WEBVTT

00:00:00.970 --> 00:00:05.290
Why do people deliberately
destroy cultural heritage?

00:00:06.517 --> 00:00:07.852
By doing so,

00:00:07.852 --> 00:00:11.236
do they believe they're
erasing our history?

00:00:11.471 --> 00:00:13.295
Our cultural memory?

00:00:14.690 --> 00:00:19.544
It's true that we are losing
cultural heritage to erosion

00:00:19.544 --> 00:00:21.244
and natural disasters,

00:00:21.244 --> 00:00:24.178
but this is something
that is simply difficult to avoid.

00:00:24.876 --> 00:00:27.350
I'm here to show you today

00:00:27.350 --> 00:00:29.219
how we can use pictures --

00:00:29.219 --> 00:00:31.063
your pictures --

00:00:31.063 --> 00:00:34.206
to reclaim the history that is being lost


00:00:34.206 --> 00:00:36.446
using innovative technology

00:00:36.446 --> 00:00:38.549
and the effort of volunteers.

00:00:40.282 --> 00:00:42.327
In the early 20th century,

00:00:42.327 --> 00:00:46.339
archaeologists discovered
hundreds of statues and artifacts

00:00:46.339 --> 00:00:48.259
at the ancient city of Hatra,

00:00:48.259 --> 00:00:49.369
in northern Iraq.

00:00:50.164 --> 00:00:53.937
Statues like this one
were found in fragments,

00:00:53.937 --> 00:00:57.042
some of them missing their heads or arms,

00:00:57.042 --> 00:00:59.579
yet the clothing that they are wearing,

00:00:59.579 --> 00:01:01.049
and their pose,

00:01:01.049 --> 00:01:03.332
can still tell us their story.

00:01:04.344 --> 00:01:05.513
For example,

00:01:05.513 --> 00:01:09.271
we believe that by wearing
a knee-length tunic

00:01:09.271 --> 00:01:10.795
and open bare feet,

00:01:10.795 --> 00:01:13.376
this was representative of a priest.

00:01:14.062 --> 00:01:17.907
However, with a closer look
at this particular piece,

00:01:17.907 --> 00:01:22.475
we can see that this tunic being worn
was elaborately decorated,

00:01:22.475 --> 00:01:25.294
which has led many researchers to believe

00:01:25.294 --> 00:01:29.167
this was actually a statue of a king
performing his religious functions.

00:01:31.377 --> 00:01:37.472
When the Mosul Cultural Museum
opened in 1952 in northern Iraq,

00:01:37.472 --> 00:01:38.522
this statue,

00:01:38.522 --> 00:01:39.592
as well as others,

00:01:39.592 --> 00:01:42.756
were placed there to preserve them
for future generations.

00:01:44.533 --> 00:01:48.464
Following the US-led invasion
of Iraq in 2003,

00:01:48.464 --> 00:01:52.328
a few statues and artifacts
were relocated to Baghdad,

00:01:52.328 --> 00:01:54.598
but this statue remained.

00:01:55.546 --> 00:01:57.972
Then in February of last year,

00:01:57.972 --> 00:01:59.394
a video was released,

00:01:59.394 --> 00:02:01.795
and it instantly went viral.

00:02:02.175 --> 00:02:04.470
Maybe some of you remember seeing it.

00:02:04.470 --> 00:02:05.800
Here's a short clip.

00:02:06.266 --> 00:02:10.512
(Video) (Music)

00:02:14.542 --> 00:02:15.543
(Statues falling)

00:02:26.046 --> 00:02:27.047
(Hammers pounding)

00:02:32.967 --> 00:02:33.967
(Music ends)

00:02:34.207 --> 00:02:36.599
Not a very pleasant sight, right?

00:02:37.779 --> 00:02:40.419
Did you notice anything
familiar in the video?

00:02:41.811 --> 00:02:43.084
There it is.

00:02:43.337 --> 00:02:45.987
There is that very statue,

00:02:45.987 --> 00:02:47.746
as it was toppled over,

00:02:47.746 --> 00:02:49.266
breaking into pieces.

00:02:50.076 --> 00:02:52.961
When Matthew Vincent and I saw this video,

00:02:52.961 --> 00:02:54.229
we were shocked.

00:02:55.159 --> 00:02:58.611
Since we are archaeologists
using innovative technology

00:02:58.611 --> 00:03:00.425
for digital preservation,

00:03:00.425 --> 00:03:01.984
an idea sprung to mind.

00:03:02.751 --> 00:03:07.439
Maybe we can crowdsource the images
that were taken of these artifacts

00:03:07.439 --> 00:03:09.278
before they were destoryed

00:03:09.278 --> 00:03:11.221
to create digital reconstructions.

00:03:11.915 --> 00:03:13.039
If we can do that,

00:03:13.039 --> 00:03:15.303
maybe we can put them
into a virtual museum

00:03:15.303 --> 00:03:16.537
to tell that story.

00:03:20.130 --> 00:03:23.658
And so two weeks after we saw this video,

00:03:23.658 --> 00:03:26.797
we started the project
called Project Mosul.

00:03:28.428 --> 00:03:31.201
Remember the pictures of the statue
I showed you before?

00:03:31.715 --> 00:03:36.060
This is actually the crowdsourced
reconstruction of it

00:03:36.060 --> 00:03:37.665
before it was destroyed.

00:03:38.876 --> 00:03:41.023
Now, many of you may be wondering,

00:03:41.023 --> 00:03:42.761
how exactly does this work?

00:03:43.186 --> 00:03:46.465
Well, the key to this technology
is called photogrammetry,

00:03:46.465 --> 00:03:48.921
and it was invented here, in Germany.

00:03:49.990 --> 00:03:53.420
It is the technology that allows us
to use two-dimensional images

00:03:53.420 --> 00:03:56.393
taken of the same object
from different angles

00:03:56.393 --> 00:03:57.788
to create a 3D model.

00:03:59.369 --> 00:04:02.900
I know you may be thinking
this sounds like magic,

00:04:02.900 --> 00:04:03.902
but it's not.

00:04:03.902 --> 00:04:05.285
Let me show you how it works.

00:04:05.285 --> 00:04:08.056
Here are two crowdsourced images
of the same statue.

00:04:09.028 --> 00:04:10.447
What the computer can do

00:04:10.447 --> 00:04:14.686
is it can detect similar features
between the photographs --

00:04:14.686 --> 00:04:16.719
similar features of the object.

00:04:17.669 --> 00:04:20.669
Then, by using multiple photos,

00:04:20.669 --> 00:04:21.692
in this case,

00:04:21.692 --> 00:04:24.397
it can begin to reconstruct
the object in 3D.

00:04:25.021 --> 00:04:26.002
In this case,

00:04:26.002 --> 00:04:29.545
you have the position of the cameras
when each image was taken

00:04:29.545 --> 00:04:30.723
shown in blue.

00:04:32.382 --> 00:04:34.749
Now, this is a partial reconstruction,

00:04:34.749 --> 00:04:35.820
I admit,

00:04:35.820 --> 00:04:37.412
but why would I say partial?

00:04:37.717 --> 00:04:42.396
Well, simply because the statue
was positioned against a wall.

00:04:42.971 --> 00:04:45.574
We don't have photographs
taken of it from the back.

00:04:46.439 --> 00:04:51.415
If I wanted to complete a full
digital reconstruction of this statue,

00:04:51.415 --> 00:04:53.148
I would need a proper camera,


00:04:53.148 --> 00:04:54.149
tripods,

00:04:54.149 --> 00:04:55.152
proper lighting,

00:04:55.152 --> 00:04:57.642
but we simply can't do that
with crowdsourced images.

00:04:58.353 --> 00:04:59.423
Think about it;

00:04:59.423 --> 00:05:00.436
how many of you,

00:05:00.436 --> 00:05:01.680
when you visit a museum,

00:05:01.680 --> 00:05:03.945
take photographs of all
parts of the statue,

00:05:03.945 --> 00:05:05.410
even the back side of it?

00:05:06.506 --> 00:05:10.127
Well, maybe if some of you find
Michelangelo's David interesting,

00:05:10.127 --> 00:05:11.232
I guess --

00:05:11.232 --> 00:05:12.226
(Laughter)

00:05:13.268 --> 00:05:14.781
But the thing is,

00:05:14.781 --> 00:05:18.071
if we can find more images of this object,

00:05:18.071 --> 00:05:19.695
we can improve the 3D model.

00:05:21.233 --> 00:05:23.431
When we started the project,

00:05:23.431 --> 00:05:25.604
we started it with
the Mosul Museum in mind.

00:05:25.604 --> 00:05:27.271
We figured we may get a few images,

00:05:27.271 --> 00:05:28.565
some people interested,

00:05:28.565 --> 00:05:31.068
make one or two virtual reconstructions,

00:05:31.068 --> 00:05:35.827
but we had no idea that we had sparked
something that would grow so quickly.

00:05:36.376 --> 00:05:37.953
Before we knew it,

00:05:37.953 --> 00:05:40.008
we realized it was obvious:

00:05:40.008 --> 00:05:44.659
we could apply this same idea
to lost heritage anywhere,

00:05:44.659 --> 00:05:48.995
and so we decided to change
the name of the project to Rekrei.

00:05:50.107 --> 00:05:52.651
Then in the summer of last year,

00:05:52.651 --> 00:05:55.691
The Economist magazine's media lab
reached out to us.

00:05:56.773 --> 00:05:57.971
They asked us,

00:05:57.971 --> 00:06:00.762
"Hey, would you like us
to build a virtual museum

00:06:00.762 --> 00:06:02.651
to put the reconstructions back inside

00:06:02.651 --> 00:06:03.931
to tell the story?"

00:06:04.298 --> 00:06:06.092
Can you imagine us saying "no?"

00:06:06.092 --> 00:06:07.417
Of course not.

00:06:07.417 --> 00:06:08.533
We said, "yes."

00:06:08.533 --> 00:06:09.713
We were so excited.

00:06:09.713 --> 00:06:12.893
This was exactly the initial
dream of that project.

00:06:13.762 --> 00:06:14.973
And so now,

00:06:14.973 --> 00:06:18.611
any of you can experience
"RecoVR Mosul" on your phone,

00:06:18.611 --> 00:06:19.928
using Google Cardboard,

00:06:19.928 --> 00:06:20.933
or a tablet,

00:06:20.933 --> 00:06:22.575
or even Youtube 360.

00:06:23.144 --> 00:06:26.334
Here is a screenshot
from the virtual museum.

00:06:26.624 --> 00:06:28.411
And there it is ...

00:06:28.411 --> 00:06:30.933
the partial reconstruction of the statue,

00:06:30.933 --> 00:06:34.030
as well as the Lion of Mosul,

00:06:34.030 --> 00:06:36.702
the first reconstruction
completed by our project.

00:06:37.639 --> 00:06:42.453
Although the video doesn't explicitly show
the Lion of Mosul being destroyed,

00:06:42.453 --> 00:06:46.610
we have many other examples
of large artifacts being destroyed

00:06:46.610 --> 00:06:49.751
that were simply too large
to have been stolen.

00:06:50.272 --> 00:06:51.659
For example,

00:06:51.659 --> 00:06:54.445
the Gate of Nimrud in northern Iraq.

00:06:54.757 --> 00:06:57.640
This is a digital
reconstruction from before,

00:06:57.640 --> 00:07:01.005
and this is actually
during the destruction.

00:07:01.506 --> 00:07:03.770
Or the Lion of Lion of al-Lāt,

00:07:03.770 --> 00:07:05.270
in Palmyra, Syria:

00:07:05.270 --> 00:07:07.001
before ...

00:07:07.001 --> 00:07:08.271
and after.

00:07:09.646 --> 00:07:12.940
Although virtual reconstructions
are primarily the main focus

00:07:12.940 --> 00:07:14.033
of our project,

00:07:14.033 --> 00:07:16.634
some people have been asking the question:

00:07:16.634 --> 00:07:20.030
can we print them in 3D?

00:07:20.655 --> 00:07:24.936
We believe 3-D printing
doesn't offer a straightforward solution

00:07:24.936 --> 00:07:26.126
to lost heritage.

00:07:26.438 --> 00:07:28.411
Once an object is destoyed,

00:07:28.411 --> 00:07:29.407
it's gone.

00:07:30.152 --> 00:07:35.029
But 3-D printing does offer
an addition to tell that story.

00:07:35.874 --> 00:07:37.013
For example,

00:07:37.013 --> 00:07:38.891
I can show you here ...

00:07:41.760 --> 00:07:44.698
there is the statue from Hetra,

00:07:44.698 --> 00:07:46.542
and the Lion of Mosul.

00:07:46.542 --> 00:07:47.535
(Applause)

00:07:53.996 --> 00:07:55.144
Thank you.

00:07:55.144 --> 00:07:56.672
Now, if you look closely,

00:07:56.672 --> 00:08:01.203
you'll notice that there are some parts
that have been printed in color,

00:08:01.203 --> 00:08:03.786
and some parts that are in white or gray.

00:08:04.815 --> 00:08:08.617
This part was added simply
to hold the statues up.

00:08:08.934 --> 00:08:11.385
This works the same way
if you visit a museum,

00:08:11.385 --> 00:08:13.690
and a statue is found in fragments;

00:08:13.690 --> 00:08:15.886
it's put together
for the people to see it.

00:08:16.071 --> 00:08:17.527
This makes sense, right?

00:08:18.621 --> 00:08:20.398
However, we're much more interested


00:08:20.398 --> 00:08:23.793
in what virtual reality
has to offer for lost heritage.

00:08:24.520 --> 00:08:27.045
Here is an example
of one of the tower tombs

00:08:27.045 --> 00:08:28.864
that was destroyed in Palmyra.

00:08:28.944 --> 00:08:30.922
Using Sketchfab's online viewer,

00:08:30.922 --> 00:08:36.601
we can show that we have reconstructed
three parts of the exterior of the tomb,

00:08:36.601 --> 00:08:38.530
but we also have photos of the inside,

00:08:38.530 --> 00:08:41.223
so we're beginning to create
a reconstruction of the wall

00:08:41.223 --> 00:08:42.335
and the ceiling.

00:08:42.881 --> 00:08:45.812
Archaeologists worked there
for many, many years,

00:08:45.812 --> 00:08:50.549
so we also have architectural
drawing plans of this lost heritage.

00:08:52.439 --> 00:08:58.845
Unfortunately, we are not only losing
cultural heritage to areas of conflict

00:08:58.845 --> 00:08:59.853
and at war,

00:08:59.853 --> 00:09:02.152
we're also losing it to natural disasters.

00:09:02.978 --> 00:09:07.004
This is a 3-D model
of Durbar Square in Kathmandu

00:09:07.004 --> 00:09:10.528
before the earthquake
that occurred last April ...

00:09:10.528 --> 00:09:11.778
and this is after.

00:09:13.116 --> 00:09:14.460
You may be thinking,

00:09:14.460 --> 00:09:18.113
you didn't create these 3-D models
with only tourist photographs,

00:09:18.113 --> 00:09:19.393
and that's true,

00:09:19.393 --> 00:09:20.893
but what this represents

00:09:20.893 --> 00:09:24.663
is the ability for large, public
organizations and private industry

00:09:24.663 --> 00:09:27.073
to come together
for initiatives like ours.

00:09:29.776 --> 00:09:32.971
And so one of the major challenges
of our project really,

00:09:32.971 --> 00:09:36.420
is to find photographs that were taken
before something happens,

00:09:36.420 --> 00:09:37.420
right?

00:09:37.720 --> 00:09:40.749
Well, the Internet is basically a database

00:09:40.749 --> 00:09:43.048
with millions of images,

00:09:43.048 --> 00:09:44.046
right?

00:09:44.046 --> 00:09:45.054
Exactly.

00:09:45.389 --> 00:09:48.602
So we have begun to develop a tool

00:09:48.602 --> 00:09:52.732
that allows us to extract images
from websites like Flickr

00:09:52.732 --> 00:09:54.205
based on their geotags

00:09:54.205 --> 00:09:55.788
to complete reconstructions.

00:09:56.496 --> 00:10:00.972
Because we're not only losing
cultural heritage to natural disasters

00:10:00.972 --> 00:10:03.411
and in war,

00:10:03.411 --> 00:10:06.380
but we're also losing it
to something else.

00:10:07.998 --> 00:10:09.051
Any idea,

00:10:09.051 --> 00:10:10.869
just looking at these two pictures?

00:10:11.749 --> 00:10:14.413
Maybe it's a little difficult to remember,

00:10:14.413 --> 00:10:16.857
but only a few weeks ago,

00:10:16.857 --> 00:10:21.467
this was the example of human
destruction by human stupidity.

00:10:22.049 --> 00:10:23.351
Because a man --

00:10:23.351 --> 00:10:27.040
a tourist in Lisbon wanted
to climb onto this statue,

00:10:27.040 --> 00:10:29.653
and take a selfie with it,

00:10:29.653 --> 00:10:31.185
and pulled it down with him.

00:10:31.696 --> 00:10:33.709
So we're already finding photographs

00:10:33.709 --> 00:10:35.863
to complete a digital
reconstruction of this.

00:10:37.074 --> 00:10:38.384
We need to remember

00:10:38.384 --> 00:10:42.931
that the destruction of cultural heritage
isn't a recent phenomenon.

00:10:43.764 --> 00:10:45.290
In the 16th century,

00:10:45.290 --> 00:10:51.703
European priests and explorers burned
thousands of Maya books in the Americas,

00:10:51.703 --> 00:10:54.216
of which we only have a handful left.

00:10:55.655 --> 00:10:57.299
Fast-forward to 2001,

00:10:57.299 --> 00:11:00.606
when the Taliban blew up
the Bamiyan Buddhas in Afghanistan.

00:11:01.854 --> 00:11:03.613
You see,

00:11:03.613 --> 00:11:07.680
cultural heritage is about
our shared global history.

00:11:08.920 --> 00:11:12.685
It helps us connect with our
ancestors and their stories,

00:11:12.685 --> 00:11:16.980
but we're losing pieces of it
every day to natural disasters

00:11:16.980 --> 00:11:19.266
and in areas of conflict.

00:11:20.296 --> 00:11:25.842
Of course the loss of human life
is the most heartbreaking loss,

00:11:25.842 --> 00:11:31.702
but cultural heritage offers us a way
to preserve the memory of the people

00:11:31.702 --> 00:11:33.212
for future generations.

00:11:34.429 --> 00:11:38.385
We need your help to reclaim
the history that is being lost.

00:11:39.485 --> 00:11:40.722
Will you join us?

00:11:41.499 --> 00:11:42.501
(Applause)