WEBVTT
00:00:00.504 --> 00:00:04.809
Ideas.
00:00:04.809 --> 00:00:10.451
One thing to get through your head is that ideas are usually cheap.
00:00:10.451 --> 00:00:12.750
Boy, those don't erase real well.
00:00:12.750 --> 00:00:15.585
I'll try using these guys.
00:00:15.585 --> 00:00:19.192
I mean, they do say: Dry erase." They don't say: Permanent, don't put it on anything!
00:00:19.192 --> 00:00:20.993
I should be okay, but...
00:00:20.993 --> 00:00:27.166
One thing to get over is the idea that great ideas make a great book.
00:00:27.166 --> 00:00:30.450
Well, a certain quality of idea is important.
00:00:30.450 --> 00:00:39.477
However, a great writer can take the most basic ideas and make a brilliant novel out of it.
00:00:39.477 --> 00:00:46.151
And a terrible writer will take the best ideas in the world and will turn them into something terrible. Okay?
00:00:46.151 --> 00:00:53.056
Once in a while there is an idea like– you know, I usually refer to Jurassic Park as one of the ideas that I wish I had.
00:00:53.056 --> 00:00:56.227
You know, bring back dinosaurs and make a theme park out of them.
00:00:56.227 --> 00:01:01.800
That is a really great story scene and some are better than others.
00:01:01.800 --> 00:01:03.969
But the thing to teach you is ideas should be cheap.
00:01:03.969 --> 00:01:05.701
You shouldn't have to worry about your ideas.
00:01:05.701 --> 00:01:08.172
You shouldn't coddle your ideas and treat them as sacrosanct.
00:01:08.172 --> 00:01:14.201
You shouldn't thing I have this one novel I have been working on for so long and it's the perfect book
00:01:14.201 --> 00:01:17.214
and I need to just get it done and then everything will be great.
00:01:17.214 --> 00:01:28.168
Instead, you should be thinking, "Boy, that book that I've been working on for ten years that I started, that is my baby, is such a big millstone hung around me.
00:01:28.168 --> 00:01:31.668
I should cast that aside, start fresh with something new,
00:01:31.668 --> 00:01:35.533
write it for a few months, and teach myself to write.
00:01:35.533 --> 00:01:38.002
And then, once I know how to write,
00:01:38.002 --> 00:01:43.675
maybe I can to do justice to that magnificent idea that I have been working on for ten years that now is turning out to be
00:01:43.675 --> 00:01:49.379
you know, I've been churning and working on it for so long that I have even forgotten how many drafts I have done.
00:01:49.379 --> 00:01:51.482
And, you know, this was in one draft
00:01:51.482 --> 00:01:53.785
and this other thing is in another draft, and I forget that I've taken this out, and oh,
00:01:53.785 --> 00:01:57.289
it gets to be a big mess."
00:01:57.289 --> 00:02:01.231
So, for this class, you will have to cast aside anything that you have been working on before,
00:02:01.231 --> 00:02:04.395
unless you come and get specific permission from me.
00:02:04.395 --> 00:02:10.233
Someone who has a book contract has permission to work on, you know, what they have a book contract for.
00:02:10.233 --> 00:02:12.036
Or, I guess you have an agent, but not a contract yet.
00:02:12.036 --> 00:02:13.519
*Yeah, not a contract yet.
00:02:13.519 --> 00:02:16.687
But, for the most part, you should be taking everything–
00:02:16.687 --> 00:02:22.447
anything have written on before–you can take something you have ideas for, something you have planned–
00:02:22.447 --> 00:02:25.616
but anything you have written on before, you should cast aside
00:02:25.616 --> 00:02:29.519
and start fresh from the beginning for this class. Yes.
00:02:29.519 --> 00:02:31.642
*If you have written like an introductory chapter, or like–?
00:02:31.642 --> 00:02:33.938
Yeah, you're fine. You're fine on that.
00:02:33.938 --> 00:02:35.505
Uh, you know, you go with the spirit of the law.
00:02:35.505 --> 00:02:39.629
What are we doing? You are putting this in front. Oh, sure, put the microphone in front of me.
00:02:39.629 --> 00:02:42.935
Make it easy for people to listen. You're going to get a lapel mic for me, right?
00:02:42.935 --> 00:02:44.721
I'm eventually gonna...
00:02:44.721 --> 00:02:46.165
*Yeah. Yeah.
00:02:46.180 --> 00:02:49.808
Then I feel all cool and techy and stuff like that. And so... um.
00:02:49.808 --> 00:02:55.146
Yeah, sorry poeple listening online who might actually be doing it. Hi!
00:02:55.146 --> 00:02:58.047
We are trying something new this year.
00:02:58.047 --> 00:03:00.952
Apparently, we can actually release this online, if we want to.
00:03:00.952 --> 00:03:03.185
So, we're going to. And he's doing a master's degree.
00:03:03.185 --> 00:03:07.163
Bachelor's degree something? Or honors something?
00:03:07.163 --> 00:03:11.964
* Well, I have't even applied for the um. It will be, um, constructional technology.
00:03:11.964 --> 00:03:13.535
Okay, okay. By the way!
00:03:13.535 --> 00:03:16.901
As an aside, I think we have like 5 PhD students in my class.
00:03:16.901 --> 00:03:19.036
Who are the PhD students? I'd love to know.
00:03:19.036 --> 00:03:20.306
There are people...
00:03:20.306 --> 00:03:23.841
Maybe, it just lists PhD if you've like too many credits or something.
00:03:23.841 --> 00:03:26.963
No one is actually in a PhD? Ahh. It said on my class role–
00:03:26.979 --> 00:03:28.312
Okay, you got... You are one.
00:03:28.312 --> 00:03:29.997
*Well, I'm a JD, not a PhD.
00:03:29.997 --> 00:03:33.999
Oh, JD. Oooooh. Hey, an attorney. It's always good to know more attorneys.
00:03:33.999 --> 00:03:35.853
Laughter
00:03:35.853 --> 00:03:37.221
Anyone else, like...
00:03:37.221 --> 00:03:40.724
I assume a few of you are in like that Marriott School, or something like that?
00:03:40.724 --> 00:03:45.863
Yeah, Marriott school? Okay. Because these people can sneak in– You're in the Marriott school too?
00:03:45.863 --> 00:03:50.825
Can sneak in and register very early for the class. And they can get all the spots.
00:03:50.825 --> 00:03:55.706
And it said on my thing that I have like four PhD students, but they must just list that if you have a certain credit threshold.
00:03:55.706 --> 00:04:03.248
Some of you must just be eternal students who are continuing education, who have like, you know, three hundred credits or something.
00:04:03.248 --> 00:04:07.017
And like, they must be at a PhD because otherwise why would they want so many classes.
00:04:07.017 --> 00:04:09.082
But anyway, ideas.
00:04:09.082 --> 00:04:13.524
Ideas should be cheap. You should not treat them as sacrosanct.
00:04:13.524 --> 00:04:16.327
Um, one of my favorite stories, um, you can ask, um,
00:04:16.327 --> 00:04:24.249
You can ask Jim Butcher about this. He shared it before, when he was making this argument on this forum once, before he was published.
00:04:24.249 --> 00:04:29.080
And, um, a certain other person was kind of of the opposite school of thought.
00:04:29.080 --> 00:04:35.012
There's a school of thought that says–and don't write this down because it is wrong–
00:04:35.012 --> 00:04:40.185
"Writing is mystical."
00:04:40.185 --> 00:04:48.613
Right? Writing is about, you know, sitting and the, you know, the muse strikes.
00:04:48.613 --> 00:04:51.676
I assume not the band. Laughter.
00:04:51.676 --> 00:04:55.967
And the muse strikes you and something like pops out of your head like Athena.
00:04:55.967 --> 00:04:58.534
And it's just like BOOM!
00:04:58.534 --> 00:05:01.406
And then BOOK!
00:05:01.406 --> 00:05:07.733
And then, somehow, in between this, it's like you win a Pulitzer!
00:05:07.733 --> 00:05:10.848
I don't know. That's probably not what they give anyway. You know, not a Pulitzer. Laughter.
00:05:10.848 --> 00:05:14.151
A national book award! There you go!
00:05:14.151 --> 00:05:17.320
And you dropped it in basketball team. Laughter.
00:05:17.320 --> 00:05:18.455
And it's wonderful.
00:05:18.455 --> 00:05:20.971
There's this feeling that that's what it is.
00:05:20.971 --> 00:05:25.963
And, um, I don't subscribe to this at all. Okay?
00:05:25.963 --> 00:05:28.098
I really, really don't.
00:05:28.098 --> 00:05:33.053
And that's not to say that sometimes cool inspirations don't hit you, because we all kind of go through that.
00:05:33.053 --> 00:05:38.647
You'll have times when we're like, "I'm just on fire today and I don't know why." And you're riding it and it's great and it's awesome.
00:05:38.647 --> 00:05:44.048
But, the thing to to remember is that for every writer who's a real pro that I talk to,
00:05:44.048 --> 00:05:47.085
they have moments like that, and they have moments where it is pure drudgery.
00:05:47.085 --> 00:05:49.220
Where they sit and... and it's like chopping wood,
00:05:49.220 --> 00:05:54.007
that's how _ puts it. You just hit and you chop the wood and you do what you know you need to do.
00:05:54.007 --> 00:06:00.011
And at the end of the day in the book, I have found that the reader can't tell the difference between these two.
00:06:00.011 --> 00:06:02.399
*Some quiet laughter.* Okay?
00:06:02.399 --> 00:06:04.791
They can't tell the difference. And that's because,
00:06:04.791 --> 00:06:09.773
through the drafting process, you make this one better and you take out all the pretentiousness of this one.
00:06:09.773 --> 00:06:12.275
Because this one had a lot of pretentiousness in it.
00:06:12.275 --> 00:06:16.680
And this one, it will probably be a little dry, but you will have some moments of inspiration where you get connections.
00:06:16.680 --> 00:06:20.883
And this prose will get a little more engaging and this one will get a little less annoying.
00:06:20.883 --> 00:06:26.091
And then they will meet in the center and have your level of writing that is pretty cool.
00:06:26.091 --> 00:06:29.761
Okay? So, anyway, Jim Butcher's arguing with this guy.
00:06:29.761 --> 00:06:32.798
And the guys like, "No, you have to have world class ideas to be a world class writer."
00:06:32.798 --> 00:06:35.066
And Jim's like, "Okay, fine. Give me the...
00:06:35.066 --> 00:06:40.269
Give me the two worst ideas you can come up with, and I will write a book about them and it will be awesome.
00:06:40.269 --> 00:06:45.842
And so the person told him, "Okay, so you're ideas are pokemon and the Lost Roman Legion. *Some quiet laughter.*
00:06:45.842 --> 00:06:50.713
Write about about that." So, he wrote this book called Codex Alera,
00:06:50.713 --> 00:06:53.918
which he eventually sold and became a big, best-selling, epic fantasy series.
00:06:53.918 --> 00:07:00.159
You can go find that story on line. It's a great story and it's true.
00:07:00.159 --> 00:07:05.462
Codex Alera is a cross between pokemon and the Lost Roman Region.
00:07:05.462 --> 00:07:10.379
And Jim, if you are watching this and I am wrong, then why didn't you tell me when I asked you?
00:07:10.379 --> 00:07:16.306
I think he dodged the question when I asked him at first. I can't remember.
00:07:16.306 --> 00:07:20.000
Anyway, ideas are cheap. Okay?