WEBVTT

00:00:01.145 --> 00:00:02.846
When someone mentions Cuba,

00:00:02.846 --> 00:00:04.925
what do you think about?

00:00:04.925 --> 00:00:07.826
Classic, classic cars?
Perhaps good cigars?

00:00:07.826 --> 00:00:11.926
Maybe you think
of a famous baseball player.

00:00:11.926 --> 00:00:14.353
What about when somebody
mentions North Korea?

00:00:14.353 --> 00:00:16.496
You think about those missile tests,

00:00:16.496 --> 00:00:18.315
maybe their notorious leader

00:00:18.315 --> 00:00:21.155
or his good friend, Dennis Rodman.

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:21.155 --> 00:00:22.457
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:22.457 --> 00:00:24.829
One thing that likely doesn't come to mind

00:00:24.829 --> 00:00:27.021
is a vision of a country

00:00:27.021 --> 00:00:28.643
with an open economy

00:00:28.643 --> 00:00:33.148
whose citizens have access to a wide range
of affordable consumer products.

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:35.527 --> 00:00:40.319
I'm not here to argue how these countries
got to where they are today.

00:00:40.319 --> 00:00:43.968
I simply want to use them as an example
of countries and citizens

00:00:43.968 --> 00:00:46.847
who have been affected,
negatively affected,

00:00:46.847 --> 00:00:50.151
by a trade policy that restricts imports

00:00:50.151 --> 00:00:52.893
and protects local industries.

00:00:52.893 --> 00:00:55.832
Recently we've heard a number of countries

00:00:55.832 --> 00:00:57.882
talk about restricting imports

00:00:57.882 --> 00:01:01.066
and protecting their local
domestic industries.

00:01:01.066 --> 00:01:04.082
Now this may sound fine in a soundbyte,

00:01:04.082 --> 00:01:07.375
but what it really is is protectionism.

00:01:07.375 --> 00:01:11.893
We heard about this during
the 2016 Presidential election,

00:01:11.893 --> 00:01:14.269
we heard about it
during the Brexit debates

00:01:14.269 --> 00:01:18.928
and most recently during
the French elections.

00:01:18.928 --> 00:01:23.847
In fact, it's been a really important
topic being talked about around the world,

00:01:23.847 --> 00:01:26.403
and many aspiring political leaders

00:01:26.403 --> 00:01:31.194
are running on platforms
positioning protectionism as a good thing.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:31.194 --> 00:01:34.114
Now, I could see why they think
protectionism is good,

00:01:34.114 --> 00:01:39.412
because sometimes it seems
like trade is unfair.

00:01:39.412 --> 00:01:41.533
Some have blamed trade

00:01:41.533 --> 00:01:44.791
for some of the problems we've
been having here at home in the US.

00:01:44.791 --> 00:01:46.371
For years we've been hearing about

00:01:46.371 --> 00:01:49.840
the loss the high-paying
US manufacturing jobs.

00:01:49.840 --> 00:01:53.299
Many think that manufacturing
is declining the US

00:01:53.299 --> 00:01:56.580
because companies are moving
their operations offshore

00:01:56.580 --> 00:02:00.250
to markets with lower cost labor

00:02:00.250 --> 00:02:03.047
like China, Mexico and Vietnam.

00:02:03.047 --> 00:02:04.639
They also think trade agreements

00:02:04.639 --> 00:02:06.634
sometimes are unfair,

00:02:06.634 --> 00:02:08.392
like NAFTA

00:02:08.392 --> 00:02:10.300
and the Trans-Pacific Partnership,

00:02:10.300 --> 00:02:14.412
because these trade agreements
allow companies to reimport

00:02:14.412 --> 00:02:18.011
those cheaply produced goods
back into the US

00:02:18.011 --> 00:02:21.112
and other countries
from where the jobs were taken.

00:02:21.112 --> 00:02:24.231
So it kind of feels like the exporters win

00:02:24.231 --> 00:02:26.374
and the importers lose.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:27.203 --> 00:02:28.419
Now, the reality is

00:02:28.419 --> 00:02:31.935
output in the manufacturing
sector in the US

00:02:31.935 --> 00:02:34.188
is actually growing,

00:02:34.188 --> 00:02:35.754
but we are losing jobs.

00:02:35.754 --> 00:02:37.689
We're losing lots of them.

00:02:37.689 --> 00:02:40.341
In fact, from 2000 to 2010,

00:02:40.341 --> 00:02:44.740
5.7 million manufacturing jobs were lost.

00:02:44.740 --> 00:02:49.456
But they're not being lost
for the reasons you might think.

00:02:49.456 --> 00:02:51.860
Mike Johnson in Toledo, Ohio

00:02:51.860 --> 00:02:54.417
didn't lose his jobs at the factory

00:02:54.417 --> 00:02:56.979
to Miguel Sanchez in Monterrey, Mexico.

00:02:56.979 --> 00:02:57.860
No.

00:02:57.860 --> 00:03:01.404
Mike lost his job to a machine.

00:03:01.404 --> 00:03:05.250
87 percent of lost manufacturing jobs

00:03:05.250 --> 00:03:08.383
have been eliminated because
we've made improvements

00:03:08.383 --> 00:03:11.516
in our own productivity
through automation.

00:03:11.516 --> 00:03:15.754
So that means that one out of 10

00:03:15.754 --> 00:03:16.753
lost manufacturing jobs

00:03:16.753 --> 00:03:19.989
was due to offshoring.

00:03:19.989 --> 00:03:22.520
Now this is not just a US phenomenon.

00:03:22.520 --> 00:03:23.583
No.

00:03:23.583 --> 00:03:27.089
In fact, automation is spreading
to every production line

00:03:27.089 --> 00:03:29.971
in every country around the world.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:29.971 --> 00:03:31.621
But look, I get it:

00:03:31.621 --> 00:03:33.171
if you just lost your job

00:03:33.171 --> 00:03:35.428
and then you read in the newspaper
that your old company

00:03:35.428 --> 00:03:37.552
just struck up a deal with China,

00:03:37.552 --> 00:03:39.852
it's easy to think you were just replaced

00:03:39.852 --> 00:03:42.135
in a one-for-one deal.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:42.135 --> 00:03:44.314
When I hear stories like this,
I think that what people picture

00:03:44.314 --> 00:03:49.336
is that trade happens

00:03:49.336 --> 00:03:49.830
between only two countries.

00:03:49.830 --> 00:03:51.756
Manufacturers in one country

00:03:51.756 --> 00:03:53.827
produce products and they export them

00:03:53.827 --> 00:03:57.224
to consumers in other countries,

00:03:57.224 --> 00:04:00.105
and it feels like the
manufacturing countries win

00:04:00.105 --> 00:04:03.635
and the importing countries lose.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:03.635 --> 00:04:07.230
Well, reality's a little bit different.

00:04:07.230 --> 00:04:09.109
I'm a supply chain professional,

00:04:09.109 --> 00:04:12.335
and I live and work in Mexico,

00:04:12.335 --> 00:04:14.450
and I work in the middle

00:04:14.450 --> 00:04:17.376
of a highly connected network
of manufacturers

00:04:17.376 --> 00:04:19.628
all collaborating from around the world

00:04:19.628 --> 00:04:22.914
to produce many of
the products we use today.

00:04:22.914 --> 00:04:25.306
What I see from my front row seat

00:04:25.306 --> 00:04:29.792
in Mexico City actually
looks more like this,

00:04:29.792 --> 00:04:34.711
and this is a more accurate depiction
of what trade really looks like.

00:04:34.711 --> 00:04:38.545
I've had the pleasure of being able
to see how many different products

00:04:38.545 --> 00:04:40.815
are manufactured, from golf clubs

00:04:40.815 --> 00:04:42.255
to laptop computers

00:04:42.255 --> 00:04:44.925
to Internet servers, automobiles,

00:04:44.925 --> 00:04:46.974
and even airplanes,

00:04:46.974 --> 00:04:50.714
and believe me, none of it
happens in a straight line.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:50.714 --> 00:04:53.008
Let me give you an example.

00:04:53.008 --> 00:04:57.939
A few months ago, I was touring
the manufacturing plant

00:04:57.939 --> 00:05:01.156
of a multinational aerospace company

00:05:01.156 --> 00:05:03.175
in ??, Mexico,

00:05:03.175 --> 00:05:07.678
and the VP of logistics points out
a completed tail assembly.

00:05:07.678 --> 00:05:12.106
It turns out the tail assemblies
are assembled from panels

00:05:12.106 --> 00:05:14.548
that are manufactured in France,

00:05:14.548 --> 00:05:16.919
and they're assembled in Mexico

00:05:16.919 --> 00:05:20.360
using components imported from the US.

00:05:20.360 --> 00:05:22.477
When those tail assemblies are done,

00:05:22.477 --> 00:05:24.865
they're exported via truck to Canada

00:05:24.865 --> 00:05:27.007
to their primary assembly plant

00:05:27.007 --> 00:05:29.497
where they come together

00:05:29.497 --> 00:05:30.821
with thousands of other parts,

00:05:30.821 --> 00:05:33.175
like the wings and the seats

00:05:33.175 --> 00:05:36.155
and the little shades
over the little windows,

00:05:36.155 --> 00:05:39.797
all coming in to become
a part of a new airplane.

00:05:39.797 --> 00:05:41.237
Think about it.

00:05:41.237 --> 00:05:43.626
These new airplanes,

00:05:43.626 --> 00:05:45.626
before they even take their first flight,

00:05:45.626 --> 00:05:48.204
they have more stamps in their passports

00:05:48.204 --> 00:05:50.942
than Angelina Jolie.

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:50.942 --> 00:05:54.510
Now this approach to processing
goes on all around the world

00:05:54.510 --> 00:05:57.009
to manufacture many of the products

00:05:57.009 --> 00:05:59.665
we use every day,

00:05:59.665 --> 00:06:02.759
from skin cream to airplanes.

00:06:02.759 --> 00:06:04.167
When you go home tonight,

00:06:04.167 --> 00:06:05.928
take a look in your house.

00:06:05.928 --> 00:06:08.161
You might be surprised to find

00:06:08.161 --> 00:06:10.243
a label that looks like this one:

00:06:10.243 --> 00:06:12.653
"Manufactured in the U.S.A.
From U.S. And Foreign Parts."

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:12.653 --> 00:06:17.667
Economist Michael Porter

00:06:17.667 --> 00:06:20.149
described what's going on here best.

00:06:20.149 --> 00:06:22.410
Many decades ago, he said

00:06:22.410 --> 00:06:24.945
that it's most beneficial for a country

00:06:24.945 --> 00:06:26.594
to focus on producing

00:06:26.594 --> 00:06:32.245
the products it can produce
most efficiently

00:06:32.245 --> 00:06:34.147
and trading for the rest.

00:06:34.147 --> 00:06:34.807
So what he's talking about here

00:06:34.807 --> 00:06:35.819
is share production,

00:06:35.819 --> 00:06:38.765
and efficiency is the name of the game.

00:06:38.765 --> 00:06:41.530
You've probably seen an example of this

00:06:41.530 --> 00:06:44.124
at home or at work.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:44.124 --> 00:06:46.652
Let's take a look at an example.

00:06:46.652 --> 00:06:48.756
Think about how your house was built,

00:06:48.756 --> 00:06:51.215
or your kitchen renovated.

00:06:51.215 --> 00:06:53.395
Typically there's a general contractor

00:06:53.395 --> 00:06:55.459
who is responsible for coordinating

00:06:55.459 --> 00:06:57.135
the efforts of all
the different contractors:

00:06:57.135 --> 00:06:59.669
an architect to draw the plans,

00:06:59.669 --> 00:07:03.285
an earth-moving company
to dig the foundation,

00:07:03.285 --> 00:07:05.301
a plumber, carpenter, and so on.

00:07:05.301 --> 00:07:07.094
So why doesn't the general contractor

00:07:07.094 --> 00:07:09.873
pick just one company

00:07:09.873 --> 00:07:11.243
to do all the work,

00:07:11.243 --> 00:07:12.848
like, say, the architect?

00:07:12.848 --> 00:07:14.785
Because this is silly.

00:07:14.785 --> 00:07:16.770
The general contractor selects experts

00:07:16.770 --> 00:07:19.190
because it takes years

00:07:19.190 --> 00:07:21.702
to learn and master

00:07:21.702 --> 00:07:24.872
how to do each of the tasks it takes
to build a house or renovate a kitchen,

00:07:24.872 --> 00:07:28.349
some of them requiring special training.

00:07:28.349 --> 00:07:29.385
Think about it:

00:07:29.385 --> 00:07:31.542
would you want your architect

00:07:31.542 --> 00:07:33.581
to install your toilet?

00:07:33.581 --> 00:07:35.061
Of course not.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:35.061 --> 00:07:38.489
So let's apply this process
to the corporate world.

00:07:38.489 --> 00:07:41.103
Companies today focus on manufacturing

00:07:41.103 --> 00:07:44.518
what they produce best
and most efficiently

00:07:44.518 --> 00:07:46.985
and they trade for everything else.

00:07:46.985 --> 00:07:49.841
So this means they rely

00:07:49.841 --> 00:07:54.736
on a global, interconnected,
interdependent network of manufacturers

00:07:54.736 --> 00:07:56.052
to produce these products.

00:07:56.052 --> 00:07:58.185
In fact, that network is so interconnected

00:07:58.185 --> 00:07:59.819
it's almost impossible

00:07:59.819 --> 00:08:04.460
to dismantle and produce
products in just one country.

00:08:04.460 --> 00:08:06.796
Let's take a look
at the interconnected web

00:08:06.796 --> 00:08:08.586
we saw a few moments ago,

00:08:08.586 --> 00:08:10.700
and let's focus on just one strand

00:08:10.700 --> 00:08:14.348
between the US and Mexico.

00:08:14.348 --> 00:08:17.867
The Wilson Institute says
that share production represents

00:08:17.867 --> 00:08:23.397
40 percent of the half a trillion dollars
of trade between the US and Mexico.

00:08:23.397 --> 00:08:26.090
That's about 200 billion dollars,

00:08:26.090 --> 00:08:30.006
or the same as the GDP for Portugal.

00:08:30.006 --> 00:08:32.566
So let's just imagine

00:08:32.566 --> 00:08:35.625
that the US decides to impose

00:08:35.625 --> 00:08:40.233
a 20 percent border tax
on all imports from Mexico.

00:08:40.233 --> 00:08:41.317
Okay, fine,

00:08:41.317 --> 00:08:46.423
but do you think Mexico is just
going to stand by and let that happen?

00:08:46.423 --> 00:08:48.085
No. No way.

00:08:48.085 --> 00:08:51.880
So in retaliation, they impose
a similar tax on all goods

00:08:51.880 --> 00:08:54.868
being imported from the US,

00:08:54.868 --> 00:08:57.512
and a little game of tit-for-tat ensues,

00:08:57.512 --> 00:09:02.296
and 20 percent, just imagine
that 20 percent duties

00:09:02.296 --> 00:09:05.444
are added to every good,
product, product component

00:09:05.444 --> 00:09:08.180
crossing back and forth across the border,

00:09:08.180 --> 00:09:11.430
and you could be looking at more
than a 40 percent increase in duties,

00:09:11.430 --> 00:09:14.092
or 80 billion dollars.

00:09:14.092 --> 00:09:15.979
Now don't kid yourself,

00:09:15.979 --> 00:09:18.715
these costs are going to be passed along

00:09:18.715 --> 00:09:22.058
to you and to me.

00:09:22.058 --> 00:09:25.676
Now, let's think about what that impact

00:09:25.676 --> 00:09:29.683
might have on some of the products,

00:09:29.683 --> 00:09:30.998
or the prices of the products,
that we buy every day.

00:09:30.998 --> 00:09:35.249
So if a 30 percent increase in duties
were actually passed along,

00:09:35.249 --> 00:09:39.959
we would be looking at some
pretty important increases in prices.

00:09:39.959 --> 00:09:45.000
A Lincoln MKZ would go
from 37,000 dollars to 48,000,

00:09:45.000 --> 00:09:49.041
and the price of a Sharp 60-inch HDTV

00:09:49.041 --> 00:09:54.294
would go from 898 dollars
to 1,167 dollars,

00:09:54.294 --> 00:09:57.868
and the price of a 16-ounce jar
of CVS skin moisturizer

00:09:57.868 --> 00:10:00.684
would go from 13 dollars to 17 dollars.

00:10:00.684 --> 00:10:07.925
Now remember, this is only looking
at one strand of the production chain

00:10:07.925 --> 00:10:09.264
between the US and Mexico,

00:10:09.264 --> 00:10:12.320
so multiply this out
across all of the strands.

00:10:12.320 --> 00:10:14.578
The impact could be considerable.

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:14.578 --> 00:10:17.305
Now just think about this:

00:10:17.305 --> 00:10:21.303
even if we were able
to dismantle this network

00:10:21.303 --> 00:10:24.983
and produce products in just one country,

00:10:24.983 --> 00:10:27.590
which by the way is easier said than done,

00:10:27.590 --> 00:10:29.987
we would still only be saving

00:10:29.987 --> 00:10:33.953
or protecting one out of 10
lost manufacturing jobs.

00:10:33.953 --> 00:10:37.665
That's right, because remember,

00:10:37.665 --> 00:10:40.382
most of those jobs, 87 percent,

00:10:40.382 --> 00:10:43.701
were lost due to improvements
in our own productivity.

00:10:43.701 --> 00:10:48.410
And unfortunately, those jobs,
they're gone for good.

00:10:48.410 --> 00:10:50.518
So the real question is,

00:10:50.518 --> 00:10:53.155
does it make sense for us
to drive up prices

00:10:53.155 --> 00:10:57.430
to the point where many of us
can't afford the basic goods

00:10:57.430 --> 00:10:59.368
we use every day

00:10:59.368 --> 00:11:01.775
for the purpose of saving a job

00:11:01.775 --> 00:11:05.820
that might be eliminated
in a couple of years anyway?

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:05.820 --> 00:11:09.462
The reality is that share production

00:11:09.462 --> 00:11:11.980
allows us to manufacture
higher quality products

00:11:11.980 --> 00:11:13.329
at lower costs.

00:11:13.329 --> 00:11:15.229
It's that simple.

00:11:15.229 --> 00:11:17.515
It allows us to get more

00:11:17.515 --> 00:11:19.472
out of the limited resources
and expertise we have,

00:11:19.472 --> 00:11:23.766
and at the same time benefit
from lower prices.

00:11:23.766 --> 00:11:25.937
It's really important to remember

00:11:25.937 --> 00:11:28.783
that for share production to be effective,

00:11:28.783 --> 00:11:34.230
it relies on efficient cross-border
movement of raw materials,

00:11:34.230 --> 00:11:37.239
components and finished products.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:37.239 --> 00:11:39.136
So remember this:

00:11:39.136 --> 00:11:41.495
the next time you're hearing somebody

00:11:41.495 --> 00:11:43.464
try to sell you on the idea

00:11:43.464 --> 00:11:46.687
that protectionism is a good deal,

00:11:46.687 --> 00:11:48.328
it's just not.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:48.328 --> 00:11:50.678
Thank you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:50.678 --> 00:11:52.028
(Applause)