WEBVTT

00:00:00.504 --> 00:00:02.619
Asahel Nettleton's feelings were often

00:00:02.619 --> 00:00:04.724
severely tried by the unwise counsel

00:00:04.724 --> 00:00:06.347
which some professing Christians

00:00:06.347 --> 00:00:07.806
were in the habit of giving

00:00:07.806 --> 00:00:09.505
to awakened sinners.

00:00:09.505 --> 00:00:10.906
He has been heard to say

00:00:10.906 --> 00:00:13.743
that he recognized more 
evil from this source,

00:00:13.743 --> 00:00:15.472
than from all the opposition

00:00:15.472 --> 00:00:17.681
of public enemies of religion.

00:00:17.681 --> 00:00:19.520
He usually occupied one meeting

00:00:19.520 --> 00:00:22.252
in considering these misguided directions.

00:00:22.252 --> 00:00:23.878
A sketch of the address delivered

00:00:23.878 --> 00:00:25.424
on these occasions is found

00:00:25.424 --> 00:00:26.665
among his papers,

00:00:26.665 --> 00:00:30.279
of which the following is an extract.

NOTE Paragraph

00:00:30.279 --> 00:00:31.574
Number one:

00:00:31.574 --> 00:00:33.097
Wait at the pool.

00:00:33.097 --> 00:00:34.844
You must not be discouraged,

00:00:34.844 --> 00:00:38.800
for we read of one who waited 38 years.

00:00:38.800 --> 00:00:42.102
This text is used by way of accommodation.

00:00:42.102 --> 00:00:44.504
The impotent man was waiting at the pool,

00:00:44.504 --> 00:00:46.486
not for the pardon of his sins,

00:00:46.486 --> 00:00:48.965
but to be healed of a bodily disease.

00:00:48.965 --> 00:00:51.474
We may accommodate 
passages of Scripture

00:00:51.474 --> 00:00:54.528
for the purpose of illustrating 
acknowledged truth,

00:00:54.528 --> 00:00:58.027
but we must not trace analogies too far.

00:00:58.027 --> 00:01:00.873
In many respects, there 
is a striking analogy

00:01:00.873 --> 00:01:02.462
between a depraved heart

00:01:02.462 --> 00:01:04.453
and a diseased body;

00:01:04.453 --> 00:01:06.068
but there is one important point

00:01:06.068 --> 00:01:08.387
in which the analogy does not hold -

00:01:08.387 --> 00:01:09.880
the one is criminal,

00:01:09.880 --> 00:01:13.039
the other is merely calamitous.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:13.039 --> 00:01:14.992
This use of the passage contradicts

00:01:14.992 --> 00:01:17.260
many plain declarations of the Bible -

00:01:17.260 --> 00:01:19.767
particularly all those which enjoin

00:01:19.767 --> 00:01:22.619
the duty of immediate repentance.

00:01:22.619 --> 00:01:24.519
Suppose a person should address sinners

00:01:24.519 --> 00:01:25.991
in this manner:

00:01:25.991 --> 00:01:29.024
Behold, now is the accepted time!

00:01:29.024 --> 00:01:31.911
Behold, now is the day of salvation!

00:01:31.911 --> 00:01:34.644
But wait at the pool.

00:01:34.644 --> 00:01:36.917
Choose ye this day whom ye will serve;

00:01:36.917 --> 00:01:39.476
but wait at the pool.

00:01:39.476 --> 00:01:41.426
God now commands all men everywhere

00:01:41.426 --> 00:01:45.401
to repent, but wait at the pool.

00:01:45.401 --> 00:01:47.013
The effect of this direction is

00:01:47.013 --> 00:01:49.331
to make the impression 
on the sinner's mind,

00:01:49.331 --> 00:01:51.073
that he is not under obligation

00:01:51.073 --> 00:01:53.084
to obey God immediately;

00:01:53.084 --> 00:01:55.207
and, of course, it 
counteracts the influence

00:01:55.207 --> 00:01:56.555
of every command of God

00:01:56.555 --> 00:01:58.765
on the sinner's conscience.

NOTE Paragraph

00:01:58.765 --> 00:02:01.639
The sinner is told that he 
must not be discouraged,

00:02:01.639 --> 00:02:05.198
for the impotent man waited 38 years.

00:02:05.198 --> 00:02:07.205
This, however, is not said.

00:02:07.205 --> 00:02:11.526
It is said that he had 
an infirmity 38 years;

00:02:11.526 --> 00:02:15.529
but it is not said that 
he had waited a day.

00:02:15.529 --> 00:02:17.373
Be this, however, as it may,

00:02:17.373 --> 00:02:20.178
he was not healed by the pool after all,

00:02:20.178 --> 00:02:21.573
nor is there any evidence

00:02:21.573 --> 00:02:22.891
that he would have been

00:02:22.891 --> 00:02:26.278
if he had waited all his life.

NOTE Paragraph

00:02:26.278 --> 00:02:27.329
Number two:

00:02:27.329 --> 00:02:30.570
Be patient and wait God's time.

00:02:30.570 --> 00:02:32.362
What is the meaning of this direction

00:02:32.362 --> 00:02:34.850
when given to an awakened sinner?

00:02:34.850 --> 00:02:36.565
Be patient!

00:02:36.565 --> 00:02:38.117
Is the sinner to understand

00:02:38.117 --> 00:02:40.119
that he is too anxious for the salvation

00:02:40.119 --> 00:02:41.334
of his soul,

00:02:41.334 --> 00:02:43.101
and that he ought to wait patiently

00:02:43.101 --> 00:02:44.748
in his sins till God shall see fit

00:02:44.748 --> 00:02:46.805
to change his heart?

00:02:46.805 --> 00:02:48.867
To tell the anxious sinner to be patient

00:02:48.867 --> 00:02:50.111
without a new heart,

00:02:50.111 --> 00:02:51.781
is the same as to tell him

00:02:51.781 --> 00:02:53.731
to dismiss all his anxiety,

00:02:53.731 --> 00:02:57.233
and to go back to a state of stupidity.

00:02:57.233 --> 00:02:59.455
Patient in his sins!

00:02:59.455 --> 00:03:01.817
Rather let him be more and more impatient

00:03:01.817 --> 00:03:05.299
with himself and with 
his deplorable condition.

00:03:05.299 --> 00:03:08.036
Let him tremble in view 
of a judgment to come,

00:03:08.036 --> 00:03:10.178
and weep and howl for the miseries

00:03:10.178 --> 00:03:12.997
that are coming upon him.

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:12.997 --> 00:03:14.456
What is meant when the sinner

00:03:14.456 --> 00:03:17.312
is directed to wait God's time?

00:03:17.312 --> 00:03:19.414
Is it meant that God is not now ready

00:03:19.414 --> 00:03:21.060
to receive the sinner?

00:03:21.060 --> 00:03:22.479
Is it meant that the sinner

00:03:22.479 --> 00:03:23.986
is willing to do his part,

00:03:23.986 --> 00:03:25.566
and that he must wait for God

00:03:25.566 --> 00:03:27.067
to do His?

00:03:27.067 --> 00:03:29.122
If so, why not speak plainly

00:03:29.122 --> 00:03:30.679
and tell the sinner:

00:03:30.679 --> 00:03:32.246
I know you are ready and willing

00:03:32.246 --> 00:03:33.361
to be a Christian,

00:03:33.361 --> 00:03:34.958
but God is not ready and willing

00:03:34.958 --> 00:03:36.700
to receive you.

00:03:36.700 --> 00:03:38.216
But if God is not ready now

00:03:38.216 --> 00:03:40.172
to receive the returning sinner,

00:03:40.172 --> 00:03:41.535
what evidence is there

00:03:41.535 --> 00:03:44.022
that He ever will be ready?

NOTE Paragraph

00:03:44.022 --> 00:03:47.131
But when is God's time?

00:03:47.131 --> 00:03:48.534
Do those who direct sinners

00:03:48.534 --> 00:03:49.873
to wait God's time,

00:03:49.873 --> 00:03:51.930
mean that it is not their duty

00:03:51.930 --> 00:03:53.364
to repent and believe till

00:03:53.364 --> 00:03:56.333
God grants them repentance and faith?

00:03:56.333 --> 00:03:57.889
Then it was never was the duty

00:03:57.889 --> 00:03:59.385
of those sinners to repent

00:03:59.385 --> 00:04:01.073
who have gone to destruction,

00:04:01.073 --> 00:04:02.981
and it never will be.

00:04:02.981 --> 00:04:04.499
They waited all their lives,

00:04:04.499 --> 00:04:06.123
and are waiting still,

00:04:06.123 --> 00:04:08.278
and will wait to all eternity.

00:04:08.278 --> 00:04:10.565
And it has never yet been the duty

00:04:10.565 --> 00:04:13.093
of any sinner who is now impenitent

00:04:13.093 --> 00:04:14.666
to repent;

00:04:14.666 --> 00:04:16.726
and if God should not 
grant him repentance,

00:04:16.726 --> 00:04:18.302
it never will be.

00:04:18.302 --> 00:04:22.034
But this directly 
contradicts the Scriptures.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:22.034 --> 00:04:24.419
The sinner under conviction is distressed

00:04:24.419 --> 00:04:26.734
with a sense of his obligation to comply

00:04:26.734 --> 00:04:29.509
with the terms of salvation without delay.

00:04:29.509 --> 00:04:31.546
And there is no way to relieve him

00:04:31.546 --> 00:04:33.848
from his distress while impenitent,

00:04:33.848 --> 00:04:35.597
but to release him from his sense

00:04:35.597 --> 00:04:38.025
of obligation to repent.

00:04:38.025 --> 00:04:40.254
To direct him to wait God's time

00:04:40.254 --> 00:04:43.409
is directly calculated 
to produce this effect,

00:04:43.409 --> 00:04:45.043
and to counteract the operations

00:04:45.043 --> 00:04:46.945
of the divine Spirit.

00:04:46.945 --> 00:04:51.375
It is to plead the sinner's 
cause against God.

NOTE Paragraph

00:04:51.375 --> 00:04:53.679
But is it not hard to distress the sinner

00:04:53.679 --> 00:04:56.369
by pressing him with his obligations?

00:04:56.369 --> 00:04:59.212
It is painful, but it is necessary.

00:04:59.212 --> 00:05:01.005
It is painful to the surgeon

00:05:01.005 --> 00:05:02.300
to probe to the bottom

00:05:02.300 --> 00:05:03.666
of a dangerous wound;

00:05:03.666 --> 00:05:05.129
but it must be done,

00:05:05.129 --> 00:05:07.070
or the patient will die.

00:05:07.070 --> 00:05:08.531
If, through false pity,

00:05:08.531 --> 00:05:11.375
we console the sinner 
under these circumstances,

00:05:11.375 --> 00:05:13.660
there is reason to fear that his blood

00:05:13.660 --> 00:05:16.473
will be required at our hands.

00:05:16.473 --> 00:05:18.180
if we direct the sinner to wait,

00:05:18.180 --> 00:05:20.628
we direct him to run the awful hazard

00:05:20.628 --> 00:05:23.840
of losing his soul.

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:23.840 --> 00:05:25.059
Number three:

00:05:25.059 --> 00:05:26.689
It is sometimes said to the sinner

00:05:26.689 --> 00:05:28.094
under deep distress,

00:05:28.094 --> 00:05:30.033
"Don't despair."

00:05:30.033 --> 00:05:32.225
This expression frequently produces

00:05:32.225 --> 00:05:34.969
a bad effect upon the sinner's mind.

NOTE Paragraph

00:05:34.969 --> 00:05:36.609
It is sometimes the case,

00:05:36.609 --> 00:05:38.279
that sinners speak of the greatness

00:05:38.279 --> 00:05:39.169
of their sins

00:05:39.169 --> 00:05:41.127
and the hopelessness of their condition,

00:05:41.127 --> 00:05:44.169
on purpose to be flattered and consoled.

00:05:44.169 --> 00:05:45.492
And when they do not,

00:05:45.492 --> 00:05:46.979
it is always best to admit that

00:05:46.979 --> 00:05:48.221
their case is quite as bad

00:05:48.221 --> 00:05:49.798
as they represent it.

00:05:49.798 --> 00:05:51.559
It is proper to hold up the fullness

00:05:51.559 --> 00:05:52.933
of the atonement,

00:05:52.933 --> 00:05:54.114
and the readiness of God

00:05:54.114 --> 00:05:56.308
to forgive all who repent.

00:05:56.308 --> 00:05:59.532
But this the sinner 
generally does not doubt.

00:05:59.532 --> 00:06:01.935
The thing that distresses 
the convicted sinner

00:06:01.935 --> 00:06:05.184
is the fear that he never shall repent.

00:06:05.184 --> 00:06:06.414
From his own experience

00:06:06.414 --> 00:06:08.616
he has full conviction 
that it will never be

00:06:08.616 --> 00:06:11.436
easier to repent than now.

00:06:11.436 --> 00:06:13.191
His sins are increasing,

00:06:13.191 --> 00:06:14.480
and his heart is becoming

00:06:14.480 --> 00:06:16.453
more and more perverse.

00:06:16.453 --> 00:06:17.652
God has said,

00:06:17.652 --> 00:06:19.317
"Except ye repent,

00:06:19.317 --> 00:06:21.757
ye shall all likewise perish."

00:06:21.757 --> 00:06:23.161
He believes it.

00:06:23.161 --> 00:06:25.170
He despairs of obtaining salvation

00:06:25.170 --> 00:06:26.386
without repentance;

00:06:26.386 --> 00:06:30.691
and of this he ought to despair.

NOTE Paragraph

00:06:30.691 --> 00:06:31.945
Number four:

00:06:31.945 --> 00:06:34.052
In every case of clear conviction

00:06:34.052 --> 00:06:35.931
there is in the mind of the sinner

00:06:35.931 --> 00:06:38.709
a painful sense of obligation to repent,

00:06:38.709 --> 00:06:40.379
and a fearful apprehension

00:06:40.379 --> 00:06:42.927
that he never shall repent.

00:06:42.927 --> 00:06:45.228
In this state he sometimes inquires:

00:06:45.228 --> 00:06:48.781
Do you think there is any hope in my case?

00:06:48.781 --> 00:06:50.223
Do you think I ever shall

00:06:50.223 --> 00:06:52.278
become a Christian?

00:06:52.278 --> 00:06:54.422
This is a most interesting crisis,

00:06:54.422 --> 00:06:57.648
and a little flattery here 
may ruin the soul.

00:06:57.648 --> 00:07:00.541
The proper answer to these inquiries is:

00:07:00.541 --> 00:07:02.717
"I do not know.

00:07:02.717 --> 00:07:04.870
It is altogether uncertain.

00:07:04.870 --> 00:07:06.272
One thing is certain,

00:07:06.272 --> 00:07:08.533
however great your sins may be,

00:07:08.533 --> 00:07:09.913
if you will repent,

00:07:09.913 --> 00:07:11.572
they shall be pardoned;

00:07:11.572 --> 00:07:13.157
but whether you ever will repent

00:07:13.157 --> 00:07:15.261
is altogether uncertain.

00:07:15.261 --> 00:07:16.757
Sinners as anxious as you,

00:07:16.757 --> 00:07:17.935
and perhaps more so,

00:07:17.935 --> 00:07:20.112
have returned to stupidity,

00:07:20.112 --> 00:07:21.993
and their last state has become worse

00:07:21.993 --> 00:07:24.173
than the first."

00:07:24.173 --> 00:07:26.255
When sinners are in this state of mind,

00:07:26.255 --> 00:07:28.188
their friends are exceedingly prone

00:07:28.188 --> 00:07:29.468
to flatter them.

00:07:29.468 --> 00:07:31.831
"Oh! Don't despair - be patient.

00:07:31.831 --> 00:07:33.273
Wait God's time.

00:07:33.273 --> 00:07:35.939
You will doubtless find relief."

00:07:35.939 --> 00:07:38.904
Such language is exceedingly dangerous.

00:07:38.904 --> 00:07:40.707
Every word takes it for granted

00:07:40.707 --> 00:07:42.733
that the sinner's concern for his soul

00:07:42.733 --> 00:07:45.183
is without foundation.

00:07:45.183 --> 00:07:47.530
One of two things is true -

00:07:47.530 --> 00:07:49.774
either such directions are wrong,

00:07:49.774 --> 00:07:52.429
or the sinner is not under conviction;

00:07:52.429 --> 00:07:54.709
for if he is under real conviction,

00:07:54.709 --> 00:07:56.830
the Spirit of God is shewing him

00:07:56.830 --> 00:07:58.973
his true condition.

00:07:58.973 --> 00:08:00.683
His apprehensions are well founded,

00:08:00.683 --> 00:08:03.897
and if we attempt to 
remove these apprehensions,

00:08:03.897 --> 00:08:06.448
we directly counteract the operations

00:08:06.448 --> 00:08:09.153
of the Holy Spirit.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:09.153 --> 00:08:11.755
The above extract will give the reader

00:08:11.755 --> 00:08:13.863
some idea of the manner in which

00:08:13.863 --> 00:08:15.554
Dr. Nettleton was in the habit

00:08:15.554 --> 00:08:17.652
of dealing with awakened sinners.

00:08:17.652 --> 00:08:20.707
He did not heal the 
heart of sinners slightly,

00:08:20.707 --> 00:08:23.563
nor cry, "Peace, peace,"

00:08:23.563 --> 00:08:26.930
when God had not spoken peace.

NOTE Paragraph

00:08:26.930 --> 00:08:29.198
Original Title: Injudicious Directions

00:08:29.198 --> 00:08:31.228
From: Asahel Nettleton: Life & Labors

00:08:31.228 --> 00:08:33.545
by Bennet Tyler & Andrew Bonar

00:08:33.545 --> 00:08:36.783
Created by: ILLBEHONEST.COM