-
Art...
-
ArtSleuth
-
A child
-
another,
-
and a third
-
with their mother in the centre.
-
A painting by Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun.
-
Just another saccharine hymn to family values?
-
But it isn’t all sweetness and light:
-
this may be a palace, but it’s empty and cold
-
a sombre curtain shrouds the cradle
-
there are shadows creeping in…
-
This woman is Marie-Antoinette, last queen of France.
-
She has seven years to live:
-
When the Revolution triumphs, she will die on the guillotine…
-
She knows already that the people hate her.
-
This picture is a last attempt at image-building.
-
An attempt which fails!
-
But how about the picture - is it a failure too?
-
Is it mere propaganda - or is it something more?
-
Episode 4: Vigee Lebrun
*Marie-Antoinette and her children - From PR exercise to guillotine?*
-
Part 1: Painting as PR
-
Let there be no mistake,
-
this glossy picture is a PR exercise.
-
Its aim - to make people forget three damaging visions of the Queen u
nwittingly projected in earlier portraits.
-
Mark I: *Frivolous fashion-freak*.
-
The bold, actressy pose,
-
with stage curtain and smoke as background,
-
the knick-knacks, the frills,
-
the outlandish wigs...
-
all gone!
-
With a pedestal-type cushion at her feet,
-
Seated on an armchair in austere surroundings,
-
and a classical column
-
in the background,
-
the Queen again becomes a figure of authority.
-
Mark II: *Wayward shepherdess.*.
-
Tired of her royal duties,
Marie-Antoinette turns her back on the palace
-
and escapes to her toy-like village at the* Trianon.*.
-
“Straw hat and plain English muslin
-
- perfect for a pleasant stroll.
-
And just what all my friends are wearimg!”
-
Buta queen who shows herself like this in public is insulting the people
-
- and France!
-
So - back to the splendours of Versailles
and Louis XIV’s *Hall of Mirrors.*
-
Crown,
-
fleur de lys
-
- this is indeed a queen of France.
-
Back to the regulation red-velvet dress.**
-
The colour of power
-
and a discreet nod
-
to her simple, pious predecessor.
-
Mark III: *Queen of diamonds. *
-
She loves jewellery, and everyone knows it.
-
Indeed, one schemer has already used her name
-
to mount a massive scam
-
- the *“Queen’s Necklace Affair”. *.
-
The Queen’s innocence is proved, but the mud sticks all the same.
-
So, austerity’s the word
-
- no necklace, no diamonds.
-
A clever move.
-
The portrait goes on show in Paris.
-
But it’s *too late*:
-
the people no longer trust the monarchy.
-
The state is backing the Americans in their fight for independence,
-
Deeply in debt,
-
it is staring ruin in the face.
-
Millions, who have lent it their money, fear the worst.
-
Known for her extravagance, the Queen makes an easy scapegoat:
-
“Madame Deficit”, “the Austrian woman”, is accused of deliberately seeking to ruin France.
-
To win back the people’s favour, she tries a new approach**
-
-and plays her role as mother to the hilt.
-
Part 2: *The might of motherhood*
-
A queen as mother
-
- nothing new, surely!
-
After all, giving French kings an heir is what French queens are there for.
-
Her predecessor as queen, is a mere *biological bridge *between:
-
her husband, the present king,
-
and her son, the future one.
-
And her mother embodies the same tradition at the Austrian court,
-
as she proudly displays the little princes,
-
who are actually shown *as miniature adults *in their own right.
-
But there’s something new here:
-
for one thing, *the triangular composition *...
-
… comes from Italian Renaissance paintings of the Holy Family:
-
the* sacred* is back.
-
There’s something else too, something more modern:
-
a real bond of affection between mother and children ...
-
... who are dressed to suit their needs - not a wig or sword in sight.
-
The guiding light here is the philosopher, Jean-Jacques Rousseau,
-
who urges mothers to abandon their loose-living ways
-
- and play a worthy role in society
-
by raising their children to be enlightened citizens.
-
The reference point here is Cornelia, the virtuous Roman matron,
-
who scorned jewellery,
-
and declared that her children were her greatest treasure.
-
Which helps to explain why this jewel cabinet
-
stays firmly in the shadows,
-
while the children are presented to the nation.
-
Embodying both *sacred *and *civic *ideals of motherhood,
-
the Queen *scores twice over*!
-
But maternal feeling has its modish side too:
-
many ladies of fashion are happy enough to be painted with their children ...
-
... but leave all the rest to nurses.
-
The public suspect that Marie-Antoinette is one of them,
-
and focus instead on one melancholy detail:
-
the empty cradle!
-
... intended for the little Princess Sophie,
-
who died before the picture was finished.
-
Will viewers feel for her mother?
-
No: the expression doesn’t fit
-
- she looks unconcerned,
-
and seems to have her mind on something else.
-
In short, she is a *bad mother*.
-
An argument taken up seven years later by the judges in the revolutionary tribunal,
-
who even accuse her of incest.
-
So the Queen’s plan collapses: the picture will not save her.
-
But what about saving the picture?
-
Part 3: *Prosperity - and posterity*
-
Of course, the artist Vigée-Lebrun is working to a royal commission,
-
and has to play down the very thing
-
that has made her fame and fortune
-
the all-new package she offers her sitters.
-
Not content to retouch their physical flaws,
-
she even arranges their costumes and hairstyles herself.
-
conventional dress codes are out,
-
and an easy elegance lets natural beauty shine through.
-
Above all, she encourages them to reveal their *private selves *
-
- to smile,
-
behave naturally,
-
and let their softer side show through.
-
And so the picture will live for other reasons
-
- reasons which apply in the 19th century
-
Long gone the haughty monarchs of the past -
-
today’s royal portraits must please the conventional, well-to-do burghers
-
and reflect their moral values
-
The good mother comes to symbolise political rectitude.
-
Queen Victoria, the century’s most powerful woman, is a typical example.
-
The French, too, choose a nursing mother
-
- Marianne - to symbolise the Republic**
-
And, less than a century after they were painted, Vigée-Lebrun’s versions of Marie-Antoinette
-
no longer seem at odds with one another.
-
The Queen is remembered, not only as mother, but also for her special creation
-
- the high life, Trianon-style, blending the refined and bucolic.
-
In her day, easy-living luxury was seen as a sign of *depravity *
-
- and as such incompatible with motherhood.
-
In the 19th century, however, it became part of the duty her successors owed their country’s economy:
-
the Empress Eugénie, for example - an exemplary mother, seen here with her ladies-in-waiting
-
- helped to boost French fashion sales world-wide.
-
And so this portrait marks the start of a new era,
-
when public opinion can no longer be ignored
-
by royals - or their painters. **
-
Next episode: Rembrandt - *The Return of the Prodigal Son*
*Force of the Dark Side*
-
Find more information on: www.canal-educatif.fr
-
Directed by
-
Produced by:
-
Written by
-
This film exists thanks to
sponsors and volunteers
-
and to the support of the Palace of Versailles
-
Voicover
-
Editing and motion graphics
-
Extra editing & sound recording
-
Musical selection
-
Musics
-
Photographic credits
-
Special thanks
English subtitles: Vincent Nash
-
A CED production