0:00:00.880,0:00:03.023
Helen Walters: Huang,[br]it's so good to see you.

0:00:03.047,0:00:05.368
Thank you for joining us.[br]How's your 2020 been?

0:00:05.392,0:00:08.786
Huang Hung: My 2020[br]started totally normal.

0:00:08.810,0:00:12.513
In January, I went to Paris,

0:00:12.537,0:00:15.842
did my interview[br]for the fashion week there,

0:00:15.866,0:00:19.527
came back to Beijing on January 22nd,

0:00:19.551,0:00:22.762
and finding things a little bit tense

0:00:22.786,0:00:25.728
because there were a lot of rumors.

0:00:25.752,0:00:29.155
Having lived through SARS,

0:00:29.179,0:00:31.371
I wasn't that concerned.

0:00:31.395,0:00:36.621
And on the 23rd, I had a friend of mine[br]from New York come to my house

0:00:36.645,0:00:38.169
who had a flu,

0:00:38.193,0:00:40.173
and we had dinner together,

0:00:40.197,0:00:42.566
and another friend who came,

0:00:42.590,0:00:47.319
who left the next day for Australia[br]for vacation on an airplane.

0:00:47.343,0:00:51.905
So we were not taking this[br]terribly seriously

0:00:51.929,0:00:54.367
until there was a lockdown.

0:00:54.391,0:00:56.547
HW: And we've seen that echo[br]around the world.

0:00:56.571,0:00:59.963
I think still some people find it hard[br]to understand the magnitude

0:00:59.987,0:01:02.176
of some of the measures that China took.

0:01:02.200,0:01:06.160
I mean -- what else are we missing[br]about China's response in all of this?

0:01:06.184,0:01:07.918
HH: You know, historically,

0:01:07.942,0:01:12.958
we're just two very different countries

0:01:12.982,0:01:15.358
in terms of culture and history.

0:01:15.382,0:01:21.508
I mean, these are two completely different[br]human experiences for its people.

0:01:21.532,0:01:23.578
So, for China,

0:01:24.493,0:01:26.701
when the lockdown happens,

0:01:27.630,0:01:31.342
people are OK.

0:01:31.366,0:01:32.835
People are OK with it,

0:01:32.859,0:01:36.837
because they think that's what[br]a good parent should do.

0:01:36.861,0:01:39.269
You know, if a kid gets sick,

0:01:39.293,0:01:40.952
you put him in the other room,

0:01:40.976,0:01:45.481
and you lock him up and make sure[br]that the other kids don't get sick.

0:01:45.505,0:01:48.388
And they expect that[br]out of the government.

0:01:48.412,0:01:54.030
But when it is outside of China,[br]from America, it becomes a huge issue

0:01:54.054,0:01:56.274
of the right political thing to do

0:01:56.298,0:02:00.293
and whether it's infringing[br]on personal freedom.

0:02:00.317,0:02:04.548
So the issues that you have to deal with[br]in a democratic society

0:02:04.572,0:02:09.022
are issues that one does not[br]have to deal with in China.

0:02:09.046,0:02:11.973
I have to say that[br]there's a word in Chinese

0:02:11.997,0:02:15.202
that doesn't exist in any other language,

0:02:15.226,0:02:17.713
and the word is called "guāi."

0:02:17.737,0:02:20.479
It is what you call a kid

0:02:20.503,0:02:24.142
who listens to his or her parents.

0:02:24.166,0:02:28.342
So I think, as a people,[br]we are very "guāi."

0:02:28.366,0:02:31.475
We have this sort of authoritarian figure

0:02:31.499,0:02:34.891
that Chinese always look up to,

0:02:34.915,0:02:39.505
and they do expect the government[br]to actually take the actions,

0:02:39.529,0:02:41.709
and they will deal with it.

0:02:41.733,0:02:44.570
However much suffering there is,

0:02:44.594,0:02:50.537
they feel that, OK, if big brother says[br]that this has to be done,

0:02:50.561,0:02:52.502
then it must be done.

0:02:52.526,0:02:57.681
And that really defines China[br]as a separate mentality,

0:02:57.705,0:03:00.291
Chinese has a separate mentality,

0:03:00.315,0:03:04.249
as, say, people in Europe and America.

0:03:04.273,0:03:06.301
HW: That sense[br]of collective responsibility

0:03:06.325,0:03:10.625
sometimes feels a little absent[br]from this culture.

0:03:10.649,0:03:14.199
At the same time, there are,[br]I think, valid concerns

0:03:14.223,0:03:18.804
around surveillance[br]and data privacy, things like that.

0:03:18.828,0:03:20.040
What is the balance here,

0:03:20.064,0:03:24.594
and what is the right trade-off[br]between surveillance and freedom?

0:03:25.467,0:03:28.623
HH: I think in the internet age,

0:03:28.647,0:03:33.634
it is somewhere between China and the US.

0:03:33.658,0:03:40.035
I think when you take[br]individual freedom

0:03:40.059,0:03:42.631
versus collective safety,

0:03:42.655,0:03:45.459
there has to be a balance somewhere there.

0:03:45.483,0:03:51.293
With surveillance, the head of Baidu,[br]Robin Li, once said

0:03:51.317,0:03:57.225
the Chinese people are quite willing[br]to give up certain individual rights

0:03:57.249,0:03:59.400
in exchange for convenience.

0:03:59.424,0:04:04.195
Actually, he was completely criticized[br]on Chinese social media,

0:04:04.219,0:04:05.823
but I think he is right.

0:04:05.847,0:04:09.313
Chinese people are willing[br]to give up certain rights.

0:04:09.337,0:04:11.820
For example, we have ...

0:04:12.834,0:04:16.329
Chinese mostly are very proud[br]of the payment system we have,

0:04:16.353,0:04:19.674
which is you can go anywhere[br]just with your iPhone

0:04:19.698,0:04:21.135
and pay for everything,

0:04:21.159,0:04:22.894
and all they do is face-scan.

0:04:22.918,0:04:26.523
I think that probably[br]freaks Americans out.

0:04:26.547,0:04:31.182
You know, China right now,[br]we're still under semi-lockdown,

0:04:31.206,0:04:35.889
so if you go anywhere,[br]there's an app where you scan

0:04:35.913,0:04:39.156
and you input your mobile phone number,

0:04:39.180,0:04:45.736
and the app will tell the guard[br]at the entrance of the mall, for example,

0:04:45.760,0:04:48.382
where you have been for the past 14 days.

0:04:48.406,0:04:51.226
Now, when I told that to an American,

0:04:51.250,0:04:52.757
she was horrified,

0:04:52.781,0:04:56.825
and she thought it was[br]such an invasion of privacy.

0:04:56.849,0:04:59.258
On the other hand,

0:04:59.282,0:05:01.367
as someone who is Chinese

0:05:01.391,0:05:06.539
and has lived in China[br]for the past 20 years,

0:05:06.563,0:05:09.877
although I understand[br]that American mentality,

0:05:09.901,0:05:15.086
I still find I'm Chinese enough[br]to think, "I don't mind this,

0:05:15.110,0:05:19.897
and I am better, I feel safer[br]entering the mall

0:05:19.921,0:05:22.962
because everybody has been scanned,"

0:05:22.986,0:05:29.986
whereas, I think individual freedom[br]as an abstract concept

0:05:30.010,0:05:32.414
in a pandemic like this

0:05:32.438,0:05:34.577
is actually really meaningless.

0:05:34.601,0:05:40.206
So I think the West really needs[br]to move a step towards the East

0:05:40.230,0:05:43.660
and to think about[br]the collective as a whole

0:05:43.684,0:05:46.800
rather than only think[br]about oneself as an individual.

0:05:46.824,0:05:49.843
HW: The rise of antagonistic rhetoric[br]between the US and China

0:05:49.867,0:05:51.506
is obviously troubling,

0:05:51.530,0:05:54.073
and the thing is,[br]the countries are interlinked

0:05:54.097,0:05:57.443
whether people understand[br]global supply chains or not.

0:05:57.467,0:05:59.652
Where do you think we head next?

0:05:59.676,0:06:04.561
HH: You know, this is the most[br]horrifying thing that came out of this,

0:06:04.585,0:06:10.632
the kind of nationalistic sentiments[br]on both sides in this pandemic.

0:06:10.656,0:06:12.586
Because I'm an optimist,

0:06:12.610,0:06:16.473
I think what will come out of this

0:06:16.497,0:06:22.228
is that both sides will realize[br]that this is a fight

0:06:22.252,0:06:26.270
that the entire human race[br]has to do together and not apart.

0:06:26.294,0:06:28.455
Despite the rhetoric,

0:06:28.479,0:06:33.940
the global economy has grown[br]to such an integration

0:06:33.964,0:06:40.029
that decoupling will be[br]extremely costly and painful

0:06:40.053,0:06:42.773
for both the United States and China.

0:06:42.797,0:06:44.571
HW: It's also been interesting to me

0:06:44.595,0:06:48.811
to see the criticism that China[br]has received quite vocally.

0:06:48.835,0:06:53.584
For instance, they've been criticized[br]for downplaying the death toll,

0:06:53.608,0:06:54.971
arguably,

0:06:54.995,0:06:57.077
also for trying to demonize Dr. Li,

0:06:57.101,0:07:03.392
the Wuhan doctor who first[br]raised the alarm about the coronavirus.

0:07:03.416,0:07:05.473
I just saw a report[br]in "The New York Times"

0:07:05.497,0:07:11.193
that Weibo users have been posting[br]repeatedly on the last post of Dr. Li

0:07:11.217,0:07:14.445
and using this as kind of[br]a living memorial to him,

0:07:14.469,0:07:15.630
chatting to him.

0:07:15.654,0:07:19.382
There's something like[br]870,000 comments and growing

0:07:19.406,0:07:20.985
on that last post.

0:07:21.009,0:07:24.093
Do you see a change in the media?

0:07:24.117,0:07:27.054
Do you see a change in the approach[br]to Chinese leadership

0:07:27.078,0:07:31.415
that actually could lead to China[br]swinging perhaps more to the center,

0:07:31.439,0:07:35.749
just as perhaps America needs[br]to swing more towards a Chinese model?

0:07:35.773,0:07:38.326
HH: Unfortunately, not really,

0:07:38.350,0:07:43.019
because I think there is a way

0:07:43.043,0:07:47.388
between authoritarian governments[br]and its people to communicate.

0:07:47.412,0:07:50.480
The night that Dr. Li died,

0:07:50.504,0:07:54.811
when it was announced that he died,

0:07:54.835,0:07:57.173
the Chinese social media just blew up.

0:07:57.197,0:08:00.036
Even though he was[br]unjustly treated as a whistleblower,

0:08:00.060,0:08:02.477
he still went to work in the hospital

0:08:02.501,0:08:04.991
and tried to save lives as a doctor,

0:08:05.015,0:08:06.817
and then he died

0:08:06.841,0:08:08.502
because he contracted the disease.

0:08:08.526,0:08:11.121
So there was anger, frustration,

0:08:11.145,0:08:13.584
and all of that came out

0:08:13.608,0:08:16.600
in kind of commemorating a figure

0:08:16.624,0:08:20.014
that they feel that[br]the government had wronged.

0:08:20.038,0:08:21.198
The verdict

0:08:22.121,0:08:26.572
and sort of the official voice on:

0:08:26.596,0:08:29.884
"Who is Dr. Li?[br]Is he a good guy or a bad guy?"

0:08:29.908,0:08:33.319
completely changed 180 degrees.

0:08:33.343,0:08:37.802
He went from a doctor who misbehaved

0:08:37.826,0:08:40.346
to the hero who warned the people.

0:08:40.370,0:08:43.811
So under authoritarian government,

0:08:43.835,0:08:48.653
they still are very aware[br]of public opinion,

0:08:48.677,0:08:50.746
but, on the other hand,

0:08:50.770,0:08:55.567
when people complain[br]and when they commemorate Dr. Li,

0:08:55.591,0:08:58.020
do they really want to change the system?

0:08:58.588,0:09:01.611
And my answer is no,

0:09:01.635,0:09:05.663
because they don't like[br]that particular decision,

0:09:05.687,0:09:08.176
but they don't want to change the system.

0:09:08.200,0:09:10.027
And one of the reasons is because

0:09:10.051,0:09:13.554
they have never, ever[br]known another system.

0:09:13.578,0:09:16.119
This is the system they know how to work.

0:09:17.516,0:09:19.457
HW: What is wok-throwing, Huang?

0:09:19.481,0:09:24.530
HH: Oh, wok-throwing is when[br]you blame somebody else.

0:09:24.554,0:09:30.387
Basically, someone who is responsible[br]in a slang Chinese

0:09:30.411,0:09:33.537
is someone who carries a black wok.

0:09:33.561,0:09:39.326
You are made to be the scapegoat[br]for something that is bad.

0:09:39.350,0:09:43.989
So basically, Trump started[br]calling it the "Chinese virus,"

0:09:44.013,0:09:45.269
the "Wuhan virus,"

0:09:45.293,0:09:51.627
and trying to blame the entire[br]coronavirus pandemic

0:09:51.651,0:09:52.843
on the Chinese.

0:09:52.867,0:09:57.142
And then the Chinese, I think,[br]threw the wok back at the Americans.

0:09:57.166,0:10:02.333
So it was a very funny joke[br]on Chinese social media,

0:10:02.357,0:10:03.621
that wok-throwing.

0:10:03.645,0:10:09.778
There's a wok-throwing gymnastics[br]aerobics exercise video that went viral.

0:10:09.802,0:10:10.964
HW: But tell us, Huang:

0:10:10.988,0:10:13.501
You're also doing dances on TikTok, right?

0:10:13.525,0:10:15.128
HH: Oh, of course.

0:10:15.152,0:10:19.308
I'm doing a lot of wok-throwing[br]aerobics on TikTok.

0:10:19.332,0:10:23.115
HW: I mean, a potential silver lining[br]of all of this is that it has laid bare

0:10:23.139,0:10:26.812
some of the inequities,[br]inequalities in the system,

0:10:26.836,0:10:29.351
some of the broken[br]structures that we have,

0:10:29.375,0:10:32.503
and if we're smart, we can rebuild better.

0:10:32.527,0:10:36.091
HH: Yes. I think one of[br]the silver linings of this pandemic

0:10:36.115,0:10:39.525
is that we do realize

0:10:40.700,0:10:47.076
that the human race[br]has to do something together

0:10:47.100,0:10:53.013
rather than to be distinguished[br]by our race, by the color of our skin

0:10:53.037,0:10:55.016
or by our nationality;

0:10:55.040,0:11:00.761
that this virus obviously[br]is not discriminating against anyone,

0:11:00.785,0:11:02.910
whether you are rich or poor,

0:11:02.934,0:11:05.098
important or not important

0:11:05.122,0:11:08.919
or whatever skin color[br]or nationality you are.

0:11:08.943,0:11:12.431
So it is a time to be together,

0:11:12.455,0:11:16.458
rather than to try to pull the world apart

0:11:16.482,0:11:20.067
and crawl back to our own[br]nationalistic shells.

0:11:20.535,0:11:22.047
HW: It's a beautiful sentiment.

0:11:22.071,0:11:24.846
Huang Hung, thank you so much[br]for joining us from Beijing.

0:11:24.870,0:11:26.252
Stay well, please.

0:11:27.324,0:11:29.834
HH: Thank you, Helen,[br]and you stay well as well.