WEBVTT

00:00:08.588 --> 00:00:11.000
How do we really know, that that 
which we see,

00:00:11.000 --> 00:00:14.288
touch and taste really exists?

00:00:14.538 --> 00:00:16.544
What is reality?

00:00:16.550 --> 00:00:19.180
The objects or how we perceive them?

00:00:19.187 --> 00:00:21.973
Do we see the world as its is, 
or is the world what it is,

00:00:21.973 --> 00:00:23.531
because we perceive it as such?

00:00:23.531 --> 00:00:24.942
Let's imagine the following:

00:00:24.942 --> 00:00:27.296
We are in a cave, deep underground.

00:00:27.296 --> 00:00:28.864
There is no visible daylight.

00:00:28.864 --> 00:00:32.037
In this cave, people are tied 
to chairs in such a way

00:00:32.037 --> 00:00:34.408
that they can only look at the cave wall.

00:00:34.408 --> 00:00:35.490
From birth onwards,

00:00:35.658 --> 00:00:38.179
Black and white movies are shown 
here non-stop

00:00:38.383 --> 00:00:42.161
The audience believes that the film
is a true reflection of reality.

00:00:42.191 --> 00:00:44.843
What sounds like an experiment
from the 3rd Reich,

00:00:44.843 --> 00:00:47.562
is actually a 2000-year-old mind game,

00:00:47.671 --> 00:00:49.596
conceived by Socrates' star pupil:

00:00:49.596 --> 00:00:50.429
Plato!

00:00:50.469 --> 00:00:51.532
Now suppose,

00:00:51.532 --> 00:00:55.188
that one of these bold youngsters 
actually escapes from the cave

00:00:55.188 --> 00:00:59.038
and sees the three-dimensional colourful 
world for the first time.

00:00:59.038 --> 00:01:00.581
How would he feel?

00:01:00.727 --> 00:01:03.399
Probably akin to the brave Keanu Reeves
in the "Matrix",

00:01:03.399 --> 00:01:06.413
in the scene where he wakes up in
real world for the first time.

00:01:06.413 --> 00:01:07.317
And worst of all,

00:01:07.317 --> 00:01:09.665
if our ancient Neo were to 
return to his friends

00:01:10.695 --> 00:01:13.342
and tell them that the world 
as they know it

00:01:13.342 --> 00:01:14.628
isn't real…

00:01:14.712 --> 00:01:17.112
then he would be dismissed as a madman.

00:01:17.221 --> 00:01:20.024
According to Plato, our reality
is based on 'ideas'

00:01:20.305 --> 00:01:23.796
Objects, and how we experience them,
are only their images

00:01:24.003 --> 00:01:27.237
However, for Plato the term 'idea'
represented more.

00:01:27.288 --> 00:01:29.214
It was about the essence of all things,

00:01:29.214 --> 00:01:32.425
that which we saw previously 
as part of an ideal world

00:01:32.545 --> 00:01:34.446
and that which we recalled from memory.

00:01:34.655 --> 00:01:37.085
What he pioneered with this is a doctrine

00:01:37.085 --> 00:01:38.081
called "idealism",

00:01:38.531 --> 00:01:41.135
to which Leibnitz and Kant 
later belonged.

00:01:41.135 --> 00:01:43.467
However, this does not mean 
diligently donating

00:01:43.467 --> 00:01:45.228
to victims of natural disasters

00:01:45.228 --> 00:01:48.222
or serving soup to the homeless 
at Christmas.

00:01:48.390 --> 00:01:51.512
Just as the real meaning of "materialism",

00:01:51.512 --> 00:01:55.306
isn't the "My house, My boat, My 
investment advisor" sung by Madonna.

00:01:55.306 --> 00:01:56.815
nor the meaning of Yuppie Lifestyle.

00:01:57.693 --> 00:02:02.022
Materialism is the philosophical 
countermovement to idealism.

00:02:02.093 --> 00:02:05.542
Idealism sees the origin 
of reality in the "idea",

00:02:05.542 --> 00:02:08.839
whereas with materialism "matter" 
is decisive.

00:02:08.839 --> 00:02:11.598
Thus, reality arises due to the 
effect of the environment

00:02:11.598 --> 00:02:13.896
and not by the way in which 
we perceive it.

00:02:14.019 --> 00:02:17.478
To the question "What is?" 
materialism answers:

00:02:17.478 --> 00:02:18.582
Only matter.

00:02:18.582 --> 00:02:20.281
The world exists how it is

00:02:20.281 --> 00:02:22.555
and we must conform to its laws.

00:02:22.555 --> 00:02:24.941
Sounds bleak in the long run, though,
doesn't it?

00:02:24.941 --> 00:02:27.932
So, are we just the ball
in a cosmic pinball machine then?

00:02:27.932 --> 00:02:29.806
So where does reality lie?

00:02:29.806 --> 00:02:32.578
Within us or out there?

00:02:32.578 --> 00:02:34.784
This game ends in a draw