WEBVTT

00:00:00.157 --> 00:00:05.875
(intro music)

00:00:07.060 --> 00:00:09.316
Hi, my name is Monte Johnson.

00:00:09.651 --> 00:00:13.136
I'm a professor at the University
of California, San Diego,

00:00:13.394 --> 00:00:16.248
and today I want to talk about
the purpose of human life,

00:00:16.494 --> 00:00:18.430
Aristotle's Ergon Argument.

00:00:19.249 --> 00:00:21.495
The word "ergon" in Greek means

00:00:21.613 --> 00:00:25.337
"work," or "job," or
"product," or "function."

00:00:25.816 --> 00:00:28.916
The term is most clearly used
in the context of artifacts

00:00:28.916 --> 00:00:29.726
or skills.

00:00:30.521 --> 00:00:32.420
So the ergon of a saw is to cut.

00:00:32.746 --> 00:00:34.745
The ergon of a house is
to protect against weather

00:00:34.745 --> 00:00:35.961
and intruders.

00:00:36.218 --> 00:00:38.561
And the argon of an
architect is to build houses.

00:00:39.457 --> 00:00:41.045
A connected term is "arete,"

00:00:41.338 --> 00:00:43.356
which means "excellence" or "virtue."

00:00:44.123 --> 00:00:45.724
The excellence of a saw is sharpness,

00:00:45.865 --> 00:00:47.361
since its function is to cut.

00:00:47.525 --> 00:00:50.020
The excellence of a house
is stability and security,

00:00:50.022 --> 00:00:52.098
since its function is protection.

00:00:52.320 --> 00:00:53.179
And the excellence

00:00:53.379 --> 00:00:55.999
of an architect is the
building of good houses.

00:00:57.544 --> 00:01:00.282
Do human beings have
an ergon, or a function?

00:01:01.155 --> 00:01:01.877
And if so,

00:01:01.877 --> 00:01:04.694
do they also have a corresponding
arete, or excellence?

00:01:05.561 --> 00:01:07.157
Aristotle argues that they do,

00:01:07.576 --> 00:01:09.597
And his argument can help
us think more clearly

00:01:09.597 --> 00:01:11.394
about the purpose of human life.

00:01:12.638 --> 00:01:15.597
But before we can discuss
the ergon argument itself

00:01:15.715 --> 00:01:17.839
we need to discuss some
background assumptions

00:01:17.839 --> 00:01:19.462
about the nature of life.

00:01:20.595 --> 00:01:24.536
Aristotle recognizes four
distinct classes of living things:

00:01:24.793 --> 00:01:27.996
plants, animals, humans, and Gods.

00:01:28.276 --> 00:01:30.120
And we'll set Gods
aside for a moment here.

00:01:31.471 --> 00:01:33.916
Aristotle defines living things by their

00:01:33.953 --> 00:01:34.961
capabilities.

00:01:35.601 --> 00:01:37.422
Plants have the ability to grow,

00:01:37.459 --> 00:01:39.442
use energy, and reproduce.

00:01:39.874 --> 00:01:42.381
When we talk about a
plant doing well or poorly,

00:01:42.381 --> 00:01:44.120
we refer to these capabilities.

00:01:44.941 --> 00:01:47.012
Thus, when a plant is growing properly,

00:01:47.316 --> 00:01:49.879
deepening its roots, throwing out leaves

00:01:49.893 --> 00:01:51.296
and flowers and shoots,

00:01:51.332 --> 00:01:52.654
and fructifying,

00:01:52.980 --> 00:01:54.593
we say that it is flourishing.

00:01:55.233 --> 00:01:58.342
The opposite happens when a
plant's capabilities are stymied,

00:01:58.878 --> 00:02:00.736
when a tree, for instance, is stunted,

00:02:00.736 --> 00:02:02.975
or leaves are withering
and dying on the vine.

00:02:03.940 --> 00:02:05.698
Botanists and gardeners know

00:02:05.698 --> 00:02:07.259
what is good or bad for plants,

00:02:07.272 --> 00:02:08.014
that is,

00:02:08.014 --> 00:02:09.118
what kinds of things help

00:02:09.118 --> 00:02:11.239
and what kinds of things
hurt the activities

00:02:11.239 --> 00:02:13.934
related to their capabilities.

00:02:14.795 --> 00:02:16.868
Notice that it is not a matter of opinion,

00:02:17.068 --> 00:02:18.673
but of scientific fact,

00:02:18.673 --> 00:02:21.074
what is good and bad for
plants in this respect.

00:02:21.714 --> 00:02:24.001
Different plants might require
different kinds of nutrients

00:02:24.001 --> 00:02:26.414
or different amounts of shade and water.

00:02:26.637 --> 00:02:29.120
But every plant is said
to do well or poorly

00:02:29.120 --> 00:02:30.375
on the objective basis

00:02:30.375 --> 00:02:34.216
of the activities related to
its specific capabilities.

00:02:35.619 --> 00:02:38.476
Animals, in a way, are like
superpowered plants.

00:02:39.101 --> 00:02:41.343
They too have the ability to grow,

00:02:41.497 --> 00:02:43.329
use nutrition, and reproduce.

00:02:43.679 --> 00:02:45.653
These things are just
as objectively important

00:02:45.653 --> 00:02:47.497
for animals as they are for plants,

00:02:47.650 --> 00:02:49.993
as veterinarians and
zoologists can tell you.

00:02:50.530 --> 00:02:53.673
But animals also have other
and higher capabilities.

00:02:54.012 --> 00:02:56.194
For example animals, unlike plants,

00:02:56.194 --> 00:02:58.514
can move themselves around in space.

00:02:59.073 --> 00:03:00.592
Animals that cannot do so,

00:03:00.594 --> 00:03:03.615
whether because of a birth
defect or because they're encaged,

00:03:03.830 --> 00:03:06.092
cannot be said to be doing well.

00:03:06.488 --> 00:03:08.067
This is why animal rights activists

00:03:08.067 --> 00:03:11.469
campaign for larger cages
or free ranges for animals,

00:03:11.669 --> 00:03:13.813
because it's obvious that
it is better for the animals

00:03:13.813 --> 00:03:14.708
if they are capable

00:03:14.708 --> 00:03:18.815
of exercising their capacity
for self-movement fully.

00:03:19.676 --> 00:03:20.826
Most importantly,

00:03:20.826 --> 00:03:23.413
animals have the capability of perception.

00:03:23.693 --> 00:03:24.632
They can feel

00:03:24.669 --> 00:03:29.125
hot and cold, smell, taste, hear, and see.

00:03:29.231 --> 00:03:30.785
And some of them can
do all of these things.

00:03:32.493 --> 00:03:34.850
Animals that are incapable of seeing,

00:03:34.850 --> 00:03:37.207
even though members of
their species are normally

00:03:37.207 --> 00:03:38.505
able to do so,

00:03:38.728 --> 00:03:40.630
are thought not to be doing as well

00:03:40.654 --> 00:03:42.254
as their relatives that can.

00:03:43.415 --> 00:03:44.711
With the ability to sense

00:03:44.711 --> 00:03:46.633
comes the ability to
feel pain and pleasure,

00:03:46.633 --> 00:03:48.385
and thus appetite and aversion.

00:03:49.072 --> 00:03:51.171
These capabilities are connected with

00:03:51.254 --> 00:03:53.794
an animal's capability for self-movement,

00:03:54.051 --> 00:03:55.306
since they pursue that which

00:03:55.597 --> 00:03:57.268
they have an appetite for

00:03:57.391 --> 00:03:58.324
and avoid things

00:03:58.324 --> 00:04:00.969
that might interfere with
their natural activities.

00:04:01.668 --> 00:04:03.850
Now an animal cannot do
well if it is deficient

00:04:04.019 --> 00:04:07.204
with respect to its plant-like
or vegetative capabilities.

00:04:07.345 --> 00:04:10.490
But even if it is fine with
respect to those capabilities,

00:04:10.490 --> 00:04:12.987
it cannot be said to
flourish if it is stymied

00:04:12.987 --> 00:04:15.690
with respect to
self-movement and sensation.

00:04:16.389 --> 00:04:17.142
For example,

00:04:17.142 --> 00:04:18.583
if an animal is in a lot of pain

00:04:18.583 --> 00:04:21.473
or is unable to satisfy
its desire for food

00:04:21.473 --> 00:04:23.793
because of injury to
its organs of movement,

00:04:24.225 --> 00:04:26.185
that animal will not be said to do well.

00:04:26.909 --> 00:04:28.346
For an animal to flourish,

00:04:28.346 --> 00:04:29.902
it needs to be able to move around

00:04:29.902 --> 00:04:31.631
and to sense the world in such a way

00:04:31.631 --> 00:04:33.186
that produces, for it, pleasure

00:04:33.942 --> 00:04:35.867
or at least more pleasure than pain.

00:04:37.065 --> 00:04:38.445
Now let's move on to humans.

00:04:39.131 --> 00:04:41.161
It's often pointed out
that humans are animals,

00:04:41.685 --> 00:04:43.402
animals with superpowers.

00:04:43.647 --> 00:04:46.109
But it is less often pointed out that

00:04:46.109 --> 00:04:47.709
we are plants too.

00:04:48.070 --> 00:04:50.311
That is, we, like other animals,

00:04:50.311 --> 00:04:52.491
have the capabilities of plants:

00:04:52.703 --> 00:04:54.511
growth, nutrition, and reproduction.

00:04:55.071 --> 00:04:57.103
And we need to exercise these capabilities

00:04:57.103 --> 00:04:58.250
if we are to live.

00:04:58.844 --> 00:05:00.109
And like the other animals,

00:05:00.109 --> 00:05:03.207
we have the capabilities for
self-movement and sensation.

00:05:03.465 --> 00:05:04.961
And with these, pleasure and pain,

00:05:05.020 --> 00:05:06.469
appetite and aversion.

00:05:07.065 --> 00:05:09.708
All life is deeply connected in this way.

00:05:10.451 --> 00:05:12.404
But humans also have unique capabilities

00:05:12.404 --> 00:05:13.969
that no other animals have,

00:05:14.110 --> 00:05:16.721
most importantly the ability
to reason and to use language.

00:05:17.663 --> 00:05:20.461
These capabilities allow
us to cultivate friendships

00:05:20.461 --> 00:05:21.866
and social relations,

00:05:22.542 --> 00:05:24.801
build and contribute to
political structures,

00:05:25.033 --> 00:05:26.322
plan for the future,

00:05:26.626 --> 00:05:28.829
modify our appetites and desires,

00:05:29.180 --> 00:05:30.607
educate our young,

00:05:30.791 --> 00:05:32.706
develop music and mathematics,

00:05:32.883 --> 00:05:34.984
and even to contemplate
the nature of the universe

00:05:34.984 --> 00:05:36.747
and the purpose of human life.

00:05:37.620 --> 00:05:39.812
If a human does not
have these capabilities,

00:05:39.874 --> 00:05:43.039
they are missing out on part
of what it is to be human.

00:05:43.586 --> 00:05:46.208
And if they also lack even
the animal capabilities

00:05:46.268 --> 00:05:48.484
we might consider them
less than animal,

00:05:48.567 --> 00:05:50.284
at least while they're in what we,

00:05:50.308 --> 00:05:51.446
for these very reasons,

00:05:51.614 --> 00:05:54.626
call a "persistent vegetative state."

00:05:55.463 --> 00:05:57.959
Thus, we can determine what is good for us

00:05:57.959 --> 00:06:00.142
in a parallel fashion to how we determine

00:06:00.142 --> 00:06:01.744
what is good with respect to the

00:06:01.744 --> 00:06:03.367
other kinds of living things.

00:06:04.464 --> 00:06:06.817
Those things that allow us
to engage in the activities

00:06:06.817 --> 00:06:09.300
that exercise our capacities are good,

00:06:09.545 --> 00:06:11.668
and those that impede
or prevent this are bad.

00:06:12.892 --> 00:06:15.199
Now that we have that background in place,

00:06:15.368 --> 00:06:17.486
we should be in a good position to answer

00:06:17.486 --> 00:06:19.070
"What, for Aristotle,

00:06:19.070 --> 00:06:21.304
"is the ergon of a human being?"

00:06:22.176 --> 00:06:23.732
It would be odd if the
purpose of human life

00:06:23.732 --> 00:06:27.178
was related to our lowest
vegetative capabilities,

00:06:27.435 --> 00:06:29.732
unless we aspire to being a good plant.

00:06:30.895 --> 00:06:34.028
Thus, the exercise of our
capabilities for reproduction,

00:06:34.134 --> 00:06:37.012
growth and stature, and even nutrition,

00:06:37.153 --> 00:06:38.636
however important for us,

00:06:38.788 --> 00:06:41.016
cannot be the ultimate purpose of our life

00:06:41.245 --> 00:06:43.571
any more than it could
be for a brute animal.

00:06:44.351 --> 00:06:46.556
Similarly, mere sensation, pleasure,

00:06:46.591 --> 00:06:49.051
and satisfaction of our bodily appetites

00:06:49.091 --> 00:06:52.487
cannot, as they are for brute animals,

00:06:52.651 --> 00:06:54.077
be the purpose of our life.

00:06:55.113 --> 00:06:57.189
What makes cows and pigs flourish

00:06:57.236 --> 00:06:59.129
can no more make a human flourish

00:06:59.129 --> 00:07:01.589
than what makes oaks and vine flourish

00:07:01.753 --> 00:07:03.573
can do so for cows and pigs.

00:07:04.214 --> 00:07:06.128
Even if those lower
vegetative capabilities

00:07:06.343 --> 00:07:08.115
must be in a satisfactory condition

00:07:08.115 --> 00:07:10.737
in order for the higher
ones to do their work.

00:07:11.922 --> 00:07:13.920
Thus, by a process of elimination,

00:07:13.920 --> 00:07:16.762
we arrive at the capabilities
to use reason and language.

00:07:17.376 --> 00:07:19.595
These are the capabilities that define us,

00:07:19.784 --> 00:07:22.915
which is why Aristotle
defined the human being

00:07:22.917 --> 00:07:25.074
as a rational animal,

00:07:25.239 --> 00:07:27.640
which is reflected in the
modern name for our species,

00:07:27.876 --> 00:07:29.276
"Homo sapiens."

00:07:29.836 --> 00:07:32.737
Thus, the forming of friendships
and social relations,

00:07:32.958 --> 00:07:35.301
the controlling of our
appetites and emotions,

00:07:35.595 --> 00:07:38.298
the cultivation of moral
and intellectual virtues,

00:07:38.334 --> 00:07:40.122
and the observing of the cosmos

00:07:40.122 --> 00:07:41.119
and our place in it

00:07:41.201 --> 00:07:42.756
are the activities that,

00:07:42.955 --> 00:07:44.919
because they correspond with our highest

00:07:44.919 --> 00:07:46.741
and most unique capabilities,

00:07:46.973 --> 00:07:48.514
give meaning to human life

00:07:48.515 --> 00:07:51.218
and represent the flourishing
of our kind of living thing.

00:07:51.778 --> 00:07:53.520
The things that are good for us

00:07:53.520 --> 00:07:54.516
follow from this,

00:07:54.691 --> 00:07:55.701
and thus can be determined

00:07:55.701 --> 00:07:58.081
with the same degree of
objectivity that gardeners

00:07:58.081 --> 00:08:00.298
and botanists can for plants,

00:08:00.752 --> 00:08:03.537
and veterinarians and
zoologists can for animals.

00:08:04.199 --> 00:08:06.778
These arts and sciences
can objectively determine

00:08:06.778 --> 00:08:09.273
what is good and bad for
those kind of living things,

00:08:09.551 --> 00:08:12.070
and so anthropology and
philosophy can determine

00:08:12.070 --> 00:08:14.936
what is good and bad for
our kind of living thing.

00:08:15.970 --> 00:08:16.713
In fact,

00:08:16.818 --> 00:08:18.292
the very highest activity,

00:08:18.659 --> 00:08:20.916
the one that Aristotle calls godlike,

00:08:21.125 --> 00:08:22.472
is philosophy,

00:08:22.739 --> 00:08:24.273
because this involves

00:08:24.273 --> 00:08:26.615
the pure exercise of reason and thought,

00:08:27.396 --> 00:08:29.506
just as the Gods constantly engage in,

00:08:29.521 --> 00:08:30.585
according to Aristotle.

00:08:31.063 --> 00:08:33.443
And philosophy engages
in reason and thought

00:08:33.443 --> 00:08:36.820
not only in order to serve our
vegetative and animal needs,

00:08:36.995 --> 00:08:39.119
but just for its own sake as well,

00:08:39.538 --> 00:08:41.184
for the sake of living a human life.

00:08:41.779 --> 00:08:44.456
For this reason, Aristotle
thought that doing philosophy

00:08:44.564 --> 00:08:46.955
was the ultimate end of human existence.

00:08:47.810 --> 00:08:48.780
In conclusion,

00:08:49.010 --> 00:08:51.064
you should be happy that
you're watching this video,

00:08:51.242 --> 00:08:53.404
because I have just shown
how you are now engaging

00:08:53.450 --> 00:08:55.198
in the exercise of your highest

00:08:55.234 --> 00:08:57.056
and most godlike capabilities.

00:08:57.594 --> 00:08:58.541
Good work.