our weekly video hangout series. I think... let's see, we started a little bit off time so I'll say it again. Welcome to GV Face, our weekly video hangout series. Today we are celebrating the 25th birthday of the World Wide Web. Pretty exciting. That was on Wednesday. We've got a really all-star lineup of guests on today's program. Moving from left to right we have Alan Emtage, a very special guest who is gonna talk to us about his very special creation of the first web browser. We have Jeremy Clark in Montreal. Jeremy is a technical director at Global Voices. Josh Levy from Free Press in Massachusetts in the U.S., and Renata Avila, campaign manager for The Web We Want Creative Commons extraordinaire, and [?] Starr who is joining us from Berlin. Welcome, everybody! So we wanna just start today's show by talking a little bit about the World Wide Web and the Internet, 'cause a lot of people think that they're the same thing when actually that's not quite true wanna first turn to Jeremy I'm and just ask chair could you break it down for us like I thought that the internet was invented in the seventies but if it's the 25th birthday have the weapons what does that mean okay well the best place to start I think is the internet who has existed in various formats since the 1970s as he say up but it was the web that made it really enter our homes and so understanding the relationship is important so the internet was invented by the US government in a lot of sense is a mix of military in science funding I that developed the network at the actual computers that can communicate with each other over wires arm now another related technology that is also comprise that built into the bad is called hypertext and that is the notion out documents that can link between each other immediately without having I to go and fetch a separate document arm so there were lots of system since the nineteen sixties that we're trying to implement hypertext like that to do with an example up but all of them where commercial expensive closed and none of them were very popular so Tim berners-lee who is the inventor of the Internet I I though web obviously the World Wide Web arm put those two things together by building a service that runs on top of the Internet and he called it the World Wide Web soul what the World Wide Web is is be decentralized hypertext I engine that we used I to communicate between computers our web pages so what makes up web is three things URL's or you our eyes universal Resource Locator which are the addresses we use to find things on the web Bob HTML which is the Hypertext Markup Language I which is the way that be information is stored and sent so that we can then used browsers to view HTML and then all the documents can be understood and then also they display the links so that the Hypertext part if it works and we can jump around from page to page I'm the final part is HTTP which is the Hypertext Transfer Protocol which is the communication method by which the different computers can talk to each other and send be I HTML documents back and forth depending on the URL's arm so when he built it there were some very important things that he built into this system that didn't exist before and the main one is universal of worship so he always intended that anyone would be able to access these web pages and anyone would be able to add their own web pages without asking for permission I with the X very explicit special condition that anyone can link to any other web page without permission previous hypertext systems required that basically for you to link to me I have to accept that link can probably create a link back to you and that was the required on the web which gives us a lot of freedom to make the people we who wit wouldn't want us to be able to link them for example so no one can say I'm putting up tree content but you can't send your readers here because I hate you et cetera are the other one is that you made it completely completely 3 so in the world a mentor in world them programming the most free thing is generally considered to be the GPL open source free software licenses and Tim berners-lee actually almost use the GPL because he wanted that what web software he was building to be free but at the last minute yes he changed his mind made it call public domain because in certain ways the GPL is actually more respect restrictive because it forces other people like certain commercial actors wouldn't have wanted to use web technology if it were GPL so he made a full public domain and then from there when I'm to make all of the standard size open and I general and three as possible are so that's my extremely brief history internet if anyone is curious he wrote a wonderful book called weaving the web about his experiences as you can see its short and he highlighted interesting technical information in it without I'll it being overwhelming it's very approachable and he's a really interesting person ended the book is much better than his tweets which are usually in procuring all crowded thank coach that's great chair I mean I think that that helps on in conversations about internet policy in Internet governance there's a lot of emphasis on the ability to kinda creepy innovate without permission like for everybody to be able to build parks a the web and and what you just laid out for us makes it clear how important a web peace up the infrastructure is for that for that capacity to become a real tangible thing and somebody that something that now we can do you know we don't have to have technical expertise to kindness build our own our own spaces there I'm so I'm if I can add just one more thing sorry I as want to give a couple examples the things that happen over the internet that arent to bad because that was the actual I miss a question so one example would be torrents where York the cookie to computers connect to each other and stream information directly without any URL's being mixed into the process I'm another one is email at its core is its own communication protocol that doesn't have to use the web although we often use web sites to access and manage our now arm and then another one was the one right before the web came out them a very popular protocol was called go for which people liked and sort it worked like the where'd you just surf around and find things but it actually became commercial right around the time that the web came out so people have would have had to start paying and instead of having to pay they switched to using HTTP a shemale and the world but thank you so I want to move to Alan now I'm how I couldn't bill the first search engine and I'm kinda like overwhelmed and feel sort of like giddy and nervous having apparently speaker her big deal I'm salome just I you could tell us cuz I think a lot of people don't know about archie on it would be really cool just to hear about E all you sir what you were doing that made you decide should to do this and kinda what it was like and then mean everything you've seen sense unfortunately where time limited but welcome you know therapy well arm I well that was lacking that 19 I 89 and a I was working out as a system and mentorship therefore I am getting worse there's no cracks chips McGill University and I'm I A was responsible for getting all software for one on my responsibilities getting software for the faculty and the students are and at that time there it three major protocols on the internet this is pretty where I'll was I world's telnet which would allow you to log into a remote machine email I which allow you to communicate I with one what we do know 10 me more machines your and FTP which was the File Transfer Protocol which allowed you to move Wow data files or file was from one which one sheet to another and at the time what we had was people had me it remember it was a non commercial Internet time actually commercial traffic was forbidden on the Internet time because it was run by the National Science Foundation was using educational money and therefore other than companies with research arms like ID and I'll and HD and those kinds of things we didn't have any commercial traffic on the Internet which why would a seems kinda amazing to even think about and I so what people who did were out to provide are three states on your machine remember you know at the time a big a big this will be a megabyte you know I'll and so people would provide common a or depositary still that that you could deposit I'm programs that you had written and I'll data files and documents back in stock into the central repositories that will spread around the internet that other people can then you cheaper and so I spend a lot of my time trying to locate software or the information that means that students in the Faculty are trying to find and I got tired and since I'm easy and the geek I A arm I A I automated the process a got instead of doing it manually I had a bunch in scripts wake up in the middle of the night every night and go all index these files now remember all of this was just file listings it's not like we will it's not like a I'll search engine will be today I if yes just I just found it's all it was bonds and so what they would do with it would go out every night yes all the file names and all the repositories allow you to search those lists a plummets I only used it for myself I only used it I'm for my own for my own personal use on at one point my eyeballs was also all students at your grad student at University I'll let peter deutsch lettin you know that I'm somebody was asking for you know to date could somebody tell them where arm emails pretty creepy software was and I we from we see you know he came in ASCII you at this database iniki mostly if I I could help out tonight gave it to him in it you know Pakistan pack a minute later I had the information and so he put this yeah posting online and I'll people then started asking well you know can you find this from Ian in all these manual request basically either through email or Usenet postings which is what we're using time and he thought was a silly that's not quite doing these things manually one week just allow people access to the database itself and in a moment of insanity I we have to come up with a name for it and I said okay well let's just call it archie which is our client without be and dad are and with a no vote so out both here for months we were consuming what's happened all high quality traffic to Eastern Canada on as this search engine became his people you know work now I you you know people who know RGR generally people up a certain age I won't mention what what ages but and it's generally people who were in university or working on the internet so it would have been researched people people in academia I in the early 90s orgiastic for about I am a.m. five years for five years %uh and only in next st PE archives it never I'll index where now I went on as or TJ popular and I got one ball in the standards policies not gonna stop I worked of very closely with Tim berners-lee to I am to standardize for example I did the and Graham media the standard-setting body to the Internet DCI 88 I to standardize URL's because 10 had come up with a set of above rules the world and the as me looked at expanding that's larger range out %uh resources we realize that what rules did not on a ver all cases so we worked for our 10 brought that specification his original specification to the to group and we worked on it for I don't remember might not see a year or so it come up with a standard for you or else so all of those you're also use day in and day out world were standardized as a result all what many so it was I it was a really exciting time it was at time out by you know the question I always get is why did I make a billion dollars of a bit and I keep reminding people that are mostly people who are pioneers with the accepted Mr edmark and Jason arm or didn't make a whole lot of money off with the squirrel the switch in the plains we were working in an environment which I'll put a premium on I'll you're getting the technology out there making it is widely available as possible I tens big coup with Sharon which is the organization that work for when we first develop where was two guests earned to put I'll the the HDD where software that he agreed into the public to me all so it wasn't even choose to give away it was surgeons property as it as an employee he it was actually belong to Sir and down I she he actually convince them to be able to but in the public domain what's what really all 17 Center with a firearm with the whole so I'll at the time the the philosophy behind it it's really let's get this out there this is a brave new world we don't know what's what all this technology can be used for I don't think any of us including 10 imagine what it would become a you know he he always had a much grander vision a bit but I don't I I can guarantee you I spent many many many many in our and I with David sandbar is changing it then and I can't guarantee you that he did not suit anymore certain I'm I should dare and you know he even he I don't think having idea that it would a CD take over the world attack the world's population will be using this system or he created twenty years later to anybody or thank you so much I mean so speaking and threats yeah it has I'm changed and I guess taken over in a way I that me that mean I'm sure wouldn't have expected a I wanted to now move to Josh and judge were not I'll cool are both perini I'll who very committed involves leaders and what is now become a global at for two mean the way it was surprising in to save the Internet or preserve and protect to open this on and all up to right to tree expression access on and up also privacy that have that me all would feel are embedded actually in the way that it was bill so Josh I wonder if you could explain to us really briefly what your where your role is in your organization and then also on tell us about the web we want campaign and explain you know how you think this rights movement is is shaping up and and if you can kinda link it with everything that Allen just laid out for us out to be really wonderful although my best so my name's Josh levy I'm from Free Press where us-based organization we advocate for better technology media policy that allows or an open Internet or better representation people in the media including in and an immediate thats online and for open access information and this Asian ever talk method anniversary at the web has really central to our work because we've been fighting for example to you at past strong mentality policies here in the US for years at basically ever since the issue first came up with the mid 2000's missile big internet service providers blocking trafficking coming from their destinations and that fight is ongoing the FCC to better communications commission here in the US which is charged with overseeing communications and technology policy past rules in 2010 they were intended to protect me chali but we're passing our in a way that we knew what was gonna hold up in court anywhere as unfortunately we saw that happened earlier this year when I court in Washington DC throughout those roles effectively throwing out any net neutrality protections that people have and so this gets back kinda but Jeremy were saying the internet versus the web right so when we're talking about net neutrality which I have a lot of people heard about this on Sat that you should be able to access any information on why online without anybody getting in the way out with it that's a big company or the government an that is essentially that's it a policy that applies to the Internet to the ways in which all are computers connect with each other and we have this basic understanding that the internet should be reno it meaning that my computer should be able next yours into this well networked computers without any entity inspecting the traffic trying to understand what you're trying to access and based on that are in a blog so it doesn't like the video watching slowing it down our denied application using walking it that that should be totally unacceptable we should be able to net to whatever we want in whatever way we want and that includes using the web rights to the web is basically an application that ride over the Internet the internet says global network the weather is just one application that uses that or network and so it is essential net challenged essential using where the as as we've seen today using the web is so essential to all our lives and big companies and governments have so much power over it bad at the inn block alright things political speech video that you want to watch features a cat there so I'm anyway so that's what the press is doing in large part is trying to protect that notion net neutrality and wall added that fight came a number campaign link their at me stock so it was that bad copyright they'll your get your the US and after that you know realization I think here the US around the world that we are needed I each other a little bit or those of us who have been advocating for reopen it for a long time and so we started doing that repressed led the development and wrapping up something called the decoration etc reno which was a simple statement of principles out they are right to access information online and Adam backing up really fruitful relationship with Tim berners-lee organization the world wide web foundation and we discussed ways in which we could move that effort forward this you that declaration effort to involve more troops around the world more people around the world and shit guarantee that we all have access to information and that that access and the principles behind it are not a demanded any one country or anyone it also added that in this great project the web we want which we're not going to tell you more about which is seeking to do just that to you pass laws around the world that will protect people's right to access the internet into to access content on the web without anybody getting in the way and its its building steam very very quickly we are working with countries around the world developed their own set of principles regarding the webinar rights on it and organizing lot smarter organizations that it really excited by getting involved in this effort and art remote uniting gross we're all fighting the same by departs the world is had come to light so I let me not to tell you more about that and hello everyone everybody'd 3d want me here a solo the way we want it would be set luncheon of a a very important group of organizations FMC society and we'll mention other then and Eve access that many of us are from you every EPC athlete Brett from the US its leader in jordan Eberle the open-source Association dorgan as well and a consumers international and article nineteen that's the only thing about God's mercy O I V 40 gb/s public knowledge she in the US and me we have the we got the confirmation that Open Knowledge Foundation which has affiliate is over war doing this book ASO basically they can be what we are trying to achieve a here you do and more from their reactions because the reactions that lets users say you you outcropping approach you have a positive agenda like this a first in different countries and a note so nobody and what happens is usually the we got together let me know and we reacted badly to his nation be alls a everybody either and specific purpose a interest what very creative but not so well-informed legislator and in so you the last let's say five years we have seen so many mobile stations against against against so we think that yeses want to have a a reaction bad legislation but he's much more effective the also people to use the Site a nobody XTS is a be understood us the whole 18 works Bentley FB you should be using the Internet government but seems as a few moline everyone enough I well rights and so and we would have a deeper and DVD sandifer Nationals it to achieve that their personal be in Ben's work in specific countries wieder it we a you get all the Advisory Committee so that there's something going on there some movement in society in there so action there it is sOooo believe the country's between the week at that decided you get that first it and got to use a button and more stronger support from the one a what we won by Jenson would be just bad Indonesia Philippines India found that they expressed to you it with your YouTube the UK Nisha aunty react Kenya and so happy so as you see each other mostly condition that no one cell outside the UK be good you a saw an opportunity there yes well so that every Christian rights and be very interesting to see how the deterioration rights in the country even had been taken in a democratic country villa in years has been very extreme is that is really affecting the region Anna apart from you a in Ben's work that we have blended national dialogue scene is going to say warm it well and we have also and we are left 1820 parts of March a meeting routes as well at the meeting Lance %uh it for everyone to apply so you don't need to be an NGO you don't need to be a a an expert like that for these plants when we will these normal people Archies musicians everyone it to be involved in the simple a.m. request once the celebrated are key or working with but at the same time that was celebrated with the start a conversation on what we do what we want what he's in what do you think that what a which by any means and which a.m. for we want it you which way we want to protect it with no wanted that free and open when and so it can be something ass as a symbol that that screen and in the published week space it can be something more elaborate it like that like a well at your local library it can be anything you want you can be given that spoke during the meeting love with Celia a it dozen people whether whether a person's in it for you and what also we know that we can know the bottom a those fighting against so we have a but it would response a grants and these rapid response plans have for it we it have I didn't buy that sometimes the make some be happened in its own resources especially in some punches in the levels out so for example did think about that very bad surveillance local last Ian nicaragua so these rapid response a which will be open during the whole give me love activist see nascent me very bad things happen and we think that if we it got another Google people together and we read the and it lets in the evening get assure PD about that we have a good chance to as she that their opinion our site there's decided rights and so that would be open as well it would be that would be up in the or so at my and March and you will be we may not be too late for year and what we will at she but the end of the year is that very interesting and when it should have experience we will see it and that web it went well people won't in a specific country with more intense the follow-up mechanism and I N O win as a scene which techniques I did this for rapid response went their separate you know of any Burnett it by adding the collection experiences from the rapid response plans and as a wee wee letter from at ways to engage uploader Monique use a in our topics in our issues so I I am very hopeful that especially artists very creative activists it went for I'm ways to engage in a broader public because the need a he's ours and their future eat the Benson also Serafini and more it people invited me despite more was the strong and you get a a at last I i will. and we'll elected by everyone to to being a slick here the way that you can gauge to use i'm nina and need to apply for these grants will not only pure bedford is Lansing to make in 20 I it you only if you want to write an article you are an expert in specific topics it he's great articles News shared knowledge with people and peace it engage in that them yet but that the egos headed here where author sauce and the Internet offers those use them for two people communicate and panicking and borders and they've been there it's lonely here a.m. the list that phone it which is not that a website but he said that on and made of the connecti that he's ready to jumper and and do think actions to say that with any moment that using in the let so yes what's it you well thanks that's really I think it's great to serve to have that out there for people to understand all the way so they can get involved wanting right so in thinking about how can we make a little show today that would celebrate the web I couldn't help but think about Global Voices because that's what brings us all together here and I think that our community and so many ways I mean we couldn't exist we wouldn't exist without the web but doctor also so many on particular attributes ovett in when it comes to access and openness that allow us to do all the things that we do like including this hang out right now I'm so I wanted to ask although we're really short on time so I'm gonna have to asking to be super presh but chair you I kinda I said is there could you talk a little bit about what with if you look at Global Voices answered the way that it's grown-up on with the Internet you've been here since the beginning so you can kinda wish just tell us tell us a bit okay well I I actually haven't been where at Global Voices since the very beginning but I joined near the start so maybe you can see on my screen Global Voices we started actually in 2005 I and one of the great things about the story is that it was started quickly in easily I by ethan Zuckerman arm who set up the original site I along with Rebecca MacKinnon who out worked on the idea content and so they actually used word press which is this system we still use today and which is very similar to the web in a lot of sense is I because it's a distributed project people all around the world develop it its open source and it's free and it is so not by convenience but by very explicit philosophy and they're very active in defending Mac arm and also in another way I originally I at the time there was a very popular free software called movable type which became commercial and instead sign a paper at people switch to Word Press I'm so this was our original website we later redesigned it several times I and over the years we have grown with I Word Press to at take advantage of the new features and I keep running our site and sell running are our whole infrastructure on this very decentralized open source model has been I really rewarding experience for us are just as using the web has then obviously I there what are the most interesting things is that Global Voices is all about the web without the web without that decentralized of the ship anyone can write to it there would be no Global Voices the whole point in little ways as well as to recognize that people all over the world were taking advantage of the benefits of the web and create one place where you can find it sort of like a archie wise I with GE pre web telnet days a archive things happening all around I've got Google Voice is dead arm so yeah no and you know we've tried a lot of different infrastructure based around the web over the years I we you strip all reviews a lot of different online service that is obviously like everyone else the temptation to take advantage of Google's free offerings has always been are part of Global Voices DNA we use Google mailing lists we use I all the different things that they make for free which is an interesting part of the web because it's not the web that Google just happening to give it away but at the company they have a tendency to follow the spirit of the web I even though they're doing so for commercial reasons up but yeah that Mike it very brief summary of the history always given how to parallel the web thank you I'm afraid we're gonna have to wrap up now but just to do that I wanted to ask for a couple love kinda final thoughts um from from Allen and perhaps also Josh just I'm Alan I guess I'm I'm especially interested in if there are kinda thoughts that you have on all of the activism and advocacy that's taking place around fundamental rights on the internet kinda from from your own unique historical perspective and then I wanted to close on by asking or not it's just tell ass very little bit about Basle I'm since there's also an important anniversary this weekend %uh so I'm gonna just let you guys go and then we will close-up won't end well arm you know I'll I have I haven't been involved awesome activists for a for a quite some time now year a sort of bernard hogan-howe patrol biatch I'll lying around the globe and and at the mall except maybe the nineties I but I certainly is its to pay a lot of attention to that stuff a I am currently in Barbados right now and down it has been really interesting to trying out for one example trying to access content from United States om all your entertainment content action star and II manual to study read but a real it but in in practice the antiquated models I'll %uh of content distribution that we are still holding onto om in this day in age where no geographical boundaries and national boundaries not on Sat are still very much at once entropies business models a get you know our are not things like but our internet esta whiten way at it on well I see no music industry a seamless happen now for ethnic I'm I would certainly from the actors on you in terms of keeping the the Internet I'm freaking and unavailable its are it's going to be a real challenge I mean it's such a important technology now and you have things like a great wall are the Great Firewall of China Omni power you know russia recently as a while yesterday today shutting down I'll using got new laws to shut down access to guess at I against hooting I'll you know this getting reelected are I'm egypt was a real wake-up call for a lot of people on the use of social networking I'll juju organize an activity on people and bring them up onto the sheets so governments are scared this technology and it's important that we worked really hard to keep it is this reason is because they realize that not for me chin are you talking to mention you control the people so I'm I think it is a strange journey partner people I let's just do not want to continue to work are very hard to you to stop the battle Austin form below the Legislature's summer just another eight rats I mean you know never ascribe to malice what will be ascribed to incompetence and on these people are just incompetent not not malicious I'll but they are people who are malicious as well so we have to deal with them as well but top it's you know it's vitally important the yes I nowadays not be these technologies reset at the core or culture and the way we communicate on may I me others at 10 quickly at I think that we read in your interesting moment where so many basic knowledge the importance on the internet and no nowhere ands be impact it's had a on every aspect of our culture and and because of that I think we as the users at the where into the internet have a duty to hold the government governments around the world in companies around the world accountable and to you its urge them and pressure them to protect the openness that lies at the core I'll this entire name and to protect not just openness but also this notion 0 comments thats I in our opinion quickly being lost this notion that the that the internet and that the web are I'll are publicly on and that it the activity that takes place on them as activity that we undertake net me it that is ours and that is not baby mean up the big companies on his platforms me undertake the activity so for example google has allowed us to do a lot of things Google lost by a lot of information extremely quickly to connect to each other extremely well he is not working at are doing right now but Google's doing all this and at while mining the data to get selling of that data that data is also creating this historic all record up everything then search warrants a online which has been no exploited by governments but also by companies as I think it's time for us to think about that relationship between us and these big companies which is becoming essential part of our online experience and have to me the centralized that happen we decouple ourselves from these giant companies and take back or should I wear so that we are all in this experience in a deeper way and that it's not and experience is purely commercial and a commercial transaction between us and and if a company so that that's a big question spent eight years for travel it right solutions but we're hoping that we can start it our station now well now now I'm not and now and we go back to something that germs set and he left a but that he met means that you did in the border Canadian border because the happier and now with a while I want to talk about the set that up at the end of the day yourself we've reduced a number of people who can actually eat some countries and not control the internet but you see Eden you understand the infrastructure and use it in a way that the weekend increase public who and they can to help people in extreme situations and 10 did it these people he said my friend but he kept happy battle back to lead the Internet basically Mathai said a and palestinian Syrian activities and he said i think is the food culture and your clothes he said you know he's not that he had not super nationalist you keep keep he had trouble lol extensively here Rams over two were and he liked that he likes to spend time and learning how things water I'll in separate so that you think will the computers and he has learned it himself healthy up to the gold that it brings the own goal then he was a he knows a lot about hardware as well and he knows and about we coach or and and he said I'm and when he so hey there You or was he so all these wonderful things happen and and said he thought the Britain's the create hacker space in the baskets I don't know how translation what's what in the apparently hackerspace what's a very scary Lord forgive CBN as is to be and you don't answer me this: and they saw it as a threat the people in power grid technology acid great who don't plan to control people paso's here on the 15 up December two years ago they hackerspace with greater all the computers where they cannot wait all the things with this month opened him up and united in wanna be set up Syrian please looking at that reedy reader only goal well the nato the delaney nuclear weapons or something like that %uh and 73 he have enough a weighty and he had been recently was that he see West the in a very very bad reason so did orchard treatment but then he was a things through that book I feel at thousands of people he was it we passed her back to his VM recent we each you can imagine how even deep is the civilian prison how is this looks like and you he said a the conditions get but worse a that goes by and the Syrian government once out all were resources the last people really feed the last people they would take care all are the prisoners on the book that last release it has a a health condition he's all relief that but me yeah what we me happy intrepid building at least it two years is the keeping baseball and didn't keep reminding him that we haven't forgotten and to keep reminded you that we yeah in braided values that he embraces the that support the cause is that he seen supports school a been up to think you know the you know just been saddened but nothing we have been deeply baffled they the 15 of March what some things are already starting today and what we want is that joint action a Bleezy mean and you can be it do remember bottle and not only battle but remember Syria because it seems that because if the new laws media's it we don't we don't be a hear about Syria and more I mean it's is like good in December been on the popular and we we will if we got some timely were OK and something is good but neither the symbol have well but then a vote no on the suffering and together we to wood bats and I'm not sober system administrators computer experts and had a fierce what I recent so that we only care about journalists in others lots of people that somebody will people for the future Syria and who would increase in our what the we need our solidarity I mean let's elect to even you're leaving a gun T air which has received a Syrian refugees you show your solidarity I know that share on your computer mind some appealing but maybe go won the nineteen a computer with internet access this refugee camp so they can stay in touch with their reluctance that growth may be do enough to shark tall coach ashore gathering your day I think that that there was no with ways who help battle because that's what what but it probably will be between if you must be so my feeling is that not forget Syria not forget that so that free internet if the up the internet with the bath and this year and that's we might want action what is the web she wants where many about on so there is a lot of work to do I'm and there are lots of ways to get involved Street right about I think you everybody so much for coming on today and um we hope to see you everybody here and out there next week on GB face thanks so much