WEBVTT

00:00:02.481 --> 00:00:04.707
Juan Arellano - Let's talk about free software in Latin America,

00:00:04.722 --> 00:00:06.338
what's your opinion?

00:00:06.864 --> 00:00:14.473
Santiago Hoerth - Well, actually, free software is extremely popular in Latin America.

00:00:14.473 --> 00:00:19.562
It is probably the place where it is most popular, regionally.

00:00:19.562 --> 00:00:25.038
There is, to begin with, Brazil and its government's

00:00:25.038 --> 00:00:27.346
decision to incorporate

00:00:27.346 --> 00:00:28.730
free software for public administration purposes,

00:00:28.730 --> 00:00:32.123
and the support for the local development of free software.

00:00:32.415 --> 00:00:37.954
Also, Venezuela, Ecuador, Argentina,

00:00:37.954 --> 00:00:43.854
Costa Rica is now implementing a new system

00:00:45.085 --> 00:00:50.140
where universities are required by law to incorporate free software.

00:00:50.140 --> 00:00:51.671
And, in other countries, free software is also

00:00:51.671 --> 00:00:54.564
growing noticeably, not only through those

00:00:54.564 --> 00:00:58.715
who actually use it, who are obviously important

00:00:58.715 --> 00:01:02.448
and who make free software possible,

00:01:02.448 --> 00:01:07.601
but also through the support of the authorities,

00:01:07.601 --> 00:01:09.984
in this case, the government.

00:01:09.984 --> 00:01:13.546
The government supporting free software is

00:01:13.546 --> 00:01:16.703
an important encouragement for those who

00:01:16.703 --> 00:01:18.947
are trying to develop free software.

00:01:18.947 --> 00:01:22.521
So, yes, the outlook of free software in

00:01:22.521 --> 00:01:25.217
the Latin American region is definitely positive.

00:01:25.217 --> 00:01:29.118
Even though some people still use privative software

00:01:29.118 --> 00:01:33.118
on their computers, when it comes to

00:01:33.118 --> 00:01:35.469
companies and public administration

00:01:35.469 --> 00:01:38.112
there has been a noticeable migration towards free

00:01:38.112 --> 00:01:40.475
software, and this also includes some universities.

00:01:40.475 --> 00:01:44.421
What Código Sur does is to encourage

00:01:44.421 --> 00:01:47.445
civil society organizations and social movements

00:01:47.445 --> 00:01:51.053
to incorporate free technologies.

00:01:51.053 --> 00:01:54.706
Not only free software, but also, once the free software

00:01:54.706 --> 00:01:57.836
has been incorporated, move on to other types of

00:01:57.836 --> 00:02:00.691
free technologies as well.

00:02:03.477 --> 00:02:07.384
It is a fact that free software has become

00:02:07.384 --> 00:02:09.821
a Latin American movement.

00:02:09.821 --> 00:02:13.344
It is so because of the growing support that

00:02:13.344 --> 00:02:16.362
free software has received from different areas.

00:02:16.362 --> 00:02:19.443
So the prospects in Latin America for free software

00:02:19.443 --> 00:02:22.048
are that free software will continue to grow,

00:02:22.048 --> 00:02:24.518
will have an even stronger market position,

00:02:24.518 --> 00:02:28.608
and will slowly replace privative software altogether.

00:02:28.608 --> 00:02:32.210
What I always say is that those who are nowadays

00:02:32.210 --> 00:02:35.590
working with privative software in most

00:02:35.590 --> 00:02:38.052
of the information technology areas

00:02:38.052 --> 00:02:40.737
have their days numbered.

00:02:41.069 --> 00:02:43.762
Because in a short time from now,

00:02:43.762 --> 00:02:50.141
no one will support privative software.

00:02:50.141 --> 00:02:53.143
I couldn't tell you exactly when.

00:02:53.143 --> 00:02:56.130
It is, obviously, a matter of years.

00:02:56.130 --> 00:02:59.162
It could be 5 to 10 years.

00:02:59.162 --> 00:03:01.790
The growth of free software is unstoppable.

00:03:03.096 --> 00:03:06.046
JA - Free software, generally...

00:03:06.554 --> 00:03:10.217
There are some criticism of it.

00:03:10.217 --> 00:03:17.079
On the one hand, those who develop free software

00:03:17.617 --> 00:03:19.186
are quite ...

00:03:20.629 --> 00:03:22.052
how can I put it?

00:03:22.052 --> 00:03:22.971
radical

00:03:23.202 --> 00:03:23.702
SH- Aha.

00:03:23.856 --> 00:03:27.061
JA - ...about its incorporation to the market.

00:03:27.061 --> 00:03:29.956
And on the other hand, I've also read

00:03:29.956 --> 00:03:32.678
that free software simply copies

00:03:32.678 --> 00:03:37.245
privative software, and provides the free software

00:03:37.245 --> 00:03:40.884
version, and that it lacks originality.

00:03:40.884 --> 00:03:43.056
What can you tell me about all this?

00:03:43.056 --> 00:03:47.205
SH - Well, the first thing I can tell you is that

00:03:47.205 --> 00:03:49.513
no, that free software is original to

00:03:49.513 --> 00:03:51.290
a very large extent.

00:03:51.290 --> 00:03:53.413
And I'm going to use Firefox as an example,

00:03:53.413 --> 00:03:57.478
a web browser of the Mozila Foundation,

00:03:57.478 --> 00:04:00.296
that is free software.

00:04:00.296 --> 00:04:02.973
In the struggle that took place between

00:04:02.973 --> 00:04:05.878
the browsers in the world,

00:04:06.224 --> 00:04:10.736
Internet Explorer had 98% of the market share

00:04:10.736 --> 00:04:15.902
two years ago. Nowadays it is starting to fall,

00:04:15.902 --> 00:04:20.241
it already lost 40% of the market share.

00:04:20.241 --> 00:04:23.498
It approximately has 60% of the market share now.

00:04:23.498 --> 00:04:27.865
When Firefox was launched, one of the

00:04:27.865 --> 00:04:32.664
improvements, related to Internet Explorer,

00:04:32.664 --> 00:04:36.442
was that, I don't know if you remember,

00:04:36.442 --> 00:04:39.646
a few years ago with Internet Explorer 5 and 6

00:04:39.646 --> 00:04:42.215
when you wanted to open a new window,

00:04:42.215 --> 00:04:45.063
you had to literally open a new window,

00:04:45.063 --> 00:04:48.021
and if you wanted to use several pages

00:04:48.021 --> 00:04:51.479
at the same time, we had to open 30 windows

00:04:51.479 --> 00:04:53.487
in our operating system, right?

00:04:53.487 --> 00:04:54.823
Different windows. Each one in a different

00:04:54.823 --> 00:04:57.023
Internet Explorer window.

00:04:57.123 --> 00:04:59.744
Firefox said, "I think it'll be a good idea to

00:04:59.790 --> 00:05:01.674
solve this with a few tabs".

00:05:01.674 --> 00:05:05.780
And it started the idea of tabs for the browsing

00:05:05.780 --> 00:05:07.711
of different web pages.

00:05:07.711 --> 00:05:10.405
So one could have 30 tabs open

00:05:10.405 --> 00:05:12.679
in only one Firefox window.

00:05:12.679 --> 00:05:17.562
Automatically, Internet Explorer, on its 7th version,

00:05:17.562 --> 00:05:21.241
if I'm not mistaken, what was its next step?

00:05:21.241 --> 00:05:23.872
Adding tabs to its browser, wasn't it?

00:05:23.872 --> 00:05:27.140
Because the way Firefox was working

00:05:27.140 --> 00:05:29.086
was obviously more functional.

00:05:29.593 --> 00:05:34.197
80% of the Internet, approximately, it is not an

00:05:34.197 --> 00:05:36.081
exact figure, but it is around that number,

00:05:36.081 --> 00:05:38.089
works through free software.

00:05:38.089 --> 00:05:41.590
Apache is the number one web server.

00:05:41.590 --> 00:05:48.484
Most of the e-mail addresses are free software.

00:05:49.531 --> 00:05:55.070
And regarding what you said about the

00:05:55.070 --> 00:06:00.152
'copying of the privative software', I think

00:06:00.152 --> 00:06:05.956
it is not imitation what we could find but attention

00:06:05.956 --> 00:06:10.679
to the needs of all those who use the product, right?

00:06:10.679 --> 00:06:15.799
For example, Photoshop is not very similar to

00:06:15.799 --> 00:06:20.562
GIMP, regarding presentation and the way some

00:06:20.562 --> 00:06:23.241
things are done. But it allows you to do--

00:06:23.241 --> 00:06:25.675
I mean, the results are practically the same.

00:06:25.675 --> 00:06:29.985
The same happens with Inkscape and Illustrator

00:06:29.985 --> 00:06:32.948
and other Adobe programs.

00:06:32.948 --> 00:06:35.515
There are a lot of programs that are

00:06:35.515 --> 00:06:39.515
characteristic of a certaing area, for example

00:06:39.515 --> 00:06:43.002
video or audio, and therefore a large

00:06:43.002 --> 00:06:47.424
number of users would be used to a specific software.

00:06:47.424 --> 00:06:52.007
So the aim would be to keep the learning process

00:06:52.007 --> 00:06:55.177
very close to what people already know,

00:06:55.177 --> 00:06:58.100
so as not to drive them crazy and to increase the

00:06:58.100 --> 00:07:01.263
potential penetration rates of the free software

00:07:01.263 --> 00:07:03.979
on users of privative platforms.

00:07:03.979 --> 00:07:07.455
So, I think it is not really 'copying',

00:07:07.455 --> 00:07:12.095
but rather some projects trying to achieve a

00:07:12.095 --> 00:07:15.272
certain level of comparison so new users

00:07:15.272 --> 00:07:16.833
would not have any problems when learning

00:07:16.833 --> 00:07:19.025
how to use the tools.

00:07:19.025 --> 00:07:21.734
But, actually, free software is much more

00:07:21.734 --> 00:07:23.757
innovative than privative software.

00:07:23.757 --> 00:07:27.905
Many of the numerous developments that are taking

00:07:27.905 --> 00:07:31.571
place are not even present in privative software.

00:07:31.571 --> 00:07:32.271
JA- Ah, OK.

00:07:32.271 --> 00:07:35.448
And I also mentioned the activists of

00:07:35.448 --> 00:07:37.496
free software being referred to as "radical".

00:07:37.496 --> 00:07:38.627
SH- Right, yes, yes.

00:07:38.627 --> 00:07:42.756
Well, radicalization, I think, has to do with

00:07:42.756 --> 00:07:46.685
being aware of what is happening with

00:07:46.685 --> 00:07:53.563
companies and people who develop privative software.

00:07:53.563 --> 00:07:56.331
What is it that happens when one uses

00:07:56.331 --> 00:07:58.185
privative software?

00:07:58.185 --> 00:08:01.282
I mean, it is not a simple matter.

00:08:01.282 --> 00:08:05.521
On the contrary, one does not have any

00:08:05.521 --> 00:08:07.646
control over what one is doing.

00:08:07.646 --> 00:08:10.204
So the purpose of radicalization is to

00:08:10.204 --> 00:08:12.572
make people understand the reasons

00:08:12.572 --> 00:08:16.318
when we talk about technology, we

00:08:16.318 --> 00:08:20.823
necessarily have to talk about freedom.

00:08:20.823 --> 00:08:25.154
And that freedom is translated in the

00:08:25.154 --> 00:08:28.785
possibilities and freedoms that

00:08:28.785 --> 00:08:31.946
the software I'm using provides me with.

00:08:31.946 --> 00:08:34.252
If a software does not let me see the source code

00:08:34.252 --> 00:08:36.723
there is no way to audit it and know

00:08:36.723 --> 00:08:39.344
exactly what that source code does.

00:08:39.344 --> 00:08:42.725
There's a thing that happens--

00:08:42.725 --> 00:08:45.319
I don't know if at some point, to those who

00:08:45.319 --> 00:08:47.875
use Windows, for example, when trying

00:08:47.875 --> 00:08:50.844
to install a program they get a notification

00:08:50.844 --> 00:08:54.736
that says: "This software in not validated by

00:08:54.736 --> 00:08:58.075
Microsoft. Do you still want to install it?"

00:08:58.075 --> 00:08:58.737
JA- Aha.

00:08:59.927 --> 00:09:04.436
SH- If us, as developers, want Microsoft to

00:09:04.436 --> 00:09:07.244
validate one of our softwares,

00:09:07.244 --> 00:09:10.333
what we need to do is send it to them,

00:09:10.333 --> 00:09:13.245
send the source code for them to analyse it,

00:09:13.245 --> 00:09:18.723
and the application that they approve is

00:09:18.723 --> 00:09:20.913
returned to us as a compilation.

00:09:20.913 --> 00:09:22.598
What does a "compilation" mean?

00:09:22.598 --> 00:09:23.898
That we can no longer see how that

00:09:23.898 --> 00:09:25.598
software is done, because we can no longer

00:09:25.598 --> 00:09:26.590
have access to the code. It is a compilation,

00:09:26.621 --> 00:09:30.653
it is closed, a package, we can no longer open it.

00:09:30.653 --> 00:09:32.829
And that is what they allow you to introduce,

00:09:32.829 --> 00:09:35.576
as a validated product, into their system.

00:09:35.576 --> 00:09:36.622
JA- Which could be completely different

00:09:36.622 --> 00:09:37.471
from the one that you sent.

00:09:37.471 --> 00:09:38.571
SH - And you don't know what it is that

00:09:38.571 --> 00:09:40.286
they changed, exactly.

00:09:40.286 --> 00:09:42.048
You don't know what they they did

00:09:42.048 --> 00:09:43.748
to it, because they send it as a compilation.

00:09:43.748 --> 00:09:46.615
So, from this point of view, what does

00:09:46.615 --> 00:09:48.146
it really mean to de radical?

00:09:48.146 --> 00:09:53.290
Is being radical making people aware of how much

00:09:53.290 --> 00:09:57.356
proprietary software is damaging society?

00:09:57.356 --> 00:09:59.790
Or are they people that--

00:09:59.790 --> 00:10:02.510
leaving aside any internal problems among

00:10:02.510 --> 00:10:05.213
free software supporters, and that some people

00:10:05.213 --> 00:10:07.595
can be more radical or more closed-minded.

00:10:07.595 --> 00:10:10.052
I mean, generally, the free software movement's

00:10:10.052 --> 00:10:12.790
main purpose is for people to see what really

00:10:12.790 --> 00:10:16.282
happens when they use privative software

00:10:16.282 --> 00:10:19.085
and what are the advantages and possibilities

00:10:19.085 --> 00:10:21.354
of using free software.

00:10:21.354 --> 00:10:23.502
And I'm not simply referring to technology, but

00:10:23.502 --> 00:10:26.548
to society as a whole. With either one of them.

00:10:26.548 --> 00:10:29.647
Socially, when we use privative software, we

00:10:29.647 --> 00:10:34.202
depend on the person or the company

00:10:34.202 --> 00:10:37.687
that develops it. We will never be free

00:10:37.687 --> 00:10:40.329
from the company that develops a

00:10:40.329 --> 00:10:42.931
certain software which we can't access.

00:10:42.931 --> 00:10:45.808
Free software, on the other hand, can be

00:10:45.808 --> 00:10:48.642
developed through a specific company

00:10:48.642 --> 00:10:51.121
and if in the future, for whatever reason, you don't

00:10:51.121 --> 00:10:52.978
want to continue working with that company,

00:10:52.978 --> 00:10:55.174
you can hire a different one to continue

00:10:55.174 --> 00:10:57.296
developing it, because the source code

00:10:57.296 --> 00:10:58.715
would be available to you.

00:10:58.746 --> 00:11:04.149
So, radicalization has to do with that.

00:11:04.956 --> 00:11:08.177
In some places where human rights are

00:11:08.177 --> 00:11:11.165
being violated, there are people who are

00:11:11.165 --> 00:11:12.948
extremelly radical exactly because of that,

00:11:12.948 --> 00:11:14.564
because they are defending human life.

00:11:15.839 --> 00:11:19.659
We can translate this into the position that

00:11:19.659 --> 00:11:23.344
the activists of free software have.

00:11:23.344 --> 00:11:25.346
JA- Aha, OK. Than you Santiago.

00:11:25.346 --> 00:11:26.469
SH - Pura vida