12 de maio , tarde
hoje foi um dia bem legal , um dos
melhores dias aqui
[música]
[Aqui passa um rio]
muita gente passando
[Deixe sua mensagem]
[Vergonha, tristeza e dor]
[música] ...
vamos ver o que tá ocorrendo na cidade inteira
... uma criança
[Por projetos urbanos]
[O Outro Lado do Muro]
A área em questão já era objeto de .. assunto de comunidades há muitos anos
porque é uma área que tá parada há mais de 50 anos sem uso
então ela já tinha sido matéria de jornais do bairro a respeito do futuro
então despertava no imaginário da população
aquela apreensão de como seria, qual futuro ela teria
Nesse momento a gente iniciou um processo de escuta Territorial
onde a gente ouvia a população numa pequena lousa branca
e ela se manifestava sobre o ideal da cidade
a gente colocava uma escadinha no muro onde as pessoas ...
e elas se manifestavam na lousinha e a gente foto digitalizava
e ia fazendo um varal, foi onde a gente conseguiu é...
trazer à tona o que a população imaginava ..... em relação a cidade .
EU QUERIA QUE AQUI Ó.. NESSE TERRENO
FOSSE UMA PRAÇA PRA TODO MUNDO PODER BRINCÁ
O QUE TODA POPULAÇÃO AQUI DESEJA.... É QUE ESSE PRÉDIO
...ESSES PRÉDIOS NÃO SEJAM CONSTRUÍDOS
[No dia 20 de julho de 2011, Ricardo criou uma página no Facebook
com o objetivo de tornar o movimento uma ação coletiva.]
a gente entrou com o pedido de reconsideração
ele apreciou esse pedido é.. em face desse pedido
ele reconsiderou deixou a página no ar
mas mandou excluir qualquer publicação que dissesse respeito
.. não só criticasse mas que dissesse respeito a construtora
e procuradora a nossa argumentação ela admite que
uma exigencia dela é fática é dizer que não houve abuso de direito
que esses direitos foram exercidos de maneira legítima
que nada foi alterado nada foi
... em momento nenhum ele passou dos limites
May 12th, afternoon
Today was a pretty good day,
one of the best days here
[Here passes a river]
Many people walking
Shame, sadness and pain
May 12th, afternoon
today was a cool day,
one of the best here
♪ soft music♪
here flows a river
soft music
THE OTHER SIDE OF THE WALL
CITY OF ALL
Many people passing by
soft music
LEAVE YOUR MESSAGE
soft music
SHAME, SADNESS, PAIN
soft music
ALL THEY NEED IS MONEY
Let's see what's going
on throughout the city.
a child...
soft music
For urban projects
soft music
THE OTHER SIDE OF
THE WALL
-The area in question was already subject
matter of the community for many years,
It is an area that has been standing for
more than fifty years. It had already
been the subject of neighborhood
newspapers about the future,
then awakened in in the imaginary of the
people the apprehension
of what the future would be,
what future they would like to have.
At that moment we started a process of
territorial listening the population
in a small whiteboard where they
manifested themselves about of the city.
we set put a small ladder
they wrote at the board, we photo scanned
their messages and made a
line of about the city
in a way to show what they
expected for the city.
I wanted here, at this land,
a playground for everybody to play.
what all people here wishes, is that
this building...buildings are not buid.
On July 20, 2011, a Facebook page was
*a Facebook page was created aiming
to make the Moviment a Collectve Action.
a Collectve Action.]
WHAT ALL PEOPLE HERE
WISHES...
IS THAT THIS BUIDING...
BUILDINGS ARE NOT BUILD
[On July 20, 2011, a Facebook page was
a Facebook page was created aiming
to make the Moviment
a Collectve Action.]
one year after , we
called the people
for a slightly larger
reflection
Then there was the
hiring of a sound car
for the people say
what they wanted
the lands are of some
the effects are on all
I think we will only
change when the hole
city has an organized
movement discussing
all that happens
in each neighborhood
we are not against
ventures, we just want
more decent projects
to the population
The Mofarege closed
this project, made a
contract, to do this work
she has an authorization
from the CET, the project
was done by the CET
not by Mofarege, this
item is already in budget,
it has to be done before
the work is completed
The construction company
filed a preliminary
injunction so that the
Facebook page was
withdrawn and that he
could not manisfest
in a mile or make
any manifestation.
taking advantage
of that boy you
forbade to be around here
he just took our cause,
he did not start it.
landlady lives here on the
street with his parents,
younger people, anyway ...
We know there's a river here.
We know there is.
(sound of water flows!
watter drops among
other sounds)
watter drops)
we asked him to
reconsider, he
he appreciated
this request, left
lthe page in the air
but didnt authorize
any criticism to the
constructor or to the
operator. Our
limitation is legal
but its assence is
also phatic
meaning that was no
abuse of rights, rights
were exercised lawfully,
nothing was changed,
he did not go
beyond the limits.
We make it clear
that we are talking
to the chief of the
expediente, so that
the process can go
and proceed.
we make it clear
that we are talking
to the head of the
chamber, to the director
for approval,we put
it on Facebook
so, we want their
position.
It doesn't make more
sense in Vila Mariana,
Vila Madalena,
in Lapa, which is my
neighborhood, in
Vila Romana, that
the public power let
let this predatory
real estate speculation
keep acting this way.
The question of the
river is important,
it really exists.
-What about the river?
-about the river?
-People, I'll show you
where the
the source is!
-Do you want?
-There is not!
They claim categorically
the river does not exist.
-Water gushes, people,
water gushes!
-Is just dump water,
that sprouts water!
-Oh my god,
I'll show you.
Which is almost a joke
-Guys, just so you to know,
were hired four of
the largest companies
in Sao Paulo that do
the four types of
probes that exist, all
terrain was probed...
-But this we never saw,
you're talking about what?
-Are sensors inside the
build, you will not see...
(Unable to understand)
What most touches
on his manifestations is that
he summons the owner of
the incorporator to a
dialogue with society,
even because the product
they are selling is not
a refrigerator, a stove,
it is a product with costs,
but they call it of
"defendant's boldness"
-I would like to
congratulate you on this act,
of this manifestation in
defense of citizenship
the residents present,
the authorities
who organized this
creative activity
denouncing real
estate speculation
with culture, with music,
visual arts.
-Excuse me, I've never
seen such a dirty
work as yours!
-Perfect, exactly, dirty
Exactly.
-Unmanaged...
- I think that what you
intend to do
will not improve the
situation
will minimize very little,
almost nothing.
The right thing is
to do here,
but you will not do
because you will
get in trouble with
the front building...
-there is one
that shouts...
-what you're doing here,
makes their houses
seems less important.
A demand for care
it never happened
before.
it is the second
or third time that is
project, our properties
are depreciated.
I would like to know
where one of us will
have some benefit when
this work is ready.
We have already
lost our patience,
our health. It's going
to be three to four
years to years
to have it done
we know it's the now,
the during and the after.
(sound of drums
and whistles)
We basically need
freedom of expression
very dangerous precedent,
where one who
protests has an opinion
in a lawful way,
to be censored in a decision
that was pronounced the
day after the entry
of the action.
-It's an incredible
sensation, at the same
time that you feel the
welcoming of the
population towards the
affection for their peaceful
approach, they turn so
violently against a person
who is simply one more
in the middle of the movement.
thus, it is not a shot
against the small ones
but against all
the social movements.
[-COME CAROL, JOIN IN!
COME DOWN FROM YOUR
APARTMENT,COME AND
SHARE THIS MOMENT WITH US.]
But we believe that
something will be done
because the collective
interest must influence.
each manifestation
above minor interests,
provided it is peacefully done,
as it has always been done.
♪ rock music ♪
(sound of many voices)
(sponsors)
12 de mayo, tarde
hoy fue un día genial,
de los mejores aquí
[música]
Mucha gente pasando...
[música] ...
Vamos a ver qué ocurre
en toda la ciudad
... un niño
Esta área ya era un asunto
de la comunidad hace muchos años
porque es una área que
hace 50 años que no se usa
y en periódicos locales
ya se había hablado de su futuro.
La gente ya empezaba
a imaginarse cosas
y a pensar en cuál sería el futuro
que podría llegar a tener.
Iniciamos un proceso
de escucha territorial
donde escuchábamos a la población
en una pequeña losa blanca
y así se manifestaba
sobre el ideal de la ciudad.
Colocamos una escalerita
en el muro, junto a la gente,
que se manifestaba en la losa
y la grabábamos