1
00:00:11,388 --> 00:00:14,444
So you probably have the sense,
as most people do,

2
00:00:14,468 --> 00:00:18,124
that polarization
is getting worse in our country,

3
00:00:18,148 --> 00:00:21,604
that the divide
between the left and the right

4
00:00:21,628 --> 00:00:25,164
is as bad as it's been
in really any of our lifetimes.

5
00:00:25,188 --> 00:00:30,468
But you might also reasonably wonder
if research backs up your intuition.

6
00:00:31,188 --> 00:00:35,868
And in a nutshell,
the answer is sadly yes.

7
00:00:35,892 --> 00:00:37,455
(Laughter)

8
00:00:37,778 --> 00:00:39,794
In study after study, we find

9
00:00:39,818 --> 00:00:43,498
that liberals and conservatives
have grown further apart.

10
00:00:44,298 --> 00:00:49,074
They increasingly wall themselves off
in these ideological silos,

11
00:00:49,098 --> 00:00:53,234
consuming different news,
talking only to like-minded others

12
00:00:53,258 --> 00:00:56,498
and more and more choosing
to live in different parts of the country.

13
00:00:57,578 --> 00:01:00,794
And I think that
most alarming of all of it

14
00:01:00,818 --> 00:01:04,617
is seeing this rising
animosity on both sides.

15
00:01:05,298 --> 00:01:06,954
Liberals and conservatives,

16
00:01:06,978 --> 00:01:08,874
Democrats and Republicans,

17
00:01:08,898 --> 00:01:12,018
more and more they just
don't like one another.

18
00:01:13,178 --> 00:01:15,194
You see it in many different ways.

19
00:01:15,218 --> 00:01:18,874
They don't want to befriend one another.
They don't want to date one another.

20
00:01:18,898 --> 00:01:22,194
If they do, if they find out,
they find each other less attractive,

21
00:01:22,218 --> 00:01:25,314
and they more and more don't want
their children to marry someone

22
00:01:25,338 --> 00:01:27,034
who supports the other party,

23
00:01:27,058 --> 00:01:28,818
a particularly shocking statistic.

24
00:01:29,478 --> 00:01:31,913
You know, in my lab,
the students that I work with,

25
00:01:31,937 --> 00:01:33,954
we're talking about some social pattern --

26
00:01:33,978 --> 00:01:37,514
I'm a movie buff, and so I'm often like,

27
00:01:37,538 --> 00:01:40,498
what kind of movie are we in here
with this pattern?

28
00:01:40,648 --> 00:01:43,928
So what kind of movie are we in
with political polarization?

29
00:01:44,648 --> 00:01:47,368
Well, it could be a disaster movie.

30
00:01:48,448 --> 00:01:50,128
It certainly seems like a disaster.

31
00:01:50,488 --> 00:01:52,488
Could be a war movie.

32
00:01:53,144 --> 00:01:54,344
Also fits.

33
00:01:55,048 --> 00:01:58,864
But what I keep thinking is that
we're in a zombie apocalypse movie.

34
00:01:58,888 --> 00:02:00,344
(Laughter)

35
00:02:00,368 --> 00:02:02,664
Right? You know the kind.

36
00:02:02,688 --> 00:02:05,104
There's people wandering around in packs,

37
00:02:05,128 --> 00:02:06,904
not thinking for themselves,

38
00:02:06,928 --> 00:02:08,544
seized by this mob mentality,

39
00:02:08,568 --> 00:02:11,808
trying to spread their disease
and destroy society.

40
00:02:12,965 --> 00:02:16,711
And if you're like me,
and you're a college-educated liberal --

41
00:02:16,735 --> 00:02:19,933
and statistically, I'm guessing,
the majority of you ...

42
00:02:19,957 --> 00:02:22,900
(Laughter)

43
00:02:22,924 --> 00:02:24,074
are exactly that.

44
00:02:24,345 --> 00:02:25,757
(Laughter)

45
00:02:25,908 --> 00:02:27,644
And you probably think, as I do,

46
00:02:27,668 --> 00:02:31,124
that you're the good guy
in the zombie apocalypse movie,

47
00:02:31,148 --> 00:02:34,846
and all this hate and polarization,
it's being propagated by the other people,

48
00:02:34,870 --> 00:02:36,070
the conservatives.

49
00:02:37,668 --> 00:02:39,548
We're Brad Pitt, right?

50
00:02:40,228 --> 00:02:43,124
Free-thinking, righteous,

51
00:02:43,148 --> 00:02:45,336
just trying to hold on
to what we hold dear,

52
00:02:45,360 --> 00:02:48,943
you know, not foot soldiers
in the army of the undead.

53
00:02:48,967 --> 00:02:50,424
Not that.

54
00:02:50,448 --> 00:02:51,648
Never that.

55
00:02:52,448 --> 00:02:53,944
But here's the thing:

56
00:02:53,968 --> 00:02:56,688
what movie do you suppose
they think they're in?

57
00:02:57,848 --> 00:02:59,064
Right?

58
00:02:59,088 --> 00:03:01,624
Well, they absolutely think
that they're the good guys

59
00:03:01,648 --> 00:03:03,504
in the zombie apocalypse movie. Right?

60
00:03:03,528 --> 00:03:06,504
And you'd better believe
that they think that they're Brad Pitt

61
00:03:06,528 --> 00:03:08,648
and that we, we are the zombies.

62
00:03:11,488 --> 00:03:13,848
And who's to say that they're wrong?

63
00:03:14,512 --> 00:03:19,369
Look, they click on stupid internet links
that say stuff like that ...

64
00:03:19,393 --> 00:03:22,359
We click on stupid internet links
that say stuff like this.

65
00:03:22,621 --> 00:03:28,247
(Laughter)

66
00:03:28,430 --> 00:03:31,383
They complain about living near us,

67
00:03:31,407 --> 00:03:32,589
having to work with us,

68
00:03:32,613 --> 00:03:34,827
even eating Thanksgiving dinner with us.

69
00:03:35,851 --> 00:03:37,684
And we do all those same things.

70
00:03:37,708 --> 00:03:38,858
Right?

71
00:03:39,510 --> 00:03:40,795
Look, it's true.

72
00:03:41,018 --> 00:03:42,922
The studies that I see on polarization

73
00:03:42,946 --> 00:03:45,200
show that conservatives
look a little bit worse.

74
00:03:45,375 --> 00:03:47,105
They look a little bit angrier,

75
00:03:47,129 --> 00:03:48,827
a little more averse to compromise.

76
00:03:48,851 --> 00:03:52,160
And we could tell ourselves that means
that this is not our problem.

77
00:03:52,184 --> 00:03:53,605
That it's them doing it.

78
00:03:54,653 --> 00:03:57,089
But I think that would be taking
the easy way out.

79
00:03:57,113 --> 00:04:00,028
I think that the truth
is that we're all a part of this.

80
00:04:00,708 --> 00:04:03,868
And the good side of that
is that we can be a part of the solution.

81
00:04:04,748 --> 00:04:06,748
So what are we going to do?

82
00:04:07,788 --> 00:04:12,044
What can we do to chip away
at polarization in everyday life?

83
00:04:12,068 --> 00:04:15,884
What could we do to connect with
and communicate with

84
00:04:15,908 --> 00:04:17,628
our political counterparts?

85
00:04:18,188 --> 00:04:22,324
Well, these were exactly the questions
that I and my colleague Matt Feinberg

86
00:04:22,348 --> 00:04:24,206
became fascinated with a few years ago,

87
00:04:24,230 --> 00:04:26,430
and we started
doing research on this topic.

88
00:04:27,388 --> 00:04:30,364
And one of the first things
that we discovered

89
00:04:30,388 --> 00:04:33,844
that I think is really helpful
for understanding polarization

90
00:04:33,868 --> 00:04:35,084
is to understand

91
00:04:35,108 --> 00:04:39,525
that the political divide in our country
is undergirded by a deeper moral divide.

92
00:04:39,549 --> 00:04:44,324
So one of the most robust findings
in the history of political psychology

93
00:04:44,348 --> 00:04:48,044
is this pattern identified
by Jon Haidt and Jesse Graham,

94
00:04:48,068 --> 00:04:49,284
psychologists,

95
00:04:49,308 --> 00:04:53,324
that liberals and conservatives
tend to endorse different values

96
00:04:53,348 --> 00:04:54,548
to different degrees.

97
00:04:55,068 --> 00:05:00,564
So for example, we find that liberals
tend to endorse values like equality

98
00:05:00,588 --> 00:05:04,244
and fairness and care
and protection from harm

99
00:05:04,268 --> 00:05:06,404
more than conservatives do,

100
00:05:06,428 --> 00:05:11,684
and conservatives tend to endorse
values like loyalty, patriotism,

101
00:05:11,708 --> 00:05:15,164
respect for authority and moral purity

102
00:05:15,188 --> 00:05:17,268
more than liberals do.

103
00:05:18,388 --> 00:05:22,444
And Matt and I were thinking
that maybe this moral divide

104
00:05:22,468 --> 00:05:25,564
might be helpful
for understanding how it is

105
00:05:25,588 --> 00:05:28,004
that liberals and conservatives
talk to one another

106
00:05:28,028 --> 00:05:30,444
and why they so often
seem to talk past one another

107
00:05:30,468 --> 00:05:31,684
when they do.

108
00:05:31,708 --> 00:05:33,684
So we conducted a study

109
00:05:33,708 --> 00:05:36,804
where we recruited liberals to a study

110
00:05:36,828 --> 00:05:39,284
where they were supposed
to write a persuasive essay

111
00:05:39,308 --> 00:05:43,748
that would be compelling to a conservative
in support of same-sex marriage.

112
00:05:44,268 --> 00:05:47,524
And what we found was that liberals
tended to make arguments

113
00:05:47,548 --> 00:05:51,724
in terms of the liberal moral values
of equality and fairness.

114
00:05:51,748 --> 00:05:53,484
So they said things like

115
00:05:53,988 --> 00:05:57,364
"everyone should have the right
to love whoever they choose,"

116
00:05:57,388 --> 00:05:59,964
and they -- "they" being gay Americans --

117
00:05:59,988 --> 00:06:02,748
"deserve the same equal rights
as other Americans."

118
00:06:03,308 --> 00:06:06,524
Overall, we found
that 69 percent of liberals

119
00:06:06,548 --> 00:06:11,964
invoked one of the more liberal
moral values in constructing their essay,

120
00:06:11,988 --> 00:06:15,684
and only nine percent invoked
one of the more conservative moral values,

121
00:06:15,708 --> 00:06:19,124
even though they were supposed
to be trying to persuade conservatives.

122
00:06:19,148 --> 00:06:23,444
And when we studied conservatives
and had them make persuasive arguments

123
00:06:23,468 --> 00:06:26,364
in support of making English
the official language of the US,

124
00:06:26,388 --> 00:06:28,924
a classically conservative
political position,

125
00:06:28,948 --> 00:06:31,164
we found that they weren't
much better at this.

126
00:06:31,188 --> 00:06:32,804
59 percent of them made arguments

127
00:06:32,828 --> 00:06:35,524
in terms of one of the more
conservative moral values,

128
00:06:35,548 --> 00:06:38,044
and just eight percent
invoked a liberal moral value,

129
00:06:38,068 --> 00:06:41,428
even though they were supposed
to be targeting liberals for persuasion.

130
00:06:42,428 --> 00:06:46,468
Now, you can see right away
why we're in trouble here. Right?

131
00:06:47,228 --> 00:06:50,724
People's moral values,
they're their most deeply held beliefs.

132
00:06:50,748 --> 00:06:54,148
People are willing
to fight and die for their values.

133
00:06:54,668 --> 00:06:57,364
Why are they going to give that up
just to agree with you

134
00:06:57,388 --> 00:07:00,924
on something that they don't particularly
want to agree with you on anyway?

135
00:07:00,948 --> 00:07:04,204
If that persuasive appeal that
you're making to your Republican uncle

136
00:07:04,228 --> 00:07:06,644
means that he doesn't
just have to change his view,

137
00:07:06,668 --> 00:07:08,804
he's got to change
his underlying values too,

138
00:07:08,828 --> 00:07:10,388
that's not going to go very far.

139
00:07:11,028 --> 00:07:12,348
So what would work better?

140
00:07:13,148 --> 00:07:17,444
Well, we believe it's a technique
that we call moral reframing,

141
00:07:17,468 --> 00:07:20,084
and we've studied it
in a series of experiments.

142
00:07:20,108 --> 00:07:21,604
In one of these experiments,

143
00:07:21,628 --> 00:07:24,764
we recruited liberals
and conservatives to a study

144
00:07:24,788 --> 00:07:27,084
where they read one of three essays

145
00:07:27,108 --> 00:07:30,148
before having their environmental
attitudes surveyed.

146
00:07:30,588 --> 00:07:32,084
And the first of these essays

147
00:07:32,108 --> 00:07:35,484
was a relatively conventional
proenvironmental essay

148
00:07:35,508 --> 00:07:39,524
that invoked the liberal values
of care and protection from harm.

149
00:07:39,548 --> 00:07:42,084
It said things like
"in many important ways

150
00:07:42,108 --> 00:07:44,924
we are causing real harm
to the places we live in,"

151
00:07:44,948 --> 00:07:47,764
and "it is essential
that we take steps now

152
00:07:47,788 --> 00:07:50,708
to prevent further destruction
from being done to our Earth."

153
00:07:51,668 --> 00:07:53,084
Another group of participants

154
00:07:53,108 --> 00:07:55,324
were assigned to read
a really different essay

155
00:07:55,348 --> 00:07:59,788
that was designed to tap into
the conservative value of moral purity.

156
00:08:00,028 --> 00:08:01,964
It was a proenvironmental essay as well,

157
00:08:01,988 --> 00:08:03,484
and it said things like

158
00:08:03,508 --> 00:08:07,748
"keeping our forests, drinking water,
and skies pure is of vital importance."

159
00:08:08,588 --> 00:08:10,084
"We should regard the pollution

160
00:08:10,108 --> 00:08:12,148
of the places we live in
to be disgusting."

161
00:08:12,748 --> 00:08:14,844
And "reducing pollution
can help us preserve

162
00:08:14,868 --> 00:08:18,028
what is pure and beautiful
about the places we live."

163
00:08:19,468 --> 00:08:20,884
And then we had a third group

164
00:08:20,908 --> 00:08:23,404
that were assigned
to read just a nonpolitical essay.

165
00:08:23,428 --> 00:08:26,164
It was just a comparison group
so we could get a baseline.

166
00:08:26,188 --> 00:08:28,141
And what we found when we surveyed people

167
00:08:28,165 --> 00:08:30,364
about their environmental
attitudes afterwards,

168
00:08:30,388 --> 00:08:33,323
we found that liberals,
it didn't matter what essay they read.

169
00:08:33,347 --> 00:08:36,443
They tended to have highly
proenvironmental attitudes regardless.

170
00:08:36,467 --> 00:08:38,884
Liberals are on board
for environmental protection.

171
00:08:38,908 --> 00:08:40,124
Conservatives, however,

172
00:08:40,148 --> 00:08:44,564
were significantly more supportive
of progressive environmental policies

173
00:08:44,588 --> 00:08:46,124
and environmental protection

174
00:08:46,148 --> 00:08:48,204
if they had read the moral purity essay

175
00:08:48,228 --> 00:08:50,628
than if they read
one of the other two essays.

176
00:08:51,748 --> 00:08:54,844
We even found that conservatives
who read the moral purity essay

177
00:08:54,868 --> 00:08:58,364
were significantly more likely to say
that they believed in global warming

178
00:08:58,388 --> 00:09:00,293
and were concerned about global warming,

179
00:09:00,317 --> 00:09:03,044
even though this essay
didn't even mention global warming.

180
00:09:03,068 --> 00:09:05,524
That's just a related environmental issue.

181
00:09:05,548 --> 00:09:08,628
But that's how robust
this moral reframing effect was.

182
00:09:09,548 --> 00:09:13,284
And we've studied this on a whole slew
of different political issues.

183
00:09:13,308 --> 00:09:17,044
So if you want to move conservatives

184
00:09:17,068 --> 00:09:20,164
on issues like same-sex marriage
or national health insurance,

185
00:09:20,188 --> 00:09:23,644
it helps to tie these liberal
political issues to conservative values

186
00:09:23,668 --> 00:09:25,410
like patriotism and moral purity.

187
00:09:26,188 --> 00:09:28,284
And we studied it the other way too.

188
00:09:28,308 --> 00:09:32,124
If you want to move liberals
to the right on conservative policy issues

189
00:09:32,148 --> 00:09:36,474
like military spending and making English
the official language of the US,

190
00:09:36,498 --> 00:09:38,154
you're going to be more persuasive

191
00:09:38,178 --> 00:09:41,514
if you tie those conservative
policy issues to liberal moral values

192
00:09:41,538 --> 00:09:43,418
like equality and fairness.

193
00:09:44,708 --> 00:09:47,564
All these studies
have the same clear message:

194
00:09:47,588 --> 00:09:50,524
if you want to persuade
someone on some policy,

195
00:09:50,548 --> 00:09:54,388
it's helpful to connect that policy
to their underlying moral values.

196
00:09:55,527 --> 00:09:59,284
And when you say it like that,
it seems really obvious. Right?

197
00:09:59,308 --> 00:10:01,084
Like, why did we come here tonight?

198
00:10:01,108 --> 00:10:02,324
Why --

199
00:10:02,348 --> 00:10:03,884
(Laughter)

200
00:10:03,908 --> 00:10:05,948
It's incredibly intuitive.

201
00:10:07,468 --> 00:10:10,764
And even though it is,
it's something we really struggle to do.

202
00:10:10,788 --> 00:10:14,644
You know, it turns out that when we go
to persuade somebody on a political issue,

203
00:10:14,668 --> 00:10:17,404
we talk like we're speaking into a mirror.

204
00:10:17,428 --> 00:10:21,804
We don't persuade so much
as we rehearse our own reasons

205
00:10:21,828 --> 00:10:24,708
for why we believe
some sort of political position.

206
00:10:24,987 --> 00:10:26,558
But, speaking as a liberal,

207
00:10:26,582 --> 00:10:30,114
I believe that we're going to need
a whole new set of arguments,

208
00:10:30,138 --> 00:10:32,373
if we're going to move
the next wave of people

209
00:10:32,397 --> 00:10:36,754
on critical issues like climate change,
immigration and inequality.

210
00:10:37,476 --> 00:10:39,690
And to come up with those arguments,

211
00:10:39,714 --> 00:10:41,484
we're going to have to take the time

212
00:10:41,508 --> 00:10:44,405
to really listen
to our conservative counterparts,

213
00:10:44,429 --> 00:10:46,698
to understand what they value,

214
00:10:47,238 --> 00:10:52,063
and then creatively think about
why they should come to agree with us,

215
00:10:52,714 --> 00:10:55,811
and in a way that doesn't
involve them having to sacrifice

216
00:10:55,835 --> 00:10:57,857
the things that they hold most dear.

217
00:10:59,268 --> 00:11:03,284
We kept saying, when we were designing
these reframed moral arguments,

218
00:11:03,308 --> 00:11:05,948
"empathy and respect,
empathy and respect."

219
00:11:06,508 --> 00:11:07,964
If you can tap into that,

220
00:11:07,988 --> 00:11:09,644
you can connect

221
00:11:09,668 --> 00:11:12,468
and you might be able to persuade
somebody in this country.

222
00:11:13,028 --> 00:11:17,748
So thinking, again,
about what movie we're in,

223
00:11:18,668 --> 00:11:20,244
maybe I got carried away before.

224
00:11:20,268 --> 00:11:22,228
Maybe it's not a zombie apocalypse movie.

225
00:11:22,988 --> 00:11:24,908
Maybe instead it's a buddy cop movie.

226
00:11:25,508 --> 00:11:27,524
(Laughter)

227
00:11:27,548 --> 00:11:29,564
Just roll with it, just go with it please.

228
00:11:29,588 --> 00:11:31,028
(Laughter)

229
00:11:31,948 --> 00:11:34,644
You know the kind:
there's a white cop and a black cop,

230
00:11:34,668 --> 00:11:36,804
or maybe a messy cop and an organized cop.

231
00:11:36,828 --> 00:11:38,884
Whatever it is, they don't get along

232
00:11:38,908 --> 00:11:40,194
because of this difference.

233
00:11:40,988 --> 00:11:44,204
But in the end, when they have
to come together and they cooperate,

234
00:11:44,228 --> 00:11:46,164
the solidarity that they feel,

235
00:11:46,188 --> 00:11:49,828
it's greater because of that gulf
that they had to cross. Right?

236
00:11:50,748 --> 00:11:52,724
And remember that in these movies,

237
00:11:52,748 --> 00:11:55,644
it's usually worst in the second act

238
00:11:55,668 --> 00:11:58,068
when our leads are further apart
than ever before.

239
00:11:58,908 --> 00:12:01,244
And so maybe that's
where we are in this country,

240
00:12:01,268 --> 00:12:03,444
late in the second act
of a buddy cop movie --

241
00:12:03,468 --> 00:12:05,615
(Laughter)

242
00:12:06,068 --> 00:12:09,250
torn apart but about
to come back together.

243
00:12:10,868 --> 00:12:12,524
It sounds good,

244
00:12:12,548 --> 00:12:14,404
but if we want it to happen,

245
00:12:14,428 --> 00:12:17,148
I think the responsibility
is going to start with us.

246
00:12:17,988 --> 00:12:20,148
So this is my call to you:

247
00:12:20,948 --> 00:12:22,948
let's put this country back together.

248
00:12:24,548 --> 00:12:27,604
Let's do it despite the politicians

249
00:12:27,628 --> 00:12:30,484
and the media and Facebook and Twitter

250
00:12:30,508 --> 00:12:32,044
and Congressional redistricting

251
00:12:32,068 --> 00:12:34,788
and all of it,
all the things that divide us.

252
00:12:35,828 --> 00:12:38,068
Let's do it because it's right.

253
00:12:39,388 --> 00:12:43,804
And let's do it
because this hate and contempt

254
00:12:43,828 --> 00:12:45,988
that flows through all of us every day

255
00:12:46,868 --> 00:12:50,044
makes us ugly and it corrupts us,

256
00:12:50,068 --> 00:12:53,388
and it threatens
the very fabric of our society.

257
00:12:55,428 --> 00:12:58,084
We owe it to one another and our country

258
00:12:58,108 --> 00:13:00,268
to reach out and try to connect.

259
00:13:01,468 --> 00:13:04,628
We can't afford to hate them any longer,

260
00:13:05,668 --> 00:13:07,868
and we can't afford
to let them hate us either.

261
00:13:09,348 --> 00:13:10,708
Empathy and respect.

262
00:13:11,348 --> 00:13:12,588
Empathy and respect.

263
00:13:13,388 --> 00:13:17,188
If you think about it, it's the very least
that we owe our fellow citizens.

264
00:13:17,868 --> 00:13:19,084
Thank you.

265
00:13:19,108 --> 00:13:23,070
(Applause)