WEBVTT

00:00:18.209 --> 00:00:23.710
These two Nazi scientists worked
at the Dachau Concentration Camp

00:00:23.729 --> 00:00:25.459
during World War II.

00:00:26.250 --> 00:00:29.250
They were conducting an experiment

00:00:29.292 --> 00:00:33.667
to see how long a human being
could survive in freezing water.

00:00:35.542 --> 00:00:37.168
Like good scientists,

00:00:37.250 --> 00:00:43.834
they took systematic measures
including duration until death.

00:00:45.834 --> 00:00:49.876
Examples of human cruelty
of this kind raise a big question.

00:00:50.501 --> 00:00:54.793
How is it possible
to treat a person as a mere object?

00:00:56.918 --> 00:01:03.210
The traditional explanation
for human cruelty is in terms of evil.

00:01:04.167 --> 00:01:09.376
I find the concept of evil
unhelpful and unscientific.

00:01:09.918 --> 00:01:13.918
It implies that the person is possessed
by some supernatural force.

00:01:14.709 --> 00:01:18.293
Even worse it's dangerously circular;

00:01:18.334 --> 00:01:22.293
if the definition of evil
is the absence of good,

00:01:22.334 --> 00:01:24.208
then all we're really saying

00:01:24.209 --> 00:01:27.541
is he did something bad
because he is not good.

00:01:27.542 --> 00:01:30.917
It hasn't really taken us
any further forward.

00:01:31.959 --> 00:01:35.251
In contrast the concept of empathy,

00:01:35.292 --> 00:01:38.666
I'm going to argue
is scientifically helpful;

00:01:38.667 --> 00:01:41.792
you can measure it, you can study it.

00:01:42.375 --> 00:01:48.458
Empathy has two distinct components --
cognitive and affective.

00:01:49.667 --> 00:01:52.209
Cognitive empathy is the ability

00:01:52.250 --> 00:01:55.001
to imagine someone else's
thoughts and feelings;

00:01:55.042 --> 00:01:57.668
putting yourself into
someone else's shoes.

00:01:57.684 --> 00:01:59.384
It's the recognition part.

00:02:00.584 --> 00:02:05.751
Affective empathy is the drive to respond
with an appropriate emotion

00:02:05.751 --> 00:02:08.252
to what someone else
is thinking or feeling.

00:02:08.959 --> 00:02:12.959
I'm going to argue
that low affective empathy

00:02:13.000 --> 00:02:17.000
is a necessary factor
to explain human cruelty.

00:02:18.209 --> 00:02:21.958
Empathy isn't all or none;
it comes by degrees,

00:02:21.959 --> 00:02:25.001
and there a individual differences in it.

00:02:25.042 --> 00:02:28.751
So it gives rise
to the empathy bell curve.

00:02:28.792 --> 00:02:31.875
Most of us are in the middle
of this spectrum

00:02:31.921 --> 00:02:34.571
with average amounts of empathy.

00:02:34.584 --> 00:02:38.918
There are some people
who have above average levels of empathy.

00:02:39.114 --> 00:02:40.494
But what are the factors

00:02:40.501 --> 00:02:44.501
that can lead an individual
to have low empathy

00:02:45.125 --> 00:02:48.500
either temporarily or permanently?

00:02:48.542 --> 00:02:52.542
What are those social factors?
What are those biological factors?

00:02:55.417 --> 00:02:59.251
One social factor
is obedience to authority.

00:03:00.209 --> 00:03:04.750
The experiment by Stanley Milgram
at Yale University showed

00:03:04.751 --> 00:03:08.874
that people are willing to administer
electric shocks to someone

00:03:08.874 --> 00:03:10.334
to help them learn,

00:03:10.335 --> 00:03:13.584
if they're instructed to do so
by an authority figure.

00:03:14.262 --> 00:03:16.035
This suggests that simply,

00:03:16.035 --> 00:03:20.334
following orders may be one factor
that can erode our empathy.

00:03:22.209 --> 00:03:25.292
A second social factor is ideology.

00:03:26.542 --> 00:03:31.834
When the terrorists flew the planes
into the World Trade Center on 9/11,

00:03:32.426 --> 00:03:34.006
Ww have to assume

00:03:34.026 --> 00:03:36.916
that they were in the grip
of a strongly-held belief

00:03:36.918 --> 00:03:38.794
that they were doing the right thing.

00:03:40.876 --> 00:03:42.500
Of course, we don't know

00:03:42.501 --> 00:03:45.210
whether the terrorists
who signed up for that action

00:03:45.233 --> 00:03:47.513
had low empathy to begin with,

00:03:48.210 --> 00:03:49.575
but it's possible

00:03:49.575 --> 00:03:52.859
that their ideological beliefs
were another factor

00:03:52.859 --> 00:03:56.519
that could erode
their empathy for their victims.

00:03:57.459 --> 00:04:01.960
A third social factor 
is in-group/out-group relations.

00:04:02.753 --> 00:04:07.463
In Rwanda, we saw one ethnic group
used propaganda

00:04:07.493 --> 00:04:09.584
to stereotype the out-group;

00:04:09.616 --> 00:04:13.966
describing them as subhuman
and as cockroaches.

00:04:14.784 --> 00:04:17.734
When we dehumanize a group as the enemy,

00:04:18.533 --> 00:04:22.743
we have the potential to lose our empathy;

00:04:23.600 --> 00:04:25.820
and we saw the catastrophic genocide

00:04:25.831 --> 00:04:27.141
that ensued.

00:04:29.317 --> 00:04:33.317
But none of these social factors
can explain individuals like Ted Bundy.

00:04:34.706 --> 00:04:38.086
He started his adult career
as a psychology student

00:04:38.114 --> 00:04:40.084
of the University of Washington

00:04:40.111 --> 00:04:43.021
where he volunteered
on a telephone helpline

00:04:43.033 --> 00:04:46.553
and persuaded women to meet him.

00:04:46.569 --> 00:04:48.829
And over the successive years,

00:04:48.834 --> 00:04:54.084
he committed rape and murder
of at least 30 women.

00:04:55.159 --> 00:04:58.369
We can assume that he had
good cognitive empathy

00:04:58.398 --> 00:05:01.878
because he was able 
to deceive his victims,

00:05:02.384 --> 00:05:07.384
but that he lacked affective empathy
- he just didn't care -

00:05:07.456 --> 00:05:10.456
and he lacked it in enduring ways.

00:05:12.203 --> 00:05:17.303
The evidence that psychopaths
like Ted Bundy lack affective empathy

00:05:17.325 --> 00:05:20.203
comes from an experiment by James Blair

00:05:20.209 --> 00:05:22.793
that was conducted in Broadmoor Hospital.

00:05:22.829 --> 00:05:25.899
He showed psychopaths and a control group

00:05:25.928 --> 00:05:28.228
three different types of images,

00:05:28.248 --> 00:05:34.238
threatening images, neutral images,
and images of people in distress.

00:05:34.980 --> 00:05:37.240
What he found was that the psychopaths

00:05:37.260 --> 00:05:41.435
only showed reduced physiological response

00:05:41.435 --> 00:05:44.445
when they saw the images
of people in distress.

00:05:44.467 --> 00:05:48.467
So this suggests that they lacked
affective empathy.

00:05:50.035 --> 00:05:54.755
People with autism have difficulties
with cognitive empathy.

00:05:54.770 --> 00:05:57.880
They struggle to imagine
other people's thoughts,

00:05:57.900 --> 00:06:01.870
their motives, their intentions,
and their feelings.

00:06:01.873 --> 00:06:05.553
But people with autism
don't tend to hurt other people;

00:06:05.569 --> 00:06:08.059
instead, they are confused by other people

00:06:08.073 --> 00:06:12.833
and withdraw socially, preferring
the more predictable world of objects.

00:06:13.845 --> 00:06:17.394
People with autism
have intact affective empathy

00:06:17.394 --> 00:06:19.864
because when they hear
that somebody is suffering

00:06:19.864 --> 00:06:21.769
it upsets them.

00:06:22.937 --> 00:06:25.097
This leads us to imagine

00:06:25.122 --> 00:06:29.712
that people with autism
and psychopaths are mirror opposites.

00:06:30.198 --> 00:06:34.198
The psychopath has good cognitive empathy
- that's how they can deceive -

00:06:34.967 --> 00:06:37.627
but they have reduced affective empathy.

00:06:37.726 --> 00:06:41.256
People with autism
have intact affective empathy,

00:06:41.278 --> 00:06:45.278
but struggle with cognitive empathy
for neurological reasons.

00:06:48.062 --> 00:06:50.462
Psychopaths don't come out of nowhere.

00:06:50.494 --> 00:06:52.084
Many of them have shown

00:06:52.124 --> 00:06:55.774
antisocial behavior 
and delinquency in their teens.

00:06:56.375 --> 00:07:01.126
John Bowlby at the Tavistock Clinic
in London studied delinquents and found

00:07:01.142 --> 00:07:06.212
that many of them had experienced
emotional neglect in early childhood.

00:07:07.248 --> 00:07:11.808
He argued that the absence
of parental love in early childhood

00:07:11.816 --> 00:07:14.836
is another factor
that can erode your empathy.

00:07:17.338 --> 00:07:20.448
But we know that early experience
can't be the whole story

00:07:20.469 --> 00:07:23.579
because not everyone
who has a bad childhood

00:07:23.595 --> 00:07:25.275
loses their empathy.

00:07:25.792 --> 00:07:31.001
Avshalom Caspi at the Institute
of Psychiatry in London showed

00:07:31.032 --> 00:07:35.553
that if you've experienced
severe maltreatment in childhood

00:07:36.017 --> 00:07:38.947
that increases your risk of delinquency.

00:07:39.542 --> 00:07:42.709
But your risk of deliquency
goes up even more

00:07:42.742 --> 00:07:47.162
if you also a carrier
of one version of the MAO-A gene

00:07:47.763 --> 00:07:49.263
shown here in red;

00:07:49.763 --> 00:07:52.463
so genes and environment interact.

00:07:54.441 --> 00:07:56.601
Another biological factor

00:07:56.628 --> 00:08:01.738
that is associated with empathy levels
is the hormone testosterone.

00:08:02.665 --> 00:08:06.405
In the fetus, testosterone
shapes brain development.

00:08:06.905 --> 00:08:08.654
We've measured testosterone

00:08:08.684 --> 00:08:11.815
in the amniotic fluid
that surrounds the baby

00:08:11.815 --> 00:08:15.945
in women who are having 
amniocentesis during pregnancy.

00:08:17.074 --> 00:08:21.964
We then wait for the baby to be born,
and we follow up the children.

00:08:22.868 --> 00:08:25.728
When the children were eight years old,

00:08:25.748 --> 00:08:28.418
we asked them which word best describes

00:08:28.448 --> 00:08:31.618
what the person in the photo
is thinking or feeling.

00:08:32.188 --> 00:08:35.467
Here the correct answer is
he is interested in something.

00:08:36.020 --> 00:08:41.191
What we found was that the higher
the level of fetal testosterone,

00:08:41.207 --> 00:08:44.668
the more difficulties the child was having

00:08:45.124 --> 00:08:47.604
at this test of cognitive empathy.

00:08:48.446 --> 00:08:53.846
How much empathy we show
is a function of the empathy circuit;

00:08:53.861 --> 00:08:56.421
a network of regions in the brain.

00:08:57.070 --> 00:08:59.190
Here we can look at just two of them:

00:08:59.209 --> 00:09:04.220
in red, for left ventromedial
prefrontal cortex,

00:09:04.667 --> 00:09:06.667
and in blue, the amygdala.

00:09:08.260 --> 00:09:10.940
This is Phineas Gage 
who suffered damage

00:09:10.940 --> 00:09:14.644
to his left ventromedial prefrontal cortex

00:09:14.644 --> 00:09:20.271
after dynamite blasted a metal rod
up behind his eye and through his brain.

00:09:21.028 --> 00:09:25.308
Before the accident, he was described
as a polite, considerate individual.

00:09:26.080 --> 00:09:29.190
After the accident,
he was described as rude

00:09:29.210 --> 00:09:30.897
and no longer able to judge

00:09:30.907 --> 00:09:34.087
what was socially appropriate
for different situations.

00:09:34.109 --> 00:09:36.479
He'd lost his cognitive empathy.

00:09:39.125 --> 00:09:43.528
Jean Decety at the University of Chicago
used brain scanning

00:09:43.578 --> 00:09:45.859
- functional magnetic resonance imaging -

00:09:46.505 --> 00:09:49.075
to look at the teenage delinquent brain

00:09:49.099 --> 00:09:53.879
whilst they were watching films
where somebody experiences pain

00:09:53.899 --> 00:09:59.250
such as when this piano player's fingers
got crushed by the lid of the piano

00:09:59.266 --> 00:10:01.436
falling down on his fingers.

00:10:01.471 --> 00:10:05.981
What he found was that teenagers
with delinquency didn't show

00:10:06.011 --> 00:10:09.141
the typical levels of activity
in the amygdala --

00:10:09.152 --> 00:10:12.382
part of the empathy circuit in the brain.

00:10:12.411 --> 00:10:15.921
But let's not forget
the positive side of empathy.

00:10:16.420 --> 00:10:19.140
Most of us have enough empathy,

00:10:19.155 --> 00:10:22.595
and some people
have high levels of empathy.

00:10:23.547 --> 00:10:26.907
When these two men formed a relationship

00:10:26.938 --> 00:10:30.408
based on mutual respect and on empathy,

00:10:30.433 --> 00:10:33.723
it let to the end of apartheid
in South Africa.

00:10:34.859 --> 00:10:38.499
Empathy is vital for a healthy democracy;

00:10:39.077 --> 00:10:41.797
it ensures that we listen
to different perspectives,

00:10:42.446 --> 00:10:46.836
we hear other people's emotions,
and we also feel them.

00:10:47.527 --> 00:10:51.527
Indeed without empathy,
democracy would not be possible.

00:10:54.292 --> 00:10:56.842
I met this two women
in Cambridge this week

00:10:56.865 --> 00:10:58.315
when they came to visit.

00:10:59.292 --> 00:11:03.292
On the left is Siham,
and she is a Palestinian woman;

00:11:04.023 --> 00:11:08.183
her brother was shot
and killed by an Israeli bullet.

00:11:10.000 --> 00:11:14.501
On the right is Robi;
she is an Israeli woman.

00:11:15.013 --> 00:11:18.303
Her son was killed
by a Palestinian bullet.

00:11:19.730 --> 00:11:23.030
These two women
have taken the courageous step

00:11:23.030 --> 00:11:26.694
of forming a relationship
across the political divide.

00:11:27.529 --> 00:11:30.669
They haven't given in
to the emotion of revenge

00:11:31.008 --> 00:11:34.078
which would simply perpetuate
the cycle of violence.

00:11:34.434 --> 00:11:38.524
Instead, they've used their empathy
to recognize that they both share

00:11:38.550 --> 00:11:44.280
the same sorrow, the same awful pain
of having lost a loved one.

00:11:46.788 --> 00:11:52.948
Empathy is our most valuable
natural resource for conflict resolution.

00:11:54.167 --> 00:11:57.209
We could wait for our political leaders

00:11:57.237 --> 00:12:00.247
to use empathy
- and that would be refreshing -

00:12:00.274 --> 00:12:03.536
but actually, 
we could all use our empathy.

00:12:03.542 --> 00:12:06.535
As Siham and Robi told me,

00:12:06.536 --> 00:12:10.226
"The conflict won't stop
until we empathize."

00:12:10.265 --> 00:12:11.545
Thank you.

00:12:11.571 --> 00:12:13.301
(Applause)