WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.982
[theme music]

00:00:04.192 --> 00:00:05.605
Oliver: Bail.

00:00:05.605 --> 00:00:06.541
We're so used to it,

00:00:06.541 --> 00:00:08.976
it has become a fixture of American life.

00:00:08.976 --> 00:00:10.160
Sorrentino: Down here at the shore,

00:00:10.160 --> 00:00:11.701
one minute you've got three girls
in the jacuzzi,

00:00:11.701 --> 00:00:13.467
the next minute somebody's in jail

00:00:13.467 --> 00:00:15.180
and you have to bail them out.

00:00:15.180 --> 00:00:16.985
That's what happens down at the shore.

00:00:16.985 --> 00:00:18.952
[audience laughs]

00:00:18.952 --> 00:00:20.020
Oliver: The other thing that happens

00:00:20.020 --> 00:00:20.882
down at the shore?

00:00:20.882 --> 00:00:21.684
Chlamydia.

00:00:21.684 --> 00:00:25.342
Just a medically astounding rate of chlamydia.

00:00:25.342 --> 00:00:26.223
At it's heart,

00:00:26.223 --> 00:00:28.451
America's bail system sounds pretty simple.

00:00:28.451 --> 00:00:29.630
If you're charged with a crime,

00:00:29.630 --> 00:00:30.685
the court might ask for

00:00:30.685 --> 00:00:32.125
an amount of money as bond,

00:00:32.125 --> 00:00:33.430
and then return it to you

00:00:33.430 --> 00:00:35.124
once you show up for trial.

00:00:35.124 --> 00:00:36.068
And if you have that money,

00:00:36.068 --> 00:00:36.931
it's no big deal.

00:00:36.931 --> 00:00:37.731
But if you don't,

00:00:37.731 --> 00:00:39.506
you could be in big trouble.

00:00:39.506 --> 00:00:40.934
Just look at one example,

00:00:40.934 --> 00:00:42.207
a man called Miguel.

00:00:42.207 --> 00:00:43.214
He was arrested

00:00:43.214 --> 00:00:44.894
for driving with a suspended license.

00:00:44.894 --> 00:00:46.606
The court set bail at $1,000,

00:00:46.606 --> 00:00:47.644
and he had the choice

00:00:47.644 --> 00:00:51.977
pay it or await a trial in Riker's Island.

00:00:51.977 --> 00:00:53.219
And I'll let Miguel and his wife

00:00:53.219 --> 00:00:54.713
take the story from there.

00:00:54.713 --> 00:00:56.688
Miguel: I wouldn't wish Riker's

00:00:56.688 --> 00:00:57.643
on my worst enemy

00:00:57.643 --> 00:00:59.158
because it's rough.

00:00:59.158 --> 00:01:00.221
Wife: It's hard because...

00:01:00.221 --> 00:01:01.417
I had to borrow--

00:01:01.417 --> 00:01:02.796
I had to try to borrow money

00:01:02.796 --> 00:01:04.665
from this person and this person

00:01:04.665 --> 00:01:06.751
and this person to try to get him out.

00:01:06.751 --> 00:01:07.426
He told the judge,

00:01:07.426 --> 00:01:09.807
"I can't afford $1,000 bill."

00:01:10.477 --> 00:01:12.097
So, he really didn't have a choice

00:01:12.097 --> 00:01:13.524
but to plead guilty.

00:01:14.244 --> 00:01:15.676
Oliver: Now, whether he was guilty or not,

00:01:15.676 --> 00:01:17.812
the fact is a non-violent offender

00:01:17.812 --> 00:01:19.512
spent time in Riker's

00:01:19.512 --> 00:01:21.478
because he didn't have $1,000.

00:01:21.478 --> 00:01:23.779
And this is a systemic problem.

00:01:23.779 --> 00:01:25.709
Increasing the bail has become a way

00:01:25.709 --> 00:01:26.510
to lock up the poor

00:01:26.510 --> 00:01:27.577
regardless of guilt

00:01:27.577 --> 00:01:29.619
because Miguel was a family man

00:01:29.619 --> 00:01:32.125
who posed no danger to society whatsoever.

00:01:32.125 --> 00:01:33.355
And he was stuck at Riker's,

00:01:33.355 --> 00:01:35.519
whereas millionaire Robert Durst

00:01:35.519 --> 00:01:38.050
who'd been accused of murder in Texas,

00:01:38.050 --> 00:01:40.092
had a completely different experience

00:01:40.092 --> 00:01:41.457
of the bail system.

00:01:41.457 --> 00:01:43.625
Durst: I had been told by the detective,

00:01:43.625 --> 00:01:46.470
"You've been charged with murder.

00:01:46.470 --> 00:01:49.875
Bail has been set at $250,000."

00:01:49.875 --> 00:01:51.573
Interviewer: But was your intention

00:01:51.573 --> 00:01:54.607
when you put up the $250,000 to run away?

00:01:54.607 --> 00:01:56.798
Durst: Oh, goodbye $250,000.

00:01:56.798 --> 00:01:59.847
Goodbye, jail. I'm out!

00:02:00.182 --> 00:02:03.223
Oliver: I'm out! [audience booing]

00:02:03.223 --> 00:02:04.158
That of course,

00:02:04.158 --> 00:02:05.359
is an excerpt from Robert Durst's

00:02:05.359 --> 00:02:07.494
children's books: Goodbye, Jail.

00:02:07.494 --> 00:02:08.988
[audience laughs and claps]

00:02:08.988 --> 00:02:09.895
Goodbye, money.

00:02:09.895 --> 00:02:10.931
Goodbye, bail.

00:02:10.931 --> 00:02:12.030
I killed them all,

00:02:12.030 --> 00:02:13.515
but goodbye jail.

00:02:13.905 --> 00:02:16.600
Of course, of course.

00:02:17.585 --> 00:02:18.799
The problem is

00:02:18.799 --> 00:02:20.760
the frequency and cost of bail

00:02:20.760 --> 00:02:22.240
has risen dramatically.

00:02:22.240 --> 00:02:24.274
And it is disproportionately hurting the poor.

00:02:24.274 --> 00:02:25.628
In fact, in 2013,

00:02:25.628 --> 00:02:28.209
an analysis of New Jersey's jail population

00:02:28.209 --> 00:02:29.917
found that nearly 40%

00:02:29.917 --> 00:02:31.885
were being held solely because

00:02:31.885 --> 00:02:33.817
they couldn't meet the terms of their bail,

00:02:33.817 --> 00:02:35.275
which is crazy.

00:02:35.275 --> 00:02:36.253
Jail is supposed to be for

00:02:36.253 --> 00:02:37.411
dangerous criminals.

00:02:37.411 --> 00:02:38.825
If 40% of the group

00:02:38.825 --> 00:02:40.757
don't meet the basic criteria

00:02:40.757 --> 00:02:41.693
to be there,

00:02:41.693 --> 00:02:43.127
that should change your perception

00:02:43.127 --> 00:02:44.056
of what that group is.

00:02:44.056 --> 00:02:46.157
If 40% of the Girl Scouts

00:02:46.157 --> 00:02:47.132
were grown men,

00:02:47.132 --> 00:02:48.089
you'd feel weird about

00:02:48.089 --> 00:02:49.340
buying cookies from them.

00:02:49.340 --> 00:02:50.668
[audience laughs]

00:02:50.668 --> 00:02:54.268
So, what happens if you can't make bail?

00:02:54.268 --> 00:02:55.705
Well, much like a game of

00:02:55.705 --> 00:02:58.406
F***, Marry, Kill with Crosby, Stills, and Nash,

00:02:58.406 --> 00:03:01.588
there are a few terrible scenarios.

00:03:01.588 --> 00:03:03.741
[audience laughs, applauds]

00:03:03.741 --> 00:03:06.710
Option 1: You're sit in jail.

00:03:06.710 --> 00:03:08.411
And again, if you're poor

00:03:08.411 --> 00:03:10.155
as this defensive attorney explains

00:03:10.155 --> 00:03:11.992
that has immediate consequences.

00:03:11.992 --> 00:03:13.727
Saunders: Our clients work at jobs

00:03:13.727 --> 00:03:15.858
where if you're absent, you're fired.

00:03:15.858 --> 00:03:17.486
Our clients live in shelters

00:03:17.486 --> 00:03:18.885
or in transitional housing.

00:03:18.885 --> 00:03:20.770
Places where if you're not there for the night,

00:03:20.770 --> 00:03:22.127
you're place is gone.

00:03:22.127 --> 00:03:23.363
So, there's a lot of different ways

00:03:23.363 --> 00:03:24.871
in which incarceration,

00:03:24.871 --> 00:03:26.206
even for a short period of time,

00:03:26.206 --> 00:03:28.341
can really destroy someone's life.

00:03:28.341 --> 00:03:29.126
Oliver: Exactly.

00:03:29.126 --> 00:03:30.570
Jail can do for your actual life,

00:03:30.570 --> 00:03:31.766
what being in a marching band

00:03:31.766 --> 00:03:33.189
can do for your social life.

00:03:33.189 --> 00:03:34.280
[audience laughs]

00:03:34.280 --> 00:03:36.680
Even if you're in just for a little while,

00:03:36.680 --> 00:03:39.019
it can destroy you [laughter, applause].

00:03:39.019 --> 00:03:41.536
Destroy you [applause].

00:03:41.536 --> 00:03:43.685
That means it's no wonder

00:03:43.685 --> 00:03:46.524
that many defendants who can't afford bail

00:03:46.524 --> 00:03:47.795
favor option number 2,

00:03:47.795 --> 00:03:50.482
simply pleading guilty even if you're not,

00:03:50.482 --> 00:03:52.762
as a former public defender explains.

00:03:52.762 --> 00:03:54.265
Feige: You sit in jail

00:03:54.265 --> 00:03:57.030
because you can't afford to pay your way to freedom.

00:03:57.030 --> 00:03:59.407
And you're often confronted with a deal

00:03:59.407 --> 00:04:00.592
that goes like this:

00:04:00.592 --> 00:04:02.006
"Plead guilty -- get out."

00:04:02.006 --> 00:04:04.213
"Maintain your innocence and go to trial."

00:04:04.213 --> 00:04:05.326
"Stay in."

00:04:05.546 --> 00:04:06.491
Oliver: And poor people

00:04:06.491 --> 00:04:08.308
are regularly choosing to admit guilt

00:04:08.308 --> 00:04:09.545
just to get out of there,

00:04:09.545 --> 00:04:10.878
which isn't good.

00:04:10.878 --> 00:04:12.211
The only time that's appropriate

00:04:12.211 --> 00:04:14.142
is in a Catholic confessional.

00:04:14.142 --> 00:04:16.421
What do you mean is there anything else?

00:04:16.421 --> 00:04:18.953
I don't know. I--I masturbated into a kiwi fruit.

00:04:18.953 --> 00:04:21.795
[audience laughs] Just let me leave.

00:04:21.795 --> 00:04:25.007
I have stuff to do [laughter and clapping].

00:04:25.007 --> 00:04:27.763
And the problem is if you do plead guilty

00:04:27.763 --> 00:04:28.924
to a crime you didn't commit,

00:04:28.924 --> 00:04:30.467
that does have it's own downsides

00:04:30.467 --> 00:04:32.696
because unfortunately on a job application

00:04:32.696 --> 00:04:33.856
next to the question:

00:04:33.856 --> 00:04:35.837
have you ever been convicted of a crime?

00:04:35.837 --> 00:04:37.171
Check yes or no.

00:04:37.171 --> 00:04:39.400
Most don't then leave full pages

00:04:39.400 --> 00:04:40.672
of blank space to explain

00:04:40.672 --> 00:04:42.682
the social and economic inequalities

00:04:42.682 --> 00:04:44.911
inherent in the legal system [light laughter].

00:04:44.911 --> 00:04:47.046
And that brings us to your final option:

00:04:47.046 --> 00:04:48.714
commercial bail bondsmen.

00:04:48.714 --> 00:04:49.812
You know, the people who make

00:04:49.812 --> 00:04:52.514
amazing ads like these:

00:04:52.514 --> 00:04:53.551
Woman: Grumpy's Bail Bonds

00:04:53.551 --> 00:04:56.658
has busted out all over middle Tennessee!

00:04:56.658 --> 00:04:58.366
Prisoner: I ain't goin' out like that.

00:04:58.366 --> 00:04:59.720
I'm a corporate bail bonds

00:04:59.720 --> 00:05:00.850
'cuz they got my back!

00:05:00.850 --> 00:05:02.133
They got me out in no time

00:05:02.133 --> 00:05:03.629
and I'm back on track.

00:05:03.629 --> 00:05:05.971
Man 1 [high pitched]: Jesus Christ Bail Bonds!

00:05:05.971 --> 00:05:07.807
May God release you in a payment plan

00:05:07.807 --> 00:05:08.970
by calling me!

00:05:08.970 --> 00:05:11.737
I'm Bishop Barry of Jesus Christ Bail Bonds!

00:05:11.737 --> 00:05:14.337
410-292-3029.

00:05:14.337 --> 00:05:15.642
If you're locked up and afraid --

00:05:15.642 --> 00:05:16.305
Man 2: Bail out!

00:05:16.305 --> 00:05:17.042
Man 1: Bail out!

00:05:17.042 --> 00:05:17.644
Man 2: Bail out!

00:05:17.644 --> 00:05:18.252
Man 1: Bail out!

00:05:18.252 --> 00:05:19.041
Man 2: Bail out!

00:05:19.041 --> 00:05:19.450
Man 1: Bail out!

00:05:19.450 --> 00:05:22.039
[high pitched voice] Jesus Christ Bail Bonds!

00:05:22.039 --> 00:05:22.909
[audience laughs, claps, oohs]

00:05:22.909 --> 00:05:23.804
Oliver: Yes.

00:05:23.804 --> 00:05:25.301
[mimics Man 1 with high pitched voice] Jesus Christ

00:05:25.301 --> 00:05:27.185
Bail Bonds [audience cheers and applauds]!

00:05:27.185 --> 00:05:28.817
Amazing. And I will say,

00:05:28.817 --> 00:05:30.953
it is a little weird given that

00:05:30.953 --> 00:05:32.730
Jesus, pretty memorably I think,

00:05:32.730 --> 00:05:35.758
was not bailed out [audience laughs].

00:05:35.758 --> 00:05:37.635
He did eventually escape custody,

00:05:37.635 --> 00:05:38.867
but it was a real work around

00:05:38.867 --> 00:05:40.800
of the system [laughter].

00:05:40.800 --> 00:05:42.842
Now here's how that system works.

00:05:42.842 --> 00:05:44.506
Bail bondsmen promise the court

00:05:44.506 --> 00:05:45.579
to pay your bail

00:05:45.579 --> 00:05:47.914
if you fail to show up for a trial.

00:05:47.914 --> 00:05:49.610
In exchange, you pay them 10-15%

00:05:49.610 --> 00:05:50.807
of the bail amount,

00:05:50.807 --> 00:05:52.014
which they then keep

00:05:52.014 --> 00:05:54.386
regardless of how your trial goes.

00:05:54.386 --> 00:05:56.155
So, if your bail is $5,000

00:05:56.155 --> 00:05:57.323
and you're found innocent,

00:05:57.323 --> 00:05:58.990
then you've basically just paid

00:05:58.990 --> 00:06:01.096
a $750 fee to a bondsmen

00:06:01.096 --> 00:06:03.055
for doing absolutely nothing wrong.

00:06:03.055 --> 00:06:06.529
And paying $750 for absolutely nothing

00:06:06.529 --> 00:06:08.066
should be reserved to one thing

00:06:08.066 --> 00:06:09.437
and one thing only --

00:06:09.437 --> 00:06:10.937
six months gym memberships.

00:06:10.937 --> 00:06:12.427
[audience laughs and applauds] That's it.

00:06:12.427 --> 00:06:14.062
You're not going to use it, Gerald.

00:06:14.062 --> 00:06:15.427
You're going to use the treadmill twice

00:06:15.427 --> 00:06:17.109
and that's it.

00:06:17.109 --> 00:06:19.280
This is learning to speak Korean

00:06:19.280 --> 00:06:21.742
all over again, Gerald [laughs].

00:06:22.522 --> 00:06:25.385
And if you don't show up for your trial,

00:06:25.385 --> 00:06:27.153
bail bondsmen routinely hire

00:06:27.153 --> 00:06:28.917
bounty hunters to track you down.

00:06:28.917 --> 00:06:30.588
And they have a frightening amount

00:06:30.588 --> 00:06:31.744
of power.

00:06:31.744 --> 00:06:33.492
Narrator: In all but 4 states,

00:06:33.492 --> 00:06:35.465
the companies are legally allowed

00:06:35.465 --> 00:06:37.383
to take almost any measure necessary

00:06:37.383 --> 00:06:38.389
to capture a client,

00:06:38.389 --> 00:06:40.432
including crossing state lines

00:06:40.432 --> 00:06:42.332
and breaking into homes.

00:06:42.332 --> 00:06:43.492
It's a dangerous business

00:06:43.492 --> 00:06:44.829
for everyone involved.

00:06:44.829 --> 00:06:47.525
With few rules and little oversight.

00:06:47.525 --> 00:06:48.927
Oliver: Well, they're not kidding.

00:06:48.927 --> 00:06:51.943
In 18 states, anyone can become a bounty hunter

00:06:51.943 --> 00:06:53.905
regardless of education, training,

00:06:53.905 --> 00:06:56.246
or prior criminal history.

00:06:56.246 --> 00:06:57.146
Becoming a bounty hunter

00:06:57.146 --> 00:06:58.177
is basically a lot like

00:06:58.177 --> 00:06:59.653
becoming a social media expert.

00:06:59.653 --> 00:07:01.677
[audience laughs] All it takes is

00:07:01.677 --> 00:07:02.656
one to get bad enough

00:07:02.656 --> 00:07:04.144
and not caring about whether strangers

00:07:04.144 --> 00:07:06.185
hate you or not [audience laughs].

00:07:06.185 --> 00:07:08.319
But then the news that any idiot

00:07:08.319 --> 00:07:09.921
can be a bounty hunter

00:07:09.921 --> 00:07:11.650
shouldn't really be that surprising to you

00:07:11.650 --> 00:07:13.491
if you've ever turned on A &E

00:07:13.491 --> 00:07:14.967
and stumbled across this:

00:07:14.967 --> 00:07:16.626
Dog the Bounty Hunter: I am law man

00:07:16.626 --> 00:07:17.962
on a mission from God.

00:07:17.962 --> 00:07:19.989
When I say, "Freeze!"

00:07:20.999 --> 00:07:22.075
They know what I'm saying.

00:07:22.075 --> 00:07:22.769
Man 1: How's it going, man?

00:07:22.769 --> 00:07:24.100
Dog the Bounty Hunter: Freeze, ****!!

00:07:24.100 --> 00:07:29.145
[overlapping yelling]

00:07:29.145 --> 00:07:31.418
The only way this guy will get away from us

00:07:31.418 --> 00:07:33.386
is if he kills himself right now

00:07:33.386 --> 00:07:35.251
and jumps into a pool of sharks.

00:07:35.251 --> 00:07:36.523
[audience laughs, oohs]

00:07:36.523 --> 00:07:39.273
Oliver: Okay, okay, I hate to be a stickler

00:07:39.273 --> 00:07:40.825
over chronology, Dog,

00:07:40.825 --> 00:07:42.489
but how do you kill yourself

00:07:42.489 --> 00:07:44.594
and then jump into a pool of sharks?

00:07:44.594 --> 00:07:45.993
[laughing]

00:07:45.993 --> 00:07:47.890
That's the point of attention to detail, Dog,

00:07:47.890 --> 00:07:49.791
that makes me worry about you

00:07:49.791 --> 00:07:52.138
operating as an unregulated vigilante.

00:07:52.138 --> 00:07:53.998
Now that show was so popular,

00:07:53.998 --> 00:07:56.400
it inspired pretty much every other bail business

00:07:56.400 --> 00:07:58.740
to pitch themselves as a reality show.

00:07:58.740 --> 00:08:00.013
Just click around online

00:08:00.013 --> 00:08:01.646
and you will find sizzle reels

00:08:01.646 --> 00:08:04.920
for a veritable smorgasbord of similar shows.

00:08:05.307 --> 00:08:06.417
♪ Walking and talking

00:08:06.417 --> 00:08:07.678
♪ He acted like a criminal

00:08:07.678 --> 00:08:08.729
♪ Running through the woods

00:08:08.729 --> 00:08:10.269
♪ Like a four legged animal

00:08:10.269 --> 00:08:11.259
Joe Ray: The bottom line is:

00:08:11.259 --> 00:08:12.753
while you're on bond,

00:08:12.753 --> 00:08:13.733
we own your ass.

00:08:13.733 --> 00:08:14.705
Tonya: Dear Idiot,

00:08:14.705 --> 00:08:15.957
We're coming to get you.

00:08:15.957 --> 00:08:18.008
Brian: Bounty huntin' is a natural high.

00:08:18.008 --> 00:08:19.469
You gotta think like them, be like them,

00:08:19.469 --> 00:08:21.499
and react quicker than them.

00:08:21.499 --> 00:08:22.980
Put your hands up!

00:08:22.980 --> 00:08:24.461
Narrator: You want tough?

00:08:24.461 --> 00:08:25.533
You want action?

00:08:25.533 --> 00:08:27.099
Meet Big Benny.

00:08:27.739 --> 00:08:29.941
They call him Teddy Bear.

00:08:29.941 --> 00:08:31.311
Denise.

00:08:32.351 --> 00:08:33.828
The Huntress.

00:08:34.498 --> 00:08:35.647
Oliver: It doesn't stop there.

00:08:35.647 --> 00:08:38.406
There's also Richard, the screwdriver.

00:08:38.406 --> 00:08:40.863
Richard L., the other Richard.

00:08:40.863 --> 00:08:43.456
Allison, the Greco-Roman wrestler.

00:08:43.456 --> 00:08:44.253
Caroline,

00:08:44.253 --> 00:08:45.383
the one who took up archery

00:08:45.383 --> 00:08:47.126
after watching The Hunger Games.

00:08:47.126 --> 00:08:48.384
And don't forget Jennifer,

00:08:48.384 --> 00:08:50.825
the arthritic alpaca in a bowler hat.

00:08:50.966 --> 00:08:53.299
Actually, you know what,

00:08:53.299 --> 00:08:54.792
I now regret making fun of that,

00:08:54.792 --> 00:08:55.932
now that I'm seeing the cast,

00:08:55.932 --> 00:08:56.990
I get the appeal.

00:08:56.990 --> 00:08:58.575
I want to see those characters grow.

00:08:58.575 --> 00:09:00.499
[laughing]

00:09:00.499 --> 00:09:01.564
Clearly,

00:09:01.564 --> 00:09:04.075
these shows are in a competitive marketplace,

00:09:04.075 --> 00:09:05.067
and the problem is,

00:09:05.067 --> 00:09:06.745
when people try to stick out,

00:09:06.745 --> 00:09:09.114
ideas like this happen:

00:09:09.114 --> 00:09:10.639
Man: So what do we do differently,

00:09:10.639 --> 00:09:12.239
we don't just bounty hunt,

00:09:12.239 --> 00:09:13.686
we bounty race.

00:09:13.686 --> 00:09:15.033
Narrator: Each week,

00:09:16.153 --> 00:09:18.538
two new teams of bounty hunters,

00:09:20.098 --> 00:09:21.575
go head to head.

00:09:21.575 --> 00:09:23.235
Welcome to the most dangerous

00:09:23.235 --> 00:09:24.973
competition on television.

00:09:24.973 --> 00:09:27.063
Bail Chasers.

00:09:27.063 --> 00:09:28.396
Oliver: Okay, first of all,

00:09:28.396 --> 00:09:29.464
first of all,

00:09:29.464 --> 00:09:31.191
the most dangerous competition on televison,

00:09:31.191 --> 00:09:32.787
is The Bachelorette.

00:09:33.237 --> 00:09:34.366
Those women have loved,

00:09:34.366 --> 00:09:35.871
and they have lost.

00:09:35.871 --> 00:09:38.976
Love is a reward, but it's also a risk godammit. It's a risk!

00:09:38.976 --> 00:09:40.703
She's putting herself on the line.

00:09:40.703 --> 00:09:42.544
She's there for the right reasons.

00:09:42.544 --> 00:09:44.300
She sees her husband in that room.

00:09:45.700 --> 00:09:46.914
And second,

00:09:46.914 --> 00:09:49.020
it says something about

00:09:49.020 --> 00:09:50.624
how comfortable we all are

00:09:50.624 --> 00:09:52.181
with how our bail system works,

00:09:52.181 --> 00:09:54.579
that a TV show where people with guns

00:09:54.579 --> 00:09:56.633
hunt humans for sport

00:09:56.633 --> 00:09:58.528
seems legitimate because we just think,

00:09:58.528 --> 00:10:01.725
"Well, they're just doing their actual job."

00:10:01.725 --> 00:10:04.270
And when you give bounty hunters this kind of power

00:10:04.270 --> 00:10:05.994
bad things happen.

00:10:05.994 --> 00:10:07.269
Female Reporter: Veteran Gene Travis

00:10:07.269 --> 00:10:10.065
says he was sitting with his wife on his Bethpage front porch,

00:10:10.065 --> 00:10:12.212
next thing he knows his barn is being searched,

00:10:12.212 --> 00:10:15.646
and Travis has a stun gun pointed at his back.

00:10:15.646 --> 00:10:18.183
The intruders Mark Brummett and his wife Angela.

00:10:18.183 --> 00:10:21.703
Bounty hunters who police say had the wrong home.

00:10:21.703 --> 00:10:23.646
Female Reporter 2: Clay was shot by one of the bondsman.

00:10:23.646 --> 00:10:26.819
He was then transported to Ermac where he died.

00:10:26.819 --> 00:10:28.396
Male Reporter: Was a bounty hunter justified

00:10:28.396 --> 00:10:31.294
in tazzing a midwest city homeowner last saturday?

00:10:31.294 --> 00:10:34.498
Was another justified in shooting his dog?

00:10:34.498 --> 00:10:38.050
Police say the videotape they took, says no.

00:10:38.050 --> 00:10:40.071
Oliver: Yeah, the video says no.

00:10:40.071 --> 00:10:42.033
Basic human decency says no.

00:10:42.033 --> 00:10:44.499
Even a magic 8 ball, having seen that would say,

00:10:44.499 --> 00:10:49.571
"Holy shit, I can't believe you're even asking me. NO!"

00:10:49.571 --> 00:10:51.613
Look, our current bail system

00:10:51.613 --> 00:10:53.119
makes no sense,

00:10:53.119 --> 00:10:54.941
and it does a lot of harm.

00:10:54.941 --> 00:10:56.019
And the frustrating thing is,

00:10:56.019 --> 00:10:58.558
we've known this for a long time.

00:10:58.558 --> 00:11:00.360
Just watch this TV news special,

00:11:00.360 --> 00:11:02.386
from 1964.

00:11:02.386 --> 00:11:04.820
Man: Yes, the jails are bursting at the seams.

00:11:04.820 --> 00:11:06.388
A problem of great concern

00:11:06.388 --> 00:11:09.137
to New York City Commissioner of Correction Anna Kross.

00:11:09.137 --> 00:11:12.006
Anna: Remaining in jail because you can't get bail

00:11:12.006 --> 00:11:14.667
is really being punished before you're even found guilty.

00:11:14.667 --> 00:11:16.033
As far as I was concerned,

00:11:16.033 --> 00:11:18.127
that was not just,

00:11:18.127 --> 00:11:21.544
that was destroying our concept of justice..

00:11:21.544 --> 00:11:22.469
Oliver: That's right.

00:11:22.469 --> 00:11:24.048
This problem has been obvious,

00:11:24.048 --> 00:11:28.846
since it was considered okay to wear a wastebasket on your head.

00:11:28.846 --> 00:11:32.022
But look, here's the good news:

00:11:32.022 --> 00:11:33.320
There is a better way,

00:11:33.320 --> 00:11:35.551
and it's already in use in our federal courts,

00:11:35.551 --> 00:11:37.625
and in Washington D.C.

00:11:37.625 --> 00:11:38.990
Narrator: Judges in Washington

00:11:38.990 --> 00:11:40.734
are allowed to set money bail

00:11:40.734 --> 00:11:43.172
only if the defendant can afford it.

00:11:43.172 --> 00:11:45.226
The results have been far fewer people

00:11:45.226 --> 00:11:46.906
spending time behind bars.

00:11:46.906 --> 00:11:49.168
Judge: We are the only city in America

00:11:49.168 --> 00:11:51.978
where tonight, at our jail,

00:11:51.978 --> 00:11:55.308
there is not a single man or woman

00:11:55.308 --> 00:11:58.385
who is sitting because they don't have the money

00:11:58.385 --> 00:12:00.914
to meet their money bond.

00:12:00.914 --> 00:12:02.121
Oliver: And it's a testament,

00:12:02.121 --> 00:12:06.225
it's a testament [applause] to the state of our Justice system.

00:12:06.225 --> 00:12:09.195
that "that" qualifies as bragging.

00:12:09.195 --> 00:12:11.094
That should be the norm.

00:12:11.094 --> 00:12:13.352
He's like a bus driver showing up at school saying,

00:12:13.352 --> 00:12:16.400
"23 kids picked up, 23 kids dropped off,

00:12:16.400 --> 00:12:18.563
I pitched a perfect game."

00:12:19.483 --> 00:12:22.104
Pre-trial services works like this:

00:12:22.104 --> 00:12:23.879
after you're arrested,

00:12:23.879 --> 00:12:26.245
specialists assess if you're dangerous,

00:12:26.245 --> 00:12:27.447
or if you're a flight risk.

00:12:27.447 --> 00:12:29.008
If a judge decides you're not,

00:12:29.008 --> 00:12:30.140
you can go home,

00:12:30.140 --> 00:12:31.748
and they may monitor you with things like

00:12:31.748 --> 00:12:34.018
drug tests or ankle monitors.

00:12:34.018 --> 00:12:36.518
They even call you to remind you of your court dates.

00:12:36.518 --> 00:12:38.209
It's a system built on interviews,

00:12:38.209 --> 00:12:40.366
pre-arranged appearances,

00:12:40.366 --> 00:12:41.481
and trust.

00:12:41.481 --> 00:12:43.257
Much like, Scientology marriages,

00:12:43.257 --> 00:12:46.096
only in this case, much more effective.

00:12:46.096 --> 00:12:48.658
And pre-trial service programs

00:12:48.658 --> 00:12:50.524
have succeeded around the country

00:12:50.524 --> 00:12:53.401
in places ranging from Oregon to Florida,

00:12:53.401 --> 00:12:55.775
and it is a truly frightening state of affairs,

00:12:55.775 --> 00:12:59.510
when Florida is a model for progressive change.

00:12:59.510 --> 00:13:00.766
It shouldn't be

00:13:00.766 --> 00:13:03.215
a judicial example for anything.

00:13:03.215 --> 00:13:04.346
Did you know, by the way,

00:13:04.346 --> 00:13:05.341
that under Florida law,

00:13:05.341 --> 00:13:07.142
if you possess over 5 grams of meth,

00:13:07.142 --> 00:13:08.619
you can marry it.

00:13:08.619 --> 00:13:09.481
That's a fact.

00:13:09.481 --> 00:13:10.989
That's a legal fact.

00:13:10.989 --> 00:13:13.468
That's an actual photo that ran in a newspaper's

00:13:13.468 --> 00:13:15.631
wedding section in Florida.

00:13:15.631 --> 00:13:20.251
And yet--and yet, even counties in Florida

00:13:20.251 --> 00:13:23.135
recognized our money-bailed system is broken.

00:13:23.135 --> 00:13:24.893
And not only is pre-trial services better,

00:13:24.893 --> 00:13:26.194
it's cheaper.

00:13:26.194 --> 00:13:27.732
A recent assessment of one system

00:13:27.732 --> 00:13:30.243
showed it costing only a 10th as much

00:13:30.243 --> 00:13:32.072
as keeping someone locked up,

00:13:32.072 --> 00:13:33.278
which makes sense because

00:13:33.278 --> 00:13:36.678
calling someone to check in costs virtually nothing,

00:13:36.678 --> 00:13:39.548
<This message brought to you by your mother.

00:13:40.158 --> 00:13:42.573
Your mother, she brought you into this world,

00:13:42.573 --> 00:13:44.713
and would like to hear your f****** voice

00:13:44.713 --> 00:13:46.783
once in awhile.>

00:13:46.783 --> 00:13:52.190
So, if pre-trial services are fairer, better, and cheaper,

00:13:52.190 --> 00:13:54.706
why aren't we all using it?

00:13:54.706 --> 00:13:56.867
Well maybe, because thanks to reality shows,

00:13:56.867 --> 00:13:59.603
we think that this is what justice looks like:

00:13:59.603 --> 00:14:01.262
Dog: We're going to hunt this scum down.

00:14:01.262 --> 00:14:04.242
[overlapped yelling]

00:14:04.242 --> 00:14:06.542
Oliver: Bad Dog!

00:14:06.542 --> 00:14:10.750
So, maybe we just need a new kind of reality show

00:14:10.750 --> 00:14:12.884
to get us used to the alternative.

00:14:12.884 --> 00:14:14.984
[police sirens]

00:14:14.984 --> 00:14:16.340
Narrator: You want tough?

00:14:17.250 --> 00:14:18.888
You want action?

00:14:21.798 --> 00:14:23.329
Meet Steve Karn.

00:14:23.329 --> 00:14:24.962
He's one of the most respected

00:14:24.962 --> 00:14:28.560
pre-trial service case workers in the U.S.

00:14:28.560 --> 00:14:30.536
Steve: So, let's see.

00:14:30.536 --> 00:14:33.064
Okay, it looks like you were ticketed with public urination.

00:14:33.064 --> 00:14:36.502
No priors. Seems like a one-off sort of thing.

00:14:36.502 --> 00:14:37.673
Can we count on you to be back here

00:14:37.673 --> 00:14:39.263
in 6 weeks for your trial?

00:14:39.263 --> 00:14:41.181
Man: Uh..of course.

00:14:42.221 --> 00:14:43.908
Steve: Great, we're done here.

00:14:47.847 --> 00:14:50.872
Steve: Uh, I mean no. This is a routine thing.

00:14:50.872 --> 00:14:53.653
Statistically, he's virtually guaranteed to turn up.

00:14:53.653 --> 00:14:54.547
We're done here.

00:14:58.997 --> 00:15:00.322
We're done here.

00:15:01.222 --> 00:15:03.825
Narrator: They call Steve "The Hand Grenade,"

00:15:04.085 --> 00:15:07.094
and he works with a crack team of legal enforcers.

00:15:07.884 --> 00:15:09.196
Meet Debra.

00:15:11.516 --> 00:15:14.248
Debra: Oh hello, this is Debra from Pre-Trial Services,

00:15:14.248 --> 00:15:15.805
I'm just calling to remind you

00:15:15.805 --> 00:15:18.150
about your upcoming court date this Thursday.

00:15:19.140 --> 00:15:20.616
Well, you're welcome.

00:15:22.706 --> 00:15:25.099
Narrator: They call her "The Viper."

00:15:26.459 --> 00:15:33.755
Debra: I feel like a cat, you know [makes cat noises]

00:15:33.755 --> 00:15:35.508
Alright, back to work.

00:15:35.508 --> 00:15:39.726
[♪ hard rock]

00:15:39.726 --> 00:15:41.604
Narrator: And then there's Brett.

00:15:41.604 --> 00:15:43.526
Brett: So all these are risk assessments.

00:15:43.946 --> 00:15:44.966
This is all computerized,

00:15:44.966 --> 00:15:47.302 line:1
but you know I keep a hard-copy,

00:15:47.302 --> 00:15:48.362
just in case.

00:15:49.677 --> 00:15:53.920
Narrator: That's why they call him "The Annihilator." [machine gun]

00:15:55.431 --> 00:15:59.788
And finally, Gerald, the guy in charge of urine tests.

00:15:59.788 --> 00:16:00.950
Gerald: Clear.

00:16:00.950 --> 00:16:02.622
If there is something in there that's illegal,

00:16:02.622 --> 00:16:04.191
I'm gonna sniff it out.

00:16:04.191 --> 00:16:05.631
'Cause that's what I do.

00:16:05.631 --> 00:16:07.156
I'm a piss sniffer.

00:16:10.580 --> 00:16:11.949
We got one.

00:16:12.498 --> 00:16:15.040
Narrator: They call him "The Nose."

00:16:15.040 --> 00:16:17.930
Gerald: You're really going to make a TV show out of this?

00:16:17.930 --> 00:16:19.406
Who's going to watch it?

00:16:19.406 --> 00:16:21.251
Narrator: You will.

00:16:21.251 --> 00:16:22.463
Because this fall,

00:16:22.463 --> 00:16:24.876
we'll bringing you all the thrills and excitement

00:16:24.876 --> 00:16:27.053
of pre-trial supervision,

00:16:27.053 --> 00:16:30.019
as this elite team brings people to justice.

00:16:30.250 --> 00:16:31.956
Steve: Well, we don't bring them to justice,

00:16:31.956 --> 00:16:33.120
it's more like we make arrangements

00:16:33.120 --> 00:16:35.990
for them to bring themselves to justice.

00:16:37.561 --> 00:16:39.933
This show is full of high-stakes drama.

00:16:39.933 --> 00:16:43.936
Debra: You better pray I don't get you for secret Santa this year.

00:16:44.726 --> 00:16:46.405
Brett: You don't want to f*** with Debra.

00:16:46.405 --> 00:16:48.465
Narrator: And inter-office romance.

00:16:48.465 --> 00:16:51.043
Debra: Gerald is a bloodhound.

00:16:51.043 --> 00:16:52.707
Gerald: Oh yeah, she wants me.

00:16:52.707 --> 00:16:54.250
If it wasn't for all them cats,

00:16:54.250 --> 00:16:56.379
I would hit that.

00:16:56.379 --> 00:16:58.518
I would knock the bottom out of it.

00:16:58.750 --> 00:17:00.180
Narrator: But most importantly,

00:17:07.620 --> 00:17:10.122
♪ Filling out forms, and filing them in triplicate.

00:17:10.122 --> 00:17:12.487
♪ We won't lock you up if your crime's not significant.

00:17:12.487 --> 00:17:15.159
♪ If you get a ticket for public urination,

00:17:15.159 --> 00:17:17.594
♪ we won't lock you up so you lose your occupation.

00:17:17.594 --> 00:17:19.869
♪ We ain't kicking in doors, screaming dead or alive,

00:17:19.869 --> 00:17:22.808
♪ this is an office job, we all go home at 5.

00:17:22.808 --> 00:17:25.304
♪ The system works well so there's no need for nervousness,

00:17:25.304 --> 00:17:29.179
♪ it's all in the game at Pre-Trial services.

00:17:29.179 --> 00:17:31.817
♪ [hard rock]

00:17:31.817 --> 00:17:33.562
Narrator: PreTrial Services.

00:17:33.562 --> 00:17:35.716
Coming this fall to A&E.