DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: We're in Saint Peter's Basilica standing
in front of Michelangelo's Pieta.
DR. BETH HARRIS: I feel very lucky,
because on this rainy Monday morning, we're the only ones.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: And it actually looks quite small--
DR. BETH HARRIS: It does.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: In relationship to the chapel
that holds it, but also especially
in relationship to Saint Peter's, which is so vast.
DR. BETH HARRIS: Of course, this sculpture
was made for a cardinal, but then it
was placed in the old Saint Peter's,
which was significantly smaller than this one.
And so it would have had a different relationship
to the architecture.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: What I'm finding interesting
is despite the fact that it's relatively small,
and probably about 20 feet away from us,
it's still a really intimate image.
There really is this extraordinary relationship
that Michelangelo has constructed
between the body of the dead Christ
and his mother, the Virgin Mary, who holds him on her lap.
DR. BETH HARRIS: Mary looks very young and beautiful,
but her body is-- and her lap is sort of enlarged to carry
the body of her dead son, but the realization that dead body,
of its weight--
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: It's weight.
DR. BETH HARRIS: One of the most beautiful passages, I think,
of the sculpture is the way that she holds up his right arm,
and pulls up that flesh a little bit.
And you really feel first of all,
that the marble is transformed by Michelangelo into flesh,
but also the weight of that body, and through that weight,
the loss of life that's so palpable for Mary.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: It's the complete lack
of resistance that his body offers
and the exertion that she has to extend in order to hold him.
And that contrast makes for the viewer,
I think, a very physical experience
looking at the sculpture.
DR. BETH HARRIS: His body looks so much
like the body of a real, young man, the ribcage
and the abdominal muscles.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: And yet it's also
idealized in the way in which there's
this beautiful turn of his body across her lap.
And for Mary as well, there's this interesting contradiction
in her sweetness, and the beauty,
but also the strength and the scale that's necessary for her
to easily hold him.
Look at how deeply carved that marble is.
DR. BETH HARRIS: The drapery.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: This real love
of the turn of the stone, that's creating this very vivid sense
of alternation, really, of light and shadow,
the complexity of surface against
the broad, pure surfaces of Christ's legs, of his torso,
of his arm.
DR. BETH HARRIS: Mary tilts her head forward, and looks down
at him.
His head is thrown back, so there's
[INAUDIBLE] between those two necks for me.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: And his neck is exposed to us,
incredibly vulnerable.
Christ's foot hangs in midair.
Mary, her left hand is open and pointing delicately forward,
as if she still trying to comprehend his death.
DR. BETH HARRIS: But I think there's also
a way of presenting Christ's body to the viewers,
saying this is the path to salvation.
This is God's sacrifice for mankind, my sacrifice of my son
that makes possible your redemption.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: There is a kind of rhythm
that points to that hand.
The drape and the knee point up towards Christ's knees,
which in turn create a kind of rhythmic bridge to her hand,
and to that sense of wondering.
This is very clearly an image that's
meant to be contemplated.
And the pain and the suffering that Christ has endured that--
DR. BETH HARRIS: And Mary's enduring.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: That Mary is enduring is
meant to be contemplated as a pathway.
DR. BETH HARRIS: They're polishing the floor.
DR. STEVEN ZUCKER: OK, let's move on.