WEBVTT

00:00:00.853 --> 00:00:02.331
When I was in the fifth grade,

00:00:02.331 --> 00:00:06.759
I bought an issue
of DC Comics Presents #57

00:00:06.759 --> 00:00:09.556
off of a spinner rack
at my local bookstore,

00:00:09.556 --> 00:00:12.737
and that comic book changed my life.

00:00:13.292 --> 00:00:16.515
The combination of words and pictures
did something inside my head

00:00:16.515 --> 00:00:18.288
that had never been done before,

00:00:18.288 --> 00:00:22.041
and I immediately fell in love
with the medium of comics.

00:00:22.041 --> 00:00:25.224
I became a voracious comic book reader,

00:00:25.224 --> 00:00:27.036
but I never brought them to school.

00:00:27.036 --> 00:00:32.293
Instinctively, I knew that comic books
didn't belong in the classroom.

00:00:32.779 --> 00:00:35.128
My parents definitely were not fans,

00:00:35.128 --> 00:00:38.302
and I was certain that my teachers
wouldn't be either.

00:00:38.302 --> 00:00:40.333
After all, they never used them to teach,

00:00:40.333 --> 00:00:44.654
comic books and graphic novels were never
allowed during silent sustained reading,

00:00:44.654 --> 00:00:48.104
and they were never sold
at our annual book fair.

00:00:48.104 --> 00:00:50.333
Even so, I kept reading comics,

00:00:50.333 --> 00:00:52.396
and I even started making them.

00:00:52.396 --> 00:00:55.056
Eventually I became a published cartoonist

00:00:55.056 --> 00:00:57.935
writing and drawing
comic books for a living.

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:58.844 --> 00:01:01.223
I also became a high school teacher.

00:01:01.223 --> 00:01:02.464
This is where I taught:

00:01:02.464 --> 00:01:05.428
Bishop O'Dowd High School
in Oakland, California.

00:01:05.428 --> 00:01:07.484
I taught a little bit of math
and a little bit of art,

00:01:07.484 --> 00:01:09.098
but mostly computer science,

00:01:09.098 --> 00:01:11.684
and I was there for 17 years.

00:01:11.684 --> 00:01:13.527
When I was brand new teacher,

00:01:13.527 --> 00:01:16.776
I tried bringing comic books
into my classroom.

00:01:16.776 --> 00:01:19.657
I remember telling my students
on the first day of every class

00:01:19.657 --> 00:01:21.813
that I was also a cartoonist.

00:01:21.813 --> 00:01:25.265
It wasn't so much that I was planning
to teach them with comics,

00:01:25.265 --> 00:01:29.646
it was more that I was hoping comics
would make them think that I was cool.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:29.646 --> 00:01:30.654
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:30.654 --> 00:01:32.000
I was wrong.

00:01:32.000 --> 00:01:34.090
This was the '90s,

00:01:34.090 --> 00:01:38.100
so comic books didn't have
the cultural cache that they do today.

00:01:38.100 --> 00:01:42.118
My students didn't think I was cool.
They thought I was kind of a dork.

00:01:42.118 --> 00:01:45.154
And even worse, when stuff
got hard in my class,

00:01:45.154 --> 00:01:48.365
they would use comic books
as a way of distracting me.

00:01:48.365 --> 00:01:51.043
They would raise their hands
and me questions like,

00:01:51.043 --> 00:01:52.930
"Mr. Yang, who do you think
would win in a fight,

00:01:52.930 --> 00:01:55.146
Superman or the Hulk?"

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:55.146 --> 00:01:56.074
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:56.074 --> 00:02:01.027
I very quickly realized I had to keep
my teaching and my cartooning separate.

00:02:01.027 --> 00:02:04.097
It seemed like my instincts
in fifth grade were correct.

00:02:04.097 --> 00:02:07.557
Comic books didn't belong
in the classroom.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:08.011 --> 00:02:09.980
But again, I was wrong.

00:02:09.980 --> 00:02:12.101
A few years into my teaching career,

00:02:12.101 --> 00:02:16.912
I learned firsthand
the educational potential of comics.

00:02:16.912 --> 00:02:20.613
One semester, I was asked to sub
for this Algebra 2 class.

00:02:20.613 --> 00:02:24.895
I was asked to long-term sub it,
and I said yes, but there was a problem.

00:02:24.895 --> 00:02:28.559
At the time, I was also the school's
educational technologist,

00:02:28.559 --> 00:02:30.572
which meant every couple of weeks

00:02:30.572 --> 00:02:33.876
I had to miss one or two periods
of this Algebra 2 class

00:02:33.876 --> 00:02:36.813
because I was in another classroom
helping another teacher

00:02:36.813 --> 00:02:38.903
with a computer-related activity.

00:02:38.903 --> 00:02:41.940
For these Algebra 2 students,
that was terrible.

00:02:41.940 --> 00:02:44.580
I mean, having a long-term
sub is bad enough,

00:02:44.580 --> 00:02:48.222
but having a sub for your sub?
That's the worst.

00:02:48.222 --> 00:02:52.386
In an effort to provide some sort
of consistency for my students,

00:02:52.386 --> 00:02:55.447
I began videotaping
myself giving lectures.

00:02:55.447 --> 00:02:58.939
I'd then give these videos to my sub
to play for my students.

00:02:58.939 --> 00:03:03.139
I tried to make these videos
as engaging as possible.

00:03:03.139 --> 00:03:05.550
I even included these
little special effects.

00:03:05.550 --> 00:03:08.317
For instance, after I finished
a problem on the board,

00:03:08.317 --> 00:03:10.332
I'd clap my hands,

00:03:10.332 --> 00:03:12.618
and the board would magically erase.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:12.618 --> 00:03:14.046
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:14.046 --> 00:03:16.452
I thought it was pretty awesome.

00:03:16.452 --> 00:03:19.223
I was pretty certain
that my students would love it,

00:03:19.223 --> 00:03:20.852
but I was wrong.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:20.852 --> 00:03:22.350
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:22.350 --> 00:03:24.809
These video lectures were a disaster.

00:03:24.809 --> 00:03:26.915
I had students coming up to me
and saying things like,

00:03:26.915 --> 00:03:29.233
"Mr. Yang, we thought
you were boring in person,

00:03:29.233 --> 00:03:32.613
but on video, you are just unbearable."

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:32.613 --> 00:03:34.752
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:34.752 --> 00:03:40.132
So as a desperate second attempt,
I began drawing these lectures as comics.

00:03:40.132 --> 00:03:42.409
I'd do these very quickly
with very little planning.

00:03:42.409 --> 00:03:45.571
I'd just take a sharpie,
draw one panel after the other,

00:03:45.571 --> 00:03:48.185
figuring out what I wanted
to say as I went.

00:03:48.185 --> 00:03:52.154
These comics lectures would come out to
anywhere between four and six pages long,

00:03:52.154 --> 00:03:55.033
I'd xerox these, give them to my sub

00:03:55.033 --> 00:03:56.945
to hand to my students,

00:03:56.945 --> 00:03:59.130
and much to my surprise,

00:03:59.130 --> 00:04:02.252
these comics lectures were a hit.

00:04:02.252 --> 00:04:04.856
My students would ask me
to make these for them

00:04:04.856 --> 00:04:07.762
even when I could be there in person.

00:04:07.762 --> 00:04:12.569
It was like they liked cartoon me
more than actual me.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:12.569 --> 00:04:14.980
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:14.980 --> 00:04:18.472
This surprised me, because my students
are part of a generation

00:04:18.472 --> 00:04:20.282
that was raised on screens,

00:04:20.282 --> 00:04:23.515
so I thought for sure they would like
learning from a screen

00:04:23.515 --> 00:04:26.015
better than learning from a page,

00:04:26.015 --> 00:04:27.991
but when I talked to my students

00:04:27.991 --> 00:04:31.125
about why they liked
these comics lectures so much,

00:04:31.125 --> 00:04:35.595
I began to understand
the educational potential of comics.

00:04:35.595 --> 00:04:38.042
First, unlike their math textbooks,

00:04:38.042 --> 00:04:40.733
these comics lectures taught visually.

00:04:40.733 --> 00:04:43.777
Our students grow up in a visual culture,

00:04:43.777 --> 00:04:46.186
so they're used to taking in
information that way.

00:04:46.186 --> 00:04:49.145
But unlike other visual narratives,

00:04:49.145 --> 00:04:53.501
like film or television
or animation or video,

00:04:53.501 --> 00:04:56.718
comics are what I call permanent.

00:04:56.718 --> 00:05:02.460
In a comic, past, present, and future
all sit side by side on the same page.

00:05:02.460 --> 00:05:05.628
This means that the rate
of information flow

00:05:05.628 --> 00:05:08.976
is firmly in the hands of the reader.

00:05:08.976 --> 00:05:13.758
When my students didn't understand
something in my comics lecture,

00:05:13.758 --> 00:05:18.119
they could just reread that passage
as quickly or as slowly as they needed.

00:05:18.119 --> 00:05:21.841
It was like I was giving them
a remote control over the information.

00:05:21.841 --> 00:05:24.759
The same was not true of my video lectures

00:05:24.759 --> 00:05:27.653
and it wasn't even true
of my in-person lectures.

00:05:27.653 --> 00:05:32.424
When I speak, I deliver the information
as quickly or slowly as I want.

00:05:32.424 --> 00:05:36.045
So for certain students
and certain kinds of information,

00:05:36.045 --> 00:05:40.957
these two aspects of the comics medium,
its visual nature and its permanence,

00:05:40.957 --> 00:05:44.574
make it an incredibly powerful
educational tool.

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:44.574 --> 00:05:46.574
When I was teaching this Algebra 2 class,

00:05:46.574 --> 00:05:50.686
I was also working on my Masters
in Education at Cal State East Bay,

00:05:50.686 --> 00:05:54.823
and I was so intrigued by this experience
that I had with these comics lectures

00:05:54.823 --> 00:05:59.936
that I decided to focus
my final Masters project on comics.

00:05:59.936 --> 00:06:03.005
I wanted to figure out
why American educators

00:06:03.005 --> 00:06:08.137
have historically been so reluctant
to use comic books in their classrooms.

00:06:08.137 --> 00:06:10.373
Here's what I discovered.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:10.373 --> 00:06:13.096
Comic books first became
a mass medium in the 1940s,

00:06:13.096 --> 00:06:15.263
with millions of copies
selling every month,

00:06:15.263 --> 00:06:17.719
and educators back then took notice.

00:06:17.719 --> 00:06:17.969
A lot of innovative teachers began
bringing comics into their classrooms

00:06:23.252 --> 00:06:24.165
to experiment.

00:06:24.165 --> 00:06:26.785
In 1944, the Journal
of Educational Sociology

00:06:26.785 --> 00:06:30.227
even devoted an entire issue
to this topic.

00:06:30.638 --> 00:06:32.929
Things seemed to be progressing.

00:06:32.929 --> 00:06:35.197
Teachers were starting
to figure things out.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:35.197 --> 00:06:37.399
But then along comes this guy.

00:06:37.399 --> 00:06:41.410
This is child psychologist
Dr. Fredric Wertham,

00:06:41.410 --> 00:06:45.352
and in 1954, he wrote a book
called "Seduction of the Innocent,"

00:06:45.352 --> 00:06:50.271
where he argues that comic books
cause juvenile delinquency.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:50.271 --> 00:06:51.302
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:51.302 --> 00:06:52.863
He was wrong.

00:06:52.863 --> 00:06:54.877
Now, Dr. Wertham was actually
a pretty decent guy.

00:06:54.877 --> 00:06:58.293
He spent most of his career
working with juvenile delinquents,

00:06:58.293 --> 00:07:03.248
and in his work he noticed
that most of his clients read comic books.

00:07:03.248 --> 00:07:07.115
What Dr. Wertham failed to realize
was in the 1940s and '50s,

00:07:07.115 --> 00:07:11.263
almost every kid in America
read comic books.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:11.263 --> 00:07:14.657
Dr. Wertham does a pretty
dubious job of proving his case,

00:07:14.657 --> 00:07:18.493
but his book does inspire
the Senate of the United States

00:07:18.493 --> 00:07:20.118
to hold a series of hearings

00:07:20.118 --> 00:07:25.043
to see if in fact comic books
cause juvenile delinquency.

00:07:25.043 --> 00:07:27.711
These hearings lasted
for almost two months.

00:07:27.711 --> 00:07:31.953
They ended inconclusively,
but not before doing tremendous damage

00:07:31.953 --> 00:07:36.480
to the reputation of comic books
in the eyes of the American public.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:36.480 --> 00:07:40.669
After this, respectable American
educators all backed away,

00:07:40.669 --> 00:07:42.781
and they stayed away for decades.

00:07:42.781 --> 00:07:46.114
It wasn't until the 1970s
that a few brave souls

00:07:46.114 --> 00:07:47.617
started making their way back in,

00:07:47.617 --> 00:07:49.630
and it really wasn't
until pretty recently,

00:07:49.630 --> 00:07:51.290
maybe the last decade or so,

00:07:51.290 --> 00:07:53.816
that comics have seen
more widespread acceptance

00:07:53.816 --> 00:07:56.098
among American educators.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:56.098 --> 00:07:59.991
Comic books and graphic novels are now
finally making their way

00:07:59.991 --> 00:08:02.021
back into American classrooms,

00:08:02.021 --> 00:08:06.025
and this is even happening
at Bishop O'Dowd, where I used to teach.

00:08:06.025 --> 00:08:07.735
Mr. Smith, one of my former colleagues,

00:08:07.735 --> 00:08:10.647
uses Scott McCloud's
"Understanding Comics"

00:08:10.647 --> 00:08:14.503
in his literature and film class,
because that book gives his students

00:08:14.503 --> 00:08:19.739
the language with which to discuss
the relationship between words and images.

00:08:19.739 --> 00:08:23.423
Mr. Burns assigns a comics essay
to his students every year.

00:08:23.423 --> 00:08:27.661
By asking his students to process
a prose novel using images,

00:08:27.661 --> 00:08:30.125
Mr. Burns asks them to think deeply

00:08:30.125 --> 00:08:32.282
not just about the story

00:08:32.282 --> 00:08:35.390
but also about how that story is told.

00:08:35.390 --> 00:08:38.450
And Ms. Murrock uses my own
"American Born Chinese"

00:08:38.450 --> 00:08:40.338
with her English 1 students.

00:08:40.338 --> 00:08:43.870
For her, graphic novels
are a great way of fulfilling

00:08:43.870 --> 00:08:45.739
a Common Core Standard.

00:08:45.739 --> 00:08:48.750
The Standard states that students
ought to be able to analyze

00:08:48.750 --> 00:08:54.788
how visual elements contribute
to the meaning, tone and beauty of a text.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:54.788 --> 00:08:57.984
Over in the library, Mr. ??
has built a pretty impressive

00:08:57.984 --> 00:09:00.370
graphic novel collection
for Bishop O'Dowd.

00:09:00.370 --> 00:09:03.672
Now, Ms. ?? and all
of her librarian colleagues

00:09:03.672 --> 00:09:06.697
have really been at the forefront
of comics advocacy,

00:09:06.697 --> 00:09:09.846
really since the early '80s,
when a school library journal article

00:09:09.846 --> 00:09:14.594
stated that the mere presence
of graphic novels in the library

00:09:14.594 --> 00:09:17.339
increased usage by about 80 percent,

00:09:17.339 --> 00:09:21.070
and increased the circulation
of non-comics material

00:09:21.070 --> 00:09:23.094
by about 30 percent.

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:23.094 --> 00:09:26.612
Inspired by this renewed interest
from American educators,

00:09:26.612 --> 00:09:31.417
American cartoonists are now producing
more explicitly educational content

00:09:31.417 --> 00:09:34.562
for the K-12 market than ever before.

00:09:34.562 --> 00:09:37.561
A lot of this is directed
at language arts,

00:09:37.561 --> 00:09:39.784
but more and more comics
and graphic novels

00:09:39.784 --> 00:09:43.378
are starting to tackle
math and science topics.

00:09:43.378 --> 00:09:47.823
STEM comics graphics novels
really are like this uncharted territory,

00:09:47.823 --> 00:09:49.842
ready to be explored.

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:49.842 --> 00:09:55.511
America is finally waking up to the fact
that comic books do not cause

00:09:55.511 --> 00:09:57.586
juvenile delinquency,

00:09:57.586 --> 00:10:01.848
that they really do belong
in every educator's toolkit.

00:10:01.848 --> 00:10:05.475
There's no good reason to keep
comic books and graphic novels

00:10:05.475 --> 00:10:07.281
out of K-12 education.

00:10:07.281 --> 00:10:09.009
They teach visually,

00:10:09.009 --> 00:10:12.567
they give our students
that remote control.

00:10:12.567 --> 00:10:15.244
The educational potential is there

00:10:15.244 --> 00:10:17.890
just waiting to be tapped

00:10:17.890 --> 00:10:19.537
by creative people like you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:19.537 --> 00:10:21.150
Thank you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:21.150 --> 00:10:23.753
(Applause)