WEBVTT

00:00:00.787 --> 00:00:03.747
Imagine that when you walked
in here this evening,

00:00:03.747 --> 00:00:05.825
you discovered that everybody in the room

00:00:05.825 --> 00:00:08.450
looked almost exactly the same:

00:00:08.450 --> 00:00:10.447
ageless, raceless,

00:00:10.447 --> 00:00:12.426
generically good-looking.

00:00:12.426 --> 00:00:14.478
That person sitting right next to you

00:00:14.478 --> 00:00:16.704
might have the most
idiosyncratic inner life,

00:00:16.704 --> 00:00:19.045
but you don't have a clue
because we're all wearing

00:00:19.045 --> 00:00:22.450
the same blank expression all the time.

00:00:22.450 --> 00:00:25.636
That is the kind of creepy transformation

00:00:25.636 --> 00:00:28.066
that is taking over cities,

00:00:28.066 --> 00:00:31.485
only it applies to buildings, not people.

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:31.485 --> 00:00:37.711
Cities are full of roughness and shadow,

00:00:37.711 --> 00:00:38.934
texture and color.

00:00:38.934 --> 00:00:44.376
You can still find architectural surfaces
of great individuality and character,

00:00:44.376 --> 00:00:47.608
in apartment buildings in Riga

00:00:47.608 --> 00:00:50.041
and [???].

00:00:50.041 --> 00:00:53.498
social housing in Vienna,

00:00:53.498 --> 00:00:55.535
Hopi villages in Arizona,

00:00:55.535 --> 00:00:57.859
brownstones in New York,

00:00:57.859 --> 00:00:59.917
wooden houses in San Francisco.

00:00:59.917 --> 00:01:02.251
These aren't palaces or cathedrals.

00:01:02.251 --> 00:01:04.094
These are just ordinary residences

00:01:04.094 --> 00:01:06.969
expressing the ordinary
splendor of cities.

00:01:06.969 --> 00:01:09.017
And the reason they're like that

00:01:09.017 --> 00:01:11.010
is that the need for shelter

00:01:11.010 --> 00:01:13.343
is so bound up with the human desire

00:01:13.343 --> 00:01:15.303
for beauty.

00:01:15.303 --> 00:01:17.792
Their rough surfaces give us

00:01:17.792 --> 00:01:21.070
a touchable city.

00:01:21.070 --> 00:01:23.448
Right? Streets that you can read
by running your fingers

00:01:23.448 --> 00:01:24.783
over brick and stone.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:24.783 --> 00:01:28.430
But that's getting harder to do,

00:01:28.430 --> 00:01:31.917
because cities are becoming smooth.

00:01:31.917 --> 00:01:34.875
New downtowns sprout towers
that are almost always made

00:01:34.875 --> 00:01:36.381
of concrete and steel

00:01:36.381 --> 00:01:39.166
and covered in glass.

00:01:39.166 --> 00:01:42.076
You can look at skylines
all over the world --

00:01:42.076 --> 00:01:45.523
Houston, Guangzhou,

00:01:45.523 --> 00:01:47.483
Frankfurt --

00:01:47.483 --> 00:01:50.987
and you see the same army
of high-gloss robots

00:01:50.987 --> 00:01:53.744
marching over the horizon.

00:01:53.744 --> 00:01:55.920
Now just think of everything we lose

00:01:55.920 --> 00:01:58.381
when architects stop using the full range

00:01:58.381 --> 00:02:00.934
of available materials.

00:02:00.934 --> 00:02:03.105
When we reject granite

00:02:03.105 --> 00:02:05.798
and limestone and sandstone
and wood and copper

00:02:05.798 --> 00:02:07.330
and terra cotta and brick

00:02:07.330 --> 00:02:09.311
and wattle and plaster,

00:02:09.311 --> 00:02:11.491
we simplify architecture

00:02:11.491 --> 00:02:13.841
and we impoverish cities.

00:02:13.841 --> 00:02:17.291
It's as if you reduced all
of the world's cuisines

00:02:17.291 --> 00:02:19.372
down to airline food.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:19.372 --> 00:02:20.936
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:20.936 --> 00:02:23.678
Chicken or pasta?

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:23.678 --> 00:02:25.960
But worse still,

00:02:25.960 --> 00:02:29.623
assemblies of glass towers
like this one in Moscow

00:02:29.623 --> 00:02:34.626
suggest a disdain for the civic
and communal aspects of urban living.

00:02:34.626 --> 00:02:39.470
Right? Buildings like these are intended
to enrich their owners and tenants,

00:02:39.470 --> 00:02:42.201
but not necessarily the lives
of the rest of us,

00:02:42.201 --> 00:02:46.457
those of us who navigate the spaces
between the buildings.

00:02:46.457 --> 00:02:50.065
And we expect to do so for free.

00:02:50.065 --> 00:02:53.198
Shiny towers are an invasive species,

00:02:53.198 --> 00:02:57.821
and they are choking our cities
and killing off public space.

00:02:57.821 --> 00:02:59.469
We tend to think of a facade

00:02:59.469 --> 00:03:01.102
as being like makeup,

00:03:01.102 --> 00:03:05.154
a decorative layer applied at the end
to a building that's effectively complete.

00:03:05.154 --> 00:03:07.877
But just because a facade is superficial

00:03:07.877 --> 00:03:10.145
doesn't mean it's not also deep.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:10.145 --> 00:03:12.420
Let me give you an example

00:03:12.420 --> 00:03:15.510
of how a city's surfaces affect
the way we live in it.

00:03:15.510 --> 00:03:18.372
When I visited Salamanca in Spain,

00:03:18.372 --> 00:03:20.760
I gravitated to the Plaza Mayor

00:03:20.760 --> 00:03:22.560
at all hours of the day.

00:03:22.560 --> 00:03:25.082
Right? Early in the morning,
sunlight rakes the facades,

00:03:25.082 --> 00:03:26.691
sharpening shadows,

00:03:26.691 --> 00:03:30.753
and at night, lamplight segments
the buildings into hundreds

00:03:30.753 --> 00:03:32.676
of distinct areas,

00:03:32.676 --> 00:03:34.913
balconies and windows and arcades,

00:03:34.913 --> 00:03:38.600
each one a separate pocket
of visual activity.

00:03:38.600 --> 00:03:41.732
That detail and depth, that glamour

00:03:41.732 --> 00:03:46.135
gives the plaza a theatrical quality.

00:03:46.135 --> 00:03:50.405
It becomes a stage where
the generations can meet.

00:03:50.405 --> 00:03:53.343
You have teenagers sprawling
on the pavement,

00:03:53.343 --> 00:03:56.286
seniors monopolizing the benches,

00:03:56.286 --> 00:04:00.591
and real life starts to look
like an opera set.

00:04:00.591 --> 00:04:03.278
The curtain goes up on Salamanca.

00:04:03.278 --> 00:04:08.645
So just because I'm talking about
the exteriors of buildings,

00:04:08.645 --> 00:04:11.981
not form, not function, not structure,

00:04:11.981 --> 00:04:17.569
even so those surfaces
give textures to our lives,

00:04:17.569 --> 00:04:20.588
because buildings create
the spaces around them,

00:04:20.588 --> 00:04:23.565
and those spaces can draw people in

00:04:23.565 --> 00:04:25.520
or push them away.

00:04:25.520 --> 00:04:29.307
And the difference often has to do
with the quality of those exteriors.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:29.307 --> 00:04:32.983
So one contemporary equivalent
of the Plaza Mayor in Salamanca

00:04:32.983 --> 00:04:36.050
is the Place de la Défense in Paris,

00:04:36.050 --> 00:04:39.504
a windswept, glass-walled open space

00:04:39.504 --> 00:04:41.582
that office workers hurry through

00:04:41.582 --> 00:04:43.840
on the way from the Metro
to their cubicles

00:04:43.840 --> 00:04:48.107
but otherwise spend
as little time in as possible.

00:04:48.107 --> 00:04:51.369
In the early 1980s,
the architect Philip Johnson

00:04:51.369 --> 00:04:55.951
tried to recreate a gracious
European plaza in Pittsburgh.

00:04:55.951 --> 00:04:57.444
This is PPG Place,

00:04:57.444 --> 00:05:02.585
a half acre of open space
encircles by commercial buildings

00:05:02.585 --> 00:05:04.254
made of mirrored glass.

00:05:04.254 --> 00:05:05.832
And he ornamented those buildings

00:05:05.832 --> 00:05:07.553
with metal trim and baize

00:05:07.553 --> 00:05:09.475
and gothic turrets

00:05:09.475 --> 00:05:11.659
which really pop on the skyline.

00:05:11.659 --> 00:05:13.680
But at ground level,

00:05:13.680 --> 00:05:18.166
the plaza feels like a black glass cage.

00:05:18.166 --> 00:05:21.146
I mean sure, in summertime kids
are running back and forth

00:05:21.146 --> 00:05:22.487
through the fountain

00:05:22.487 --> 00:05:24.227
and there's ice skating in the winter,

00:05:24.227 --> 00:05:27.993
but it lacks the informality
of a leisurely hangout.

00:05:27.993 --> 00:05:33.640
It's just not the sort of place
you really want to just hang out and chat.

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:33.640 --> 00:05:39.584
Public spaces thrive or fail
for many different reasons.

00:05:39.584 --> 00:05:41.702
Architecture is only one,

00:05:41.702 --> 00:05:43.938
but it's an important one.

00:05:43.938 --> 00:05:45.373
Some recent plazas

00:05:45.373 --> 00:05:48.131
like Federation Square in Melbourne

00:05:48.131 --> 00:05:52.126
or Superkilen in Copenhagen

00:05:52.126 --> 00:05:55.613
succeed because they combine old and new,

00:05:55.613 --> 00:05:57.526
rough and smooth,

00:05:57.526 --> 00:05:59.334
neutral and bright colors,

00:05:59.334 --> 00:06:04.049
and because they don't rely
excessively on glass.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:04.049 --> 00:06:07.180
Now, I'm not against glass.

00:06:07.180 --> 00:06:11.312
It's an ancient and versatile material.

00:06:11.312 --> 00:06:16.125
It's easy to manufacture and transport

00:06:16.125 --> 00:06:18.170
and install and replace

00:06:18.170 --> 00:06:19.744
and clean.

00:06:19.744 --> 00:06:22.593
It comes in everything
from enormous, ultra-clear sheets

00:06:22.593 --> 00:06:25.467
to translucent bricks.

00:06:25.467 --> 00:06:27.569
New coatings make it change mood

00:06:27.569 --> 00:06:29.867
in the shifting light.

00:06:29.867 --> 00:06:33.296
In expensive cities like New York,
it has the magical power

00:06:33.296 --> 00:06:37.036
of being able to multiply real estate
values by allowing views,

00:06:37.036 --> 00:06:40.016
which is really the only commodity
that developers have to offer

00:06:40.016 --> 00:06:43.821
to justify those surreal prices.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:43.821 --> 00:06:46.396
In the middle of the 19th century,

00:06:46.396 --> 00:06:49.360
with the construction
of the Crystal Palace in London,

00:06:49.360 --> 00:06:54.566
glass leapt to the top of the list
of quintessentially modern substances.

00:06:54.566 --> 00:06:56.082
By the mid-20th century,

00:06:56.082 --> 00:06:59.905
it had come to dominate the downtowns
of some American cities,

00:06:59.905 --> 00:07:02.015
largely through some really spectacular

00:07:02.015 --> 00:07:03.730
office buildings like Lever House

00:07:03.730 --> 00:07:07.685
in midtown Manhattan, designed
by Skidmore, Owings and Merrill.

00:07:07.685 --> 00:07:09.602
Eventually, the technology

00:07:09.602 --> 00:07:13.347
advanced to the point where architects
could design structures so transparent

00:07:13.347 --> 00:07:16.421
they practically disappear.

00:07:16.421 --> 00:07:18.015
And along the way,

00:07:18.015 --> 00:07:22.697
glass became the default material
of the high rise city,

00:07:22.697 --> 00:07:25.351
and there's a very
powerful reason for that,

00:07:25.351 --> 00:07:30.216
because as the world's populations
converge on cities,

00:07:30.216 --> 00:07:33.842
the least fortunate pack into
jerrybuilt shantytowns,

00:07:33.842 --> 00:07:37.726
but hundreds of millions of people
need apartments and places to work

00:07:37.726 --> 00:07:38.979
in ever larger buildings,

00:07:38.979 --> 00:07:41.513
so it makes economic sense
to put up towers

00:07:41.513 --> 00:07:45.329
and wrap them in cheap
and practical curtain walls.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:45.329 --> 00:07:48.448
But glass has a limited ability

00:07:48.448 --> 00:07:51.459
to be expressive.

00:07:51.459 --> 00:07:53.604
This is a section of wall framing a plaza

00:07:53.604 --> 00:07:56.676
in the pre-Hispanic city of Mitla,
in southern Mexico.

00:07:56.676 --> 00:08:00.394
Those 2,000-year old carvings

00:08:00.394 --> 00:08:04.696
make it clear that this was a place
of high ritual significance.

00:08:04.696 --> 00:08:11.182
Today we look at those and we can see
a historical and textural continuity

00:08:11.182 --> 00:08:13.811
between those carvings,
the mountains all around,

00:08:13.811 --> 00:08:17.937
and that church which is built
on top of the ruins

00:08:17.937 --> 00:08:21.126
using stone plundered from the site.

00:08:21.126 --> 00:08:23.931
In nearby Oaxaca, even
ordinary plaster buildings

00:08:23.931 --> 00:08:27.937
become canvasses for bright colors,
political murals,

00:08:27.937 --> 00:08:31.082
and sophisticated graphic arts.

00:08:31.082 --> 00:08:34.136
It's an intricate, communicative language

00:08:34.136 --> 00:08:37.654
that an epidemic of glass
would simply wipe out.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:38.196 --> 00:08:41.147
The good news is that architects
and developers

00:08:41.147 --> 00:08:43.933
have begun to rediscover
the joys of texture

00:08:43.933 --> 00:08:46.572
without backing away from modernity.

00:08:46.572 --> 00:08:50.901
Some find innovative uses
for old materials like brick

00:08:50.901 --> 00:08:54.013
and terra cotta.

00:08:54.013 --> 00:08:56.863
Others invent new products
like the molded panels

00:08:56.863 --> 00:08:58.618
that Snøhetta used

00:08:58.618 --> 00:09:01.645
to give their San Francisco
Museum of Modern Art

00:09:01.645 --> 00:09:04.835
that crinkly, sculptural quality.

00:09:04.835 --> 00:09:08.519
The architect Stefano Boeri
even created living facades.

00:09:08.519 --> 00:09:12.580
This is his Vertical Forest,
a pair of apartment towers in Milan,

00:09:12.580 --> 00:09:15.436
whose most visible feature is greenery.

00:09:15.436 --> 00:09:21.310
And Boeri is designing a version of this
for Nanjing in China.

00:09:21.310 --> 00:09:25.453
And imagine if green facades
were as ubiquitous as glass ones

00:09:25.453 --> 00:09:28.633
how much cleaner the air
in Chinese cities would become.

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:29.464 --> 00:09:32.563
But the truth is that these
are mostly one-offs,

00:09:32.563 --> 00:09:34.115
boutique projects,

00:09:34.115 --> 00:09:37.347
not easily reproduced
at a global scale.

00:09:37.347 --> 00:09:40.448
And that is the point.

00:09:40.448 --> 00:09:43.571
When you use materials
that have a local significance,

00:09:43.571 --> 00:09:47.003
you prevent cities from
all looking the same.

00:09:47.003 --> 00:09:49.916
Copper has a long history in New York --

00:09:49.916 --> 00:09:51.622
the Statue of Liberty,

00:09:51.622 --> 00:09:54.006
the crown of the Woolworth Building --

00:09:54.006 --> 00:09:57.705
but it fell out of fashion for a long time

00:09:57.705 --> 00:10:02.105
until shop architects used it to cover
the American Copper Building,

00:10:02.105 --> 00:10:05.295
a pair of twisting towers
on the East River.

00:10:05.295 --> 00:10:08.179
It's not even finished and you
can see the way sunset

00:10:08.179 --> 00:10:10.787
lights up that metallic facade,

00:10:10.787 --> 00:10:13.824
which will weather to green as it ages.

00:10:13.824 --> 00:10:16.289
Buildings can be like people.

00:10:16.289 --> 00:10:19.270
Their faces broadcast their experience.

00:10:19.270 --> 00:10:21.089
And that's an important point,

00:10:21.089 --> 00:10:23.257
because when glass ages,

00:10:23.257 --> 00:10:25.429
you just replace it,

00:10:25.429 --> 00:10:27.669
and the building looks pretty much
the same way it did before

00:10:27.669 --> 00:10:30.234
until eventually it's demolished.

00:10:30.234 --> 00:10:33.942
Almost all other materials
have the ability to absorb

00:10:33.942 --> 00:10:36.278
infusions of history and memory

00:10:36.278 --> 00:10:40.850
and project it into the present.

00:10:40.850 --> 00:10:43.053
The firm Ennead

00:10:43.053 --> 00:10:47.866
clad the Utah Natural History Museum
in Salt Lake City in copper and zinc,

00:10:47.866 --> 00:10:53.410
ores that had been mined
in the area for 150 years

00:10:53.410 --> 00:10:57.691
and that also camouflage the building
against the ochre hills

00:10:57.691 --> 00:10:59.594
so that you have a natural history museum

00:10:59.594 --> 00:11:03.723
that reflects the region's
natural history.

00:11:03.723 --> 00:11:06.739
And when the Chinese
Pritzker Prize Winner Wang Shu

00:11:06.739 --> 00:11:09.851
was building a history museum in Ningbo,

00:11:09.851 --> 00:11:13.124
he didn't just create
a wrapper for the past,

00:11:13.124 --> 00:11:16.407
he built memory right into the walls

00:11:16.407 --> 00:11:19.883
by using brick and stones and shingles

00:11:19.883 --> 00:11:24.513
salvaged from villages
that had been demolished.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:24.513 --> 00:11:27.822
Now, architects can use glass

00:11:27.822 --> 00:11:30.436
in equally lyrical and inventive ways.

00:11:30.436 --> 00:11:32.049
Here in New York, two buildings,

00:11:32.049 --> 00:11:34.838
one by Jean Nouvel
and this one by Frank Gehry

00:11:34.838 --> 00:11:37.787
face off across West 19th Street,

00:11:37.787 --> 00:11:40.811
and the play of reflections
that they toss back and forth

00:11:40.811 --> 00:11:43.421
is like a symphony in light.

00:11:43.421 --> 00:11:47.553
But when a city defaults to glass

00:11:47.553 --> 00:11:49.032
as it grows,

00:11:49.032 --> 00:11:51.070
it becomes a hall of mirrors,

00:11:51.070 --> 00:11:54.142
disquieting and cold.

00:11:54.142 --> 00:11:58.581
After all, cities are places
of concentrated variety

00:11:58.581 --> 00:12:04.869
where the world's cultures
and languages and lifestyles

00:12:04.869 --> 00:12:06.886
come together and mingle.

00:12:06.886 --> 00:12:09.963
So rather than encase all that variety

00:12:09.963 --> 00:12:14.763
and diversity in buildings
of crushing sameness,

00:12:14.763 --> 00:12:17.007
we should have an architecture that honors

00:12:17.007 --> 00:12:19.589
the full range of the urban experience.

NOTE Paragraph

00:12:19.589 --> 00:12:21.177
Thank you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:12:21.177 --> 00:12:26.631
(Applause)