WEBVTT

00:00:00.858 --> 00:00:03.344
We all go to doctors,

00:00:04.944 --> 00:00:09.208
and we do so with trust and blind faith

00:00:09.208 --> 00:00:13.085
that the test they are ordering
and the medications they're prescribing

00:00:13.085 --> 00:00:16.336
are based upon evidence,

00:00:16.336 --> 00:00:20.330
evidence that's designed to help us.

00:00:20.330 --> 00:00:23.116
However, the reality is

00:00:23.116 --> 00:00:26.924
that that hasn't always
been the case for everyone.

00:00:26.924 --> 00:00:32.380
What if I told you that the medical
science discovered over the past century

00:00:32.380 --> 00:00:36.003
has been based on
only half the population?

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:36.003 --> 00:00:38.696
I'm an emergency medicine doctor.

00:00:38.696 --> 00:00:42.829
I was trained to be prepared
in a medical emergency.

00:00:42.829 --> 00:00:48.471
It's about saving lives.
How cool is that?

00:00:48.471 --> 00:00:52.117
Okay, there's a lot of runny noses
and stubbed toes,

00:00:52.117 --> 00:00:55.762
but no matter who walks
through the door to the ER,

00:00:55.762 --> 00:00:57.991
we order the same tests,

00:00:57.991 --> 00:00:59.988
we prescribe the same medication

00:00:59.988 --> 00:01:05.444
without ever thinking about
the sex or gender of our patients.

00:01:05.444 --> 00:01:07.348
Why would we?

00:01:07.348 --> 00:01:10.854
We were never taught that there were
any differences between men and women.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:10.854 --> 00:01:15.545
A recent Government Accountability study
revealed that 80 percent of the drugs

00:01:15.545 --> 00:01:17.518
withdrawn from the market

00:01:17.518 --> 00:01:21.140
are due to side effects on women.

00:01:21.140 --> 00:01:23.416
So let's think about that for a minute.

00:01:23.416 --> 00:01:26.806
Why are we discovering
side effects on women

00:01:26.806 --> 00:01:31.357
only after a drug has been released
to the market?

00:01:31.357 --> 00:01:35.165
Do you know that it takes years for a drug

00:01:35.165 --> 00:01:40.226
to go from an idea to being tested
on cells in a laboratory,

00:01:40.226 --> 00:01:42.270
to animal studies,

00:01:42.270 --> 00:01:44.545
to then clinical trials on humans,

00:01:44.545 --> 00:01:48.237
finally to go through
a regulatory approval process,

00:01:48.237 --> 00:01:54.158
to be available for your doctor
to prescribe to you,

00:01:54.158 --> 00:01:57.469
not to mention the millions
and billions of dollars of funding

00:01:57.469 --> 00:02:01.625
it takes to go through that process.

00:02:01.625 --> 00:02:04.371
So why are we discovering
unacceptable side effects

00:02:04.371 --> 00:02:09.802
on half the population
after that has gone through?

00:02:11.244 --> 00:02:13.055
What's happening?

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:13.055 --> 00:02:16.909
Well, it turns out that those cells
used in that laboratory,

00:02:16.909 --> 00:02:18.952
they're male cells,

00:02:18.952 --> 00:02:22.203
and the animals used
in the animal studies were male animals,

00:02:22.203 --> 00:02:29.169
and the clinical trials have been
performed almost exclusively on men.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:29.169 --> 00:02:34.672
How is it that the male model became
our framework for medical research?

00:02:34.672 --> 00:02:38.526
Let's look at an example that has
been popularized in the media,

00:02:38.526 --> 00:02:41.823
and it has to do
with the sleep aid Ambien.

00:02:41.823 --> 00:02:46.769
Ambien was released on the market
over 20 years ago,

00:02:46.769 --> 00:02:51.296
and since then, hundreds of millions
of prescriptions have been written,

00:02:51.296 --> 00:02:56.962
primarily to women because women
suffer more sleep disorders than men.

00:02:56.962 --> 00:02:59.307
But just this past year,

00:02:59.307 --> 00:03:02.743
the Food and Drug Administration
recommended cutting the dose in half

00:03:02.743 --> 00:03:05.367
for women only,

00:03:05.367 --> 00:03:08.409
because they just realized
that women metabolize the drug

00:03:08.409 --> 00:03:11.334
at a slower rate than men,

00:03:11.334 --> 00:03:16.628
causing them to wake up in the morning
with more of the active drug in the system

00:03:16.628 --> 00:03:20.552
and then they're drowsy and they're
getting behind the wheel of the car,

00:03:20.552 --> 00:03:25.219
and they're at risk
for motor vehicle accidents.

00:03:25.219 --> 00:03:28.795
And I can't help but think,
as an emergency physician,

00:03:28.795 --> 00:03:33.973
how many of my patients
that I've cared for over the years

00:03:33.973 --> 00:03:36.434
that were involved
in a motor vehicle accident

00:03:36.434 --> 00:03:40.033
possibly could have been prevented

00:03:40.033 --> 00:03:45.211
if this type of analysis was performed
and acted upon 20 years ago

00:03:45.211 --> 00:03:49.135
when this drug was first released.

00:03:49.135 --> 00:03:53.268
How many other things
need to be analyzed by gender?

00:03:53.268 --> 00:03:55.335
What else are we missing?

00:03:57.531 --> 00:04:01.246
World War II changed a lot of things,

00:04:01.246 --> 00:04:04.581
and one of them was this need
to protect people

00:04:04.581 --> 00:04:09.503
from becoming victims of medical research
without informed consent.

00:04:09.503 --> 00:04:13.033
So some much-needed guidelines
or rules were set into place,

00:04:13.033 --> 00:04:18.234
and part of that was this desire
to protect women of childbearing age

00:04:18.234 --> 00:04:22.135
from entering into any
medical research studies.

00:04:22.135 --> 00:04:27.452
There was fear, what if something
happened to the fetus during this study?

00:04:27.452 --> 00:04:29.959
Who would be responsible?

00:04:29.959 --> 00:04:32.258
And so the scientists
at this time actually thought

00:04:32.258 --> 00:04:35.114
this was a blessing in disguise,

00:04:35.114 --> 00:04:37.482
because let's face it,

00:04:37.482 --> 00:04:40.710
men's bodies are pretty homogeneous.

00:04:40.710 --> 00:04:44.091
They don't have the constantly
fluctuating levels of hormones

00:04:44.091 --> 00:04:49.245
that could disrupt clean data
they could get if they had only men.

00:04:49.245 --> 00:04:53.518
It was easier. It was cheaper.

00:04:53.518 --> 00:04:56.411
Not to mention, at this time,
there was a general assumption

00:04:56.411 --> 00:05:00.707
that men and women were alike in every way

00:05:00.707 --> 00:05:05.304
apart from their reproductive organs
and sex hormones.

00:05:05.304 --> 00:05:09.042
So it was decided:

00:05:09.042 --> 00:05:12.331
medical research was performed on men

00:05:12.331 --> 00:05:15.414
and the results were later
applied to women.

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:17.314 --> 00:05:20.797
What did this do to the notion
of women's health?

00:05:20.797 --> 00:05:25.185
Women's health became synonymous
with reproduction:

00:05:25.185 --> 00:05:30.317
breasts, ovaries, uterus, pregnancy.

00:05:30.317 --> 00:05:34.589
It's this term we now refer to
as bikini medicine.

00:05:34.589 --> 00:05:37.468
And this stayed this way
until about the 1980s,

00:05:37.468 --> 00:05:40.556
when this concept was challenged
by the medical community

00:05:40.556 --> 00:05:44.805
and by the public health policymakers
when they realized that,

00:05:44.805 --> 00:05:48.451
by excluding women
from all medical research studies,

00:05:48.451 --> 00:05:52.328
we actually did them a disservice,

00:05:52.328 --> 00:05:54.975
in that apart from reproductive issues,

00:05:54.975 --> 00:06:00.826
virtually was nothing was known about
the unique needs of the female patient.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:00.826 --> 00:06:06.468
Since that time, an overwhelming amount
of evidence has come to light

00:06:06.468 --> 00:06:12.370
that shows us just how different
men and women are in every way.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:17.224 --> 00:06:20.034
You know, we have this saying in medicine:

00:06:20.034 --> 00:06:24.724
children are not just little adults.

00:06:24.724 --> 00:06:28.161
And we say that to remind ourselves
that children actually have

00:06:28.161 --> 00:06:32.665
a different physiology than normal adults.

00:06:32.665 --> 00:06:37.634
And it's because of this that the medical
specialty of pediatrics came to light.

00:06:37.634 --> 00:06:45.180
And we now conduct research on children
in order to improve their lives.

00:06:45.180 --> 00:06:47.850
And I know the same thing
can be said about women.

00:06:47.850 --> 00:06:54.584
Women are not just men
with boobs and tubes,

00:06:54.584 --> 00:06:58.159
but they have their own anatomy
and physiology

00:06:58.159 --> 00:07:01.671
that deserves to be studied
with the same intensity.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:03.337 --> 00:07:06.820
Let's take the cardiovascular
system, for example.

00:07:06.820 --> 00:07:11.580
This are in medicine has done the most
to try to figure out why it seems

00:07:11.580 --> 00:07:15.922
men and women have
completely different heart attacks.

00:07:15.922 --> 00:07:21.030
Heart disease is the number one killer
for both men and women,

00:07:21.030 --> 00:07:27.044
but more women die within the first year
of having a heart attack than men.

00:07:27.044 --> 00:07:31.061
Men will complain of crushing chest pain.

00:07:31.061 --> 00:07:34.846
An elephant is sitting on their chest.

00:07:34.846 --> 00:07:37.655
And we call this typical.

00:07:37.655 --> 00:07:40.697
Women have chest pain too,

00:07:40.697 --> 00:07:44.133
but more women than men

00:07:44.133 --> 00:07:48.336
will complain of just not feeling right,

00:07:48.336 --> 00:07:51.261
can't seem to get enough air in,

00:07:51.261 --> 00:07:55.000
just so tired lately.

00:07:55.000 --> 00:07:57.972
And for some reason we call this atypical,

00:07:57.972 --> 00:08:03.266
even though, as I mentioned,
women do make up half the population.

00:08:03.266 --> 00:08:09.976
And so what is some of the evidence
to help explain some of these differences?

00:08:09.976 --> 00:08:12.414
If we look at the anatomy,

00:08:12.414 --> 00:08:18.660
the blood vessels that surround the heart
are smaller in women compared to men,

00:08:18.660 --> 00:08:23.118
and the way that those blood vessels
develop disease is different

00:08:23.118 --> 00:08:25.904
in women compared to men,

00:08:25.904 --> 00:08:30.943
and the test that we use to determine
if someone is at risk for a heart attack,

00:08:30.943 --> 00:08:35.540
well they were initially designed
and tested and perfected in men,

00:08:35.540 --> 00:08:40.137
and so aren't as good
at determining that in women.

00:08:40.137 --> 00:08:43.179
And then if we think
about the medications,

00:08:43.179 --> 00:08:45.060
common medications that we use,

00:08:45.060 --> 00:08:47.730
like Aspirin,

00:08:47.730 --> 00:08:52.211
we give Aspirin to healthy men to help
prevent them from having a heart attack,

00:08:52.211 --> 00:08:56.553
but do you know that if you give Aspirin
to a healthy woman,

00:08:56.553 --> 00:08:58.604
it's actually harmful?

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:00.361 --> 00:09:02.822
What this is doing is merely telling us

00:09:02.822 --> 00:09:07.141
that we are scratching the surface.

00:09:07.141 --> 00:09:11.576
Emergency medicine
is a fast-paced business.

00:09:11.576 --> 00:09:19.006
How many life-saving areas of medicine
like cancer and stroke?

00:09:19.006 --> 00:09:24.161
Are there important differences between
men and women that we could be utilizing?

00:09:24.161 --> 00:09:30.081
Or even, why is it that some people
get those runny noses more than others,

00:09:30.081 --> 00:09:34.493
or why the pain medication that we give
to those stubbed toes

00:09:34.493 --> 00:09:39.158
work in some and not in others?

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:41.296 --> 00:09:43.432
The Institute of Medicine has said

00:09:43.432 --> 00:09:47.937
every cell has a sex.

00:09:47.937 --> 00:09:50.607
What does this mean?

00:09:50.607 --> 00:09:52.743
Sex is DNA.

00:09:52.743 --> 00:09:57.875
Gender is how someone
presents themselves in society.

00:09:57.875 --> 00:10:00.522
And these two many not always match up,

00:10:00.522 --> 00:10:04.631
as we can see with our
transgendered population.

00:10:04.631 --> 00:10:09.438
But it's important to realize
that from the moment of conception,

00:10:09.438 --> 00:10:11.829
every cell in our bodies --

00:10:11.829 --> 00:10:15.117
skin, hair, heart, and lungs --

00:10:15.117 --> 00:10:18.391
contain our own unique DNA,

00:10:18.391 --> 00:10:23.825
and that DNA contains the chromosomes
that determine whether we become

00:10:23.825 --> 00:10:28.329
male or female, man or woman.

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:28.329 --> 00:10:30.279
It used to be thought

00:10:30.279 --> 00:10:34.343
that those sex-determining
chromosomes pictured here --

00:10:34.343 --> 00:10:37.593
xy if you're male, xx if you're female --

00:10:37.593 --> 00:10:42.864
merely determined whether you
would be born with ovaries or testes,

00:10:42.864 --> 00:10:46.765
and it was the sex hormones
that those organs produced

00:10:46.765 --> 00:10:52.988
were what was responsible for the
differences we see in the opposite sex.

00:10:52.988 --> 00:11:00.046
But we now know that that theory was wrong
or it's at least a little incomplete.

00:11:00.046 --> 00:11:04.945
And thankfully, scientists like Dr. Page
from the Whitehead Institute,

00:11:04.945 --> 00:11:06.849
who works on the y chromosome,

00:11:06.849 --> 00:11:11.470
and Doctor Yang from UCLA,
they have found evidence

00:11:11.470 --> 00:11:14.767
that tells us that those
sex-determining chromosomes

00:11:14.767 --> 00:11:17.298
that are in every cell in our bodies

00:11:17.298 --> 00:11:20.502
continue to remain active

00:11:20.502 --> 00:11:24.542
for our entire lives,

00:11:24.542 --> 00:11:28.025
and could be what's responsible
for the differences we see

00:11:28.025 --> 00:11:30.254
in the dosing of drugs,

00:11:30.254 --> 00:11:32.971
or why there are differences
between men and women

00:11:32.971 --> 00:11:37.566
in the susceptibility
and severity of diseases.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:39.008 --> 00:11:42.967
This new knowledge is the game-changer,

00:11:45.338 --> 00:11:48.751
and it's up to those scientists
that continue to find that evidence,

00:11:48.751 --> 00:11:53.000
but it's up to the clinicians
to start translating this data

00:11:53.000 --> 00:11:55.299
at the bedside,

00:11:55.299 --> 00:11:59.755
today, right now.

00:12:01.498 --> 00:12:04.470
And to help do this, I'm a co-founder
of a national organization

00:12:04.470 --> 00:12:07.419
called Sex and Gender
Women's Health Collaborative,

00:12:07.419 --> 00:12:12.225
and we collect all of this data
so that it's available for teaching

00:12:12.225 --> 00:12:14.245
and for patient care.

00:12:14.245 --> 00:12:19.771
And we're working to bring together
the medical educators to the table.

NOTE Paragraph

00:12:19.771 --> 00:12:22.116
That's a big job.

00:12:22.116 --> 00:12:29.105
It's changing the way medical training
has been done since its inception.

00:12:29.105 --> 00:12:31.722
But I believe in them.

00:12:31.722 --> 00:12:37.720
I know they're going to see the value
of incorporating the gender lens

00:12:37.720 --> 00:12:40.738
into the current curriculum.

00:12:40.738 --> 00:12:45.766
It's about training the future
health care providers correctly.

00:12:48.299 --> 00:12:51.038
And regionally, I'm a co-creator
of a division

00:12:51.038 --> 00:12:53.546
within the Department
of Emergency Medicine

00:12:53.546 --> 00:12:55.473
here at Brown University

00:12:55.473 --> 00:12:57.865
called Sex and Gender
in Emergency Medicine,

00:12:57.865 --> 00:13:02.462
and we conduct the research to determine
the differences between men and women

00:13:02.462 --> 00:13:04.807
in emergent conditions,

00:13:04.807 --> 00:13:09.823
like heart disease and stroke
and sepsis and substance abuse,

00:13:09.823 --> 00:13:14.232
but we also believe
that education is paramount.

00:13:15.302 --> 00:13:19.250
We've created a 360-degree
model of education.

00:13:19.250 --> 00:13:24.961
We have programs for the doctors,
for the nurses, for the students,

00:13:24.961 --> 00:13:27.423
and for the patients.

00:13:27.423 --> 00:13:32.392
Because this cannot just be left up
to the health care leaders.

00:13:32.392 --> 00:13:36.290
We all have a role in making a difference.

00:13:36.826 --> 00:13:41.842
But I must warn you, this is not easy.

00:13:41.842 --> 00:13:45.046
In fact, it's hard.

00:13:45.046 --> 00:13:49.504
It's essentially changing the way
we think about medicine

00:13:49.504 --> 00:13:53.683
and health and research.

00:13:53.683 --> 00:13:57.863
It's changing our relationship
to the health care system.

NOTE Paragraph

00:13:57.863 --> 00:14:01.322
But there's no going back.

00:14:01.322 --> 00:14:05.061
We now know just enough

00:14:05.061 --> 00:14:09.565
to know that we weren't doing it right.

NOTE Paragraph

00:14:09.565 --> 00:14:12.769
Martin Luther King, Jr. has said,

00:14:12.769 --> 00:14:16.763
"Change does not roll in
on the wheels of inevitability,

00:14:16.763 --> 00:14:20.339
but comes through continuous struggle."

NOTE Paragraph

00:14:20.339 --> 00:14:24.007
And the first step towards change
is awareness.

00:14:24.007 --> 00:14:28.558
This is not just about improving
medical care for women.

00:14:28.558 --> 00:14:34.990
This is about personalized,
individualized health care for everyone.

00:14:34.990 --> 00:14:42.256
This awareness has the power to transform
medical care for men and women.

00:14:42.931 --> 00:14:48.550
And from now on, I want you
to ask your doctors

00:14:48.550 --> 00:14:54.215
whether the treatments you are receiving
are specific to your sex and gender.

00:14:54.215 --> 00:14:57.025
They may not know the answer,

00:14:57.025 --> 00:14:59.045
yet,

00:14:59.045 --> 00:15:03.797
but the conversation has begun,
and together we can all learn.

00:15:03.797 --> 00:15:08.240
Remember, for me
and my colleagues in this field,

00:15:08.240 --> 00:15:11.397
your sex and gender matter.

NOTE Paragraph

00:15:11.397 --> 00:15:13.650
Thank you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:15:13.650 --> 00:15:16.491
(Applause)