WEBVTT

00:00:01.017 --> 00:00:04.887
Today we're going to take a brief look at 
the importance of institutions

00:00:04.927 --> 00:00:07.956
this'll be brief and that we're not going 
to look today

00:00:07.976 --> 00:00:11.838
at which institution are important, and
we're not going to try and explain

00:00:11.858 --> 00:00:15.078
the mechanisms by which institutions work

00:00:15.147 --> 00:00:17.384
instead what we want to do is offer 
the big picture:

00:00:17.384 --> 00:00:19.485
Why do people study institutions?

00:00:19.513 --> 00:00:23.933
Why do people think that institutions are
important for economic growth?

00:00:23.934 --> 00:00:25.161
Let's take a look

00:00:26.754 --> 00:00:30.236
North and South Korea provide almost a 
perfect natural experiment

00:00:30.284 --> 00:00:32.590
demonstrating the power of institutions

00:00:32.590 --> 00:00:36.650
In 1944, North Korea and South Korea were 
very similar

00:00:36.650 --> 00:00:38.370
they had the same people

00:00:38.411 --> 00:00:41.660
the same culture, the same language,
the same history

00:00:41.680 --> 00:00:44.060
very similar economies

00:00:44.120 --> 00:00:46.839
If anything, North Korea was a little bit 
more industrialized

00:00:46.999 --> 00:00:49.772
South Korea, a little bit more agrarian

00:00:49.843 --> 00:00:53.539
Then in 1945, the country was split

00:00:53.628 --> 00:00:58.181
and North Korea chose communism, a
totalitarian state

00:00:58.351 --> 00:01:00.571
centrally planned, centrally directed

00:01:00.760 --> 00:01:02.541
no private property rights

00:01:02.731 --> 00:01:06.059
very little room for private initiative,
no free press

00:01:06.220 --> 00:01:09.561
South Korea, broadly speaking, chose
capitalism

00:01:09.781 --> 00:01:12.491
private property rights, a free economy,


00:01:12.711 --> 00:01:15.514
much bigger scope of private initiative,
a free press

00:01:15.712 --> 00:01:17.923
not always honored, of course

00:01:18.113 --> 00:01:24.351
but broadly speaking, South Korea chose
capitalism, North Korea chose communism

00:01:24.371 --> 00:01:26.510
Now, 
what were the results of these choices?

00:01:26.702 --> 00:01:33.012
50 years later, the results are so clear:
an alien could see them from outer space;

00:01:33.203 --> 00:01:37.382
that this is a picture of North and South 
Korea, taken from outer space

00:01:37.591 --> 00:01:42.191
and what you see is South Korea has lights,
broad lights

00:01:42.191 --> 00:01:44.732
people going out to parties, lighting 
up their home

00:01:44.872 --> 00:01:48.600
what you see in South Korea is a developed
modern economy

00:01:48.660 --> 00:01:53.202
Up here, in North Korea,
what you see is darkness

00:01:53.402 --> 00:02:00.043
With the one exception of Pyongyang, the 
central city where the ruling elite lives

00:02:00.203 --> 00:02:03.542
Massive differences created in just
50 years

00:02:03.712 --> 00:02:11.212
Today South Korea has a GDP per capita at 
least 10 times, probably 15 times higher

00:02:11.372 --> 00:02:13.252
than that in North Korea

00:02:13.432 --> 00:02:17.882
South Korea is a modern developed economy,
the most wired economy in the world

00:02:17.952 --> 00:02:21.734
the standard of living, equal to that of
most western countries

00:02:21.844 --> 00:02:27.886
North Korea is in periodic starvation,
a militarized state

00:02:27.957 --> 00:02:30.432
where the people are regularly starving

00:02:30.580 --> 00:02:32.972
That is the difference which institutions 
can make

00:02:33.062 --> 00:02:36.373
in just a matter of a few generations

00:02:38.573 --> 00:02:42.524
Here's another picture which could suggest
the power of institutions

00:02:43.144 --> 00:02:44.814
This is Nogales

00:02:44.838 --> 00:02:47.185
On the right is Nogales, Mexico

00:02:47.214 --> 00:02:49.496
On the left is Nogales, Arizona

00:02:49.640 --> 00:02:52.074
Now there's a lot here which is the same

00:02:52.234 --> 00:02:54.455
clearly, for example, the geography is 
the same

00:02:54.559 --> 00:02:57.965
you might think the people are different,
but actually the people and the culture

00:02:58.094 --> 00:02:59.604
are also very similar

00:02:59.694 --> 00:03:03.964
So until the 1850s, both parts of Nogales
were parts of Mexico

00:03:04.028 --> 00:03:10.496
so many of the people share, on both sides
of this fence, share the same ancestors

00:03:10.528 --> 00:03:12.574
they have a very similar culture

00:03:12.645 --> 00:03:13.966
So what differs?

00:03:14.002 --> 00:03:22.248
In Nogales, Arizona, income is about three
times higher than in Nogales, Mexico

00:03:22.377 --> 00:03:24.307
which is actually one of the richer parts 
of Mexico

00:03:24.457 --> 00:03:28.377
Life expectancy is higher on the left

00:03:28.507 --> 00:03:33.627
the infrastructure, the roads, the other
public infrastructure, the hospitals

00:03:33.737 --> 00:03:36.357
and so forth, is better in 
the United States

00:03:36.428 --> 00:03:41.418
It's easier to open a business in Nogales,
Arizona than in Nogales, Mexico

00:03:41.528 --> 00:03:46.998
democracy is more reliable on the left of 
this picture than it is on the right

00:03:47.068 --> 00:03:52.558
crime is lower on the left than it is
on the right

00:03:52.600 --> 00:03:57.799
Well, why?
The difference here again, is institutions

00:03:57.868 --> 00:04:00.407
Institutions make the difference

00:04:00.507 --> 00:04:06.559
These two examples, I think, are good
illustrations of the fact that

00:04:06.590 --> 00:04:07.768
institutions matter

00:04:07.928 --> 00:04:12.206
but we haven't said which institutions 
matter and why do they matter

00:04:12.305 --> 00:04:15.846
in future lectures we'll be talking more
about some of the possibilities

00:04:15.926 --> 00:04:19.406
about institutions like property rights,
the rule of laws, free press,

00:04:19.476 --> 00:04:23.526
honest government, open markets
We'll also be talking about facts which

00:04:23.561 --> 00:04:27.807
may underlie something such as 
honest government, like trust

00:04:27.847 --> 00:04:32.222
and then we'll be asking not only what 
are the effects of institutions,

00:04:32.291 --> 00:04:34.930
but what are the causes of institutions?

00:04:35.000 --> 00:04:38.268
Why is it, that some countries have
different institutions than others?

00:04:38.397 --> 00:04:40.811
Is this due to accidents of history?

00:04:40.821 --> 00:04:43.634
Is this due to differences in geography or 
in culture?

00:04:43.654 --> 00:04:46.083
All of these questions are really 
important,

00:04:46.154 --> 00:04:48.934
and we'll be dealing with them more as 
we go on

00:04:48.934 --> 00:04:50.164
Thanks