0:00:00.190,0:00:05.670
When it comes to dietary-centered discussions[br]between non-vegans and vegans, things can

0:00:05.670,0:00:11.690
easily become heated. From academic one-upmanship[br]of the most recent research to the far more

0:00:11.690,0:00:16.990
informal frenzied exchange of sardonic memes[br]and crafty YouTube comments,

0:00:16.990,0:00:20.050
it's safe to say: “words are had.”

0:00:20.500,0:00:24.960
Well, one team of international scientists[br]decided to analyze the arguments from

0:00:24.960,0:00:29.900
the meat-eating camp by bringing out the big guns: [br]the N-Words.

0:00:34.999,0:00:40.480
Hi it's Emily from Bite Size Vegan and welcome[br]to another vegan nugget. Humans have a wide

0:00:40.480,0:00:46.199
array of reasons for eating animals. From[br]taste to tradition to nutrition, to the absurd

0:00:46.199,0:00:52.449
assertion that animals want to be eaten—yes[br]that’s a thing and it’s far more common

0:00:52.449,0:00:53.289
than you may think.

0:00:53.900,0:00:59.340
But what’s behind this need to justify,[br]explain and rationalize the consumption of animals?

0:00:59.840,0:01:05.780
Why do omnivores often offer up unbidden[br]impassioned defenses of their dietary practices

0:01:05.790,0:01:11.080
upon learning someone is vegan—whether they[br]be passive apologies for consuming meat in

0:01:11.080,0:01:13.970
their presence or outright attacks and challenges?

0:01:14.260,0:01:20.380
Well, nothing provokes our knee-jerk defenses[br]or highlights our human capacity for award-worthy

0:01:20.380,0:01:25.560
rationalizations, and impassioned justifications,[br]quite like the perceived judgment

0:01:25.560,0:01:28.240
of behaviors we’re already insecure about.

0:01:28.550,0:01:34.340
Despite the seemingly endless iterations of[br]meat-eating defenses, a similar refrain has

0:01:34.340,0:01:39.820
been coursing through them for thousands of[br]years. (Yes, thousands).

0:01:40.540,0:01:46.240
In 2015, an international team of researchers[br]produced the first empirical systematic study

0:01:46.240,0:01:51.930
of meat-consumption rationalizations, more[br]or less corralling the multitudes of justifications

0:01:51.930,0:01:57.060
into four main categories, denoted by what[br]they call the 4N’s:

0:01:57.060,0:02:01.520
that it’s Natural, Normal, Necessary, and Nice.

0:02:01.530,0:02:05.910
Building off of the 3N’s presented in Dr.[br]Melanie Joy’s landmark text

0:02:05.910,0:02:12.240
Why We Love Dogs, Eat Pigs and Wear Cows, the team added the 4th N of “Nice” to capture “the

0:02:12.240,0:02:16.980
enjoyment people derive from eating meat,”[br]which they said “is a major barrier to reducing

0:02:16.980,0:02:22.350
meat consumption and/or adopting a vegetarian[br]diet,” as they found that, “meat-eaters…often

0:02:22.350,0:02:27.760
appeal to the tastiness of meat, or the hedonic[br]pleasure that they derive from it, as a justification

0:02:27.760,0:02:33.440
for its continued consumption,” a rationale[br]not encompassed within Joy’s original 3 strata.

0:02:33.450,0:02:38.340
In this video, I’ll be presenting an overview[br]of this particular study, the drive behind

0:02:38.340,0:02:42.530
the human need for rationalization, as well[br]as touch upon the broader implications of

0:02:42.530,0:02:47.110
the 4Ns—which reach far beyond the realm[br]of dietary dissonance into

0:02:47.110,0:02:50.880
“Many historical practices, from slavery to sexism.”

0:02:50.880,0:02:56.640
Perhaps most controversially, the study strove[br]to address the question: are omnivores inherently

0:02:56.640,0:03:01.050
more tolerant of social inequality within[br]their own species?

0:03:01.050,0:03:05.990
Let’s start with a quick look at the 4N’s[br]as defined within the study’s parameters,

0:03:05.990,0:03:11.910
again with the first 3 taking inspiration[br]from Dr. Joy’s Three N’s of Justification.”

0:03:11.910,0:03:14.990
N #1: Eating Meat Is Natural

0:03:14.990,0:03:21.090
Our first N “Appeals to biology, biological[br]hierarchy, natural selection, human evolution,

0:03:21.090,0:03:23.490
or the naturalness of eating meat.”

0:03:23.490,0:03:27.700
Examples include: It is natural for humans[br]to eat meat; Humans are carnivores; We’ve

0:03:27.709,0:03:32.040
always eaten meat and/or have evolved to do[br]so; We have canine teeth; Animals eat other

0:03:32.040,0:03:34.780
animals; Animals are here for us to eat; et[br]cetera

0:03:34.780,0:03:37.870
N #2: Eating Meat Is Necessary

0:03:37.870,0:03:43.560
The 2nd N “Appeals to the necessity of meat[br]for survival, strength, development, health,

0:03:43.560,0:03:46.459
animal population control, or economic stability.”

0:03:46.459,0:03:51.310
Examples include: Humans need meat to survive;[br]Meat provides good nutrients; Our bodies need

0:03:51.310,0:03:55.569
the protein; Protein is a necessary part of[br]our diet; and, one of my personal favorites:

0:03:55.569,0:03:59.689
Because if we didn’t, there would be an[br]overabundance of certain animals.

0:04:01.700,0:04:06.760
I made a video about that. A while ago. I dance in[br]it.

0:04:06.760,0:04:09.940
N #3: Eating Meat Is Normal

0:04:09.940,0:04:14.240
The 3rd N “Appeals to dominant [br]societal norms, normative behavior,

0:04:14.240,0:04:18.460
historical human behavior, or socially constructed food pyramids.”

0:04:18.470,0:04:22.720
Examples include: Society says it’s okay;[br]I was raised eating meat; Meat is culturally

0:04:22.720,0:04:25.760
accepted or an important part of tradition;[br]A lot of other people eat meat;

0:04:25.760,0:04:28.740
It’s abnormal NOT to eat meat; et cetera

0:04:28.740,0:04:34.060
And finally the additional N #4: Eating Meat[br]Is Nice

0:04:34.060,0:04:38.320
This new N was introduced to capture “Appeals[br]to the tastiness of meat,

0:04:38.320,0:04:41.080
or that it is fulfilling or satisfying.”

0:04:41.090,0:04:46.250
Examples include: It tastes good; It’s delicious;[br]Tastes great (I mean bacon...come on)

0:04:47.320,0:04:52.760
[yes, that’s actually in the official study. Table1];

0:04:54.100,0:04:58.160
Meat adds so much flavor to a meal it does not make sense to leave it out”, “The best tasting food

0:04:58.160,0:05:02.500
is normally a meat-based dish; Meals without meat would just be bland and boring; et cetera

0:05:02.900,0:05:06.840
It’s important to note that a number of[br]objections and diversion tactics fall a bit

0:05:06.840,0:05:12.840
outside the realm of the 4Ns. In the first[br]two studies, wherein respondents offered spontaneous

0:05:12.840,0:05:18.900
justifications, categories of Humane Slaughter,[br]Religion, Sustainability, Various Miscellany

0:05:18.910,0:05:22.930
and the outright rejection of the study’s[br]premise were recorded.

0:05:22.930,0:05:27.530
While they subsequently included concepts[br]of religion, hierarchy and fate within the

0:05:27.530,0:05:31.980
“Natural” category and health arguments[br]within the “Necessary,” at the study’s

0:05:31.990,0:05:36.790
outset, the team clarified that while “there[br]are numerous strategies available to omnivores

0:05:36.790,0:05:42.380
to bring their beliefs and behavior in line,[br]including denying that animals used as food

0:05:42.380,0:05:47.270
suffer or that such animals are worthy of[br]moral concern,” their goal was to focus

0:05:47.270,0:05:51.740
on the “common, yet under-studied mechanism[br][of] rationalization.”

0:05:51.740,0:05:56.780
Unlike straight up denials of animal sentience,[br]willful ignorance or passive avoidance of what

0:05:56.780,0:06:02.100
we do to animals—essentially the “I don’t[br]see it so it doesn’t happen” mentality—“

0:06:02.100,0:06:06.940
rationalization involves providing reasonable[br]justifications for one’s behavior when it

0:06:06.949,0:06:12.130
comes under scrutiny or criticism, or when[br]one’s behavior is perceived as discrepant

0:06:12.130,0:06:14.900
with an integral aspect of one’s character.”

0:06:14.900,0:06:19.830
So what were the results? To go in depth,[br]please see the blog post for this video linked

0:06:19.830,0:06:23.580
in the description, but some of the main[br]findings were as follows:

0:06:23.580,0:06:29.850
Overall, as expected, “omnivores had the[br]highest 4N scores, followed by semi-vegetarians.”

0:06:29.850,0:06:33.570
(meaning people who only eat some animals…apparently).

0:06:33.820,0:06:38.759
“Vegetarians and dietary and lifestyle vegans had the lowest 4N scores.”

0:06:38.759,0:06:42.440
Men endorsed the 4Ns more strongly than did[br]women.

0:06:42.440,0:06:47.750
Men also engaged in more direct justification[br]strategies, while women tended towards “indirect

0:06:47.750,0:06:51.830
strategies of dissociating or avoiding thoughts[br]of animal suffering.”

0:06:51.830,0:06:56.289
In regards to whether “individuals…who[br]consume higher quantities of meat…tend to

0:06:56.289,0:07:02.820
be more supportive of inequality in group[br]relationships” and “endorse anti-egalitarian values,"

0:07:02.820,0:07:08.160
they found, as did previous research,[br]that “meat justification appears to be related

0:07:08.169,0:07:10.460
to inequality justification.”

0:07:10.460,0:07:16.280
The researchers invoked Dr. Joy’s examples[br]of the 3Ns employment across others issues,

0:07:16.280,0:07:21.850
from slavery to women’s suffrage. “Opponents[br]of women’s suffrage… appealed to the necessity

0:07:21.850,0:07:28.110
of denying women the vote to prevent ‘irreparable[br]damage’ to the nation, to the natural superiority

0:07:28.110,0:07:33.730
of male intelligence, and to the historical[br]normalness of male-only voting as

0:07:33.730,0:07:35.750
“designed by our forefathers.”

0:07:36.260,0:07:40.960
In the end, it’s the reasons behind the[br]rationalizations, the very need for them at

0:07:40.970,0:07:45.699
all that are the most profound aspect of this[br]entire issue. It’s something I’ve gone

0:07:45.699,0:07:50.460
into in depth in many of my videos, including[br]this revealing speech, along with others I’ve

0:07:50.460,0:07:52.160
listed in the video description below.

0:07:52.880,0:07:57.840
Living in a state of cognitive dissonance[br]wherein our actions directly conflict with

0:07:57.850,0:08:03.330
our own professed morals and values, causes[br]extreme dis-ease within us.

0:08:03.330,0:08:10.270
Eating animals is, in essence, living a double life. Attempting to be animal lovers and animal killers.

0:08:10.720,0:08:15.919
To see ourselves as good people while we pay[br]others to carry out barbaric acts of cruelty

0:08:15.919,0:08:19.139
we would never directly inflict upon another being.

0:08:19.620,0:08:23.260
This is what the study’s creators termed[br]the “meat paradox.”

0:08:23.260,0:08:28.600
Omnivores are left with the choice of either changing their behaviors to align with their values by ceasing

0:08:28.600,0:08:34.120
to eat animals and their byproducts, or manipulating[br]their perception of reality in such a way

0:08:34.120,0:08:38.140
that it at least appears that their behaviors[br]align with their values.

0:08:38.140,0:08:43.580
Not surprisingly, the majority of the world[br]chooses the latter. Because changing our behavior

0:08:43.589,0:08:48.399
when it comes to eating animals means confronting[br]head-on our complicity in their enslavement,

0:08:48.399,0:08:54.510
torture, and murder. It means facing the horrors[br]we’ve supported and vehemently defended.

0:08:54.510,0:08:58.110
It means looking ourselves in the mirror with[br]outright honesty.

0:08:58.760,0:09:03.820
And brining up protein, desert islands, canines,[br]traditions, the wisdom of the masses, and all

0:09:03.830,0:09:10.790
the litany of rationalizations, justifications and[br]avoidances, is by far an easier and safer choice.

0:09:11.640,0:09:16.800
There is bliss in ignorance. [br]For the ignorant.

0:09:18.040,0:09:22.760
I hope that this video was helpful, and perhaps[br]even prompts the slightest moment of reflection

0:09:22.760,0:09:26.920
at the aspects of our behavior we strive so[br]ardently to justify.

0:09:27.140,0:09:30.700
Please share it around to spark discussion[br]and I’d love to hear your thoughts in the

0:09:30.700,0:09:34.850
comments below. Do give the video a like if[br]you liked it and subscribe for more vegan

0:09:34.850,0:09:39.750
content every Monday, Wednesday and some Fridays.[br]To support messages like this, see the support

0:09:39.750,0:09:44.350
links below or join us in the Nugget Army[br]on Patreon via the link in the sidebar.

0:09:44.350,0:09:48.510
Now go live vegan, own up to your actions,[br]and I’ll see you soon.

0:09:49.120,0:09:54.220
There's a stink bug that keeps flying. He's haning out on the light right now.

0:09:55.400,0:09:56.600
Whoop! There he goes!

0:09:57.000,0:09:57.540
Ahh!

0:09:57.960,0:09:59.960
Dude, you're freaking me out!

0:10:01.280,0:10:04.900
You're making me feel very unvegan. When you fly at me and it scares me

0:10:04.920,0:10:08.900
because I'm supposed to love all creatures and you're scaring me a little bit, when you do that.

0:10:09.280,0:10:12.320
Alright little dude, I'm taking you outside.