-
Let’s take a look at the atoms of visual design: letterforms.
-
This is the letter R, typeset in Gill Sans.
-
Gill Sans was designed by Eric Gill and released in 1928.
-
There’s a couple of things that I’d like to point out about this letter right here:
-
One of them is that it has the perceptual characteristic of consistent weight all throughout;
-
however, the actual thickness of the letter varies considerably over different parts.
-
So, if you look at some points of the letter, like the bottom,
-
you can see that they are much thicker than at other points in the letter.
-
And what you see in these atoms is exactly what you’ll see throughout the entirety of graphic design,
-
which is that we’re going for something that feels perceptually balanced —
-
or may have perceptual uniformity — when the actuality may be quite different.
-
This letter was also my very first assignment as a graphic design student at the Rhode Island School of Design:
-
We had to draw this letter, one foot high, in black paint, on a white background.
-
It may seem like a silly exercise,
-
but it’s a great way to understand intimately the curves and strokes of the letterform,
-
and it’s also really good at training both your eye and training your hand;
-
Maybe it’s also a hazing ritual that I’ve just post-hoc rationalized.
-
Anyhow, moving along, let’s look at the different parts of a typeface.
-
One term you may be familiar with from using on your computer is the point size or the font size.
-
And what’s notable about this is
-
it seems like a number that ought to be set in stone and consistent across all typefaces,
-
but it’s really not.
-
Most of our terminology from typefaces comes from when they were set in lead,
-
and the point size of a typeface really just means the height of the lead block that the type was set in,
-
which has some relationship to the actual letter size, but is not completely consistent.
-
For example, you can see, for the same point size,
-
here’s a letter S in Gill Sans, and a letter S in Calibri,
-
and you can that the Calibri S is lower than the Gill Sans S.
-
Our second term is leading.
-
If we have solid blocks of lead type that form the letters,
-
the spacing that we get between the lines was achieved by putting thin strips of lead in between the lines,
-
and that was called the leading.
-
It’s customary to have 20% of your font size as your leading;
-
and so, if in your word processor you’ve set 10-point type,
-
it will usually automatically add an extra 2 points of spacing to put 12 points in between each line.
-
The height of the lowercase letters is called the x-height, from the “x”.
-
Some typefaces have a higher x-height, like Lucida Bright or Georgia;
-
other typefaces have a lower x-height, like Baskerville.
-
And this is important for design — especially online —
-
because typefaces that have a higher x-height will be easier to read at smaller point sizes
-
and on low resolution devices like most screens.
-
Conversely, typefaces with a low x-height, like Baskerville,
-
are used when you’re trying to give elegance, or a “Belle Époque” feel to something.
-
And sprouting up and dropping down from the x-height
-
are the ascenders — like the top stem of the h and the dot of the i —,
-
and your descenders — like the y, p, g.
-
In general, a typeface that has a low x-height will tend to have long ascenders and descenders,
-
and a typeface that has a tall x-height will tend to have more squashed ascenders and descenders.
-
Typefaces can also vary in their weight.
-
So here have an example of light on the left, regular or roman in the middle, and bold on the right.
-
Sometimes you’ll see weights in between like demibold or semibold,
-
and, even to the further to the right of bold, you’ll see black.
-
Number six on the list are serifs.
-
Serifs are the doohickeys on the end of letters that give them that chiselled look.
-
[There are] a couple more that are bonus:
-
Some faces (typefaces) will also include small caps — which sure are exactly what they sound like,
-
smaller versions of capital[s and] numbers.
-
These can be used as headers, or they can also be used
-
to put acronyms and other capital texts inside a block of body text.
-
And one thing that you may not know is —
-
just like letters come in uppercase and lowercase, numbers do too.
-
These numbers, set in Neutraface,
-
provide an example of something that has just small ascenders and descenders;
-
in some cases these can be more dramatic.
-
Lowercase numbers are useful
-
when you want numbers to fit in with a larger block of text and not stand out.
-
One of the most common questions I get asked about graphic design is:
-
“Which typeface should I use?”
-
And a lot of people have heard a story
-
where serif typefaces are generally recommended for body text
-
and sans serif typefaces are recommended for headers.
-
And that’s, on the whole, not bad advice.
-
There is an often-repeated claim that the reason that this is a good heuristic
-
is because serif typefaces, with those doohickeys at the end,
-
give your eyes something to latch onto, and consequently they’re easier to read.
-
It’s an interesting hypothesis.
-
So I looked into this a little bit for all of you,
-
and there’s some challenges in trying to figure this out.
-
For starters, individual differences in readers dwarf any manipulation effects of the typeface —
-
like, some people read a whole lot faster than others,
-
and so it’s difficult to measure differences in the readability of typefaces.
-
Also, reading requires familiarity:
-
It’s not like we’re born knowing what a letter R looks like; we need to practice.
-
And so if you learn with one style of the letter R, you’ll probably be faster with that one;
-
and if you learn with another style of the letter R, you’ll be faster with that one.
-
If even when we got past all those challenges,
-
it can be a little bit difficult to figure out exactly how you should measure this.
-
Well, I can’t go so far as to say that the serif hypothesis is definitively untrue;
-
what I can say is that there’s a lot of evidence to support that it actually is real.
-
And Alex Poole does a great job of describing this on his web site:
-
He writes that “What initially seemed a neat dichotomous question of serif versus sans serif
-
has resulted in a body of research consisting of weak claims and counter-claims,
-
and study after study with findings of ‘no difference’.
-
Is it the case that more than one hundred years of research has been marred by [repeated] methodological flaws,
-
or are serifs simply a typographical ‘red herring’?”
-
It does seem that mixed-case type like you get in a sentence — upper and lower mixed together —
-
is faster to read than all caps, presumably because
-
you get greater vertical variation with the ascenders and descenders in lowercase letters,
-
and that gives your eye more information as it’s reading.
-
Also, in general, proportional fonts seem to be faster than monospaced fonts, like a typewriter.
-
So, typewriter font[s] — slower to read — [but] that stuff only matters if you have to read a whole lot.
-
But the simplest summary is that, in practice, legibility simply amounts to what you’re accustomed to.
-
What do these words say? The bottom half is obscured.
-
As many of you guessed, “I am a jelly donut”.
-
How about this one here? Here the top half is obscured.
-
Seems a little harder?
-
“jfk spoke in berlin.”
-
Turns out that more information seems to be encoded in the top half of texts than in the bottom half.
-
And what does this say?
-
[I] bet many of you saw it as “THE CAT”,
-
and fewer people, “TAE CHT”.
-
And that’s because expectation plays a really important role in what we read.
-
And if you’re really perceptive,
-
you may have realized that those two middle letters are actually exactly the same letter,
-
so the only difference is what you’re expecting to see in each case.
-
Your prior probability influences your interpretation.
-
So, if you put all that together and return to our original question of “Which typeface should I use”,
-
the answer is “It depends.”
-
If you’re putting down a long block of text,
-
it’s best to use a typeface that many people will be familiar with;
-
and if you’re working online, use something that has a relatively high x-height.
-
On the other hand, if you’re making a logo or a sign,
-
or something that’s short and intended to be dramatic,
-
then you probably want to use something a little bit funkier as your typeface —
-
something that’s going to catch attention and be unique, memorable.
-
And typefaces — like everything in life — [build] up reputation.
-
So, over time, certain typefaces come to mean certain things.
-
And here’s a great example from Hoefler and Frere-Jones, writing on their blog.
-
They talk about how Baskerville seems like it’s out of a literary magazine
-
and Optima seems to remind us of cheap 1950’s hygiene products.
-
Here are two easy exercises you can use to improve your typographical eye:
-
The first one is: Look around you for all of the different ways that the same typeface gets deployed;
-
that will give you a sense of its range.
-
And the second one is: Look at how the same text, with different typefaces, really changes its meaning.
-
In this class we have a lot of ground to cover quickly,
-
and so unfortunately we can’t spend too much time on typography;
-
but it’s a fascinating subject, and if you’d like to learn more about this,
-
there are many great books and design resources online, and they’re growing rapidly.
-
Here are just a few that I think are particularly good.