1 00:00:01,785 --> 00:00:04,290 Chris Anderson: Joia, both you and Partners In Health 2 00:00:04,314 --> 00:00:08,444 have spent decades in various battlegrounds, 3 00:00:08,468 --> 00:00:09,833 battling epidemics. 4 00:00:09,857 --> 00:00:13,697 Perhaps for context you could give us a couple examples of that work. 5 00:00:15,689 --> 00:00:17,706 Joia Mukherjee: Yeah, so Partners In Health 6 00:00:17,730 --> 00:00:21,928 is a global nonprofit that is more than 30 years old. 7 00:00:21,952 --> 00:00:25,713 We started famously in Haiti in a squatter settlement, 8 00:00:25,737 --> 00:00:27,587 people who were displaced. 9 00:00:27,611 --> 00:00:28,960 And when we talked to them, 10 00:00:28,984 --> 00:00:31,206 they wanted health care and education, 11 00:00:31,230 --> 00:00:32,783 houses, jobs. 12 00:00:32,807 --> 00:00:34,583 And that has informed our work, 13 00:00:34,607 --> 00:00:38,048 that proximity to people who are suffering. 14 00:00:39,300 --> 00:00:42,087 When you think about health care and the poor, 15 00:00:42,111 --> 00:00:45,024 there is always disproportionate suffering 16 00:00:45,048 --> 00:00:48,095 for people who have been historically marginalized, 17 00:00:48,119 --> 00:00:50,889 like our communities that we serve in Haiti. 18 00:00:51,286 --> 00:00:54,183 And so we've always tried to provide health care 19 00:00:54,207 --> 00:00:56,340 for the poorest people on earth. 20 00:00:57,165 --> 00:01:00,546 And we were launched into an international dialogue 21 00:01:00,570 --> 00:01:02,548 about whether that was possible 22 00:01:02,572 --> 00:01:06,048 for drug-resistant tuberculosis, for HIV. 23 00:01:06,866 --> 00:01:09,771 Indeed, for surgery, for cancer 24 00:01:09,795 --> 00:01:11,556 for mental health, 25 00:01:11,580 --> 00:01:13,609 for noncommunicable diseases. 26 00:01:13,633 --> 00:01:16,617 And we believe it's possible 27 00:01:16,641 --> 00:01:20,633 and it is part of the basic human right care. 28 00:01:20,657 --> 00:01:25,201 So when COVID started, we saw this immediately as a threat 29 00:01:25,225 --> 00:01:27,709 to the health of people who were the poorest. 30 00:01:27,733 --> 00:01:30,301 And Partners In Health now works in 11 countries, 31 00:01:30,325 --> 00:01:32,363 five on the African continent, 32 00:01:32,387 --> 00:01:33,887 Latin America and the Caribbean 33 00:01:33,911 --> 00:01:36,506 as well as the former Soviet Union. 34 00:01:36,530 --> 00:01:40,467 And we immediately prepared to scale up testing, 35 00:01:40,491 --> 00:01:43,656 contact tracing, treatment, care, 36 00:01:43,680 --> 00:01:48,045 and then aw that it wasn't being done in the United States in that way. 37 00:01:48,069 --> 00:01:52,331 And in fact, we were just sitting, passively waiting for people to get sick 38 00:01:52,355 --> 00:01:54,283 and treat them in hospital. 39 00:01:54,307 --> 00:01:58,093 And that message got to the governor of Massachusetts 40 00:01:58,117 --> 00:02:02,813 and we started supporting the state to do contact tracing for COVID, 41 00:02:02,837 --> 00:02:08,285 with the very idea that this would help us identify and resource 42 00:02:08,309 --> 00:02:10,761 the communities that were most vulnerable. 43 00:02:12,859 --> 00:02:17,684 CA: So it's really quite ironic that these decades of experience 44 00:02:17,708 --> 00:02:19,565 in the developing world and elsewhere, 45 00:02:19,589 --> 00:02:25,011 that that has now really been seen as a crucial need to bring to the US. 46 00:02:25,035 --> 00:02:27,965 And especially to bring your expertise around contact tracing. 47 00:02:27,989 --> 00:02:30,504 So, talk a bit about contact tracing, 48 00:02:30,528 --> 00:02:32,752 why does it matter so much, 49 00:02:32,776 --> 00:02:34,694 and what would, I don't know, 50 00:02:34,718 --> 00:02:37,652 a perfect contact tracing set up look like? 51 00:02:39,752 --> 00:02:43,152 JM: Well, first I want to say that you want to always, 52 00:02:43,176 --> 00:02:45,296 in any type of illness, 53 00:02:45,320 --> 00:02:47,503 you want to do prevention, 54 00:02:47,527 --> 00:02:51,236 and diagnosis and treatment and care. 55 00:02:51,260 --> 00:02:54,513 That is what comprehensive approaches look like, 56 00:02:54,537 --> 00:02:59,923 and that care piece to us is about the provision of social support 57 00:02:59,947 --> 00:03:03,993 and material support, to allow people to get the care they need. 58 00:03:04,017 --> 00:03:07,128 So that might be transportation, it might be food. 59 00:03:07,152 --> 00:03:10,180 So when you look at that comprehensive approach, 60 00:03:10,204 --> 00:03:11,926 for an infectious disease, 61 00:03:11,950 --> 00:03:16,553 part of prevention is knowing where the disease is spreading 62 00:03:16,577 --> 00:03:19,569 and how it's spreading and in whom it's spreading, 63 00:03:19,593 --> 00:03:23,283 so that resources can be disproportionately put 64 00:03:23,307 --> 00:03:25,041 to the highest-risk areas. 65 00:03:25,355 --> 00:03:28,561 So contact tracing is a staple of public health 66 00:03:28,585 --> 00:03:32,387 and what it means is that every time a new person is diagnosed 67 00:03:32,411 --> 00:03:35,514 with COVID or any infectious disease, 68 00:03:35,538 --> 00:03:38,537 then you investigate and innumerate 69 00:03:38,561 --> 00:03:41,657 the people they've been in contacts with, 70 00:03:41,681 --> 00:03:44,395 and call those contacts 71 00:03:44,419 --> 00:03:46,286 and say, "You've been exposed," 72 00:03:46,310 --> 00:03:48,844 or talk to them, "You've been exposed, 73 00:03:48,868 --> 00:03:51,077 these are the things you need to know. 74 00:03:51,101 --> 00:03:52,680 First of all, how are you? 75 00:03:52,704 --> 00:03:55,728 Do you need care yourself," and facilitating that. 76 00:03:56,037 --> 00:04:00,822 "Second of all, these are the information you need to know to keep yourself safe. 77 00:04:00,846 --> 00:04:03,417 About quarantine, about prevention." 78 00:04:03,441 --> 00:04:06,096 And again, this would be with any infectious disease, 79 00:04:06,120 --> 00:04:11,536 from Ebola, to cholera, to a sexually transmitted disease like HIV. 80 00:04:12,583 --> 00:04:14,671 And then we say, 81 00:04:14,695 --> 00:04:17,234 "OK, knowing what you know, 82 00:04:17,258 --> 00:04:20,191 do you have the means to protect yourself?" 83 00:04:20,734 --> 00:04:23,311 Because often the most vulnerable 84 00:04:23,335 --> 00:04:25,958 do not have the means to protect themselves. 85 00:04:26,267 --> 00:04:30,466 So that is also where this resource component comes in, 86 00:04:30,490 --> 00:04:33,853 and where equity is so critical 87 00:04:33,877 --> 00:04:38,240 to making this disease stop 88 00:04:38,264 --> 00:04:41,444 and also getting the information and the resources 89 00:04:41,468 --> 00:04:43,668 to people who need them the most. 90 00:04:44,759 --> 00:04:48,727 CA: And in a pandemic, the people who need them the most, 91 00:04:48,751 --> 00:04:51,433 the most vulnerable as you say, 92 00:04:51,457 --> 00:04:52,790 are probably also -- 93 00:04:52,814 --> 00:04:54,870 That's where the disease is spreading a lot. 94 00:04:54,894 --> 00:04:56,768 It's in everyone's interest to do this. 95 00:04:56,792 --> 00:05:00,109 You're not just making this sort of, wonderful, equity moral point, 96 00:05:00,133 --> 00:05:01,895 that we've got to help these people. 97 00:05:01,919 --> 00:05:03,998 It's actually in all of interest, right? 98 00:05:04,022 --> 00:05:05,178 JM: Yes. 99 00:05:05,202 --> 00:05:07,998 Yes, we are one humanity, 100 00:05:08,022 --> 00:05:12,439 and any disease, any infectious disease that is spreading, 101 00:05:12,463 --> 00:05:14,680 is a threat to all of us. 102 00:05:14,704 --> 00:05:19,751 And that is one of the pieces, there's the moral imperative, 103 00:05:19,775 --> 00:05:22,211 there is the epidemiologic imperative, 104 00:05:22,235 --> 00:05:25,735 that if you can't control these diseases everywhere, 105 00:05:25,759 --> 00:05:27,441 that it's a threat anywhere. 106 00:05:27,465 --> 00:05:32,029 And so as we look to the kind of society we want to live in, 107 00:05:32,053 --> 00:05:38,752 good health is something that gives us all so much return on our investment. 108 00:05:39,411 --> 00:05:42,672 CA: Now, some countries were able to use contact tracing 109 00:05:42,696 --> 00:05:46,950 almost to shut down the pandemic before it took off in that country. 110 00:05:47,966 --> 00:05:49,799 The US was unable to do that, 111 00:05:49,823 --> 00:05:51,562 and some people have taken the view 112 00:05:51,586 --> 00:05:54,435 that therefore contact tracing became irrelevant, 113 00:05:54,459 --> 00:05:58,078 that the strategy was mitigation, shut everything down. 114 00:05:58,886 --> 00:06:00,197 You've argued against that, 115 00:06:00,221 --> 00:06:03,249 that even in a process of lock down 116 00:06:03,273 --> 00:06:06,975 that actually contact tracing plays a key role. 117 00:06:06,999 --> 00:06:09,409 Help us understand the scale, 118 00:06:09,433 --> 00:06:10,774 when there's a lot of cases, 119 00:06:10,798 --> 00:06:13,097 the scale of tracing, both cases, 120 00:06:13,121 --> 00:06:15,425 and everyone they may have been in contact with 121 00:06:15,449 --> 00:06:16,633 and their contacts. 122 00:06:16,657 --> 00:06:19,077 It quickly gets to a huge problem. 123 00:06:19,784 --> 00:06:23,345 What sort of workforce do you need to make a difference 124 00:06:23,369 --> 00:06:26,464 at this moment, where the US is at? 125 00:06:27,543 --> 00:06:28,750 JM: It's massive. 126 00:06:28,774 --> 00:06:30,211 I mean, the scale is massive, 127 00:06:30,235 --> 00:06:32,721 and we should not take that lightly. 128 00:06:32,745 --> 00:06:34,514 And we don't, Partners In Health, 129 00:06:34,538 --> 00:06:38,093 I mean, we are willing to try to figure this out, 130 00:06:38,117 --> 00:06:41,643 and I always feel that if we could stop Ebola 131 00:06:41,667 --> 00:06:44,180 in some of the poorest countries in the world, 132 00:06:44,204 --> 00:06:46,022 of course we ought to do it here, 133 00:06:46,046 --> 00:06:51,614 and was it too late when there were 28,000 deaths in Ebola? 134 00:06:51,638 --> 00:06:54,161 Sure, it's always too late. 135 00:06:54,574 --> 00:06:56,077 We should have started earlier, 136 00:06:56,101 --> 00:06:58,062 but it's not too late to have an impact. 137 00:06:58,086 --> 00:07:02,267 And so there's three aspects of timing and scale. 138 00:07:02,593 --> 00:07:05,156 First is, the earlier you start, 139 00:07:05,180 --> 00:07:06,355 the better, right? 140 00:07:06,379 --> 00:07:08,014 And that's what we saw in Rwanda, 141 00:07:08,038 --> 00:07:12,177 they went from early testing and contact tracing, 142 00:07:12,201 --> 00:07:15,201 the first two cases entered into the country 143 00:07:15,225 --> 00:07:17,233 on March 15, 144 00:07:17,257 --> 00:07:18,410 and in one month, 145 00:07:18,434 --> 00:07:22,312 because of contact tracing, isolation, and plenty of testing, 146 00:07:22,336 --> 00:07:26,772 they had held that case rate to 134 people. 147 00:07:26,796 --> 00:07:28,836 It's remarkable, it's remarkable. 148 00:07:28,860 --> 00:07:30,704 In the state of Georgia, 149 00:07:30,728 --> 00:07:32,823 where is home to the CDC, 150 00:07:32,847 --> 00:07:35,971 similar population size, about 12 million, 151 00:07:35,995 --> 00:07:38,629 from the first two cases in the first month, 152 00:07:38,653 --> 00:07:41,971 those cases became 4,400 cases. 153 00:07:41,995 --> 00:07:44,225 And in the country of Belgium, 154 00:07:44,249 --> 00:07:45,409 a similar population, 155 00:07:45,433 --> 00:07:48,233 those two cases became 7,400. 156 00:07:48,539 --> 00:07:50,734 So you do have to make scale 157 00:07:50,758 --> 00:07:52,309 to stop this. 158 00:07:52,333 --> 00:07:53,876 But the earlier you do it, 159 00:07:53,900 --> 00:07:56,696 the more benefits there are to your society, 160 00:07:56,720 --> 00:08:01,233 and also to the other people who need medical services, 161 00:08:01,257 --> 00:08:02,468 women who are pregnant, 162 00:08:02,492 --> 00:08:05,003 people who need their fracture repaired, 163 00:08:05,027 --> 00:08:07,569 because services themselves in the United States 164 00:08:07,593 --> 00:08:11,733 have been, you know, really hampered by this huge amount of COVID. 165 00:08:12,328 --> 00:08:15,010 So the first point is, 166 00:08:15,034 --> 00:08:18,166 it's always late, but it's never too late. 167 00:08:18,867 --> 00:08:20,047 Why? 168 00:08:20,071 --> 00:08:24,243 Because vulnerable populations are sitting ducks, 169 00:08:24,267 --> 00:08:29,337 and so imagine if one of your contacts was a nursing assistant 170 00:08:29,361 --> 00:08:30,949 who worked in a nursing home. 171 00:08:31,257 --> 00:08:36,585 We know that one nursing assistant can spread it throughout a nursing home. 172 00:08:36,609 --> 00:08:39,958 And is it important to identify that person as a contact, 173 00:08:39,982 --> 00:08:43,656 and assure that he or she is able to remain quarantined? 174 00:08:43,680 --> 00:08:45,466 That is critical. 175 00:08:45,490 --> 00:08:47,450 And so it's hard to say, 176 00:08:47,474 --> 00:08:50,428 "Well, it's not worth it if it's just one person, two persons." 177 00:08:50,452 --> 00:08:51,925 Every life matters, 178 00:08:51,949 --> 00:08:56,855 and all of their contacts in the community of that person matters as well. 179 00:08:56,879 --> 00:08:58,252 So that's one thing. 180 00:08:58,276 --> 00:09:01,490 The second about scale is people need jobs right now. 181 00:09:02,085 --> 00:09:04,717 And they want to be part of a solution, 182 00:09:04,741 --> 00:09:07,463 and some of the frustration we see, 183 00:09:07,487 --> 00:09:09,463 the antilockdown movement, 184 00:09:09,487 --> 00:09:11,809 is really out of anger and frustration 185 00:09:11,833 --> 00:09:15,188 and feeling, "What can we do?" 186 00:09:15,212 --> 00:09:19,926 And so this gives people this feeling that they're part of a solution, 187 00:09:19,950 --> 00:09:22,700 and can provide thousands of jobs. 188 00:09:23,288 --> 00:09:24,463 And then third, 189 00:09:24,487 --> 00:09:28,042 I would say for us to reopen our schools, 190 00:09:28,066 --> 00:09:30,529 our churches, our workplaces, 191 00:09:30,553 --> 00:09:33,863 we have to know where the virus is spreading, 192 00:09:33,887 --> 00:09:37,010 so that we don't just continue on this path. 193 00:09:37,034 --> 00:09:40,653 And so contact tracing provides the platform to control 194 00:09:40,677 --> 00:09:43,831 but also to see outbreaks in real time popping up, 195 00:09:43,855 --> 00:09:45,363 and then respond promptly. 196 00:09:45,387 --> 00:09:49,899 So there are many reasons that we have to bring this to scale now. 197 00:09:49,923 --> 00:09:51,923 Even though it is tardy. 198 00:09:53,106 --> 00:09:56,568 CA: So especially as we have this pressure to go back to work, 199 00:09:56,592 --> 00:10:00,068 like, contact tracing has to be part of that strategy, 200 00:10:00,092 --> 00:10:04,166 or we're just inviting another disaster in a few week's time. 201 00:10:04,190 --> 00:10:07,702 Whatever you make of what's happened during this mitigation process. 202 00:10:08,147 --> 00:10:09,967 JM: Exactly, exactly. 203 00:10:10,393 --> 00:10:13,409 Exactly, and so that's such an important part, Chris, 204 00:10:13,433 --> 00:10:16,109 and something that we are just really keen 205 00:10:16,133 --> 00:10:19,744 to look at the United States in a different way. 206 00:10:19,768 --> 00:10:23,939 What are the long term public health infrastructures 207 00:10:23,963 --> 00:10:28,590 that we need to protect us for the second wave, the third wave, 208 00:10:28,614 --> 00:10:31,267 and in the future, for future pandemics? 209 00:10:32,095 --> 00:10:33,348 CA: Whitney. 210 00:10:34,220 --> 00:10:36,561 Whitney Pennigton Rogers: You know, to that point, 211 00:10:36,585 --> 00:10:38,973 there is a question out there from of our anonymous 212 00:10:38,997 --> 00:10:40,164 community members, 213 00:10:40,188 --> 00:10:43,901 about why contact tracing isn't already part of our public health system, 214 00:10:43,925 --> 00:10:45,926 it seems like it does make a lot of sense 215 00:10:45,950 --> 00:10:48,608 this would be the way to mitigate the spread of disease. 216 00:10:48,632 --> 00:10:50,440 Could you speak a little bit to that? 217 00:10:50,911 --> 00:10:53,368 JM: I think many people have said, 218 00:10:53,392 --> 00:10:55,426 and I am not a politician, 219 00:10:55,450 --> 00:10:59,537 but there are American health care infrastructure 220 00:10:59,561 --> 00:11:03,726 is built on treatment and not prevention. 221 00:11:03,750 --> 00:11:08,183 It's built on procedures, 222 00:11:08,207 --> 00:11:10,350 and not keeping people well. 223 00:11:10,374 --> 00:11:12,668 And some of that was driven by profit, 224 00:11:12,692 --> 00:11:16,229 and some of that was driven by need, 225 00:11:16,253 --> 00:11:19,149 but I think we need to rethink 226 00:11:19,173 --> 00:11:22,033 how we deliver care in this environment. 227 00:11:22,736 --> 00:11:26,329 WPR: "There is some fear and suspicion about privacy and contact tracing. 228 00:11:26,353 --> 00:11:28,353 How can we build trust in the process?" 229 00:11:29,092 --> 00:11:30,743 JM: Yeah, that's a great question 230 00:11:30,767 --> 00:11:34,120 and I think there's fear about privacy 231 00:11:34,144 --> 00:11:40,149 and part of it comes from the idea of what contact tracing is. 232 00:11:40,173 --> 00:11:43,664 And I think that's why we feel strongly, 233 00:11:43,688 --> 00:11:46,860 is if you lead with the idea that it's care, 234 00:11:46,884 --> 00:11:51,185 and it's trying to get resources and information 235 00:11:51,209 --> 00:11:52,907 and help to people, 236 00:11:52,931 --> 00:11:54,522 it seems very different 237 00:11:54,546 --> 00:11:58,276 than just, oh, who's sick, and who's a threat. 238 00:11:58,300 --> 00:12:00,400 And so fundamentally, 239 00:12:00,424 --> 00:12:04,375 and that's why we're so pleased to be at this TED talk today, 240 00:12:04,399 --> 00:12:06,482 is it's about communication, right? 241 00:12:06,506 --> 00:12:08,356 It's not about surveillance, 242 00:12:08,380 --> 00:12:11,434 it's about communication and care and support. 243 00:12:11,458 --> 00:12:12,625 That's one thing. 244 00:12:12,649 --> 00:12:15,863 And we'll be hearing from our colleagues 245 00:12:15,887 --> 00:12:17,069 on the tech side. 246 00:12:17,093 --> 00:12:21,137 There's ways to add tech, even to care, 247 00:12:21,161 --> 00:12:26,510 that it can be a resource for caring and communication. 248 00:12:26,812 --> 00:12:29,755 But there are ways to protect people's privacy 249 00:12:29,779 --> 00:12:31,588 and also to provide care 250 00:12:31,612 --> 00:12:35,633 and public health has many laws attached to it. 251 00:12:36,067 --> 00:12:41,567 This is all done within the constructs of our state public health laws. 252 00:12:41,990 --> 00:12:45,244 And so I think some of the communication around this is, 253 00:12:45,268 --> 00:12:47,479 how do we take care of each other, 254 00:12:47,503 --> 00:12:49,899 how do we take care of the most vulnerable, 255 00:12:49,923 --> 00:12:52,780 and if we frame contact tracing as care, 256 00:12:52,804 --> 00:12:56,133 I think that starts a different kind of conversation. 257 00:12:58,523 --> 00:13:00,992 CA: So, Joia, can you just talk in a bit more detail 258 00:13:01,016 --> 00:13:06,441 about what it is that you are advising Massachusetts to do 259 00:13:06,465 --> 00:13:07,840 in terms of contact tracing. 260 00:13:07,864 --> 00:13:09,577 Give us a sense of the scale of it. 261 00:13:09,601 --> 00:13:12,537 JM: Yeah, so the scale -- thank you. 262 00:13:12,561 --> 00:13:19,309 You know, we are able now to make about 10,000 calls a day 263 00:13:19,333 --> 00:13:20,498 to contacts. 264 00:13:20,522 --> 00:13:23,117 So every new case that comes in, 265 00:13:23,141 --> 00:13:26,823 the case is investigated by someone on the phone, 266 00:13:26,847 --> 00:13:29,276 and then those investigations 267 00:13:29,300 --> 00:13:32,537 mean writing down the names and the phone numbers of the persons 268 00:13:32,561 --> 00:13:35,876 you've been in contact with for the time you were sick 269 00:13:35,900 --> 00:13:37,847 and a couple days before. 270 00:13:37,871 --> 00:13:40,268 And with those numbers then, the contact tracers -- 271 00:13:40,292 --> 00:13:43,931 And that's what we really redoubled the work for us and really expanded, 272 00:13:43,955 --> 00:13:45,852 more than doubled, 273 00:13:45,876 --> 00:13:48,796 to support the department of public health 274 00:13:48,820 --> 00:13:50,815 to do that contact tracing. 275 00:13:50,839 --> 00:13:56,986 So we have 1,700 people employed full time, with benefits, 276 00:13:57,010 --> 00:14:01,418 to call those contacts and say, "Are you OK? 277 00:14:01,442 --> 00:14:03,078 This is the information you need," 278 00:14:03,102 --> 00:14:06,560 and then, and I think this is the critical piece, 279 00:14:06,584 --> 00:14:09,536 when someone doesn't have the information, 280 00:14:09,560 --> 00:14:11,768 then we have another cadre of people 281 00:14:11,792 --> 00:14:14,569 we call the resource care coordinators, 282 00:14:14,593 --> 00:14:17,903 who help that person, that contact, 283 00:14:17,927 --> 00:14:20,887 to do the things they need to do to protect themselves. 284 00:14:20,911 --> 00:14:22,498 It might be food delivery, 285 00:14:22,522 --> 00:14:25,458 it might be filing for unemployment benefits, 286 00:14:25,482 --> 00:14:30,600 it might be trying to get them medical care or a test. 287 00:14:31,004 --> 00:14:33,687 That piece is the care piece. 288 00:14:33,711 --> 00:14:38,546 And that is what turns social distancing from very regressive -- 289 00:14:38,570 --> 00:14:41,545 Look at me in my beautiful house, social distancing -- 290 00:14:41,569 --> 00:14:43,799 To something that's progressive 291 00:14:43,823 --> 00:14:47,006 and paying attention to those who need the resources. 292 00:14:47,030 --> 00:14:48,843 So the scale is massive, 293 00:14:48,867 --> 00:14:52,156 with 1,700 employees hired to do this, 294 00:14:52,180 --> 00:14:53,409 but they are connected 295 00:14:53,433 --> 00:14:57,190 with local community food banks and churches, and facilities, 296 00:14:57,214 --> 00:15:01,200 and primary health care centers as well. 297 00:15:02,619 --> 00:15:04,067 CA: Thank you so much, Joia.