WEBVTT

00:00:00.526 --> 00:00:02.686
I'm a marine biologist

00:00:02.710 --> 00:00:05.845
here to talk to you
about the crisis in our oceans,

00:00:05.869 --> 00:00:09.847
but this time perhaps not
with a message you've heard before,

00:00:09.871 --> 00:00:13.165
because I want to tell you
that if the survival of the oceans

00:00:13.189 --> 00:00:16.775
depended only on people like me,

00:00:16.799 --> 00:00:20.021
scientists trading in publications,

00:00:20.045 --> 00:00:22.791
we'd be in even worse trouble than we are.

00:00:22.815 --> 00:00:24.716
Because, as a scientist,

00:00:24.740 --> 00:00:27.104
the most important things
that I've learned

00:00:27.128 --> 00:00:30.608
about keeping our oceans
healthy and productive

00:00:30.632 --> 00:00:34.441
have come not from academia,
but from fishermen and women

00:00:34.465 --> 00:00:36.994
living in some of the poorest
countries on earth.

00:00:37.379 --> 00:00:39.378
I've learned that as a conservationist,

00:00:39.402 --> 00:00:43.242
the most important question is not,
"How do we keep people out?"

00:00:43.728 --> 00:00:48.746
but rather, "How do we make sure
that coastal people throughout the world

00:00:48.770 --> 00:00:50.158
have enough to eat?"

00:00:51.079 --> 00:00:54.685
Our oceans are every bit as critical
to our own survival

00:00:54.709 --> 00:00:57.845
as our atmosphere,
our forests or our soils.

00:00:57.869 --> 00:01:01.457
Their staggering productivity
ranks fisheries with farming

00:01:01.481 --> 00:01:03.583
as a mainstay of food production

00:01:03.607 --> 00:01:05.297
for humanity.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:05.321 --> 00:01:07.170
Yet something's gone badly wrong.

00:01:07.976 --> 00:01:10.848
We're accelerating
into an extinction emergency,

00:01:10.872 --> 00:01:16.249
one that my field has so far
failed abysmally to tackle.

00:01:16.273 --> 00:01:20.392
At its core is a very human
and humanitarian crisis.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:21.316 --> 00:01:24.202
The most devastating blow
we've so far dealt our oceans

00:01:24.226 --> 00:01:25.981
is through overfishing.

00:01:26.005 --> 00:01:29.664
Every year, we fish harder,
deeper, further afield.

00:01:29.688 --> 00:01:32.585
Every year, we chase ever fewer fish.

00:01:32.912 --> 00:01:36.590
Yet the crisis of overfishing
is a great paradox:

00:01:36.614 --> 00:01:40.813
unnecessary, avoidable
and entirely reversible,

00:01:40.837 --> 00:01:45.607
because fisheries are one of the most
productive resources on the planet.

00:01:45.631 --> 00:01:49.384
With the right strategies,
we can reverse overfishing.

00:01:49.846 --> 00:01:52.958
That we've not yet done so is, to my mind,

00:01:52.982 --> 00:01:55.878
one of humanity's greatest failures.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:55.902 --> 00:01:58.599
Nowhere is this failure more apparent

00:01:58.623 --> 00:02:02.155
than in the warm waters
on either side of our equator.

00:02:02.179 --> 00:02:06.023
Our tropics are home to most
of the species in our ocean,

00:02:06.047 --> 00:02:10.036
most of the people whose existence
depends on our seas.

00:02:10.445 --> 00:02:14.216
We call these coastal fishermen and women
"small-scale fishers,"

00:02:14.240 --> 00:02:16.470
but "small-scale" is a misnomer

00:02:16.494 --> 00:02:22.174
for a fleet comprising over 90 percent
of the world's fishermen and women.

00:02:22.198 --> 00:02:25.940
Their fishing is generally
more selective and sustainable

00:02:25.964 --> 00:02:28.285
than the indiscriminate destruction

00:02:28.309 --> 00:02:31.449
too often wrought
by bigger industrial boats.

00:02:31.473 --> 00:02:34.561
These coastal people have the most
to gain from conservation

00:02:34.585 --> 00:02:36.222
because, for many of them,

00:02:36.246 --> 00:02:41.196
fishing is all that keeps them
from poverty, hunger or forced migration,

00:02:41.220 --> 00:02:44.856
in countries where the state
is often unable to help.

00:02:45.313 --> 00:02:47.544
We know that the outlook is grim:

00:02:47.568 --> 00:02:50.981
stocks collapsing
on the front lines of climate change,

00:02:51.005 --> 00:02:54.671
warming seas, dying reefs,
catastrophic storms,

00:02:54.695 --> 00:02:57.283
trawlers, factory fleets,

00:02:57.307 --> 00:03:01.641
rapacious ships from richer countries
taking more than their share.

00:03:01.665 --> 00:03:05.109
Extreme vulnerability is the new normal.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:05.692 --> 00:03:09.533
I first landed on the island
of Madagascar two decades ago,

00:03:09.557 --> 00:03:12.848
on a mission to document
its marine natural history.

00:03:12.872 --> 00:03:16.041
I was mesmerized
by the coral reefs I explored,

00:03:16.065 --> 00:03:18.321
and certain I knew how to protect them,

00:03:18.345 --> 00:03:20.967
because science provided all the answers:

00:03:20.991 --> 00:03:23.816
close areas of the reef permanently.

00:03:23.840 --> 00:03:26.822
Coastal fishers
simply needed to fish less.

00:03:26.846 --> 00:03:30.315
I approached elders here
in the village of Andavadoaka

00:03:30.339 --> 00:03:32.094
and recommended that they close off

00:03:32.118 --> 00:03:35.658
the healthiest and most diverse
coral reefs to all forms of fishing

00:03:35.682 --> 00:03:38.388
to form a refuge to help stocks recover

00:03:38.412 --> 00:03:43.048
because, as the science tells us,
after five or so years,

00:03:43.072 --> 00:03:46.905
fish populations inside those refuges
would be much bigger,

00:03:46.929 --> 00:03:49.345
replenishing the fished areas outside,

00:03:49.369 --> 00:03:51.903
making everybody better off.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:51.927 --> 00:03:54.734
That conversation didn't go so well.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:54.758 --> 00:03:55.940
(Laughter)

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:55.964 --> 00:03:59.290
Three-quarters of Madagascar's
27 million people

00:03:59.314 --> 00:04:01.495
live on less than two dollars a day.

00:04:01.519 --> 00:04:04.335
My earnest appeal to fish less
took no account

00:04:04.359 --> 00:04:06.356
of what that might actually mean

00:04:06.380 --> 00:04:08.746
for people who depend
on fishing for survival.

00:04:08.770 --> 00:04:11.341
It was just another squeeze from outside,

00:04:11.365 --> 00:04:13.891
a restriction rather than a solution.

00:04:14.338 --> 00:04:18.591
What does protecting a long list
of Latin species names mean to Resaxx,

00:04:18.615 --> 00:04:20.886
a woman from Andavadoaka
who fishes every day

00:04:20.910 --> 00:04:22.735
to put food on the table

00:04:22.759 --> 00:04:24.521
and send her grandchildren to school?

00:04:25.941 --> 00:04:30.398
That initial rejection taught me
that conservation is, at its core,

00:04:31.219 --> 00:04:34.755
a journey in listening deeply,

00:04:34.779 --> 00:04:38.278
to understand the pressures
and realities that communities face

00:04:38.302 --> 00:04:40.122
through their dependence on nature.

00:04:40.146 --> 00:04:43.877
This idea became
the founding principle for my work

00:04:43.901 --> 00:04:46.933
and grew into an organization
that brought a new approach

00:04:46.957 --> 00:04:48.314
to ocean conservation

00:04:48.338 --> 00:04:52.440
by working to rebuild fisheries
with coastal communities.

00:04:53.150 --> 00:04:56.811
Then, as now, the work
started by listening,

00:04:56.835 --> 00:04:59.282
and what we learned astonished us.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:59.644 --> 00:05:01.383
Back in the dry south of Madagascar,

00:05:01.407 --> 00:05:04.779
we learned that one species
was immensely important for villagers:

00:05:04.803 --> 00:05:06.904
this remarkable octopus.

00:05:06.928 --> 00:05:11.306
We learned that soaring demand
was depleting an economic lifeline.

00:05:11.330 --> 00:05:14.988
But we also learned that this animal
grows astonishingly fast,

00:05:15.012 --> 00:05:18.196
doubling in weight
every one or two months.

00:05:18.220 --> 00:05:21.899
We reasoned that protecting
just a small area of fishing ground

00:05:21.923 --> 00:05:23.448
for just a few months

00:05:23.472 --> 00:05:26.625
might lead to dramatic
increases in catches,

00:05:26.649 --> 00:05:29.992
enough to make a difference
to this community's bottom line

00:05:30.016 --> 00:05:32.950
in a time frame that might
just be acceptable.

00:05:33.895 --> 00:05:35.333
The community thought so too,

00:05:35.357 --> 00:05:39.986
opting to close a small area of reef
to octopus fishing temporarily,

00:05:40.010 --> 00:05:42.216
using a customary social code,

00:05:42.240 --> 00:05:45.875
invoking blessings from the ancestors
to prevent poaching.

00:05:46.930 --> 00:05:50.242
When that reef reopened
to fishing six months later,

00:05:50.266 --> 00:05:53.432
none of us were prepared
for what happened next.

00:05:53.945 --> 00:05:55.822
Catches soared,

00:05:55.846 --> 00:05:59.013
with men and women landing
more and bigger octopus

00:05:59.037 --> 00:06:01.227
than anyone had seen for years.

00:06:01.251 --> 00:06:03.791
Neighboring villages saw the fishing boom

00:06:03.815 --> 00:06:05.331
and drew up their own closures,

00:06:05.355 --> 00:06:08.911
spreading the model virally
along hundreds of miles of coastline.

00:06:08.935 --> 00:06:10.523
When we ran the numbers,

00:06:10.547 --> 00:06:13.824
we saw that these communities,
among the poorest on earth,

00:06:13.848 --> 00:06:18.506
had found a way to double their money
in a matter of months, by fishing less.

00:06:19.584 --> 00:06:21.116
Imagine a savings account

00:06:21.140 --> 00:06:23.603
from which you withdraw
half your balance every year

00:06:23.627 --> 00:06:25.150
and your savings keep growing.

00:06:25.174 --> 00:06:28.578
There is no investment
opportunity on earth

00:06:28.602 --> 00:06:31.578
that can reliably deliver
what fisheries can.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:32.244 --> 00:06:35.601
But the real magic went beyond profit,

00:06:35.625 --> 00:06:39.656
because a far deeper transformation
was happening in these communities.

00:06:40.442 --> 00:06:42.384
Spurred on by rising catches,

00:06:42.408 --> 00:06:46.989
leaders from Andavadoaka joined force
with two dozen neighboring communities

00:06:47.013 --> 00:06:52.346
to establish a vast conservation area
along dozens of miles of coastline.

00:06:52.735 --> 00:06:55.791
They outlawed fishing with poison
and mosquito nets

00:06:55.815 --> 00:06:57.877
and set aside permanent refuges

00:06:57.901 --> 00:07:00.494
around threatened
coral reefs and mangroves,

00:07:00.518 --> 00:07:03.235
including, to my astonishment,

00:07:03.259 --> 00:07:06.998
those same sights that I'd flagged
just two years earlier

00:07:07.022 --> 00:07:11.425
when my evangelism for marine protection
was so roundly rejected.

00:07:11.449 --> 00:07:14.094
They created a community-led
protected area,

00:07:14.118 --> 00:07:17.736
a democratic system
for local marine governance

00:07:17.760 --> 00:07:21.355
that was totally unimaginable
just a few years earlier.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:21.950 --> 00:07:23.482
And they didn't stop there:

00:07:23.506 --> 00:07:26.828
within five years, they'd secured
legal rights from the state

00:07:26.852 --> 00:07:29.867
to manage over 200 square miles of ocean,

00:07:29.891 --> 00:07:34.987
eliminating destructive
industrial trawlers from the waters.

00:07:35.011 --> 00:07:38.067
Ten years on, we're seeing
recovery of those critical reefs

00:07:38.091 --> 00:07:39.702
within those refuges.

00:07:39.726 --> 00:07:42.663
Communities are petitioning
for greater recognition

00:07:42.687 --> 00:07:44.353
of the right to fish

00:07:44.377 --> 00:07:46.956
and fairer prices
that reward sustainability.

NOTE Paragraph

00:07:47.502 --> 00:07:51.216
But all that is just
the beginning of the story,

00:07:51.240 --> 00:07:54.804
because this handful
of fishing villages taking action

00:07:54.828 --> 00:07:57.587
has sparked a marine
conservation revolution

00:07:57.611 --> 00:07:59.992
that has spread over thousands of miles,

00:08:00.016 --> 00:08:02.714
impacting hundreds of thousands of people.

00:08:02.738 --> 00:08:06.572
Today in Madagascar, hundreds of sites
are managed by communities

00:08:06.596 --> 00:08:09.564
applying this human rights-based
approach to conservation

00:08:09.588 --> 00:08:13.146
to all kinds of fisheries,
from mud crabs to mackerel.

00:08:13.170 --> 00:08:17.770
The model has crossed borders
through East Africa and the Indian Ocean

00:08:17.794 --> 00:08:20.302
and is now island-hopping
into Southeast Asia.

00:08:20.326 --> 00:08:25.070
From Tanzania to Timor-Leste,
from India to Indonesia,

00:08:25.094 --> 00:08:27.363
we're seeing the same story unfold:

00:08:28.502 --> 00:08:30.534
that when we design it right,

00:08:30.558 --> 00:08:35.249
marine conservation reaps dividends
that go far beyond protecting nature,

00:08:35.273 --> 00:08:36.790
improving catches

00:08:36.814 --> 00:08:40.688
and driving waves of social change
along entire coastlines,

00:08:40.712 --> 00:08:43.797
strengthening confidence, cooperation

00:08:43.821 --> 00:08:48.043
and the resilience of communities
to face the injustice of poverty

00:08:48.067 --> 00:08:49.685
and climate change.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:50.543 --> 00:08:53.601
I've been privileged to spend my career

00:08:53.625 --> 00:08:58.524
catalyzing and connecting these movements
throughout the tropics,

00:08:58.548 --> 00:09:00.604
and I've learned that as conservationists,

00:09:00.628 --> 00:09:03.341
our goal must be to win at scale,

00:09:03.365 --> 00:09:05.365
not just to lose more slowly.

00:09:06.143 --> 00:09:09.300
We need to step up
to this global opportunity

00:09:09.324 --> 00:09:11.270
to rebuild fisheries:

00:09:11.294 --> 00:09:14.279
with field workers to stand
with communities

00:09:14.303 --> 00:09:18.615
and connect them, to support them
to act and learn from one another;

00:09:18.639 --> 00:09:21.767
with governments and lawyers
standing with communities

00:09:21.791 --> 00:09:24.702
to secure their rights
to manage their fisheries;

00:09:24.726 --> 00:09:28.218
prioritizing local food and job security

00:09:28.242 --> 00:09:31.868
above all competing interests
in the ocean economy;

00:09:31.892 --> 00:09:36.512
ending subsidies for grotesquely
overcapitalized industrial fleets

00:09:36.536 --> 00:09:39.417
and keeping those industrial
and foreign vessels

00:09:39.441 --> 00:09:41.632
out of coastal waters.

00:09:41.656 --> 00:09:43.418
We need agile data systems

00:09:43.442 --> 00:09:46.298
that put science
in the hands of communities

00:09:46.322 --> 00:09:50.733
to optimize conservation
to the target species or habitat.

00:09:51.204 --> 00:09:55.736
We need development agencies,
donors and the conservation establishment

00:09:55.760 --> 00:09:59.164
to raise their ambition
to the scale of investment

00:09:59.188 --> 00:10:02.235
urgently required to deliver this vision.

00:10:02.991 --> 00:10:04.325
And to get there,

00:10:04.349 --> 00:10:07.482
we all need to reimagine
marine conservation

00:10:07.506 --> 00:10:11.229
as a narrative of abundance
and empowerment,

00:10:11.253 --> 00:10:13.254
not of austerity and alienation;

00:10:13.278 --> 00:10:18.197
a movement guided by the people who depend
on healthy seas for their survival,

00:10:18.221 --> 00:10:21.848
not by abstract scientific values.

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:22.719 --> 00:10:26.901
Of course, fixing overfishing
is just one step to fixing our oceans.

00:10:26.925 --> 00:10:32.520
The horrors of warming,
acidification and pollution grow each day.

00:10:32.544 --> 00:10:34.457
But it's a big step.

00:10:34.481 --> 00:10:36.710
It's one we can take today,

00:10:36.734 --> 00:10:39.409
and it's one that will give
a much-needed boost

00:10:39.433 --> 00:10:41.423
to those exploring scalable solutions

00:10:41.447 --> 00:10:44.217
to other dimensions
of our ocean emergency.

00:10:44.241 --> 00:10:46.622
Our success propels theirs.

00:10:47.287 --> 00:10:49.541
If we throw up our hands in despair,

00:10:49.565 --> 00:10:51.086
it's game over.

00:10:51.110 --> 00:10:55.429
We solve these challenges
by taking them on one by one.

NOTE Paragraph

00:10:56.348 --> 00:11:00.395
Our overwhelming dependence
on our ocean is the solution

00:11:00.419 --> 00:11:03.641
that has been hiding in plain sight,

00:11:03.665 --> 00:11:07.315
because there's nothing small
about small-scale fishers.

00:11:07.339 --> 00:11:11.038
They're a hundred million strong
and provide nutrition to billions.

00:11:11.062 --> 00:11:14.634
It's this army of everyday
conservationists

00:11:14.658 --> 00:11:16.320
who have the most at stake.

00:11:16.344 --> 00:11:19.967
Only they have the knowledge
and global reach needed

00:11:19.991 --> 00:11:23.174
to reshape our relationship
with our oceans.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:23.980 --> 00:11:28.760
Helping them achieve this
is the most powerful thing we can do

00:11:28.784 --> 00:11:30.826
to keep our oceans alive.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:30.850 --> 00:11:32.001
Thank you.

NOTE Paragraph

00:11:32.025 --> 00:11:36.428
(Applause)