0:00:00.500,0:00:01.000
employment laws, good health and[br]safety laws, and that's what

0:00:01.000,0:00:01.500
employment laws, good health and[br]safety laws, and that's what we've

0:00:01.500,0:00:02.000
safety laws, and that's what we've[br]invested in through this

0:00:02.000,0:00:02.500
safety laws, and that's what we've[br]invested in through this Budget.

0:00:02.500,0:00:05.000
safety laws, and that's what we've[br]invested in through this Budget.

0:00:05.000,0:00:05.500
safety laws, and that's what we've[br]invested in through this Budget. I

0:00:05.500,0:00:06.000
invested in through this Budget. I[br]call

0:00:06.000,0:00:06.500
invested in through this Budget. I[br]call Denis

0:00:06.500,0:00:07.000
invested in through this Budget. I[br]call Denis O'Rourke. Thank

0:00:07.000,0:00:08.000
invested in through this Budget. I[br]call Denis O'Rourke. Thank

0:00:08.000,0:00:08.500
invested in through this Budget. I[br]call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you,

0:00:08.500,0:00:11.000
call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you, Mr[br]Chairman.

0:00:11.000,0:00:11.500
call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you, Mr[br]Chairman. I'm

0:00:11.500,0:00:14.000
call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you, Mr[br]Chairman. I'm going

0:00:14.000,0:00:14.500
call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you, Mr[br]Chairman. I'm going to

0:00:14.500,0:00:15.000
call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you, Mr[br]Chairman. I'm going to talk for

0:00:15.000,0:00:15.500
call Denis O'Rourke. Thank you, Mr

0:00:18.000,0:00:18.500
about the Estimates, because that is[br]what

0:00:18.500,0:00:19.000
about the Estimates, because that is[br]what this debate is supposed

0:00:19.000,0:00:20.000
about the Estimates, because that is[br]what this debate is supposed

0:00:20.000,0:00:20.500
about the Estimates, because that is[br]what this debate is supposed to

0:00:20.500,0:00:21.000
what this debate is supposed to be[br]about, as opposed

0:00:21.000,0:00:21.500
what this debate is supposed to be[br]about, as opposed to

0:00:21.500,0:00:22.000
about, as opposed to the diatribe of[br]drivel

0:00:22.000,0:00:22.500
about, as opposed to the diatribe of[br]drivel

0:00:22.500,0:00:23.000
about, as opposed to the diatribe of[br]drivel we just heard from the

0:00:23.000,0:00:23.500
drivel we just heard from the[br]minister.

0:00:23.500,0:00:24.000
drivel we just heard from the[br]minister. I want to

0:00:24.000,0:00:24.500
drivel we just heard from the[br]minister. I want to particularly

0:00:24.500,0:00:25.000
minister. I want to particularly[br]talk about transport,

0:00:25.000,0:00:25.500
minister. I want to particularly[br]talk about transport,

0:00:25.500,0:00:26.000
minister. I want to particularly[br]talk about transport, and begin with

0:00:26.000,0:00:26.500
minister. I want to particularly[br]talk about transport, and begin with

0:00:26.500,0:00:27.000
talk about transport, and begin with[br]Christchurch where

0:00:27.000,0:00:27.500
talk about transport, and begin with[br]Christchurch where

0:00:27.500,0:00:28.000
talk about transport, and begin with[br]Christchurch where I live,

0:00:28.000,0:00:28.500
talk about transport, and begin with[br]Christchurch where I live,

0:00:28.500,0:00:29.000
Christchurch where I live, because[br]all we're

0:00:29.000,0:00:29.500
Christchurch where I live, because[br]all we're

0:00:29.500,0:00:30.000
Christchurch where I live, because[br]all we're seeing in

0:00:30.000,0:00:30.500
Christchurch where I live, because[br]all we're seeing in Christchurch

0:00:30.500,0:00:31.000
all we're seeing in Christchurch is[br]some old

0:00:31.000,0:00:32.000
all we're seeing in Christchurch is[br]some old

0:00:32.000,0:00:32.500
all we're seeing in Christchurch is[br]some old projects

0:00:32.500,0:00:34.000
all we're seeing in Christchurch is[br]some old projects being completed to

0:00:34.000,0:00:35.000
all we're seeing in Christchurch is[br]some old projects being completed to

0:00:35.000,0:00:35.500
some old projects being completed to[br]connect

0:00:35.500,0:00:36.000
some old projects being completed to[br]connect the novshen

0:00:36.000,0:00:37.000
some old projects being completed to[br]connect the novshen

0:00:37.000,0:00:37.500
some old projects being completed to[br]connect the novshen Motorway

0:00:40.000,0:00:40.500
Northern Motorway with Cranford[br]Street

0:00:40.500,0:00:41.000
Northern Motorway with Cranford[br]Street and

0:00:41.000,0:00:41.500
Northern Motorway with Cranford[br]Street and

0:00:41.500,0:00:42.000
Northern Motorway with Cranford[br]Street and connect the

0:00:42.000,0:00:43.000
Northern Motorway with Cranford[br]Street and connect the

0:00:43.000,0:00:43.500
Northern Motorway with Cranford[br]Street and connect the Southern

0:00:43.500,0:00:44.000
Street and connect the Southern[br]bypass, and there will be

0:00:44.000,0:00:44.500
Street and connect the Southern[br]bypass, and there will be

0:00:44.500,0:00:45.000
bypass, and there will be some work[br]on the motorway,

0:00:45.000,0:00:45.500
bypass, and there will be some work[br]on the motorway,

0:00:45.500,0:00:46.000
on the motorway, but that's all[br]we're

0:00:46.000,0:00:46.500
on the motorway, but that's all[br]we're seeing

0:00:46.500,0:00:47.000
on the motorway, but that's all[br]we're seeing in Christchurch,

0:00:47.000,0:00:47.500
on the motorway, but that's all[br]we're seeing in Christchurch,

0:00:47.500,0:00:48.000
we're seeing in Christchurch, and[br]those are very old

0:00:48.000,0:00:48.500
we're seeing in Christchurch, and[br]those are very old

0:00:48.500,0:00:49.000
those are very old projects which[br]we're

0:00:49.000,0:00:49.500
those are very old projects which[br]have been there

0:00:49.500,0:00:50.000
those are very old projects which[br]have been there for

0:00:50.000,0:00:50.500
those are very old projects which[br]have been there for

0:00:50.500,0:00:51.000
have been there for decades and are[br]only

0:00:51.000,0:00:51.500
have been there for decades and are[br]only

0:00:51.500,0:00:54.000
have been there for decades and are[br]only now actually being completed.

0:00:54.000,0:00:54.500
only now actually being completed.[br]What

0:00:54.500,0:00:56.000
only now actually being completed.[br]What we're not

0:00:56.000,0:00:56.500
only now actually being completed.[br]What we're not seeing

0:00:56.500,0:00:57.000
What we're not seeing in[br]Christchurch is any

0:00:57.000,0:00:57.500
What we're not seeing in[br]Christchurch is any

0:00:57.500,0:00:58.000
Christchurch is any work on[br]passenger

0:00:58.000,0:00:58.500
Christchurch is any work on[br]passenger

0:00:58.500,0:00:59.000
Christchurch is any work on[br]passenger rail. The lines

0:00:59.000,0:00:59.500
Christchurch is any work on[br]passenger rail. The lines

0:00:59.500,0:01:00.000
passenger rail. The lines are[br]already

0:01:00.000,0:01:00.500
passenger rail. The lines are[br]already

0:01:00.500,0:01:03.000
passenger rail. The lines are[br]already there, the need

0:01:03.000,0:01:03.500
passenger rail. The lines are[br]already there, the need is

0:01:03.500,0:01:04.000
already there, the need is there[br]between

0:01:04.000,0:01:05.000
already there, the need is there[br]between

0:01:05.000,0:01:05.500
already there, the need is there[br]between Rollaston

0:01:05.500,0:01:06.000
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in

0:01:06.000,0:01:06.500
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in

0:01:06.500,0:01:10.000
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the

0:01:12.000,0:01:12.500
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south,

0:01:12.500,0:01:14.000
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south,

0:01:14.000,0:01:14.500
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south, and

0:01:14.500,0:01:16.000
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south, and

0:01:16.000,0:01:16.500
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south, and between

0:01:16.500,0:01:17.000
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south, and between Rangiora

0:01:17.000,0:01:17.500
between Rollaston and Christchurch[br]in the south, and between Rangiora

0:01:17.500,0:01:18.000
in the south, and between Rangiora[br]and Christchurch, and

0:01:18.000,0:01:18.500
in the south, and between Rangiora[br]and Christchurch, and

0:01:18.500,0:01:19.000
in the south, and between Rangiora[br]and Christchurch, and there is no

0:01:19.000,0:01:19.500
in the south, and between Rangiora[br]and Christchurch, and there is no

0:01:19.500,0:01:20.000
and Christchurch, and there is no[br]action on that

0:01:20.000,0:01:20.500
and Christchurch, and there is no[br]action on that

0:01:20.500,0:01:21.000
and Christchurch, and there is no[br]action on that being taken at all,

0:01:21.000,0:01:21.500
and Christchurch, and there is no[br]action on that being taken at all,

0:01:21.500,0:01:22.000
action on that being taken at all,[br]there is a desperate

0:01:22.000,0:01:22.500
action on that being taken at all,[br]there is a desperate

0:01:22.500,0:01:23.000
there is a desperate need tore[br]infrastructure

0:01:23.000,0:01:23.500
there is a desperate need tore[br]infrastructure

0:01:23.500,0:01:24.000
there is a desperate need tore[br]infrastructure to support

0:01:24.000,0:01:24.500
there is a desperate need tore[br]infrastructure to support

0:01:24.500,0:01:25.000
infrastructure to support passenger[br]rail

0:01:25.000,0:01:25.500
infrastructure to support passenger[br]rail

0:01:25.500,0:01:26.000
rail in Christchurch. Provision in[br]the

0:01:26.000,0:01:26.500
rail in Christchurch. Provision in[br]the

0:01:26.500,0:01:27.000
rail in Christchurch. Provision in

0:01:27.000,0:01:29.000
rail in Christchurch. Provision in

0:01:29.000,0:01:29.500
rail in Christchurch. Provision in

0:01:31.000,0:01:31.500
that's the record of the National[br]Government

0:01:31.500,0:01:32.000
that's the record of the National[br]Government there. In

0:01:32.000,0:01:33.000
that's the record of the National[br]Government there. In

0:01:33.000,0:01:33.500
that's the record of the National[br]Government there. In Auckland,

0:01:33.500,0:01:35.000
Government there. In Auckland, it's[br]even worse.

0:01:35.000,0:01:35.500
Government there. In Auckland, it's[br]even worse. Aucklanders

0:01:35.500,0:01:36.000
even worse. Aucklanders are being[br]absolute

0:01:36.000,0:01:36.500
even worse. Aucklanders are being[br]absolute shafted.

0:01:36.500,0:01:37.000
even worse. Aucklanders are being[br]absolute shafted. What we see

0:01:37.000,0:01:37.500
even worse. Aucklanders are being[br]absolute shafted. What we see is

0:01:37.500,0:01:39.000
absolute shafted. What we see is a

0:01:39.000,0:01:39.500
absolute shafted. What we see is a

0:01:39.500,0:01:42.000
absolute shafted. What we see is a

0:01:44.000,0:01:44.500
absolute shafted. What we see is a

0:01:47.000,0:01:47.500
years 2018 and '28, and the[br]Government

0:01:47.500,0:01:48.000
years 2018 and '28, and the[br]Government has said

0:01:48.000,0:01:49.000
years 2018 and '28, and the[br]Government has said

0:01:49.000,0:01:49.500
years 2018 and '28, and the[br]Government has said that

0:01:49.500,0:01:50.000
years 2018 and '28, and the[br]Government has said that the

0:01:50.000,0:01:50.500
Government has said that the[br]available

0:01:50.500,0:01:51.000
Government has said that the[br]available funds are

0:01:51.000,0:01:51.500
Government has said that the[br]available funds are

0:01:51.500,0:01:52.000
available funds are something that,[br]well,

0:01:52.000,0:01:52.500
available funds are something that,[br]well, will

0:01:52.500,0:01:53.000
available funds are something that,[br]well, will have to be

0:01:53.000,0:01:54.000
available funds are something that,[br]well, will have to be

0:01:54.000,0:01:54.500
available funds are something that,[br]well, will have to be found

0:01:54.500,0:01:55.000
well, will have to be found by[br]Aucklanders, by

0:01:55.000,0:01:55.500
well, will have to be found by[br]Aucklanders, by

0:01:55.500,0:01:56.000
Aucklanders, by the Auckland[br]Council,

0:01:56.000,0:01:56.500
Aucklanders, by the Auckland[br]Council,

0:01:56.500,0:01:57.000
Aucklanders, by the Auckland[br]Council, because the Government

0:01:57.000,0:01:57.500
Aucklanders, by the Auckland[br]Council, because the Government

0:01:57.500,0:01:58.000
Council, because the Government[br]itself has absolutely no plans

0:01:58.000,0:01:58.500
Council, because the Government[br]itself has absolutely no plans

0:01:58.500,0:01:59.000
itself has absolutely no plans in[br]these estimates or elsewhere

0:01:59.000,0:01:59.500
itself has absolutely no plans in[br]these estimates or elsewhere

0:01:59.500,0:02:00.000
these estimates or elsewhere to fill[br]that gap. And

0:02:00.000,0:02:00.500
these estimates or elsewhere to fill[br]that gap. And

0:02:00.500,0:02:01.000
these estimates or elsewhere to fill[br]that gap. And yet, at the

0:02:01.000,0:02:01.500
these estimates or elsewhere to fill[br]that gap. And yet, at the same

0:02:01.500,0:02:02.000
that gap. And yet, at the same time,[br]the Government will

0:02:02.000,0:02:02.500
that gap. And yet, at the same time,[br]the Government will not

0:02:02.500,0:02:04.000
that gap. And yet, at the same time,[br]the Government will not allow

0:02:04.000,0:02:04.500
that gap. And yet, at the same time,[br]the Government will not allow the

0:02:04.500,0:02:05.000
the Government will not allow the[br]Auckland Council

0:02:05.000,0:02:05.500
the Government will not allow the[br]Auckland Council

0:02:05.500,0:02:06.000
the Government will not allow the[br]Auckland Council to impose

0:02:06.000,0:02:06.500
the Government will not allow the[br]Auckland Council to impose

0:02:06.500,0:02:07.000
Auckland Council to impose a[br]regional fuel tax.

0:02:07.000,0:02:09.000
Auckland Council to impose a[br]regional fuel tax.

0:02:09.000,0:02:09.500
Auckland Council to impose a[br]regional fuel tax. So

0:02:09.500,0:02:10.000
regional fuel tax. So it says to[br]Auckland,

0:02:10.000,0:02:10.500
regional fuel tax. So it says to

0:02:10.500,0:02:11.000
regional fuel tax. So it says to

0:02:11.000,0:02:11.500
regional fuel tax. So it says to

0:02:14.000,0:02:14.500
we're not going to give you any[br]ability

0:02:14.500,0:02:15.000
we're not going to give you any

0:02:15.000,0:02:16.000
we're not going to give you any

0:02:16.000,0:02:16.500
we're not going to give you any

0:02:19.000,0:02:19.500
that, there is no action to be taken[br]on

0:02:19.500,0:02:20.000
that, there is no action to be taken[br]on implementing

0:02:20.000,0:02:20.500
that, there is no action to be taken[br]on implementing

0:02:20.500,0:02:21.000
that, there is no action to be taken[br]on implementing a road pricing

0:02:21.000,0:02:21.500
that, there is no action to be taken[br]on implementing a road pricing

0:02:21.500,0:02:22.000
on implementing a road pricing[br]regime for Auckland, because that

0:02:22.000,0:02:22.500
on implementing a road pricing[br]regime for Auckland, because that

0:02:22.500,0:02:23.000
regime for Auckland, because that[br]ultimately is

0:02:23.000,0:02:23.500
regime for Auckland, because that[br]ultimately is

0:02:23.500,0:02:24.000
regime for Auckland, because that[br]ultimately is going to

0:02:24.000,0:02:24.500
regime for Auckland, because that[br]ultimately is going to

0:02:27.000,0:02:27.500
not only to raise funds, but as an[br]essential

0:02:27.500,0:02:28.000
not only to raise funds, but as an[br]essential demand management

0:02:28.000,0:02:28.500
not only to raise funds, but as an[br]essential demand management

0:02:28.500,0:02:29.000
essential demand management tool.[br]Looking

0:02:29.000,0:02:29.500
essential demand management tool.[br]Looking

0:02:29.500,0:02:30.000
essential demand management tool.[br]Looking at some

0:02:30.000,0:02:30.500
essential demand management tool.[br]Looking at some

0:02:30.500,0:02:31.000
essential demand management tool.[br]Looking at some other things

0:02:31.000,0:02:31.500
essential demand management tool.[br]Looking at some other things

0:02:31.500,0:02:32.000
Looking at some other things about[br]Auckland,

0:02:32.000,0:02:32.500
Looking at some other things about[br]Auckland,

0:02:32.500,0:02:33.000
Looking at some other things about[br]Auckland, the Government has

0:02:33.000,0:02:33.500
Looking at some other things about[br]Auckland, the Government has

0:02:33.500,0:02:34.000
Auckland, the Government has talked

0:02:34.000,0:02:34.500
Auckland, the Government has talked

0:02:34.500,0:02:37.000
Auckland, the Government has talked

0:02:43.000,0:02:43.500
that's far too little, far too late.[br]There

0:02:43.500,0:02:44.000
that's far too little, far too late.[br]There should

0:02:44.000,0:02:44.500
that's far too little, far too late.[br]There should

0:02:44.500,0:02:45.000
that's far too little, far too late.[br]There should have been

0:02:45.000,0:02:45.500
that's far too little, far too late.[br]There should have been

0:02:45.500,0:02:46.000
There should have been a much[br]greater provision

0:02:46.000,0:02:46.500
There should have been a much[br]greater provision

0:02:46.500,0:02:47.000
greater provision by central[br]government

0:02:47.000,0:02:47.500
greater provision by central[br]government for

0:02:47.500,0:02:48.000
greater provision by central[br]government for that rail

0:02:48.000,0:02:48.500
greater provision by central[br]government for that rail

0:02:48.500,0:02:49.000
government for that rail link in[br]Auckland. It

0:02:49.000,0:02:49.500
government for that rail link in[br]Auckland. It

0:02:49.500,0:02:50.000
government for that rail link in[br]Auckland. It should have been

0:02:50.000,0:02:52.000
government for that rail link in[br]Auckland. It should have been

0:02:52.000,0:02:52.500
Auckland. It should have been[br]probably

0:02:52.500,0:02:54.000
Auckland. It should have been

0:02:54.000,0:02:54.500
Auckland. It should have been

0:02:54.500,0:02:56.000
Auckland. It should have been

0:02:56.000,0:02:56.500
Auckland. It should have been

0:02:58.000,0:02:58.500
relieve Auckland ratepayers of that[br]burden,

0:02:58.500,0:02:59.000
relieve Auckland ratepayers of that[br]burden, because that

0:02:59.000,0:02:59.500
relieve Auckland ratepayers of that[br]burden, because that rail

0:02:59.500,0:03:00.000
relieve Auckland ratepayers of that[br]burden, because that rail link is

0:03:00.000,0:03:00.500
burden, because that rail link is[br]needed

0:03:00.500,0:03:01.000
burden, because that rail link is[br]needed to relieve

0:03:01.000,0:03:01.500
burden, because that rail link is[br]needed to relieve

0:03:01.500,0:03:02.000
needed to relieve congestion on[br]Auckland's infrastructure

0:03:02.000,0:03:02.500
needed to relieve congestion on[br]Auckland's infrastructure as

0:03:02.500,0:03:03.000
Auckland's infrastructure as a[br]whole. In addition

0:03:03.000,0:03:03.500
Auckland's infrastructure as a[br]whole. In addition to

0:03:03.500,0:03:06.000
Auckland's infrastructure as a[br]whole. In addition to that,

0:03:06.000,0:03:06.500
Auckland's infrastructure as a[br]whole. In addition to that, the

0:03:06.500,0:03:09.000
whole. In addition to that, the[br]Government will spend

0:03:09.000,0:03:09.500
whole. In addition to that, the[br]Government will spend at

0:03:09.500,0:03:12.000
whole. In addition to that, the

0:03:17.000,0:03:17.500
in Auckland, which has a very, very[br]poor

0:03:17.500,0:03:18.000
in Auckland, which has a very, very[br]poor BCR

0:03:18.000,0:03:18.500
in Auckland, which has a very, very[br]poor BCR

0:03:18.500,0:03:19.000
in Auckland, which has a very, very

0:03:19.000,0:03:20.000
in Auckland, which has a very, very

0:03:20.000,0:03:20.500
in Auckland, which has a very, very

0:03:22.000,0:03:22.500
of Transport won't even release it,[br]and

0:03:22.500,0:03:23.000
of Transport won't even release it,[br]and won't see

0:03:23.000,0:03:23.500
of Transport won't even release it,[br]and won't see

0:03:23.500,0:03:24.000
of Transport won't even release it,[br]and won't see it updated because

0:03:24.000,0:03:24.500
of Transport won't even release it,[br]and won't see it updated because

0:03:24.500,0:03:25.000
and won't see it updated because[br]he's

0:03:25.000,0:03:25.500
and won't see it updated because[br]he's actually

0:03:25.500,0:03:26.000
and won't see it updated because[br]he's actually ashamed of it, and

0:03:26.000,0:03:26.500
he's actually ashamed of it, and[br]that

0:03:26.500,0:03:27.000
he's actually ashamed of it, and[br]that is a dog,

0:03:27.000,0:03:27.500
he's actually ashamed of it, and[br]that is a dog,

0:03:27.500,0:03:28.000
he's actually ashamed of it, and[br]that is a dog, that project. It

0:03:28.000,0:03:29.000
he's actually ashamed of it, and[br]that is a dog, that project. It

0:03:29.000,0:03:29.500
that is a dog, that project. It[br]should

0:03:29.500,0:03:30.000
that is a dog, that project. It[br]should not

0:03:30.000,0:03:30.500
that is a dog, that project. It[br]should not

0:03:30.500,0:03:31.000
that is a dog, that project. It[br]should not be proceeding

0:03:31.000,0:03:32.000
that is a dog, that project. It[br]should not be proceeding

0:03:32.000,0:03:32.500
that is a dog, that project. It[br]should not be proceeding at

0:03:32.500,0:03:33.000
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in

0:03:33.000,0:03:33.500
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in

0:03:33.500,0:03:34.000
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in fact the whole

0:03:34.000,0:03:34.500
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in fact the whole of

0:03:34.500,0:03:35.000
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in fact the whole of the

0:03:35.000,0:03:37.000
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in fact the whole of the

0:03:37.000,0:03:37.500
should not be proceeding at all, and[br]in fact the whole of the National

0:03:37.500,0:03:38.000
in fact the whole of the National[br]Government's RONS project approach

0:03:38.000,0:03:38.500
in fact the whole of the National[br]Government's RONS project approach

0:03:38.500,0:03:39.000
Government's RONS project approach[br]to transport is

0:03:39.000,0:03:39.500
Government's RONS project approach[br]to transport is

0:03:39.500,0:03:40.000
Government's RONS project approach[br]to transport is itself a

0:03:40.000,0:03:40.500
Government's RONS project approach[br]to transport is itself a

0:03:40.500,0:03:41.000
Government's RONS project approach[br]to transport is itself a dog. It

0:03:41.000,0:03:41.500
Government's RONS project approach[br]to transport is itself a dog. It

0:03:41.500,0:03:42.000
to transport is itself a dog. It[br]represents what

0:03:42.000,0:03:42.500
to transport is itself a dog. It[br]represents what

0:03:42.500,0:03:44.000
to transport is itself a dog. It[br]represents what is

0:03:44.000,0:03:44.500
to transport is itself a dog. It[br]represents what is essentially

0:03:44.500,0:03:45.000
to transport is itself a dog. It[br]represents what is essentially a

0:03:45.000,0:03:45.500
to transport is itself a dog. It[br]represents what is essentially a

0:03:45.500,0:03:46.000
represents what is essentially a[br]1960's transport strategy.

0:03:46.000,0:03:47.000
represents what is essentially a[br]1960's transport strategy.

0:03:47.000,0:03:47.500
represents what is essentially a[br]1960's transport strategy. Much

0:03:47.500,0:03:48.000
1960's transport strategy. Much[br]better

0:03:48.000,0:03:48.500
1960's transport strategy. Much[br]better alternatives

0:03:48.500,0:03:49.000
1960's transport strategy. Much[br]better alternatives are available,

0:03:49.000,0:03:50.000
1960's transport strategy. Much[br]better alternatives are available,

0:03:50.000,0:03:50.500
better alternatives are available,[br]especially

0:03:50.500,0:03:51.000
better alternatives are available,[br]especially in reinvestment

0:03:51.000,0:03:51.500
better alternatives are available,[br]especially in reinvestment

0:03:51.500,0:03:52.000
especially in reinvestment and rail,[br]which

0:03:52.000,0:03:52.500
especially in reinvestment and rail,[br]which New

0:03:52.500,0:03:53.000
especially in reinvestment and rail,[br]which New Zealand First has as

0:03:53.000,0:03:53.500
especially in reinvestment and rail,[br]which New Zealand First has as its

0:03:53.500,0:03:54.000
which New Zealand First has as its[br]number one priority. That

0:03:54.000,0:03:54.500
which New Zealand First has as its[br]number one priority. That

0:03:54.500,0:03:55.000
number one priority. That would[br]include

0:03:55.000,0:03:55.500
number one priority. That would[br]include

0:03:55.500,0:03:56.000
number one priority. That would[br]include a heavy

0:03:56.000,0:03:56.500
number one priority. That would[br]include a heavy rail

0:03:56.500,0:03:57.000
number one priority. That would[br]include a heavy rail link

0:03:57.000,0:03:57.500
number one priority. That would[br]include a heavy rail link

0:03:57.500,0:03:58.000
include a heavy rail link to[br]Auckland

0:03:58.000,0:03:58.500
include a heavy rail link to[br]Auckland

0:03:58.500,0:04:01.000
include a heavy rail link to[br]Auckland International

0:04:01.000,0:04:01.500
include a heavy rail link to[br]Auckland International Airport,

0:04:01.500,0:04:02.000
Auckland International Airport,[br]along

0:04:02.000,0:04:02.500
Auckland International Airport,[br]along

0:04:02.500,0:04:03.000
Auckland International Airport,[br]along Puanui

0:04:03.000,0:04:03.500
Auckland International Airport,[br]along Puanui Road,

0:04:03.500,0:04:04.000
Auckland International Airport,[br]along Puanui Road, to

0:04:04.000,0:04:04.500
Auckland International Airport,[br]along Puanui Road, to

0:04:04.500,0:04:05.000
along Puanui Road, to the railway[br]system. It

0:04:05.000,0:04:05.500
along Puanui Road, to the railway[br]system. It

0:04:05.500,0:04:06.000
along Puanui Road, to the railway[br]system. It would also

0:04:06.000,0:04:06.500
along Puanui Road, to the railway[br]system. It would also

0:04:06.500,0:04:07.000
system. It would also allow a fully[br]developed

0:04:07.000,0:04:07.500
system. It would also allow a fully[br]developed

0:04:07.500,0:04:08.000
developed passenger rail system from[br]the

0:04:08.000,0:04:09.000
developed passenger rail system from[br]the

0:04:09.000,0:04:09.500
developed passenger rail system from[br]the south,

0:04:09.500,0:04:10.000
developed passenger rail system from[br]the south, from

0:04:10.000,0:04:10.500
developed passenger rail system from[br]the south, from

0:04:10.500,0:04:11.000
developed passenger rail system from[br]the south, from Hamilton, as well as

0:04:11.000,0:04:11.500
the south, from Hamilton, as well as[br]from

0:04:11.500,0:04:12.000
the south, from Hamilton, as well as[br]from Auckland City itself. There are

0:04:12.000,0:04:12.500
the south, from Hamilton, as well as[br]from Auckland City itself. There are

0:04:12.500,0:04:13.000
from Auckland City itself. There are[br]many other ways in which

0:04:13.000,0:04:13.500
from Auckland City itself. There are[br]many other ways in which

0:04:13.500,0:04:14.000
from Auckland City itself. There are[br]many other ways in which the money

0:04:14.000,0:04:14.500
from Auckland City itself. There are[br]many other ways in which the money

0:04:14.500,0:04:15.000
many other ways in which the money[br]could be better spent than

0:04:15.000,0:04:15.500
many other ways in which the money[br]could be better spent than

0:04:15.500,0:04:16.000
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to

0:04:16.000,0:04:16.500
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to

0:04:16.500,0:04:18.000
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to do.

0:04:18.000,0:04:18.500
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to do. A

0:04:18.500,0:04:20.000
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to do. A

0:04:20.000,0:04:20.500
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to do. A tunnel

0:04:20.500,0:04:23.000
could be better spent than this[br]Government is going to do. A tunnel

0:04:23.000,0:04:23.500
Government is going to do. A tunnel[br]for

0:04:23.500,0:04:24.000
Government is going to do. A tunnel[br]for the Manuatu Gorge would

0:04:24.000,0:04:24.500
Government is going to do. A tunnel[br]for the Manuatu Gorge would

0:04:24.500,0:04:25.000
for the Manuatu Gorge would be a[br]much

0:04:25.000,0:04:25.500
for the Manuatu Gorge would be a[br]much

0:04:25.500,0:04:26.000
for the Manuatu Gorge would be a[br]much better expenditure

0:04:26.000,0:04:26.500
for the Manuatu Gorge would be a[br]much better expenditure

0:04:26.500,0:04:27.000
much better expenditure of[br]taxpayers' money

0:04:27.000,0:04:27.500
much better expenditure of[br]taxpayers' money

0:04:27.500,0:04:28.000
taxpayers' money than billions[br]spent,

0:04:28.000,0:04:28.500
taxpayers' money than billions[br]spent,

0:04:28.500,0:04:29.000
taxpayers' money than billions[br]spent, for example, on

0:04:29.000,0:04:29.500
taxpayers' money than billions[br]spent, for example, on

0:04:29.500,0:04:30.000
spent, for example, on the Waterview[br]connection. That tunnel.

0:04:30.000,0:04:32.000
spent, for example, on the Waterview[br]connection. That tunnel.

0:04:32.000,0:04:32.500
spent, for example, on the Waterview[br]connection. That tunnel. And

0:04:32.500,0:04:34.000
spent, for example, on the Waterview[br]connection. That tunnel. And

0:04:34.000,0:04:34.500
spent, for example, on the Waterview[br]connection. That tunnel. And there

0:04:34.500,0:04:35.000
connection. That tunnel. And there[br]are other opportunities for rail

0:04:35.000,0:04:36.000
connection. That tunnel. And there[br]are other opportunities for rail

0:04:36.000,0:04:36.500
are other opportunities for rail[br]that

0:04:36.500,0:04:37.000
are other opportunities for rail[br]that are so

0:04:37.000,0:04:38.000
are other opportunities for rail[br]that are so

0:04:38.000,0:04:38.500
are other opportunities for rail[br]that are so many,

0:04:38.500,0:04:39.000
that are so many, that I wouldn't[br]know

0:04:39.000,0:04:39.500
that are so many, that I wouldn't[br]know where

0:04:39.500,0:04:40.000
that are so many, that I wouldn't[br]know where to begin. But

0:04:40.000,0:04:40.500
that are so many, that I wouldn't[br]know where to begin. But

0:04:40.500,0:04:41.000
that are so many, that I wouldn't[br]know where to begin. But to put

0:04:41.000,0:04:41.500
that are so many, that I wouldn't[br]know where to begin. But to put

0:04:41.500,0:04:42.000
know where to begin. But to put it[br]this

0:04:42.000,0:04:42.500
know where to begin. But to put it[br]this

0:04:42.500,0:04:43.000
know where to begin. But to put it[br]this way

0:04:43.000,0:04:43.500
know where to begin. But to put it

0:04:43.500,0:04:44.000
know where to begin. But to put it

0:04:44.000,0:04:44.500
know where to begin. But to put it

0:04:44.500,0:04:45.000
know where to begin. But to put it

0:04:45.000,0:04:45.500
know where to begin. But to put it

0:04:52.000,0:04:52.500
two years, when billions upon[br]billions

0:04:52.500,0:04:54.000
two years, when billions upon[br]billions

0:04:54.000,0:04:54.500
two years, when billions upon[br]billions are

0:04:54.500,0:04:56.000
two years, when billions upon[br]billions are being

0:04:56.000,0:04:56.500
two years, when billions upon[br]billions are being spent,

0:04:56.500,0:04:58.000
two years, when billions upon[br]billions are being spent, relatively

0:04:58.000,0:04:58.500
billions are being spent, relatively[br]uselessly,

0:04:58.500,0:04:59.000
billions are being spent, relatively[br]uselessly, on major roading

0:04:59.000,0:04:59.500
billions are being spent, relatively[br]uselessly, on major roading

0:04:59.500,0:05:00.000
uselessly, on major roading projects[br]shows

0:05:00.000,0:05:00.500
uselessly, on major roading projects[br]shows

0:05:00.500,0:05:01.000
uselessly, on major roading projects[br]shows that this

0:05:01.000,0:05:01.500
uselessly, on major roading projects[br]shows that this Government

0:05:01.500,0:05:02.000
uselessly, on major roading projects[br]shows that this Government has got

0:05:02.000,0:05:02.500
uselessly, on major roading projects[br]shows that this Government has got

0:05:02.500,0:05:03.000
shows that this Government has got[br]its priorities

0:05:03.000,0:05:03.500
shows that this Government has got[br]its priorities

0:05:03.500,0:05:04.000
shows that this Government has got[br]its priorities utterly and

0:05:04.000,0:05:04.500
shows that this Government has got[br]its priorities utterly and

0:05:04.500,0:05:05.000
its priorities utterly and[br]completely wrong. These

0:05:05.000,0:05:05.500
its priorities utterly and[br]completely wrong. These

0:05:05.500,0:05:06.000
completely wrong. These are not[br]estimates which

0:05:06.000,0:05:06.500
completely wrong. These are not[br]estimates which

0:05:06.500,0:05:07.000
estimates which this party, New[br]Zealand First,

0:05:07.000,0:05:07.500
estimates which this party, New[br]Zealand First,

0:05:07.500,0:05:09.000
Zealand First, can support.

0:05:12.000,0:05:12.500
Michael Wood. I'm very happy to[br]stand

0:05:12.500,0:05:14.000
Michael Wood. I'm very happy to[br]stand and

0:05:14.000,0:05:14.500
Michael Wood. I'm very happy to[br]stand and speak

0:05:14.500,0:05:15.000
Michael Wood. I'm very happy to[br]stand and speak on the

0:05:15.000,0:05:16.000
Michael Wood. I'm very happy to[br]stand and speak on the

0:05:16.000,0:05:16.500
stand and speak on the[br]Appropriations

0:05:18.000,0:05:18.500
Bill and to reaffirm the Labour[br]Party's

0:05:18.500,0:05:20.000
Bill and to reaffirm the Labour[br]Party's opposition

0:05:20.000,0:05:20.500
Bill and to reaffirm the Labour[br]Party's opposition to

0:05:20.500,0:05:22.000
Party's opposition to this[br]particular vote

0:05:22.000,0:05:22.500
Party's opposition to this[br]particular vote and

0:05:22.500,0:05:23.000
Party's opposition to this[br]particular vote and I wonder when

0:05:23.000,0:05:23.500
Party's opposition to this[br]particular vote and I wonder when

0:05:23.500,0:05:25.000
particular vote and I wonder when my[br]comments focus on

0:05:25.000,0:05:25.500
particular vote and I wonder when my[br]comments focus on

0:05:25.500,0:05:26.000
comments focus on in the[br]expenditures proposed in

0:05:26.000,0:05:26.500
comments focus on in the[br]expenditures proposed in the

0:05:26.500,0:05:27.000
expenditures proposed in the area of[br]transport. The

0:05:27.000,0:05:27.500
expenditures proposed in the area of[br]transport. The

0:05:27.500,0:05:28.000
expenditures proposed in the area of[br]transport. The first thing I want

0:05:28.000,0:05:28.500
expenditures proposed in the area of[br]transport. The first thing I want

0:05:28.500,0:05:29.000
transport. The first thing I want to[br]do, actually,

0:05:29.000,0:05:29.500
transport. The first thing I want to[br]do, actually, is

0:05:29.500,0:05:30.000
transport. The first thing I want to[br]do, actually, is pay tribute

0:05:30.000,0:05:30.500
transport. The first thing I want to[br]do, actually, is pay tribute

0:05:30.500,0:05:32.000
do, actually, is pay tribute to[br]Minister

0:05:32.000,0:05:32.500
do, actually, is pay tribute to[br]Minister

0:05:32.500,0:05:34.000
Minister Joyce for his speech[br]before,

0:05:34.000,0:05:34.500
Minister Joyce for his speech[br]before,

0:05:34.500,0:05:37.000
Minister Joyce for his speech[br]before, and