1
00:00:01,096 --> 00:00:05,927
In the months following
the 2009 presidential election in Iran,

2
00:00:05,927 --> 00:00:08,821
protests erupted across the country.

3
00:00:09,757 --> 00:00:12,755
The Iranian government
violently suppressed

4
00:00:12,755 --> 00:00:16,164
what came to be known
as the Iranian Green Moevement.

5
00:00:16,676 --> 00:00:18,856
Even blocking mobile signals

6
00:00:18,856 --> 00:00:21,798
to cut off communication
between the protesters.

7
00:00:22,404 --> 00:00:27,009
My parents, who emigrated
to the United States in the late 1960s,

8
00:00:27,009 --> 00:00:28,964
spend substantial time there,

9
00:00:28,964 --> 00:00:31,897
where all of my large,
extended family live.

10
00:00:32,865 --> 00:00:36,139
When I would call my family in Tehran

11
00:00:36,139 --> 00:00:39,644
during some of the most violent
crackdowns of the protest,

12
00:00:39,644 --> 00:00:42,686
none of them dared discuss
with me what was happening.

13
00:00:43,334 --> 00:00:46,763
They or I knew to quickly steer
the conversation to other topics.

14
00:00:47,211 --> 00:00:50,663
All of us understood what
the consequences could be

15
00:00:50,663 --> 00:00:53,143
of a perceived dissident action.

16
00:00:54,215 --> 00:00:57,707
But I still wish I could have known
what they were thinking

17
00:00:57,707 --> 00:00:59,325
or what they were feeling.

18
00:01:00,249 --> 00:01:01,642
What if I could have?

19
00:01:02,149 --> 00:01:03,411
Or more frighteningly,

20
00:01:03,411 --> 00:01:06,428
what if the Iranian
government could have?

21
00:01:06,870 --> 00:01:10,114
Would they have arrested them
based on what their brains revealed?

22
00:01:11,037 --> 00:01:14,175
That day may be closer than you think.

23
00:01:14,662 --> 00:01:18,496
With our growing capabilities
in neuroscience, artificial intelligence

24
00:01:18,496 --> 00:01:20,222
and machine learning,

25
00:01:20,222 --> 00:01:22,784
we may soon know a lot more

26
00:01:22,784 --> 00:01:24,614
of what's happening
in the human brain.

27
00:01:25,083 --> 00:01:28,489
As a bioethicist, a lawyer,
a philosopher

28
00:01:28,489 --> 00:01:30,379
and an Iranian-American,

29
00:01:30,379 --> 00:01:34,189
I'm deeply concerned about what
this means for our freedoms

30
00:01:34,189 --> 00:01:36,360
and what kinds of protections we need.

31
00:01:37,081 --> 00:01:40,517
I believe we need
a right to cognitive liberty

32
00:01:40,517 --> 00:01:43,409
as a human right
that needs to be protected.

33
00:01:43,772 --> 00:01:46,547
If not, our freedom of thought,

34
00:01:46,547 --> 00:01:49,487
access and control over our own brains

35
00:01:49,487 --> 00:01:52,597
and our mental privacy will be threatened.

36
00:01:53,698 --> 00:01:54,701
Consider this.

37
00:01:54,701 --> 00:01:58,194
The average person thinks
thousands of thoughts each day.

38
00:01:58,784 --> 00:01:59,969
As a thought takes form,

39
00:01:59,969 --> 00:02:03,702
like a math calculation or a number,

40
00:02:03,702 --> 00:02:05,080
a word,

41
00:02:05,080 --> 00:02:07,949
neurons are interacting in the brain,

42
00:02:07,949 --> 00:02:11,217
creating [a] miniscule
electrical discharge.

43
00:02:11,888 --> 00:02:15,293
When you have a dominant
mental state like relaxation,

44
00:02:15,293 --> 00:02:19,534
hundreds and thousands of neurons
are firing in the brain,

45
00:02:19,534 --> 00:02:23,775
creating concurrent electrical discharges
in characteristic patterns

46
00:02:23,775 --> 00:02:27,386
that can measured with
electroencephalography,

47
00:02:27,386 --> 00:02:28,530
or EEG.

48
00:02:29,230 --> 00:02:31,390
In fact, that's what
you're seeing right now.

49
00:02:32,075 --> 00:02:36,178
You're seeing my brain activity
that was recorded in real time

50
00:02:36,178 --> 00:02:38,913
with a simple device
that was worn on my head.

51
00:02:39,804 --> 00:02:45,457
What you're seeing is my brain activity
when I was relaxed and curious.

52
00:02:46,225 --> 00:02:47,903
To share this information with you,

53
00:02:47,903 --> 00:02:51,013
I wore one of the early
consumer-based EEG devices

54
00:02:51,013 --> 00:02:52,247
like this one,

55
00:02:52,247 --> 00:02:56,235
which recorded the electrical
activity in my brain in real time.

56
00:02:56,993 --> 00:03:00,780
It's not unlike the fitness trackers
that some of you may be wearing

57
00:03:00,780 --> 00:03:04,309
to measure your heart rate
or the steps that you've taken

58
00:03:04,309 --> 00:03:06,058
or even your sleep activity.

59
00:03:07,154 --> 00:03:10,978
It's hardly the most sophisticated
neuroimaging technique on the market.

60
00:03:11,740 --> 00:03:14,103
But it's already the most portable

61
00:03:14,103 --> 00:03:17,255
and the most likely to impact
our everyday lives.

62
00:03:18,019 --> 00:03:19,264
This is extraordinary.

63
00:03:19,482 --> 00:03:21,971
Through a simple, wearable device,

64
00:03:21,971 --> 00:03:25,616
we can literally see
inside the human brain

65
00:03:25,616 --> 00:03:29,229
and learn aspects of our mental landscape

66
00:03:29,229 --> 00:03:32,279
without ever uttering a word.

67
00:03:32,829 --> 00:03:36,601
While we can't reliably decode
complex thoughts just yet,

68
00:03:36,601 --> 00:03:39,143
we can already gage a person's mood,

69
00:03:39,143 --> 00:03:42,039
and with the help
of artificial intelligence,

70
00:03:42,039 --> 00:03:46,530
we can even decode
some single-digit numbers

71
00:03:46,530 --> 00:03:51,217
or shapes or simple words
that a person is thinking

72
00:03:51,217 --> 00:03:53,768
or hearing, or seeing.

73
00:03:54,306 --> 00:03:57,806
Despite some inherent limitations in EEG,

74
00:03:57,806 --> 00:04:02,502
I think it's safe to say that with
our advances in technology,

75
00:04:02,502 --> 00:04:06,274
more and more of what's happening
in the human brain

76
00:04:06,274 --> 00:04:08,873
can and will be decoded over time.

77
00:04:09,442 --> 00:04:13,909
Already, using one of these devices,
an epileptic can know

78
00:04:13,909 --> 00:04:16,785
they're going to have an epileptic
seizure before it happens.

79
00:04:16,911 --> 00:04:21,712
A paraplegic can type on a computer
with their thoughts alone.

80
00:04:22,613 --> 00:04:26,761
A US-based company has developed
a technology to embed these censors

81
00:04:26,761 --> 00:04:29,088
into the headrest of automobilies

82
00:04:29,088 --> 00:04:31,579
so they can track driver concentration,

83
00:04:31,579 --> 00:04:32,582
distraction

84
00:04:32,582 --> 00:04:34,579
and cognitive load while driving.

85
00:04:34,937 --> 00:04:38,995
Nissan, insurance companies
and AAA have all taken note.

86
00:04:40,147 --> 00:04:44,600
You could even watch this
choose-your-own-adventure movie,

87
00:04:44,600 --> 00:04:46,053
"The Moment,"

88
00:04:46,053 --> 00:04:48,745
which, with an EEG headset,

89
00:04:48,745 --> 00:04:52,838
changes the movie based
on your brain-based reactions,

90
00:04:52,838 --> 00:04:57,191
giving you a different ending
every time your attention wanes.

91
00:04:59,226 --> 00:05:02,005
This may all sound great,

92
00:05:02,005 --> 00:05:04,154
and as a bioethicist,

93
00:05:04,154 --> 00:05:07,985
I am a huge proponent of empowering people

94
00:05:07,985 --> 00:05:10,535
to take charge of their own
health and wellbeing

95
00:05:10,535 --> 00:05:13,476
by giving them access
to information about themselves,

96
00:05:13,476 --> 00:05:16,452
including this incredible,
new, brain-decoding technology.

97
00:05:18,014 --> 00:05:19,181
But I worry.

98
00:05:19,760 --> 00:05:24,695
I worry that we will voluntarily
or involuntarily give up

99
00:05:24,695 --> 00:05:27,552
our last bastion of freedom,

100
00:05:27,552 --> 00:05:29,006
our mental privacy.

101
00:05:29,374 --> 00:05:32,384
That we will trade our brain activity

102
00:05:32,384 --> 00:05:36,534
for rebates or discounts on insurance,

103
00:05:36,534 --> 00:05:40,508
or free access to social
media accounts ...

104
00:05:40,508 --> 00:05:42,356
or even to keep our jobs.

105
00:05:43,060 --> 00:05:46,469
In fact, in China,

106
00:05:46,469 --> 00:05:52,299
the train drivers on
the Beijing-Shanghai high-speed rail,

107
00:05:52,299 --> 00:05:54,724
the busiest of its kind in the world,

108
00:05:54,724 --> 00:05:57,407
are required to wear EEG devices

109
00:05:57,407 --> 00:05:59,834
to monitor their brain
activity while driving.

110
00:06:00,189 --> 00:06:02,506
According to some news sources,

111
00:06:02,506 --> 00:06:05,206
in government-run factories in China,

112
00:06:05,206 --> 00:06:10,577
the workers are required to wear
EEG censors to monitor their productivity

113
00:06:10,577 --> 00:06:12,692
and their emotional state at work.

114
00:06:13,482 --> 00:06:15,752
Workers are even sent home

115
00:06:15,752 --> 00:06:19,806
if their brains show less-than-stellar
concentration on their jobs,

116
00:06:19,806 --> 00:06:21,928
or emotional agitation.

117
00:06:23,340 --> 00:06:25,085
It's not going to happen tomorrow,

118
00:06:25,085 --> 00:06:28,171
but we're headed to a world
of brain transparency.

119
00:06:28,641 --> 00:06:32,081
And I don't think people understand
that that could change everything.

120
00:06:32,498 --> 00:06:36,284
Everything from our definitions
of data privacy to our laws,

121
00:06:36,284 --> 00:06:38,084
to our ideas about freedom.

122
00:06:38,771 --> 00:06:41,832
In fact, in my lab at Duke University,

123
00:06:41,832 --> 00:06:43,898
we recently conducted a nationwide study

124
00:06:43,898 --> 00:06:45,134
in the United States

125
00:06:45,134 --> 00:06:47,173
to see if people appreciated

126
00:06:47,173 --> 00:06:49,244
the sensitivity of
their brain information.

127
00:06:50,412 --> 00:06:53,736
We asked people to rate
their perceived sensitivity

128
00:06:53,736 --> 00:06:56,151
of 33 different kinds of information,

129
00:06:56,151 --> 00:06:58,235
from their social security numbers

130
00:06:58,235 --> 00:07:00,984
to the content of their
phone conversations,

131
00:07:00,984 --> 00:07:03,200
their relationship history,

132
00:07:03,200 --> 00:07:05,249
their emotions, their anxiety,

133
00:07:05,249 --> 00:07:07,089
the mental images in their mind

134
00:07:07,089 --> 00:07:08,627
and the thoughts in their mind.

135
00:07:09,537 --> 00:07:14,789
Shockingly, people rated their social
security number as far more sensitive

136
00:07:14,789 --> 00:07:17,065
than any other kind of information,

137
00:07:17,065 --> 00:07:19,500
including their brain data.

138
00:07:20,523 --> 00:07:23,721
I think this is because
people don't yet understand

139
00:07:23,731 --> 00:07:28,043
or believe the implications
of this new brain-decoding technology.

140
00:07:28,693 --> 00:07:32,053
After all, if we can know the inner
workings of the human brain,

141
00:07:32,053 --> 00:07:34,782
our social security numbers
are the least of our worries.

142
00:07:34,782 --> 00:07:36,090
(Laughter)

143
00:07:36,090 --> 00:07:37,280
Think about it.

144
00:07:37,280 --> 00:07:39,783
In a world of total brain transparency,

145
00:07:39,783 --> 00:07:42,209
who would dare have
a politically dissident thought?

146
00:07:43,470 --> 00:07:45,011
Or a creative one?

147
00:07:45,575 --> 00:07:49,194
I worry that people will self-censor

148
00:07:49,194 --> 00:07:52,494
in fear of being ostracized by society,

149
00:07:52,494 --> 00:07:56,330
or that people will lose their jobs
because of their waning attention

150
00:07:56,330 --> 00:07:58,503
or emotional instability,

151
00:07:58,503 --> 00:08:02,053
or because they're contemplating
collective action against their employers.

152
00:08:02,677 --> 00:08:05,838
That coming out
will no longer be an option

153
00:08:05,838 --> 00:08:10,968
because people's brains will long ago
have revealed their sexual orientation,

154
00:08:10,968 --> 00:08:12,739
their political ideaology,

155
00:08:12,739 --> 00:08:14,729
or their religious preferences,

156
00:08:14,729 --> 00:08:17,746
well before they were ready
to conciously share that information

157
00:08:17,746 --> 00:08:18,999
with other people.

158
00:08:19,629 --> 00:08:24,541
I worry about the ability of our laws
to keep up with technological change.

159
00:08:24,986 --> 00:08:27,229
Take the First Amendment
of the US Constitution,

160
00:08:27,229 --> 00:08:28,930
which protects freedom of speech.

161
00:08:29,368 --> 00:08:31,540
Does it also protect freedom of thought?

162
00:08:32,174 --> 00:08:35,962
And if so, does that mean that we're free
to alter our thoughts however we want?

163
00:08:36,177 --> 00:08:40,851
Or can the government or society tell us
what we can do with our own brains?

164
00:08:41,750 --> 00:08:45,467
Can the NSA spy on our brains
using these new mobile devices?

165
00:08:46,157 --> 00:08:50,316
Can the companies that collect
the brain data through their applications

166
00:08:50,316 --> 00:08:52,390
sell this information to third parties?

167
00:08:53,214 --> 00:08:56,600
Right now, no laws prevent
them from doing so.

168
00:08:57,363 --> 00:08:59,348
It could be even more problematic

169
00:08:59,348 --> 00:09:01,906
in countries that don't share
the same freedoms

170
00:09:01,906 --> 00:09:04,009
enjoyed by people in the United States.

171
00:09:05,011 --> 00:09:08,787
What would've happened during
the Iranian Green Movement

172
00:09:08,787 --> 00:09:12,635
if the government had been
monitoring my family's brain activity,

173
00:09:12,635 --> 00:09:16,642
and had believed them to be
sympathetic to the protesters?

174
00:09:18,242 --> 00:09:21,273
Is it so far-fetched to imagine a society


175
00:09:21,273 --> 00:09:24,065
in which people are arrested
based on their thoughts

176
00:09:24,065 --> 00:09:25,343
of committing a crime?

177
00:09:25,343 --> 00:09:29,655
LIke in the science-fiction, dystopian
society in "Minority Report."

178
00:09:30,366 --> 00:09:33,432
Already, in the United States,

179
00:09:33,432 --> 00:09:34,832
in Indiana,

180
00:09:34,832 --> 00:09:39,735
an 18-year-old was charged
with attempting to intimidate his school

181
00:09:39,735 --> 00:09:44,080
by posting a video of himself
shooting people in the hallways ...

182
00:09:44,080 --> 00:09:46,968
except the people were zombies

183
00:09:46,968 --> 00:09:52,038
and the video was of him playing
and augmented-reality video game,

184
00:09:52,038 --> 00:09:56,810
all interpreted to be a mental projection
of his subjective intent.

185
00:09:58,607 --> 00:10:02,944
This is exactly why our brains
need special protection.

186
00:10:03,331 --> 00:10:06,866
If our brains are just as subject
to data tracking and aggregation

187
00:10:06,876 --> 00:10:09,324
as our financial records and transactions,

188
00:10:09,324 --> 00:10:13,665
if you brains can be hacked
and tracked like our online activities,

189
00:10:13,665 --> 00:10:16,089
our mobile phones and applications,

190
00:10:16,089 --> 00:10:20,575
then we're on the brink of a dangerous
threat to our collective humanity.

191
00:10:21,493 --> 00:10:24,092
Before you panic,

192
00:10:24,092 --> 00:10:27,342
I believe that there are solutions
to these concerns,

193
00:10:27,342 --> 00:10:30,167
but we have to start by focusing
on the right things.

194
00:10:30,612 --> 00:10:33,589
When it comes to privacy
protections in general,

195
00:10:33,589 --> 00:10:35,438
I think we're fighting a losing battle

196
00:10:35,438 --> 00:10:38,022
by trying to restrict
the flow of information.

197
00:10:38,273 --> 00:10:42,505
Instead, we should be focusing
on securing rights and remedies

198
00:10:42,505 --> 00:10:44,780
against the misuse of our information.

199
00:10:45,403 --> 00:10:48,680
If people had the right to decide
how their information was shared,

200
00:10:48,680 --> 00:10:49,929
and more importantly,

201
00:10:49,929 --> 00:10:51,642
have legal redress,

202
00:10:51,642 --> 00:10:53,817
if their information
was misused against them,

203
00:10:53,817 --> 00:10:56,871
say to discriminate against them
in an employment setting

204
00:10:56,871 --> 00:10:59,679
or in health care and education,

205
00:10:59,679 --> 00:11:02,407
this would go a long way to build trust.

206
00:11:02,843 --> 00:11:04,796
In fact, in some instances,

207
00:11:04,796 --> 00:11:08,320
we want to be sharing more
of our personal information.

208
00:11:08,968 --> 00:11:11,984
Studying aggregated information
can tell us so much

209
00:11:11,984 --> 00:11:14,697
about our health and our wellbeing,

210
00:11:14,697 --> 00:11:18,033
but to be able to safely
share our information,

211
00:11:18,033 --> 00:11:21,256
we need special protections
for mental privacy.

212
00:11:21,888 --> 00:11:25,229
This is why we need
a right to cognitive liberty.

213
00:11:25,662 --> 00:11:29,842
This right would secure for us
our freedom of thought and rumination,

214
00:11:29,842 --> 00:11:32,307
our freedom of self-determination

215
00:11:32,307 --> 00:11:36,656
and it would insure that we have
the right to consent to or refuse

216
00:11:36,656 --> 00:11:39,513
access and alteration
of our brains by others.

217
00:11:39,891 --> 00:11:42,081
This right could be recognized

218
00:11:42,081 --> 00:11:44,958
as part of the universal
declaration of human rights,

219
00:11:44,958 --> 00:11:47,266
which has established mechanisms

220
00:11:47,266 --> 00:11:50,122
for the enforcement of these
kinds of social rights.

221
00:11:51,872 --> 00:11:54,149
During the Iranian Green Movement,

222
00:11:54,149 --> 00:11:59,320
the protesters used the internet
and good old-fashioned word of mouth

223
00:11:59,320 --> 00:12:01,268
to coordinate their marches.

224
00:12:02,373 --> 00:12:05,134
And some of the most oppressive
restrictions in Iran

225
00:12:05,134 --> 00:12:07,011
were lifted as a result.

226
00:12:08,135 --> 00:12:12,302
But what if the Iranian government
had used brain surveillance

227
00:12:12,302 --> 00:12:15,363
to detect and prevent the protest?

228
00:12:16,982 --> 00:12:20,350
Would the world have ever heard
the protester's cries?

229
00:12:21,867 --> 00:12:26,988
The time has come for us to call
for a cognitive liberty revolution.

230
00:12:27,695 --> 00:12:30,982
To make sure that we responsibly
advance technology

231
00:12:30,982 --> 00:12:33,928
that can enable us to embrace the future

232
00:12:33,928 --> 00:12:37,206
while fiercely protecting all of us

233
00:12:37,206 --> 00:12:40,678
from any person, company or government

234
00:12:40,678 --> 00:12:45,718
that attempts to unlawfully access
or alter our innermost lives.

235
00:12:46,731 --> 00:12:47,877
Thank you.

236
00:12:48,305 --> 00:12:50,491
(Applause)