0:00:00.061,0:00:01.429


0:00:01.429,0:00:02.628


0:00:02.628,0:00:06.502
人們常討論文學死亡

0:00:06.502,0:00:09.021
我認為人們曾短暫地討論它

0:00:09.021,0:00:11.880
在這一本的文學作品出現時

0:00:11.880,0:00:14.414
但之後就愈來愈多人討論了

0:00:14.414,0:00:19.136
而這個現象是由讀者逐漸變少產生的

0:00:19.136,0:00:23.213
由於他們的逐漸增加的冷默

0:00:23.213,0:00:31.920
或者是焦慮又或是對文學的不信任

0:00:33.273,0:00:36.135
以至於這個風氣造就螢幕以至於所以的一切

0:00:36.135,0:00:39.476
都會在螢幕出現 所以如果不夠好的書本

0:00:39.476,0:00:41.797
就無法在螢幕上出現

0:00:41.797,0:00:44.321
雖然你無法十分流暢地在螢幕上看書

0:00:44.321,0:00:45.459
但

0:00:45.475,0:00:49.801


0:00:49.801,0:00:52.665
書本是無法完全在媒體上呈現

0:00:52.665,0:00:56.384
所以我們懷疑還會有人看書嗎

0:00:56.384,0:01:01.774
我認為這是必需的或是會成為必需的

0:01:01.774,0:01:06.506
是指只有文學可以做到 只有文學可以達到的溝通

0:01:06.506,0:01:09.773
我不認為文學一定比其他的藝術好

0:01:09.773,0:01:12.354
像電影 舞蹈 音樂等

0:01:13.154,0:01:17.029
事實上，文學還是比起

0:01:17.029,0:01:19.061
電影 音樂來得吸引我

0:01:19.061,0:01:21.056
但我知道我生命我此時刻

0:01:21.056,0:01:25.084
我需要文學 或是只需要文學

0:01:25.084,0:01:28.619
例如像 我一位年紀朋友的母親

0:01:28.634,0:01:30.013
一周前過世

0:01:30.013,0:01:32.940
之後我去華盛頓去看她，而我是住紐約

0:01:33.355,0:01:38.583
當時我很擔心不知道要跟她說什麼

0:01:38.583,0:01:42.145
甚至覺得尷尬到覺得是痛苦的沉默

0:01:42.898,0:01:48.079


0:01:48.079,0:01:50.410


0:01:51.025,0:01:54.097


0:01:54.097,0:01:58.068


0:01:58.068,0:02:03.954


0:02:05.507,0:02:07.254


0:02:07.500,0:02:12.489


0:02:13.473,0:02:18.760


0:02:18.760,0:02:22.757


0:02:24.311,0:02:28.981


0:02:28.981,0:02:34.611


0:02:34.611,0:02:39.174


0:02:39.174,0:02:40.835


0:02:40.835,0:02:43.904


0:02:43.904,0:02:47.213


0:02:47.213,0:02:48.951


0:02:50.690,0:02:55.530


0:02:55.530,0:02:59.743


0:02:59.743,0:03:03.928


0:03:03.928,0:03:06.547


0:03:06.547,0:03:09.380


0:03:09.380,0:03:11.527


0:03:11.527,0:03:15.320


0:03:15.643,0:03:18.494


0:03:20.262,0:03:23.089


0:03:23.779,0:03:26.281


0:03:26.281,0:03:27.319


0:03:27.319,0:03:28.741


0:03:28.741,0:03:31.815


0:03:31.815,0:03:34.263


0:03:35.063,0:03:37.653


0:03:39.006,0:03:43.415


0:03:43.415,0:03:48.902


0:03:48.902,0:03:52.487


0:03:53.290,0:03:57.491


0:03:57.491,0:04:02.054


0:04:03.536,0:04:05.837


0:04:06.344,0:04:10.512


0:04:10.767,0:04:14.471


0:04:14.471,0:04:22.198


0:04:22.874,0:04:27.095


0:04:27.556,0:04:29.758


0:04:29.758,0:04:32.857


0:04:32.857,0:04:36.287


0:04:37.017,0:04:39.055


0:04:39.055,0:04:41.668


0:04:41.668,0:04:44.878


0:04:44.878,0:04:48.247


0:04:48.247,0:04:50.853


0:04:51.499,0:04:54.506


0:04:54.506,0:04:57.584


0:04:58.353,0:04:59.806


0:04:59.806,0:05:02.180


0:05:03.087,0:05:05.324


0:05:06.617,0:05:07.911


0:05:07.911,0:05:09.580


0:05:10.149,0:05:14.253


0:05:14.683,0:05:16.151


0:05:16.152,0:05:19.407


0:05:19.407,0:05:20.522


0:05:21.691,0:05:23.067


0:05:23.067,0:05:28.225


0:05:28.225,0:05:32.721


0:05:34.105,0:05:36.609


0:05:36.609,0:05:37.893


0:05:37.893,0:05:39.239


0:05:39.239,0:05:40.646


0:05:41.199,0:05:43.398


0:05:43.398,0:05:48.123


0:05:48.123,0:05:51.338


0:05:52.310,0:05:53.760


0:05:54.221,0:05:57.435


0:05:57.435,0:06:00.230


0:06:00.230,0:06:03.478


0:06:03.478,0:06:08.590


0:06:08.590,0:06:12.368


0:06:12.937,0:06:16.486


0:06:16.486,0:06:18.732


0:06:20.263,0:06:23.618


0:06:24.310,0:06:28.004


0:06:28.004,0:06:33.386


0:06:33.386,0:06:35.922


0:06:35.922,0:06:38.845


0:06:38.845,0:06:43.443


0:06:44.565,0:06:46.983


0:06:46.983,0:06:49.955


0:06:49.955,0:06:52.804


0:06:53.511,0:06:55.026


0:06:55.026,0:06:57.862


0:06:58.292,0:07:04.487


0:07:04.487,0:07:11.734


0:07:12.795,0:07:15.702


0:07:15.702,0:07:17.155


0:07:17.570,0:07:20.624


0:07:21.562,0:07:25.707


0:07:25.707,0:07:27.807


0:07:27.807,0:07:33.264


0:07:33.264,0:07:36.134


0:07:37.856,0:07:42.268


0:07:42.268,0:07:44.429


0:07:44.429,0:07:46.826


0:07:46.826,0:07:49.325


0:07:49.325,0:07:53.367


0:07:53.367,0:07:58.572


0:07:58.572,0:07:59.963


0:07:59.963,0:08:02.047


0:08:02.047,0:08:05.046


0:08:05.784,0:08:07.791


0:08:07.791,0:08:08.937


0:08:08.937,0:08:12.875


0:08:12.875,0:08:14.174


0:08:16.266,0:08:17.658


0:08:17.658,0:08:20.887


0:08:20.887,0:08:22.986


0:08:22.986,0:08:24.301


0:08:24.301,0:08:26.769


0:08:27.796,0:08:28.780


0:08:29.087,0:08:31.550


0:08:32.211,0:08:38.939


0:08:38.939,0:08:40.962


0:08:40.962,0:08:44.702


0:08:44.702,0:08:47.773


0:08:47.773,0:08:49.580


0:08:49.580,0:08:51.218


0:08:51.218,0:08:53.579


0:08:53.579,0:08:57.603


0:08:57.603,0:09:01.332


0:09:01.332,0:09:05.498


0:09:05.498,0:09:07.638


0:09:07.638,0:09:10.639


0:09:10.639,0:09:12.123


0:09:12.123,0:09:15.400


0:09:15.400,0:09:20.985


0:09:21.508,0:09:24.764


0:09:24.764,0:09:28.526


0:09:28.526,0:09:30.518


0:09:31.087,0:09:33.533


0:09:35.655,0:09:38.999


0:09:39.521,0:09:44.308


0:09:45.938,0:09:47.976


0:09:47.976,0:09:51.638


0:09:53.437,0:09:55.198


0:09:55.198,0:09:58.195


0:09:59.748,0:10:01.417


0:10:01.417,0:10:03.393


0:10:03.962,0:10:06.156


0:10:06.156,0:10:08.117


0:10:08.840,0:10:14.883


0:10:14.883,0:10:17.064


0:10:17.064,0:10:19.295


0:10:20.202,0:10:22.636


0:10:22.636,0:10:24.731


0:10:25.423,0:10:29.661


0:10:30.568,0:10:32.717


0:10:32.717,0:10:36.714


0:10:36.714,0:10:38.275


0:10:38.951,0:10:41.494


0:10:41.494,0:10:44.037


0:10:44.037,0:10:49.669


0:10:49.669,0:10:52.534


0:10:53.257,0:10:56.258


0:10:56.258,0:11:00.943


0:11:00.943,0:11:03.729


0:11:03.729,0:11:06.068


0:11:06.068,0:11:07.198


0:11:07.198,0:11:09.082


0:11:09.882,0:11:13.974


0:11:14.466,0:11:15.658


0:11:15.658,0:11:19.733


0:11:19.733,0:11:22.582


0:11:22.582,0:11:25.855


0:11:25.855,0:11:27.616


0:11:27.616,0:11:29.423


0:11:30.130,0:11:32.408


0:11:33.131,0:11:34.892


0:11:34.892,0:11:38.589


0:11:41.188,0:11:43.629


0:11:44.121,0:11:46.344


0:11:48.020,0:11:51.846


0:11:51.846,0:11:54.989


0:11:55.604,0:11:56.656


0:11:57.041,0:11:59.572


0:12:00.156,0:12:04.198


0:12:04.198,0:12:07.298