0:00:06.738,0:00:10.329
Why does salt dissolve in water but oil doesn't?

0:00:10.329,0:00:12.124
Well, in a word, chemistry,

0:00:12.124,0:00:14.328
but that's not very satisfying, is it?

0:00:14.328,0:00:17.442
Well, the reason salt dissolves and oil does not

0:00:17.442,0:00:19.152
comes down to the two big reasons

0:00:19.152,0:00:21.348
why anything happens at all:

0:00:21.348,0:00:22.281
energetics

0:00:22.281,0:00:23.489
and entropy.

0:00:23.489,0:00:25.322
Energetics deals primarily

0:00:25.322,0:00:28.203
with the attractive forces between things.

0:00:28.203,0:00:31.155
When we look at oil or salt in water,

0:00:31.155,0:00:34.152
we focus on the forces between particles

0:00:34.152,0:00:36.779
on a very, very, very small scale,

0:00:36.779,0:00:38.180
the molecular level.

0:00:38.180,0:00:39.898
To give you a sense of this scale,

0:00:39.898,0:00:41.599
in one glass of water,

0:00:41.599,0:00:43.110
there are more molecules

0:00:43.110,0:00:45.816
than known stars in the universe.

0:00:45.816,0:00:49.448
Now, all of these molecules are in constant motion,

0:00:49.448,0:00:52.460
moving, vibrating, and rotating.

0:00:52.460,0:00:54.774
What prevents almost all of those molecules

0:00:54.774,0:00:56.858
from just flying out of the glass

0:00:56.858,0:01:00.027
are the attractive interactions between molecules.

0:01:00.027,0:01:01.230
The strength of the interactions

0:01:01.230,0:01:04.482
between water, itself, and other substances

0:01:04.482,0:01:07.733
is what we mean when we say energetics.

0:01:07.733,0:01:09.874
You can think of the water molecules engaging

0:01:09.874,0:01:11.419
in a constant dance,

0:01:11.419,0:01:13.047
sort of like a square dance

0:01:13.047,0:01:16.501
where they constantly and randomly exchange partners.

0:01:16.501,0:01:19.185
Put simply, the ability for substances

0:01:19.185,0:01:20.676
to interact with water,

0:01:20.676,0:01:22.298
balanced with how they disrupt

0:01:22.298,0:01:24.881
how water interacts with itself,

0:01:24.881,0:01:27.230
plays an important role in explaining

0:01:27.230,0:01:29.899
why certain things mix well into water

0:01:29.899,0:01:31.649
and others don't.

0:01:32.048,0:01:33.912
Entropy basically describes

0:01:33.912,0:01:36.631
the way things and energy can be arranged

0:01:36.631,0:01:38.503
based on random motion.

0:01:38.503,0:01:41.200
For example, think of the air in a room.

0:01:41.200,0:01:44.062
Imagine all the different possible arrangements

0:01:44.062,0:01:46.650
in space for the trillions of particles

0:01:46.650,0:01:48.131
that make up the air.

0:01:48.131,0:01:49.167
Some of those arrangments

0:01:49.167,0:01:52.163
might have all the oxygen molecules over here

0:01:52.163,0:01:54.814
and all the nitrogen molecules over there,

0:01:54.814,0:01:55.855
separated.

0:01:55.855,0:01:58.023
But far more of those possible arrangments

0:01:58.023,0:02:01.023
have those molecules mixed up with one another.

0:02:01.023,0:02:03.481
So, entropy favors mixing.

0:02:03.481,0:02:06.334
Energetics deals with attractive forces.

0:02:06.334,0:02:08.417
And so, if attractive forces are present,

0:02:08.417,0:02:10.321
the probability of some arrangements

0:02:10.321,0:02:11.500
can be enhanced,

0:02:11.500,0:02:13.780
the ones where things are attracted to each other.

0:02:13.780,0:02:16.294
So, it is always the balance of these two things

0:02:16.294,0:02:18.871
that determines what happens.

0:02:18.871,0:02:20.285
On the molecular level,

0:02:20.285,0:02:22.664
water is comprised of water molecules,

0:02:22.664,0:02:25.829
made up of two hydrogen atoms and an oxygen atom.

0:02:25.829,0:02:28.497
As liquid water, these molecules are engaged

0:02:28.497,0:02:30.831
in a constant and random square dance

0:02:30.831,0:02:34.386
that is called the hydrogen-bonding network.

0:02:34.386,0:02:35.771
Entropy favors keeping

0:02:35.771,0:02:38.018
the square dance going at all times.

0:02:38.018,0:02:39.314
There are always more ways

0:02:39.314,0:02:41.142
that all the water molecules can arrange

0:02:41.142,0:02:42.349
in a square dance,

0:02:42.349,0:02:44.079
as compared to if the water molecules

0:02:44.079,0:02:45.421
did a line dance.

0:02:45.421,0:02:47.781
So, the square dance constantly goes on.

0:02:47.781,0:02:50.750
So, what happens when you put salt in the water?

0:02:50.750,0:02:52.748
Well, on the molecular level,

0:02:52.748,0:02:55.584
salt is actually made up of two different ions,

0:02:55.584,0:02:57.838
chlorine and sodium,

0:02:57.838,0:03:00.082
that are organized like a brick wall.

0:03:00.082,0:03:01.502
They show up to the dance

0:03:01.502,0:03:03.386
as a big group in formation

0:03:03.386,0:03:05.040
and sit on the side at first,

0:03:05.040,0:03:07.431
shy and a bit reluctant to break apart

0:03:07.431,0:03:10.272
into individual ions to join the dance.

0:03:10.272,0:03:12.456
But secretly, those shy dancers

0:03:12.456,0:03:15.009
just want someone to ask them to join.

0:03:15.009,0:03:18.233
So, when a water randomly bumps into one of them

0:03:18.233,0:03:20.817
and pulls them into the dance away from their group,

0:03:20.817,0:03:21.983
they go.

0:03:21.983,0:03:23.362
And once they go into the dance,

0:03:23.362,0:03:24.948
they don't come back out.

0:03:24.948,0:03:27.352
And in fact, the addition of the salt ions

0:03:27.352,0:03:29.412
adds more possible dance positions

0:03:29.412,0:03:30.790
in the square dance,

0:03:30.790,0:03:33.973
so it is favored for them to stay dancing with water.

0:03:35.156,0:03:37.119
Now, let's take oil.

0:03:37.119,0:03:39.800
With oil, the molecules are sort of interested

0:03:39.800,0:03:40.887
in dancing with water,

0:03:40.887,0:03:43.138
so entropy favors them joining the dance.

0:03:43.138,0:03:45.193
The problem is that oil molecules

0:03:45.193,0:03:47.471
are wearing gigantic ballgowns,

0:03:47.471,0:03:50.040
and they're way bigger than water molecules.

0:03:50.040,0:03:52.474
So, when an oil molecule gets pulled in,

0:03:52.474,0:03:55.299
their size is really disruptive to the dance

0:03:55.299,0:03:56.919
and the random exchange of partners

0:03:56.919,0:03:58.622
that the waters engage in,

0:03:58.622,0:04:00.329
a very important part of the dance.

0:04:00.329,0:04:02.885
In addition, they are not great dancers.

0:04:02.885,0:04:04.805
The water molecules try to engage

0:04:04.805,0:04:06.464
the oil molecules in the dance,

0:04:06.464,0:04:08.890
but they just keep bumping into their dresses

0:04:08.890,0:04:11.055
and taking up all the room on the dance floor.

0:04:11.055,0:04:13.723
There are way more ways the waters can dance

0:04:13.723,0:04:15.765
when the oil gets off the floor,

0:04:15.765,0:04:18.214
so the waters squeeze out the oil,

0:04:18.214,0:04:20.803
pushing it back to the bench with the others.

0:04:20.803,0:04:22.887
Pretty soon, when a large number of oils

0:04:22.887,0:04:24.971
have been squeezed over to the side,

0:04:24.971,0:04:27.028
they band together to commiserate

0:04:27.028,0:04:29.455
about how unfair the waters are being

0:04:29.455,0:04:31.408
and stick together as a group.

0:04:31.408,0:04:32.746
So, it is this combination

0:04:32.746,0:04:35.082
of the interactions between molecules

0:04:35.082,0:04:37.472
and the configurations available to them

0:04:37.472,0:04:38.890
when they're moving randomly

0:04:38.890,0:04:41.216
that dictates whether they mix.

0:04:41.216,0:04:43.637
In other words, water and oil don't mix

0:04:43.637,0:04:47.217
because they just don't make great dance partners.