?
-
I don't understand
what you're saying.
-
Somebody saw you coming
down from the dam.
-
What are you trying to be?
-
If you're a lawyer,
act like one.
-
Why playing prosecutor?
-
How'd you move the body?
-
HAN.
-
Get down.
-
Scared?
-
That I might jump?
-
It would be over then.
-
Okay.
-
Okay.
-
How did you move
your wife's body?
-
You still look at me like that.
-
Like when we first met.
-
Answer me.
-
HAN Cheol-min.
-
Get down.
-
Get down!
-
Come here!
-
Don't move!
-
- What do you want in return?
- I don't know.
-
Smoking together?
-
You broke the attorney
client privilege.
-
I reported an act of crime.
-
But it will affect your rep.
-
I don't care.
-
Anyway, let's put all this
behind us.
-
We're much alike after all.
-
No, we are not.
-
I still think you're doing it
the wrong way.
-
Do me a favor.
Drop my charge, will you?
-
It's here
-
See you around.