-
What is False Dilemma/False Dichotomy Fallacy
-
The False Dilemma (also known as
False Dichotomy) Fallacy occurs
-
when an argument presents two options as the only
possibilities, when in fact more options exist.
-
This fallacy limits the possibilities
to two, often extreme, options,
-
with the intent to force a choice between
them, ignoring other viable alternatives.
-
It's a tactic used in argumentation
to corner the opponent into choosing
-
an undesirable option or to oversimplify
complex issues into black-and-white choices.
-
Everyday Example:
In a discussion about career choices, Person
-
A says, "You either go to college and succeed,
or you don't go and end up failing in life."
-
Here, Person A is presenting a false dilemma by
suggesting that success is only achievable through
-
college education and that not attending college
inevitably leads to failure. This ignores other
-
paths to success, like vocational training,
entrepreneurship, or self-taught skills.