WEBVTT

00:00:01.341 --> 00:00:05.327
Right now, there's a lot
happening with the Moon.

00:00:05.351 --> 00:00:09.162
China has announced plans
for an inhabited South Pole station

00:00:09.186 --> 00:00:11.041
by the 2030s,

00:00:11.065 --> 00:00:13.652
and the United States has
an official road map

00:00:13.676 --> 00:00:18.473
seeking an increasing number of people
living and working in space.

00:00:18.497 --> 00:00:20.949
This will start with
NASA's Artemis program,

00:00:20.973 --> 00:00:24.926
an international program to send
the first woman and the next man

00:00:24.950 --> 00:00:26.854
to the Moon this decade.

00:00:26.878 --> 00:00:29.576
Billionaires and the private sector
are getting involved

00:00:29.600 --> 00:00:31.367
in unprecedented ways.

00:00:31.852 --> 00:00:35.244
There are over a hundred
launch companies around the world

00:00:35.268 --> 00:00:38.919
and roughly a dozen private
lunar transportation companies

00:00:38.943 --> 00:00:41.905
readying robotic missions
to the lunar surface.

00:00:42.754 --> 00:00:46.619
We have reusable rockets
for the first time in human history.

00:00:47.167 --> 00:00:49.716
This will enable the development
of infrastructure

00:00:49.740 --> 00:00:51.707
and utilization of resources.

00:00:52.227 --> 00:00:54.767
While estimates vary, scientists think

00:00:54.791 --> 00:00:58.902
there could be up to a billion metric tons
of water ice on the Moon.

00:00:58.926 --> 00:01:01.354
That's greater than the size of Lake Erie,

00:01:01.378 --> 00:01:05.351
and enough water to support
perhaps hundreds of thousands of people

00:01:05.375 --> 00:01:07.505
living and working on the Moon.

00:01:08.092 --> 00:01:11.099
So although official plans
are always evolving,

00:01:11.123 --> 00:01:13.738
there's real reason to think
that we could see people

00:01:13.762 --> 00:01:15.555
starting to live and work on the Moon

00:01:15.579 --> 00:01:16.789
in the next decade.

00:01:17.559 --> 00:01:22.148
However, the Moon is roughly
the size of the continent of Africa,

00:01:22.172 --> 00:01:24.934
and we're starting to see
that the key resources

00:01:24.958 --> 00:01:27.232
may be concentrated in small areas

00:01:27.256 --> 00:01:28.562
near the poles.

00:01:29.053 --> 00:01:34.062
This raises important questions about
coordinating access to scarce resources.

00:01:34.872 --> 00:01:38.670
And there are also legitimate questions
about going to the Moon:

00:01:38.694 --> 00:01:40.672
colonialism, cultural heritage

00:01:40.696 --> 00:01:44.723
and reproducing the systemic inequalities
of today's capitalism.

00:01:45.442 --> 00:01:47.268
And more to the point:

00:01:47.292 --> 00:01:50.051
Don't we have enough
big challenges here on Earth?

00:01:50.433 --> 00:01:54.787
Internet governance, pandemics, terrorism
and, perhaps most importantly,

00:01:54.811 --> 00:01:57.500
climate crisis and biodiversity loss.

00:01:58.519 --> 00:01:59.686
In some senses,

00:01:59.710 --> 00:02:03.165
the idea of the Moon as just a destination

00:02:03.189 --> 00:02:05.997
embodies these problematic qualities.

00:02:06.021 --> 00:02:08.119
It conjures a frontier attitude

00:02:08.143 --> 00:02:09.537
of conquest,

00:02:09.561 --> 00:02:11.913
big rockets and expensive projects,

00:02:11.937 --> 00:02:13.812
competition and winning.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:14.671 --> 00:02:17.305
But what's most interesting about the Moon

00:02:17.329 --> 00:02:19.870
isn't the billionaires with their rockets

00:02:19.894 --> 00:02:22.927
or the same old
power struggle between states.

00:02:23.495 --> 00:02:26.140
In fact, it's not the hardware at all.

00:02:26.837 --> 00:02:28.700
It's the software.

00:02:28.724 --> 00:02:31.244
It's the norms, customs and laws.

00:02:31.268 --> 00:02:33.497
It's our social technologies.

00:02:33.902 --> 00:02:37.668
And it's the opportunity to update
our democratic institutions

00:02:37.692 --> 00:02:39.521
and the rule of law

00:02:39.545 --> 00:02:43.559
to respond to a new era
of planetary-scale challenges.

00:02:44.439 --> 00:02:47.660
I'm going to tell you about
how the Moon can be a canvas

00:02:47.684 --> 00:02:50.915
for solving some of our biggest
challenges here on Earth.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:51.550 --> 00:02:56.522
I've been kind of obsessed with this topic
since I was a teenager.

00:02:56.546 --> 00:03:01.294
I've spent the last two decades
working on international space policy,

00:03:01.318 --> 00:03:05.608
but also on small community projects
with bottom-up governance design.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:06.462 --> 00:03:07.870
When I was 17,

00:03:07.894 --> 00:03:11.206
I went to a UN conference
on the peaceful uses of outer space

00:03:11.230 --> 00:03:12.403
in Vienna.

00:03:13.002 --> 00:03:17.429
Over two weeks, 160 young people
from over 60 countries

00:03:17.453 --> 00:03:20.861
were crammed into a big hotel
next to the UN building.

00:03:21.405 --> 00:03:23.412
We were invited to make recommendations

00:03:23.436 --> 00:03:24.603
to Member States

00:03:24.627 --> 00:03:27.565
about the role of space
in humanity's future.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:28.452 --> 00:03:29.834
After the conference,

00:03:29.858 --> 00:03:31.553
some of us were so inspired

00:03:31.577 --> 00:03:34.416
that we actually decided
to keep living together.

00:03:34.779 --> 00:03:39.130
Now, living with 20 people
might sound kind of crazy,

00:03:39.154 --> 00:03:44.665
but over the years, it enabled us
to create a high-trust group

00:03:44.689 --> 00:03:49.228
that allowed us to experiment
with these social technologies.

00:03:49.252 --> 00:03:53.273
We designed governance systems
ranging from assigning a CEO

00:03:53.297 --> 00:03:55.409
to using a jury process.

00:03:55.941 --> 00:03:58.420
And as we grew into our careers,

00:03:58.444 --> 00:04:01.883
and we moved from DC think tanks
to working for NASA

00:04:01.907 --> 00:04:04.400
to starting our own companies,

00:04:04.424 --> 00:04:06.952
these experiments enabled us to see

00:04:06.976 --> 00:04:09.980
how even small groups
could be a petri dish

00:04:10.004 --> 00:04:13.732
for important societal questions
such as representation,

00:04:13.756 --> 00:04:16.016
sustainability or opportunity.

00:04:16.993 --> 00:04:20.741
People often talk about the Moon
as a petri dish

00:04:20.765 --> 00:04:22.610
or even a blank slate.

00:04:23.506 --> 00:04:27.797
But because of the legal agreements
that govern the Moon,

00:04:27.821 --> 00:04:30.989
it actually has something
very important in common

00:04:31.013 --> 00:04:33.608
with our global challenges here on Earth.

00:04:34.343 --> 00:04:40.538
They both involve issues that require us
to think beyond territory and borders,

00:04:40.562 --> 00:04:43.166
meaning the Moon is actually
more of a template

00:04:43.190 --> 00:04:44.778
than a blank slate.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:45.922 --> 00:04:51.288
Signed in 1967, the Outer Space Treaty
is the defining treaty

00:04:51.312 --> 00:04:53.466
governing activities in outer space,

00:04:53.490 --> 00:04:54.829
including the Moon.

00:04:55.645 --> 00:04:57.804
And it has two key ingredients

00:04:57.828 --> 00:05:02.357
that radically alter the basis
on which laws can be constructed.

00:05:02.904 --> 00:05:08.966
The first is a requirement for free access
to all areas of a celestial body.

00:05:09.935 --> 00:05:13.951
And the second is that the Moon
and other celestial bodies

00:05:13.975 --> 00:05:17.598
are not subject to national appropriation.

00:05:17.622 --> 00:05:20.406
Now, this is crazy,

00:05:20.430 --> 00:05:24.168
because the entire earthly
international system --

00:05:24.192 --> 00:05:25.418
the United Nations,

00:05:25.442 --> 00:05:28.294
the system of treaties
and international agreements --

00:05:28.318 --> 00:05:31.588
is built on the idea of state sovereignty,

00:05:31.612 --> 00:05:34.919
on the appropriation of land
and resources within borders

00:05:34.943 --> 00:05:38.744
and the autonomy to control free access
within those borders.

00:05:39.618 --> 00:05:41.839
By doing away with both of these,

00:05:41.863 --> 00:05:45.132
we create the conditions
for what are called the "commons."

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:45.719 --> 00:05:49.912
Based on the work of Nobel
Prize-winning economist Elinor Ostrom,

00:05:49.936 --> 00:05:53.743
global commons are those resources
that we all share

00:05:53.767 --> 00:05:56.645
that require us to work together
to manage and protect

00:05:56.669 --> 00:06:00.551
important aspects
of our survival and well-being,

00:06:00.575 --> 00:06:02.970
like climate or the oceans.

00:06:03.414 --> 00:06:07.748
Commons-based approaches offer
a greenfield for institution design

00:06:07.772 --> 00:06:09.581
that's only beginning to be explored

00:06:09.605 --> 00:06:12.741
at the global and interplanetary level.

00:06:12.765 --> 00:06:14.445
What do property rights look like?

00:06:14.469 --> 00:06:16.208
And how do we manage resources

00:06:16.232 --> 00:06:20.668
when the traditional tools
of external authority and private property

00:06:20.692 --> 00:06:21.902
don't apply?

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:22.429 --> 00:06:24.687
Though we don't have all the answers,

00:06:24.711 --> 00:06:27.822
climate, internet governance,
authoritarianism --

00:06:27.846 --> 00:06:30.593
these are all deeply existential threats

00:06:30.617 --> 00:06:33.665
that we have failed to address
with our current ways of thinking.

00:06:34.486 --> 00:06:38.580
Successful paths forward
will require us to develop new tools.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:39.143 --> 00:06:43.014
So how do we incorporate
commons-based logic

00:06:43.038 --> 00:06:46.399
into our global and space institutions?

00:06:47.088 --> 00:06:51.862
Well, here's one attempt
that came from an unlikely source.

00:06:51.886 --> 00:06:54.810
As a young activist in World War II,

00:06:54.834 --> 00:06:58.134
Arvid Pardo was arrested
for anti-fascist organizing

00:06:58.158 --> 00:07:01.340
and held under death sentence
by the Gestapo.

00:07:01.856 --> 00:07:03.105
After the war,

00:07:03.129 --> 00:07:06.092
he worked his way
into the diplomatic corps,

00:07:06.116 --> 00:07:09.779
eventually becoming the first
permanent representative of Malta

00:07:09.803 --> 00:07:11.528
to the United Nations.

00:07:11.552 --> 00:07:15.197
Pardo saw that international law
did not have the tools

00:07:15.221 --> 00:07:18.248
to address management
of shared global resources,

00:07:18.272 --> 00:07:19.976
such as the high seas.

00:07:20.683 --> 00:07:25.796
He also saw an opportunity to advocate
for equitable sharing between nations.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:26.156 --> 00:07:31.310
In 1967, Pardo gave a famous speech
to the United Nations,

00:07:31.334 --> 00:07:32.959
introducing the idea

00:07:32.983 --> 00:07:38.706
that the oceans and their resources
were the "common heritage of mankind."

00:07:38.730 --> 00:07:43.071
The phrase was eventually adopted
as part of the Law of the Sea Treaty,

00:07:43.095 --> 00:07:46.243
probably the most sophisticated
commons-management regime

00:07:46.267 --> 00:07:47.665
on the planet today.

00:07:48.070 --> 00:07:50.603
It was seen as a watershed moment,

00:07:50.627 --> 00:07:53.125
a constitution for the seas.

00:07:53.760 --> 00:07:56.749
But the language proved so controversial

00:07:56.773 --> 00:07:59.729
that it took over 12 years
to gain enough signatures

00:07:59.753 --> 00:08:01.889
for the treaty to enter into force,

00:08:01.913 --> 00:08:05.064
and some states still refuse to sign it.

00:08:06.208 --> 00:08:10.145
The objection was not so much
about sharing per se,

00:08:10.169 --> 00:08:12.370
but the obligation to share.

00:08:13.124 --> 00:08:18.314
States felt that the principle of equality
undermined their autonomy

00:08:18.338 --> 00:08:20.719
and state sovereignty,

00:08:20.743 --> 00:08:25.615
the same autonomy and state sovereignty
that underpins international law.

00:08:26.631 --> 00:08:29.030
So in many ways,

00:08:29.054 --> 00:08:31.622
the story of the common heritage principle

00:08:31.646 --> 00:08:32.930
is a tragedy.

00:08:33.819 --> 00:08:36.788
But it's powerful because it makes plain

00:08:36.812 --> 00:08:42.433
the ways in which the current world order
will put up antibodies and defenses

00:08:42.457 --> 00:08:45.378
and resist attempts at structural reform.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:46.870 --> 00:08:49.087
But here's the thing:

00:08:49.111 --> 00:08:53.015
the Outer Space Treaty has already
made these structural reforms.

00:08:53.832 --> 00:08:55.426
At the height of the Cold War,

00:08:55.450 --> 00:08:58.241
terrified that each
would get to the Moon first,

00:08:58.265 --> 00:09:00.476
the United States and the USSR

00:09:00.500 --> 00:09:04.099
made the Westphalian equivalent
of a deal with the devil.

00:09:04.613 --> 00:09:09.373
By requiring free access
and preventing territorial appropriation,

00:09:09.397 --> 00:09:13.403
we are required to redesign
our most basic institutions,

00:09:13.427 --> 00:09:15.197
and perhaps in doing so,

00:09:15.221 --> 00:09:18.024
learn something new
we can apply here on Earth.

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:18.808 --> 00:09:22.865
So although the Moon might seem
a little far away sometimes,

00:09:22.889 --> 00:09:25.358
how we answer basic questions now

00:09:25.382 --> 00:09:28.500
will set precedent
for who has a seat at the table

00:09:28.524 --> 00:09:30.316
and what consent looks like.

00:09:30.928 --> 00:09:33.751
And these are questions
of social technology,

00:09:33.775 --> 00:09:35.789
not rockets and hardware.

NOTE Paragraph

00:09:36.703 --> 00:09:40.818
In fact, these conversations
are starting to happen right now.

00:09:41.381 --> 00:09:44.589
The space community is discussing
basic shared agreements,

00:09:44.613 --> 00:09:49.264
such as how do we designate
lunar areas as heritage sites,

00:09:49.288 --> 00:09:52.184
and how do we get permission
for where to land

00:09:52.208 --> 00:09:54.456
when traditional external authority

00:09:54.480 --> 00:09:56.098
doesn't apply?

00:09:56.122 --> 00:09:59.096
How do we enforce requirements
for coordination

00:09:59.120 --> 00:10:02.197
when it's against the rules
to tell people where to go?

00:10:02.727 --> 00:10:06.338
And how do we manage
access to scarce resources

00:10:06.362 --> 00:10:08.706
such as water, minerals,

00:10:08.730 --> 00:10:12.015
or even the peaks of eternal light --

00:10:12.039 --> 00:10:14.668
craters that sit
at just the right latitude

00:10:14.692 --> 00:10:17.355
to receive near-constant
exposure to sunlight --

00:10:17.379 --> 00:10:19.127
and therefore, power?

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:19.151 --> 00:10:23.151
Now, some people think
that the lack of rules on the Moon

00:10:23.175 --> 00:10:24.738
is terrifying.

00:10:24.762 --> 00:10:28.794
And there are legitimately
some terrifying elements of it.

00:10:29.961 --> 00:10:31.821
If there are no rules on the Moon,

00:10:31.845 --> 00:10:35.737
then won't we end up
in a first-come, first-served situation?

00:10:36.451 --> 00:10:38.464
And we might,

00:10:38.488 --> 00:10:40.700
if we dismiss this moment.

00:10:41.470 --> 00:10:45.732
But not if we're willing to be bold
and to engage the challenge.

00:10:46.826 --> 00:10:49.538
As we learned in our communities
of self-governance,

00:10:49.562 --> 00:10:54.099
it's easier to create something new
than trying to dismantle the old.

00:10:54.821 --> 00:10:56.681
And where else but the Moon

00:10:56.705 --> 00:11:00.900
can we prototype
new institutions at global scale

00:11:00.924 --> 00:11:04.903
in a self-contained environment
with the exact design constraints needed

00:11:04.927 --> 00:11:07.721
for our biggest challenges here on Earth?

00:11:09.197 --> 00:11:11.042
Back in 1999,

00:11:11.066 --> 00:11:14.546
the United Nations taught
a group of young space geeks

00:11:14.570 --> 00:11:16.731
that we could think bigger,

00:11:16.755 --> 00:11:19.899
that we could impact nations
if we chose to.

00:11:20.645 --> 00:11:24.340
Today, the stage is set for the next step:

00:11:24.364 --> 00:11:28.340
to envision what comes after
territory and borders.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:29.227 --> 00:11:30.379
Thank you.