0:00:00.913,0:00:03.110
I am a neurosurgeon,

0:00:03.134,0:00:07.462
and I'm here to tell you today[br]that people like me need your help.

0:00:08.119,0:00:10.143
And in a few moments, I will tell you how.

0:00:10.167,0:00:14.287
But first, let me start off by telling you[br]about a patient of mine.

0:00:14.311,0:00:16.954
This was a woman in her 50s,

0:00:16.978,0:00:19.025
she was in generally good shape,

0:00:19.049,0:00:21.437
but she had been in and out[br]of hospital a few times

0:00:21.461,0:00:24.688
due to curative breast cancer treatment.

0:00:25.768,0:00:28.641
Now she had gotten a prolapse[br]from a cervical disc,

0:00:28.665,0:00:32.339
giving her radiating pain of a tense kind,

0:00:32.363,0:00:34.307
out into the right arm.

0:00:35.061,0:00:37.823
Looking at her MRI[br]before the consultation,

0:00:37.847,0:00:39.616
I decided to suggest an operation.

0:00:40.411,0:00:44.852
Now, neck operations like these[br]are standardized, and they're quick.

0:00:45.279,0:00:46.890
But they carry a certain risk.

0:00:46.914,0:00:49.064
You make an incision right here,

0:00:49.088,0:00:51.945
and you dissect carefully[br]past the trachea,

0:00:51.969,0:00:53.307
the esophagus,

0:00:53.331,0:00:56.568
and you try not to cut[br]into the internal carotid artery.

0:00:56.592,0:00:57.855
(Laughter)

0:00:57.879,0:01:00.117
Then you bring in the microscope,

0:01:00.141,0:01:02.514
and you carefully remove[br]the disc and the prolapse

0:01:02.538,0:01:03.728
in the nerve root canal,

0:01:03.752,0:01:05.871
without damaging the cord[br]and the nerve root

0:01:05.895,0:01:08.209
lying only millimeters underneath.

0:01:08.625,0:01:11.085
The worst case scenario[br]is the damage to the cord,

0:01:11.109,0:01:15.267
which can result in paralysis[br]from the neck down.

0:01:16.673,0:01:19.205
Explaining this to the patient,[br]she fell silent.

0:01:19.229,0:01:20.436
And after a few moments,

0:01:20.460,0:01:24.244
she uttered a few very decisive words[br]for me and for her.

0:01:25.887,0:01:29.371
"Doctor, is this really necessary?"

0:01:29.395,0:01:30.883
(Laughter)

0:01:32.101,0:01:35.034
And you know what I realized,[br]right there and then?

0:01:35.418,0:01:36.568
It was not.

0:01:37.561,0:01:40.585
In fact, when I get patients[br]like this woman,

0:01:40.609,0:01:43.085
I tend to advise not to operate.

0:01:43.665,0:01:45.798
So what made me do it this time?

0:01:47.153,0:01:48.805
Well, you see,

0:01:48.829,0:01:51.065
this prolapse was so delicate,

0:01:51.089,0:01:54.780
I could practically see myself[br]pulling it out of the nerve root canal

0:01:54.804,0:01:57.280
before she entered the consultation room.

0:01:57.907,0:02:00.907
I have to admit it,[br]I wanted to operate on her.

0:02:01.359,0:02:03.232
I'd love to operate on her.

0:02:03.256,0:02:06.873
Operating, after all,[br]is the most fun part of my job.

0:02:06.897,0:02:09.531
(Laughter)

0:02:10.538,0:02:12.728
I think you can relate to this feeling.

0:02:12.752,0:02:16.633
My architect neighbor says[br]he loves to just sit and draw

0:02:16.657,0:02:18.093
and design houses.

0:02:18.117,0:02:19.490
He'd rather do that all day

0:02:19.514,0:02:23.406
than talk to the client[br]paying for the house

0:02:23.430,0:02:26.374
that might even give him[br]restrictions on what to do.

0:02:27.073,0:02:28.348
But like every architect,

0:02:28.372,0:02:31.358
every surgeon needs[br]to look their patient in the eye

0:02:31.382,0:02:32.847
and together with the patient,

0:02:32.871,0:02:36.865
they need to decide on what is best[br]for the person having the operation.

0:02:38.264,0:02:39.684
And that might sound easy.

0:02:39.708,0:02:42.329
But let's look at some statistics.

0:02:44.009,0:02:47.107
The tonsils are the two lumps[br]in the back of your throat.

0:02:47.419,0:02:49.569
They can be removed surgically,

0:02:49.593,0:02:51.649
and that's called a tonsillectomy.

0:02:51.673,0:02:55.974
This chart shows the operation rate[br]of tonsillectomies in Norway

0:02:55.998,0:02:57.427
in different regions.

0:02:57.451,0:03:01.133
What might strike you[br]is that there is twice the chance

0:03:01.157,0:03:04.688
that your kid --[br]because this is for children --

0:03:04.712,0:03:08.250
will get a tonsillectomy in Finnmark[br]than in Trondheim.

0:03:08.862,0:03:11.613
The indications[br]in both regions are the same.

0:03:12.196,0:03:14.452
There should be[br]no difference, but there is.

0:03:14.759,0:03:16.211
Here's another chart.

0:03:16.235,0:03:18.403
The meniscus helps stabilize the knee

0:03:18.427,0:03:20.683
and can be torn or fragmented acutely,

0:03:20.707,0:03:23.107
topically during sports like soccer.

0:03:23.625,0:03:26.861
What you see here is the operation rate[br]for this condition.

0:03:27.354,0:03:31.125
And you see that the operation[br]rate in Møre og Romsdal

0:03:31.149,0:03:34.834
is five times the operation[br]rate in Stavanger.

0:03:35.427,0:03:36.775
Five times.

0:03:37.133,0:03:38.418
How can this be?

0:03:38.442,0:03:40.424
Did the soccer players in Møre og Romsdal

0:03:40.448,0:03:42.599
play more dirty[br]than elsewhere in the country?

0:03:42.623,0:03:44.265
(Laughter)

0:03:44.815,0:03:45.965
Probably not.

0:03:47.109,0:03:49.268
I added some information now.

0:03:49.292,0:03:51.442
What you see now[br]is the procedures performed

0:03:51.466,0:03:53.498
in public hospitals, in light blue,

0:03:53.522,0:03:56.506
the ones in private clinics[br]are light green.

0:03:56.530,0:03:59.880
There is a lot of activity[br]in the private clinics

0:03:59.904,0:04:01.837
in Møre og Romsdal, isn't there?

0:04:02.363,0:04:03.736
What does this indicate?

0:04:03.760,0:04:07.696
A possible economic motivation[br]to treat the patients.

0:04:08.522,0:04:09.672
And there's more.

0:04:11.577,0:04:15.340
Recent research has shown[br]that the difference of treatment effect

0:04:15.364,0:04:18.815
between regular physical therapy[br]and operations for the knee --

0:04:18.839,0:04:20.363
there is no difference.

0:04:20.387,0:04:24.142
Meaning that most[br]of the procedures performed

0:04:24.166,0:04:26.372
on the chart I've just shown

0:04:26.396,0:04:29.047
could have been avoided,[br]even in Stavanger.

0:04:29.785,0:04:32.222
So what am I trying to tell you here?

0:04:32.246,0:04:37.371
Even though most indications[br]for treatments in the world

0:04:37.395,0:04:38.561
are standardized,

0:04:38.585,0:04:42.879
there is a lot of unnecessary variation[br]of treatment decisions,

0:04:42.903,0:04:44.736
especially in the Western world.

0:04:45.572,0:04:48.748
Some people are not getting[br]the treatment that they need,

0:04:49.493,0:04:52.556
but an even greater portion of you

0:04:52.580,0:04:54.167
are being overtreated.

0:04:56.649,0:04:59.434
"Doctor, is this really necessary?"

0:04:59.458,0:05:02.450
I've only heard that question[br]once in my career.

0:05:02.474,0:05:06.332
My colleagues say they never heard[br]these words from a patient.

0:05:07.431,0:05:09.185
And to turn it the other way around,

0:05:09.209,0:05:11.764
how often do you think[br]you'll get a "no" from a doctor

0:05:11.788,0:05:13.588
if you ask such a question?

0:05:14.487,0:05:16.196
Researchers have investigated this,

0:05:16.220,0:05:18.973
and they come up[br]with about the same "no" rate

0:05:18.997,0:05:20.164
wherever they go.

0:05:20.188,0:05:21.895
And that is 30 percent.

0:05:21.919,0:05:25.886
Meaning, three out of 10 times,

0:05:25.910,0:05:29.449
your doctor prescribes[br]or suggests something

0:05:29.473,0:05:32.147
that is completely unnecessary.

0:05:34.545,0:05:37.434
And you know what they claim[br]the reason for this is?

0:05:38.117,0:05:39.267
Patient pressure.

0:05:40.832,0:05:42.165
In other words, you.

0:05:42.943,0:05:44.943
You want something to be done.

0:05:46.665,0:05:49.061
A friend of mine came to me[br]for medical advice.

0:05:49.085,0:05:50.237
This is a sporty guy,

0:05:50.261,0:05:53.815
he does a lot of cross-country skiing[br]in the winter time,

0:05:53.839,0:05:55.545
he runs in the summer time.

0:05:55.569,0:05:59.569
And this time, he'd gotten a bad back ache[br]whenever he went jogging.

0:05:59.593,0:06:01.786
So much that he had to stop doing it.

0:06:03.053,0:06:06.357
I did an examination,[br]I questioned him thoroughly,

0:06:06.381,0:06:09.515
and what I found out is[br]that he probably had a degenerated disc

0:06:09.539,0:06:11.606
in the lower part of his spine.

0:06:12.087,0:06:14.450
Whenever it got strained, it hurt.

0:06:16.165,0:06:18.513
He'd already taken up[br]swimming instead of jogging,

0:06:18.537,0:06:20.038
there was really nothing to do,

0:06:20.062,0:06:22.196
so I told him, "You need[br]to be more selective

0:06:22.220,0:06:23.537
when it comes to training.

0:06:23.561,0:06:25.164
Some activities are good for you,

0:06:25.188,0:06:26.418
some are not."

0:06:27.665,0:06:28.957
His reply was,

0:06:29.919,0:06:31.719
"I want an MRI of my back."

0:06:33.776,0:06:35.155
"Why do you want an MRI?"

0:06:36.236,0:06:39.036
"I can get it for free[br]through my insurance at work."

0:06:39.807,0:06:42.926
"Come on," I said --[br]he was also, after all, my friend.

0:06:42.950,0:06:44.832
"That's not the real reason."

0:06:44.856,0:06:49.356
"Well, I think it's going to be good[br]to see how bad it looks back there."

0:06:51.094,0:06:54.039
"When did you start interpreting[br]MRI scans?" I said.

0:06:54.063,0:06:56.113
(Laughter)

0:06:56.137,0:06:57.589
"Trust me on this.

0:06:58.026,0:07:00.086
You're not going to need the scan."

0:07:00.780,0:07:02.533
"Well," he said,

0:07:02.557,0:07:05.478
and after a while, he continued,[br]"It could be cancer."

0:07:05.869,0:07:08.073
(Laughter)

0:07:08.097,0:07:09.897
He got the scan, obviously.

0:07:10.907,0:07:12.541
And through his insurance at work,

0:07:12.565,0:07:14.605
he got to see one[br]of my colleagues at work,

0:07:14.629,0:07:16.756
telling him about the degenerated disc,

0:07:16.780,0:07:18.196
that there was nothing to do,

0:07:18.220,0:07:21.605
and that he should keep on swimming[br]and quit the jogging.

0:07:24.196,0:07:26.260
After a while,[br]I met him again and he said,

0:07:26.284,0:07:28.237
"At least now I know what this is."

0:07:28.712,0:07:30.331
But let me ask you a question.

0:07:30.355,0:07:34.474
What if all of you in this room[br]with the same symptoms had an MRI?

0:07:34.498,0:07:37.188
And what if all the people in Norway

0:07:37.212,0:07:40.822
had an MRI due to occasional back pain?

0:07:42.061,0:07:45.673
The waiting list for an MRI[br]would quadruple, maybe even more.

0:07:46.180,0:07:48.945
And you would all take[br]the spot on that list

0:07:48.969,0:07:51.302
from someone who really had cancer.

0:07:51.919,0:07:55.491
So a good doctor sometimes says no,

0:07:55.515,0:07:59.864
but the sensible patient[br]also turns down, sometimes,

0:07:59.888,0:08:02.542
an opportunity[br]to get diagnosed or treated.

0:08:04.782,0:08:08.083
"Doctor, is this really necessary?"

0:08:08.472,0:08:11.789
I know this can be[br]a difficult question to ask.

0:08:12.377,0:08:14.276
In fact, if you go back 50 years,

0:08:14.300,0:08:16.653
this was even considered rude.

0:08:16.677,0:08:17.799
(Laughter)

0:08:17.823,0:08:20.269
If the doctor had decided[br]what to do with you,

0:08:20.293,0:08:21.627
that's what you did.

0:08:23.574,0:08:25.819
A colleague of mine,[br]now a general practitioner,

0:08:25.843,0:08:30.184
was sent away to a tuberculosis[br]sanatorium as a little girl,

0:08:30.208,0:08:31.367
for six months.

0:08:31.391,0:08:33.248
It was a terrible trauma for her.

0:08:33.703,0:08:36.044
She later found out, as a grown-up,

0:08:36.068,0:08:39.609
that her tests on tuberculosis[br]had been negative all along.

0:08:40.403,0:08:43.942
The doctor had sent her away[br]on nothing but wrong suspicion.

0:08:44.419,0:08:48.823
No one had dared or even considered[br]confronting him about it.

0:08:49.268,0:08:50.668
Not even her parents.

0:08:51.506,0:08:54.752
Today, the Norwegian health minister

0:08:54.776,0:08:58.156
talks about the patient[br]health care service.

0:08:58.680,0:09:03.086
The patient is supposed to get advice[br]from the doctor about what to do.

0:09:04.340,0:09:06.181
This is great progress.

0:09:06.205,0:09:09.586
But it also puts more[br]responsibility on you.

0:09:09.919,0:09:12.836
You need to get in the front seat[br]with your doctor

0:09:12.860,0:09:15.007
and start sharing[br]decisions on where to go.

0:09:15.420,0:09:18.983
So, the next time[br]you're in a doctor's office,

0:09:19.007,0:09:20.896
I want you to ask,

0:09:20.920,0:09:23.983
"Doctor, is this really necessary?"

0:09:24.315,0:09:26.624
And in my female patient's case,

0:09:26.648,0:09:28.958
the answer would be no,

0:09:28.982,0:09:31.649
but an operation could also be justified.

0:09:32.165,0:09:36.886
"So doctors, what are the risks[br]attached to this operation?"

0:09:37.488,0:09:42.942
Well, five to ten percent of patients[br]will have worsening of pain symptoms.

0:09:43.427,0:09:45.141
One to two percent of patients

0:09:45.165,0:09:48.180
will have an infection in the wound[br]or even a rehemorrhage

0:09:48.204,0:09:50.604
that might end up in a re-operation.

0:09:52.069,0:09:55.656
0.5 percent of patients[br]also experience permanent hoarseness

0:09:55.680,0:09:57.474
and a few, but still a few,

0:09:57.498,0:10:01.867
will experience reduced function[br]in the arms or even legs.

0:10:03.163,0:10:05.615
"Doctor, are there other options?"

0:10:06.131,0:10:09.509
Yes, rest and physical therapy[br]over some time

0:10:09.533,0:10:11.559
might get you perfectly well.

0:10:13.105,0:10:15.835
"And what happens if I don't do anything?"

0:10:15.859,0:10:17.034
It's not recommended,

0:10:17.058,0:10:20.089
but even then, there's a slight chance[br]that you will get well.

0:10:21.002,0:10:22.152
Four questions.

0:10:22.780,0:10:24.297
Simple questions.

0:10:24.321,0:10:28.678
Consider them your new toolbox to help us.

0:10:28.702,0:10:30.313
Is this really necessary?

0:10:30.337,0:10:32.130
What are the risks?

0:10:32.154,0:10:33.710
Are there other options?

0:10:33.734,0:10:36.894
And what happens if I don't do anything?

0:10:37.334,0:10:41.381
Ask them when your doctor[br]wants to send you to an MRI,

0:10:41.405,0:10:43.698
when he prescribes antibiotics

0:10:43.722,0:10:45.825
or suggests an operation.

0:10:46.282,0:10:47.990
What we know from research

0:10:48.014,0:10:51.204
is that one out of five[br]of you, 20 percent,

0:10:51.228,0:10:53.759
will change your opinion on what to do.

0:10:54.624,0:10:57.966
And by doing that, you will[br]not only have made your life

0:10:57.990,0:11:01.552
a whole lot easier,[br]and probably even better,

0:11:01.576,0:11:03.532
but the whole health care sector

0:11:03.556,0:11:06.616
will have benefited from your decision.

0:11:07.354,0:11:08.536
Thank you.

0:11:08.560,0:11:12.246
(Applause)